Bhim Singh v. State Of Punjab


  
     


 

 !

"#

!$%&%"'(

)* *  

     

   
( + , * 
     

   

!" 

 

 ! 

#  

$$$$   

-

* %  

  "   

&'  (

  ")  )*+* ,-.
% ,/ - ,-01-2 -, ,-312,21,-0  "    ,, -.

,-2  4  

  " !"  " ,,*+ " 56/

  "     ""        &  &  "   &     7 &

%  "  4"            87  * .  

5 -3 ,-0  " ,,*+ "   " )!'    &"   7  " &   447 " )

 

4 7    7#   9)4  9)*   )
7+!  "!    4 &4

,
 "":     !!"4 &"   %
 %);:  " !  4"     4  &  "  

  ": & <   &

!" "    

 4  " " :   

 9       =

 > % 7  "      :    :  ""   4 "  "    " &#? <"  4" "     @   

      " "  !  

"   4  %4  

  !   "   % 7  " " 

  "!  A" 4   &  ! 1

4"4   ":4 % 4 "

":-  ""! 4 4 ": 

  ""      A" 4 4 

/0- 4""    ""  1

%  7  "  A"  4  ":4 BB

    " A       ": &4 ! 7   

":  4  "    &   "  4     "  4 

%  C  4     &       )7  +!        87 %  &     

0
 "   / 0-

 %

 4 ! DA +1 "   !   7  "       "    

     4    "   &  "  ""!    " ""  4 7  "(   9< 9 ! ""  "  &4    (     "  &4

9)

<  A &  7  " :

"  & 9)  " 

  4 "  &  ( 7) 4

"   

"  ! & 

"   "

 &    "  :   %     ( "    :     ! - :     :  "      !     "  4      

  B B %  4 "   "     ! 7  "    ( " :   % 7  "    "

 &4 9)( " : 4"  &

< ,, -3 ,-0 9)#"  4 ! : " "   /,-  A"  4     ! -

  A"   4     4   B B          " "   -  A"  4 &

9) 4    ( " :   % 4 &

3
 ,, -3 ,-0 ) *  "     ""  A           "  .0=,>  )  )  4

    

 "  )

 " !  "    !"  " A  ) * ;
 4 

 !  " ! 94"
A  !&&&    ""  9)  ;
, 4    !  " ! A 

" 4 "
A  !&&&   ""  %  7

         ;
0  4  4  "
A     

7  "   ;
3 4"
A  

 % 7  "(    449<"    ;
/ 4"
A   & 

 ""  " !  " "   

  " 00)  ) 4"

%

   A   3  4      "  <     9    

!"4A  +;
 9#  4 

 +;
,   '+;
0  +;
3

%   "" "   "!  "

'   "       

         

  & "    "     )4 &    "!  "&4" 4 !    

!"9    9#  4

 

 4 " ":  & &   

/
/ 0-       " 4      

    ! 

 4  
=> < 4   &  7#   4 4  &   "  "        4        4 

94!4 A  & "  "    &

 4     "        4        4  44 A   4" 4  & "   " 

=>  &  4   & 9)4  4        "  & 4   A   4  &  "       " 

=> % &4  !!"   " 4&&4  #!   !"4  4""" 4" "

=!> *  4 4  

"!&       "  !  "    7  "   7   4    " "" " %)4: 4 !& 4#!  "4:  4   & ;
0 7

      ""&         :   

2
"    %)  4:  4  "      !   %) 4: ,--
0-- &  ""!&

=!>  %7 !  <" "   4    7  "     4 "

=!> % - 4"4 4    " (

7)  4" B B4  4 !         8 "  '&    "" A  4 4"4 4    && &4"4   "" BB B(B4   "A    4&4!  " /, *+ "

=!> %  "  " 

  " 4 

<   !  

#     
    4   ""    7 < 4   

"  !44 4 &)   " 9 B ) E


     F   

     !

 9        

"  "  & 4    "   "  "!"  " 4       !4"4 4

.
A    ,& 9 

  4 !!  4" *+ " 4" 4" !"

7  " 4" !"  &  ---1
  "4 "         0       " 9 

" 4 !"&    

 

 

7  !         "           

 "

%  "         !    "  A   4 4   & * ;
 ;
,    !  4: &    "& %44   &  7  ;
0 7  " ;
34A   ! "!&4   

  4  !  "   " 7  "  %9< 4 4 "!&4A  ;
/

%  "A   

!"  & 9  +;


!

 4& "  "4

    / 0-   4 &

  

   & 9#  4   +;
,  

%4   &  " 

 444   &  7#   9) 4 4 A  & "  4 

6
"  " 4 4 7#  4  &  ;
0 7

  44  &  "
A   "   

 4" & 7#   4 4:4  & 9)4     4 4   & &   

&  7  "  44 

&  "
A   "  4  4 &4  & 7#   4     "   "   144 

& 7   9)4  "   DA +4 4 4  & 7    9)4  %  7#   4 ""  " 4 ! "  4 "  44      " .0)  ) 4 4 4     7  #         !            4 A 

 *  "    "  4    4      4&    4 4 A 

&    4 4  &  & 9)4 44  "   4 4 " 

4  " .0)  )  4 A  !  44    "

        &       "     

 4 &4  !!" "" 

5
 " &   "   

  44   "  4&#!  !"4    & !!"4    

 7  "  ;
34 4 A 

" & 4    !!"  "
A  

&)7 <", --

 "   &  ++ &4  !7 !!"4  &

& :4   94!   "   4& & !!"4         "4"       7 <    4    " ! ! &

 

*A  4"4 &  " 

 4   4 4A     4 " %  7  ;
04 4  "
A  &    4     "4 "  C %41  4

   4  &7 <     "!

 &4 & 9" "&   :  4:   !    "%)4: 4 "   !    4: ,--10-- & %)4:    &    7  " ;
3 4" " "
A  4  &: ,
0     &4 &

-
 9   

 ,
0   " &:      :"    4   & % " "&

  " &"4:  

&  " &    4" 4  %)4:

!   ,
0   44:   &4  "&" 4 "" "

  !  !   ! *+ "

94!    "   " 

  !   "          4        "      7 <

%     " !     4    " 4 !4       %)  4:    ,--10--  &   4&  4        &4: 4   &4  4  ,
0   44 & "&"4   &   % "  &   &   7  "  4  " & "     "   

94! C 4 
    4  4   "  4"   4 4     "  "

"    !&  "              4  "  

"" "

  4"4 &  "  

 44" "    "4


 !   

!"  & 9  +;
 9# +;
, 4 

     " 

  

!" 4

 4 A " "&  5 -3 ,-0-/ 0/  4 4  

4: 4

 4   " 4

"  "  4   C      

          &" " 

   & 9#     :   " && ""  !  &": 4  "     

  *+ " %  9#  4

  4

4"  "& 4   & 9   

!" 4  

  : & "" 44   4 ) & C 

 

 7 "
A      "    "    9  )   4 4 " "  &    "4   '+;
0 -/ 0-  4 

 # 4 &  " 44  =

 >  4 " 4 ""

 "" & &4  C

       4 

,
!  ": 4"     

 
  %  )4 "   " !  """ "  " &"  ! 

 "4 "

   & 9#   !"   9  )     "  &" &    &   9  ) A"    4"4 4   3 - ,-3 9 ! 

"   "  4 C &+ )&
7  4    

"      ""  "      "4  % 
 "  &    & 9   )  C&" " &+ )&
7  4"  " " "      !  "  &  "  9   

!" 9#          '  4  4        

"  "           4       &   "!" 7"    "&  ! "    " &4   "      &  

&  "4  %  %)  4 &    "4  44  4"

          4"       &     "       

   4              

"!& 4 - "4 4 //-

0

 A" 4   BB B(B4     

 4  "    ( 7)  4 A"  4  4   "   ( 7)   ! - 4:  " 4"4 4( 7)B B

94! 4  4  "&   4"4 4    "  ( 7)4   A   4"4 4 & "4   "A      &! " /, = >*+ "& "

7  A  "   "      &  ( 7) ,- -3 ,-0

% "" "45 -3 ,-0 

 4  "

  ( 7) ,- -3 ,-0    //-   A"  4 "    "   ""   /0-

 4 ""   -
- "   BB B(B4  "

8: 4"4      "  (

7)   ! -  ""  4   4  :     4       (

7)  

  B B   : "   /0- 4  4   B B %   

,- -3 ,-0  "  



      

        

        

               

  

3

 !"

       

 #$    

    

     %  



& %      !

 

    

       

 %    !

      '

& %    (      !

      '

)   

      

  

%    

        * +,





)     

     

      

  %    (      $ 

    

%   

    #  -% .

/ '  

#-*/( 0 (

7" ""&  ) *   :  -  1( :  ,, -3 ,-0 9)   8 "'&  %4 4"4 4 &

& 5 -3 ,-0 4"7  " 4

BB   9<(   4  B(B 4"4&  "&A 

 ""A 4 4 C & "! &4-  4 BG(B 74 4"  4 4" 4  1,  ,! % "  4"4 4    "  ( 7) 4"

/
( 7)
    4      B B  4  !          " &""A 

%

 9 B )   E"

  # $  
 % $F &' 

(! 4  ! 4 ? &*""+  &" "

"    "    ) !& "    "         4 "
"   "  "   4     "  /0      *+  "  %  " " "   

" 4 

"   " /,
=,> " 4"4 &   &C  " 0" /,
   B?    %         !          0         

      "  

 

   



  

 4   !

   

  !            !  "

         

          

  

  



  

  '

2 

        -     



  ('5(6   '"

     !

 -      !



7  



      ('"

   !

    !

  



 
4   .

2     



       -      $ 

 

 



.

2
% " " : & 4" &4 4 &9 B ) "



# $  
 % $)  " 4" 4 4    "  ( 7) 4"B B4

  4   !          "  &  %  "             !      4    "!&     & "       

 

      !    4   " 4&44   &  7#  

9)4 4 A 

% 
     4  " "  "C " "" "  "  &  ! "  4  44 : !" &  & %)4: 4"4 &,--
0--&  " "" "  4    "     4       "  &

8 !  "

" &  " 3+;!     &

" &  ) 4   " !  " 4  "& !4 "  4    " 

 

7   " ) "            "           "   "&

 &  

 7 "   *+ "  " !  "  A  !&"&A" !&" "  "  94!         "    !4      

.
"" "4"! A    " &"  !    4  " !"      "" 1

   %  

    !   ) C &   

 4           ,, -.

,-2  4&    

   4 " !"    " & %

 "C  "     %

  " & 4  C   &"

)* *

   & %

   ; : 1 

H , ; 

H