Jitender v. State Of Haryana And Others

  
    
 

 ! !"#$#%&

# !%'!( )! # #%!( *!($+$
,  ! (-%%' .!($ )!$/%'!% $

(0& %123!4(+$ #"! ,3# (!$!% & 4(,%5-6+$.37,!%#('8" !$$#$ !'2- 4(,! #7'8" !

( .!/! # #%!( 4(/%6+0(7 7(-% 999 




  (-!( #% .! /! # #% +%'!( ( #"3!$

:;

   .!
%$ # + #%   %'# #$ ( .! #$$+%"!    <(#   
!( #((# ( =+$.#%> ('!(7 %%!?+(! ;

7 ' !' @

 '#$0#$$#%> .! /! # #%!( (0$!(8#"!%""+%  .#$.8#%>"%"!3!'0 !(#3 " $ <.#3!//3-#%> ( .!/$  
%$ 23! 

(#!

" $   .! "$! 3!'#%>  .! #3#%>   .! #%$ %  /! # #%(! . #%(!$/%$! '8!( #$!0!% ;

@2- .!(-% ,

 ,!3!" #%
00#$$#%7 .! /! # #%!( //3#!' ( .! /$  
%$ 23! % 

@ A3 .+>. 8#'! "((#>!%'+07 .! 3$  ' ! ( //3-#%> <$ !? !%'!' 

@7B <$ $!3!" !' %' //#% !' $ $+".8#'!//#% 0!% 3! !(%%!?+(!;:' !' 

C%'#$$+!'
%$ 2+3(-+02!(% .!$0!'-7 . D ' !' @ C

D $ '(!>#$ !(!'>#%$  .!/! # #%!(%' .!($+%'!(,!" #%DE A B 
 3#"!,  #% F7.$!E7+(>+>(02+  .!$0!(!$+3 !'#% "=+# 3   .! /! # #%!( 8#'! ('!( %%!?+(! ; ' !' 

:7

% .!(#!:C ' !'

D$ '(!>#$ !(!'>#%$  .! /! # #%!(%' .!($+;,$ D@; DC; ;D %' :
 3#"!,  #%
#8#3 F#%!7 #$ (#"  #$(7 #% <.#". .! /! # #%!( <$ "%8#" !' %

: @

@2+ <$(!3!$!'%/(2 #%8#'!('!(%%!?+(!;D' !'

C @

@7 . % .!2$#$ "0/3#% 7#0/+>%!'('!(7%%!?+(! ;

 ' !' @

 <$ /$$!'7 #% !( 3# % .! >(+%'  "%"!30!%    (!>#$ ( #% (!0!% #%!' 7 (0#%>   ".(>!$7 %'"%$!=+!% #3#%!3#>#2#3# -  .!/! # #%!( //3- ( .!/$    % @

7 3!(%!' !/+ - '8" ! !%!(37 .' (!=+!$ !' ( % '5+(%0!%   !%23! .#0  $$#$  #% .! 0 !( 2- (!

!((#%>  .!(!"('""('#%>3-7 .!"$!<$'5+(%!' ( '-% ""+%   .!('!(<.#".#$ .!$+25!" E0 !( ".33!%>!"0#%>#%  /!( #% <! 

 '-7 %3#%! //3#" #% (0 .$ 2!!% /('+"!'.!$0!#$ G!%%(!"('$4(GH1(%$3 !'8!($#% 
3+$! D   .! #%$ (+" #%$ #% .! //3#" #% (07 #$ (!/('+"!' .!(!+%'!(&E 



 






 
   
 
  


 



 


  

 








 


  
 
  




 D % .! (!0!% #%!' 2"G>(+%'7 3!(%!' ,!%#(
+%$!3 "% !%'$ . &E #B .!//3#" #% (0#$ 2!3'!'%3#%!%' .!(!#$%"3+0% #% .! $0! ( 0!% #%#%> '! #3$ (!>('#%> #%838!0!%  #%  "(#0#%3 "$! ( .! $  +$ #% (!$/!"  .!(! 7 .!(! (! .!  ( (0#%>  ".(>!$"+3'% .8!2!!%0!% #%!'#% .!//3#" #% (0I ##B .!/! # #%!(.'0!% #%!'"0/3! !'! #3$  .!"(#0#%3"$! #% .! !$  #% (02+ .!<$$ #33//#% !'%'%" #%<$ G!%7

.!(!

(!%< .! (!$/%'!% $(! !$ //!' (0 /$$#%> .!#0/+>%!' ('!(I ###B $ /!( 3!>3 /#%#%7 %%!?+(! ;

7 "%8#" #%7 #% "$!  :C ' !'

D+%'!(,!" #%$ D@7 DC7 7D %' :
 %' $+2$!=+!%  (!3!$!   .! /! # #%!( % /(2 #% '#' %   ("  ;  ".'#$=+3# #" #% (!0/3-0!% #% !(0$ +3!  @ABAB .! +%52 3#"! +3!$7 CD $ //3#"23!  .! ,  !   (-%7 .!(!

(! .!#0/+>%!'('!("+3'% .8!2!!%/$$!'I #8B
0/3#%  3!'#%>  /$$#%>   .! #0/+>%!' ('!( <$ 2- .! /! # #%!(1$ '#$>(+% 3!' 2( .!( #% 3< % ""+%    .! /! # #%!(1$ 0 (#0%#3'#$/+ !7 .!(!

(! .!$0!+>.  .8!2!!%#>%(!'I 8B ,.< "+$! % #"! #$$+!' 2- .! .!% ,+/!(#% !%'!%    3#"!7  !.2'7 /(/$#%> /+%#$.0!%    '#$0#$$3 (0 $!(8#"! 8#'! 0!0 ' !' :

 /+($+%   #%=+#(- +%'!( +3! : D   .! +%52 3#"! +3!$ CD $ //3#"23!  .! ,  !   (-%7 <$ <# .  /(!'! !(0#%!'0#%'$$ (#>. <-$.<"+$!% #"!<$#$$+!'$  <.- .! /! # #%!( $.+3' %  2! '#$0#$$!' (0 $!(8#"!7 .!(!

(! .! #0/+>%!'('!(<$8# # !'   F!(%!' !/+ - '8" ! !%!(3 % .!  .!( .%' "% !%'!'I #B . 3 .+>. .!(!#$%"3+0%#% .!//3#" #% (0 (>#8#%> '! #3$  .!"(#0#%3"$!7.<!8!(7
3+$!A###BABJA2B  .!!%!(3 %$ (+" #%$ #% .! '8!( #$!0!% 7 %%!?+(! ;  "(! !' % !02(> >#%$ "%'#' !>#%$ <.0".(>!$.'2!!% (0!' (%

!%"! #%838#%>0(3 +(/# +'!(<.#".<$/+%#$.23!<# .#0/(#$%0!%  .(!! -!($ ( 0(! (0 //3-#%> <.!(!$ '!$/# ! (!>#$ ( #%    :C ' !'

D+;,$ D@7 DC7 7D %' :
 3#"!

,  #%
#8#3 F#%!7 #$( %' ".(>!$ .8#%> 2!!% (0!' >#%$  .! /! # #%!(#% .!$#'"$!<# . .!

!%"!+;$ D@2!#%>/+%#$.23!<# . #0/(#$%0!%  +/   -!($7 .! /! # #%!( //3#!' ( .! /$  
%$ 23!7 .!(!

(! .!#0/+>%!'('!(<$(#>. 3-/$$!'
3+$!A###B AB J A2B   .! !%!(3 %$ (+" #%$7 "% #%!' #% '8!( #$!0!%  %%!?+(!E (!(!/('+"!'$+%'!(&E 



!
 "
 

 





 

 





  


  


  

 "
 

 

#

 

 
  


 
  

 








  


  


  


 



. #% .! (!0!% #%!'"#("+0$ %"!$7#((!$/!" #8!  .!(!2!#%>% "3+0% #% .! //3#" #% (07 $+20#$$#%  (0 2- .! /! # #%!(  (" !'"%$!=+!%"!$ '#$=+3# #" #%  .!"%'#' +(!+ (#>. 3-$ $ #/+3 !' +%'!(  +3!  @ A B %' '#$".(>! (0 $!(8#"!   .! /! # #%!( 2- .! //#% #%> + .(# - (0 .! ' !   //#% 0!% 7 $+00(#3-#% !(0$  +3!  @ADB  .!+%523#"!+3!$7 CD !3!8% !? ("  (+3!  @  .!+%523#"!A(-%0!%'0!% B +3!$7

% # #!'% @ :

7#$(!/('+"!'$+%'!(&E $% $&
'
(  





  ')
$

%

* 
 
 



 





+,




 


  


)










 
 

  





 













-)  




  
 
 

.

 








"
 



 '

/  




 "
 


0  

 








 




 


1  
1
2

/



 
!

"
%333"
 

 

.

 




) 









 

  





 


5




   


 
   



  








 


 
  


 


6

  


  

 "

 



 
 

  

 



 



   "
 






 
  
 "



 

 

 





  



 

.!(!

(! .! #0/+>%!' ('!( <$ $ /!( (+3!$7 .+$ #00+%! (0 ".33!%>!I ##B .  .!0 !(<$$=+(!3-"8!(!'>#%$  .!/! # #%!(2- .!'!"#$#% 
E('#% ! !%".  .#$
+( #% 

#% "$! # 3!'$H
 
  

 





  
1,  




 
 

 




' $5

  "


 
 



 




   "



 
 
 






 

, 
$% $&%


/ 0
/
,  

 

 



  
 




 






 







+,






 





 
 

  
 
 
 





.

 




 



 

*

  

  

 



  





  









 



  


  


  
 

*
 



 











 
0

   











   

 
 


 6


 




 

 

 

  

*







  






 


%


, 
$% $&

 6





  
, 
$% $&%
 6

  


  







%5

 
8   
 


 
 
 


  



   


  

 
 



  
 
  

+ 
 

 



 
 "





 





 


 

 



 




 



9 

*


 






 


 



  


 




 
 

* 8  

 

  












 
, 
$% $&
%

  


 

$& 3:

%3$;   





 

 






  

 




 
 


 





  




  



 




 


 
 




 
 




 
, 
$% $&
%

###B .  .! !$$!%"!   .! 0 !( <$ <.! .!( .! //3#"%  .' $/G!% .! (+ . 2!"+$! #  <$   /(0+%  #0/( %"! .  % +% (+ .

+3 0% $.+3' %  <!(  /3#"! +%# (0 %' .  #% .! "#("+0$ %"!$7  3$! $ (  2- .! /! # #%!( 0+$  !%' <# . .! " #% "% !0/3 !'+%'!(+3!  @A B$$/!G#%>3#!<$<. 0!%'!'

+3!  @A B$+>.  /(!8!% $/(/.-3" #"  .!2!(( #%I #8B . 3!>3/#%#%%%!?+(!;

<$#((!3!8% $# '#'%  ''(!$$ .!/#% #%#$$+!% .!2$#$ <.#".('!(7%%!?+(!;

.' 2!!% /$$!' #!   .! /! # #%!( .8#%> "%"!3!' 0 !(#3 " $ <.#3! //3-#%> ( .! /$  '!$/# ! /(.#2# #% #% .! '8!( #$!0!%   "%'#' !$ >#%$  <.0 ".(>!$ .' 2!!% (0!' ( % 

!%"! #%838#%>/+%#$.0!%   .(!!-!($A,!" #% D@
B%' .!'#$0#$$3 %  .8#%> 2!!% ('!(!' % ""+%    "%8#" #%7 2+  % ""+%   "%"!30!% 7"%$!=+!% #33- (" #%>" #%+%'!(+3!  @A BJADB  .!+%523#"!A(-%0!%'0!% B+3!$7

I 
.  .!/3! .  .!/! # #%!(.'0!% #%!'"0/3! !'! #3$ .!"(#0#%3 "$! #% .! !$  #% (0 2+  <$$ #33 //#% !' %'% " #% <$ G!%7 .!(!

(! %< .! (!$/%'!% $ <!(! !$ //!' (0 /$$#%> .! #0/+>%!' ('!(7 <$ '!8#'   0!(#  $ //#% 0!%  3! !( %%!?+(!;:%'#$$+%"! 
%$ 2+3(-+02!(<$% 

C <.!(!$ !$  #% (0>#8#%>'! #3$ #%838!0!% #% .!"(#0#%3"$! <$    $+2$!=+!%  ' ! #!  

C %' #% .! "#("+0$ %"!$ .! (!$/%'!% $ <!(! <!33 <# .#% .!#( (#>. $  /("!$$ .! "0/3#%  % (!"!#/ %' G!" #%#%(!$/!"  .!(! $/!(3<#% !(0$  .!(+3!$ //3#"23!#!+3!  @ !$#'!$7 .!(!<$%!$ //!3>#%$ 3<I 8#B .  .!/3!  .!$.<"+$!% #"!% 2!#%>#%""('%"!<# . 3<<$3$'!8#' 0!(# $ .!$.<"+$!% #"!<$".33!%>!'2- .!/! # #%!(2-<- 
 

%'$#'<(# /! # #% <$ '#$/$!'   $ /(!0 +(! <.!(!

!( .! /! # #%!( $ /!( .#$ <% $.<#%>#%/(>(/.

 .!<(# /! # #% #3!''! #3!'(!/3-7  .!$.<"+$!% #"!7<$

('!'//( +%# - /!($%3.!(#%>%' <$.!(' 3!%> .% D @

72!$#'!$%/(!5+'#"!7# %-"+$!' 

.! /! # #%!( .' 2!!% /#% !' + 7 .!(! (! .! #0/+>%!' ('!( <$ #00+%! (0".33!%>! 8##B .  .!#0/+>%!'('!(2!#%>//!323!7 .!/! # #%!(<$3#23! 2!(!3!> !' 8#3(!0!'- //!3+%'!(+3! : C  .!+%52 3#"!+3!$7 CD$//3#"23!  .!,  ! (-% : F!(%!',!%#(
+%$!3$  !$ .  .!/! # #%!(<+3'%  2! 8!($!  8#3#%> (!0!'-   //!3 /(8#'!' .! #0/+>%!'('!(#$ $ -!' (+/ %!<!!G !( .!'!"#$#%  .!//!3$'!"#$#%  .! //!3<+3' G!3%> #0!  .8!"%$#'!(!' .!$+20#$$#%$ 3!(%!'"+%$!3$/!( 3< <!33 $! 3!' #% "$!$ # 3!' $ H


 


   

   

 

 1 %3%$
$
,2,
2
:34"H!
 
"

 

  
!


 

"


 
 1 %3%$4
/<,
:;47 #% 8#!<   .! #0/+>%!' ('!( 2!#%> //!323! %' % !?"!/ #%3 "#("+0$ %"!$ .8#%> 2!!% /#% !' +  ( !% !( #%#%> .! <(#  /! # #%7  .!(! (!7 <# .+  '5+'#" #%> .! (!$/!" #8! /3!$ % 0!(# 7 3!$  .! $0! /(!5+'#"!$%-/( -7<.#3!(!5!" #%> .!/3! ($ -  .!#0/+>%!' ('!( #% .! 3#>.     3# -   "#("+0$ %"!$7  '!!0 #  //(/(# !  (!3!> ! .!/! # #%!( 8#3(!0!'- //!3+%'!(+3! : C  .! +%523#"!+3!$7 CD$//3#"23!  .!,  ! (-%2!

(! .! %$/!" (!%!(3 3#"!A#%8#!<  .! $0!% #%!'#%+3! : C2!#%>#%(!

!(!%"! /(!E/( # #%/!(#'+%'!( .!3'"   @:  <.#". $ %'$ (!/!3!' 2- .! (-% 3#"! " 7

B .! F!(%!' //!33 !+ .(# -#$(!=+!$ !' '!"#'! .!//!3<# .#% <!!G$ (0 .! ' !   (!"!#/    //!3 #% ""('%"! <# . 3< !( G#%> #%  ""+% 33$/!" $  .!0 !(%'  +(%#$."/-  .!'!"#$#% 

.!/! # #%!(<# .#%/!(#' '-$ .!(!

!(!!'3!$$ 0!% #%7 %/#%#%.$2!!%!?/(!$$!'% .!0!(# $  .!"$! @ (# /! # #%$ %'$ 
$28! C
/-  .#$('!(2!>#8!% 3!(%!'"+%$!3 ( .!/( #!$ +%'!( .!$#>% +(!$  .! !%".,!"(! (-




















H5%!!$.1 #

 6
 
'
= -
#




'
= -