← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3683/1987disposed of

Durga Parshad v. Prabha Shankar Etc.

2016-05-25Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages

 

     

 

!"##$%&%'(!)*+  ",-*.   /01! !0&,!23#2%!

44#55!'"

6#0&/&

0!7,!,!'8!0 ",#0&  #&4'2#'"&  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&  9,#",#0 #40"#0&5$!54!4#0&:!)7#!55;#2"&##",#</21:#'"= * 7#0##00#2"",# #40"#0&0'"=  9,#",#0",#</21:#'"&,/527#0#40"#2%'",#%1#&"=

0#&#'"( 03!/&,%8-2>$!"#- 0",#!44#55!'" 0 !<%'2#0)!5-2>$!"#- 00#&4'2#'" ?????  *)+%,'

 /0  1/

#45)"",#!445%$!"%'04#0:%&&%'"5#!2!22%"%'!5 #>%2#'$#%&"!8#''0#$02 &"!'2&2%&4&#2

 

,#40#&#'" #1/5!0#$'244#!5%&2%0#$"#2!1!%'&"",#

1 $'$/00#'"%'2%'1&!$"&!'25!;-;,#0#7)",#&/%"",#45!%'"%& &##8%'12#$5!0!"%'!'2%'</'$"%',!&7##'2#$5%'#2;%",!0%2#0",!"",# 404#0")&527)2##'2!'"&"+%'!>/02##'2!'"&!'2

&,!557#&/7<#$""",#4!0"%"%' 03!/&,%8-5#!0'#2$/'&#5!44#!0%'1'7#,!5",# !44#55!'"@45!%'"%&/7:%"&",!"",#$!&#&#"/"%'",#45!%'";!&",!" ,!0&% !:,!2/0&'&-'!:#5)- !'&%,!0- !:#&,;!0!&&-

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

 7)%'>8%'1",#40>%&%'& 02#0C /5#*  "45!$#'0#$02 ",#</21:#'"!'22#$0##2!"#2**4!&&#27)",#A;#044#55!"# /0"%'%>%544#!5.-"%"5#2!& !07,!,!'8!0-!% ,!'8!0-6%<!),!'8!0&'&!2!'A!56#0&/& : !08!&,3#2%)!

&'!'&%,!03#2%)!-/01! !0&,!2&' !2,!'3%&,!'3#2%)!

%5#2!1!%'&"",#</21:#'"!'22#$0##2!"#2+4!&&#2%'%>%5 /%"-%5#27)2##'2!'"&!'2+ !&45!%'"%& '",#40#:%&#",!"

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

50&/%"-",# &!:#$!'!5;!)&7#"!8#''0#$027)#B#0$%&%'1",#4;#0/'2#0 02#0 C /5#*  ,/&-%&$445%$!"%'*@*.C%&!55;#2 ,#</21:#'"!'22#$0##2!"#2**%&"!8#''0#$02!&''#B/0# @ 0 !<%'2#0)!5-':#0%"&-&/7:%"&",!"",#0#;!&' $$!&%'  0  &##8%'1  0#&5/"%'    2%&4/"#  ",0/1,  !44%'":#'"   07%"0!"0!&2##'2!'"&"+!0#",#5#1!5,#%0&!2!'A!5!'2 ",#",#070",#0&!2!'A!52%2'",!>#!')&"!8#%',%&&,!0#" ;/52'5)2#>5>#/4'",#5#1!5,#%0&!'

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

!:0#D/%0#&0#1%&"0!"%';%'1"",#40#@#B%&"%'10%1," 7#";##'",#&%75%'1&=   ,!>#  ,#!02  ",#  5#!0'#2  $/'&#5  0  ",#  4!0"%#&  !'2 !440!%&#2",#4!4#078!'2",#>%#;",!"7)",#%'2%'1&0#'2#0#27) ",#44#55!"#/0"%'%>%544#!5. &/40! -",#!;!02 ",#07%"0!"02!"#2.+ B C ,!&7##'/4,#52-%'#&&#'$#%",!&

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

0#%'",#404#0"),#527)",#:;/52'"0#D/%0# 0#1%&"0!"%' #&4%"#",#4!0"%"%'",#404#0")!:'1&"",#4!0"%#&7) >%0"/#",#!;!02-2##'2!'"&"+&52",#5!'2"2##'2!'" &!'2 !'2%"%&!:!""#00#$02",!"",#&!%25!'2-!&4#0",# !;!02-,!2!55#'"",#&,!0#",#45!%'"%& 0",#&!8#70#>%")- ",#%'2%'1&0#$02#27)",#A;#044#55!"#/0"%'",#</21:#'"!'2 2#$0##2!"#2**4!&&#2%'%>%544#!5.-;,%$,%& "!8#''0#$02"2!)7);!)!22%"%'!5#>%2#'$#-0#!

     

 

     

 

      

 

   

    

!



  

         

 

       

"

# $% &'(   )) 

  *+ ,     -     

-

   



        

            

 

 -       



 -     

   



  -     -

  

  

         ) )    

     

 

    

    -

     

  

  -  



   



         

            -     

   

 

- 

  .  -

 

            

 -  -

  )      -  -  

 

    

    

   -  

 -          

   /0 1 ,  $2 

         34-    

)       



 

 5    -   

 -        

   

      - 

 - 

           .                     6"

 ("     7 . 

 

     )   

)              

    

      

      & -+   * + ,           1  8   7 ""

  

7 

79 -) .    

 

   

   4 :  

   ,        /   4 ,          ;

( $2     

 4 , 

 .7    

,  

.<   ,

4

         .7  0 . ,  

    

  -     .  7            ,

  4



 



  -  $

      

         

  



   

*   + 7 ,

            

    ..< .      * + ,       & -  +        

  - 

 

    



  

  -    

               

    

   



 

  

   5    

      

   



       -   6"

& )(6    & -+   *+ , 

  & -+ ,

*+ ,  

-   5    

             

-   8  5

3 

 ) )

     - 

    

0   "   -   = ,#&/7&#D/#'"#>#'"5#!>#&':!''#02/7"",!"",# 4!0"%#&,!2!$"#2/4'",#!;!02!'2,!2&/7:%""#2"",#</0%&2%$"%' ",#  07%"0!"0  !'2-  ",/&-  $!''"  7#  !55;#2  "  ;0%115#  /"  %"& !445%$!7%5%")$$02%'1"0)!5-&/7&#D/#'"#>#'"&D/!&!5#",# 5!'2,!>#!5&"!8#'45!$#'$!&#",#!44#55!'"@45!%'"%,!&&52",# 5!'27#)'2,%&&,!0#-,#&,!557#5%!75#"0#%:7/0&#!'2$:4#'&!"# 2##'2!'"&!'2+",#&!5#$'&%2#0!"%'-;,%$,;/52!5&#'"!%5 %'"#0#&"EF4#0!''/:!'2&%:%5!05)-2##'2!'"&"+&,!55!5& $:4#'&!"#",#45!%'"%&%'0#&4#$"",#&!5#2##2##$"#2%'!>/0

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

41356,1/    *)+%

786 '(-.&