Kartar Singh v. Addl. Director
!"#$%&'()*+( ,-./-.0 "12-"!/2
.3%3 !! / "-& .
%"5-6-"!/2
"/3 + 8 ,-./-.0 "12-"!/2
.3%3 !! / "-& .
%"5-6-"!/2
"/3 ,-./-.0 "12-"!/2
.3%3 !! / "-& .
%"5-6-"!/2
"/3
9 )(( ,-./-.0 "12-"!/2
.3%3 !! / "-& .
%"5-6-"!/2
"/3 )( ,-./-.0 "12-"!/2
.3%3 !! / "-& .
%"5-6-"!/2
"/3 :# ;<:
0 4<< ;<:
0: < 0
"/#$ :. 11-.=-&*!> -/ .3 :. 0-5=-*!! / "-&!> -/ "
.-&* %"5-6 :. ,-%32-&-"!:.:<0- " *!> -/
"/3 :.0,..-*!> -/ .:%" 7-&?? //
* 7-.
'=-' /2 3.!
.*= 32-&&! 373 > > &=. /7 / / "3 -3/2 '&-' 2-&& "1 //2 3-?
.-"!7 ./- "//2 3-?
&-"! - /3 -.
*2= > .*6 "1/-@ " .?
2 .37.-' . 33%-"
-=. / "/2 "-/%.
./ .-. A%-32 "1 .!
.3 !-/ ! + ""
B%.
$ -"! 988 ""
B%.
$7-33 !6'!! / "-& .
&! "13 -"! .!
. !-/ ! )988 ""
B%.
$+ 7-33 ! 6' /2 "3& !-/ "
. %"3 & .33%6? /3/2-/-3/2 &-"! "! 37%/
=-33%65 //. > .- / " /=-3 B &%!
.?02-?&-/ 2*-"!-&&// !/ /2 .3-"!/2 .3 - 0 "12-"!0 =-0 "123"3 -&0 "12* !%. "1 "3& !-/ " . ?.
/2-" ( '
-.3 ?7& / "
"3& !-/ "7.
! "13*/2 "/3 !-"-77& -/ "
%"!
. 0 / " 9+ /2 / 98 6
/2 !! / "-& .
/.* "3& !-/ " %"5-62-"! 1-.27.-' "1/2-/-3/2 '2-!
"-&&// 33&-"! "-"!6& @36%/!
"/&-"! ";;& @* /2 ... ?-' 6 .
! 2 !! / "-& .
/.* "3& !-/ "
%"5-62-"! 1-.2*> !
.!-/ !988""
B%.
$ ?-"!
!/2 .//2
./ B-? "
.!-"!
?-@ 1! /2 !
" ' - . 2 -. "1 /2 7-./ 3 2 "3& !-/ "
.* 2-3 > !
.!
. !-/ ! )988 ""
B%.
$+* .!
! /2-/
" ' 6 ?-!
1! .? 02-?&-/ 2* =2 2 6 &"13 / /2
.3-"!/2 7. .?-.
"/3*= /2%/-
.! "1-"77./%" /'
.3-"!= /2%/.
.! "1- "! "1=2 /2 .-"'
33&-"!2-!6
"-&&// 02-?&-/,2 =-/ 02-?&-/&-"!/2 /2-"&-"!6 &"1 "1//2 -" 2-'-/2 .3 2-&& "1 /
/2 3 .!
. 2-3 6
" .
! 6' !! / "-& .
/.* "3& !-/ "
%"5-66'2&! "1/2-//2 .3!"/-77 -./2->
3%
! -"' &33 -"! -3 ./- " 7 .3"3 = 7.
"/ 6
/2
"3& !-/ "
.*/2 .3= !%&'.
7.
"/ !7 .%3-&
.!
.7-33 !6'/2
..
> -&3/2-//2 7.
"
7. >-/ "/3=23%12/-!! / "-&&-"!-"!-/-B "37 /."6 2-&
:%" 7-&?? //
2-> 6
".
.!
!%"3 & -&33%6? /3/2-//2 .32-> 6
"!
&-.
!="
.3 " 0( /2 6'.
"!
. "1/2 ?7%1"
!.!
."%&&-"!> ! %"3 & 7. >-/ "/3 - .&' "
/2-/.!
!-/ !988=-37-33 !6'/2
.= /2%/-
.! "1-"
77./%" /' .36%/7.-'/2-/ " -3 / / "3 -.
-&&= !*/2 .?-'6 ? // /.*<-"!
.!3*
%"5-6*-&-"!2-.= /2-! .
/ "/!
.? "
=2 /2 ./2 =-3-"'
32./ -&& "/2 &-"!-&&// 7. >-/ "/3-"! " -3 * / 32 &!
/2-//2 =-3-"'!
" '*/.
'/2 ... %"3 & 0/-/ %"5-6-3= &&-3 %"3 &
:%" 7-&?? //
3%6? //2-//2 &-"! "! 37%/ 3-!? // !&'!
3 . 6 -302-?&-/ 2-"!*/2
*> 3/ ! "/2 -" 2-'-/6%/-3/2
.-? -" 2-'-/2-3 -3 !/ B 3/*> 3/3 ":%" 7-&%" &* 7-.2
5%!1?
"/-"!!
7-33 ! " ->%. .3 " 0(
3 & -.&' &&%3 > -3/2 0-.7-" 2?-!
-3/-/ ?
"/ "
! "1/2
&- ? .3*= /2%/-"'-%/2. 3-/ "..
3&%/ "6'/2 .-?
-" 2-'-/2 5%!1?
"/-"!!
!-/ !+7-33 ! " 0( *! 3"/6 "!/2 . 12/3 -" 2-'-/. /33% 33./2
:%" 7-&?? //
2-> 2 -.! %"3 & . /2 7-./ 3 -"! 7 .%3 ! /2
?7%1"
!.!
7-./ .?/2 - //2-//2 " / -&7 / / " !%"!
.0 / "
9+ /3%
.?-!
&-' '
-.3*/2 !! / "-& .
/.* "3& !-/ " &! "13* %"5-6* =2 & ! .
/ "1 /2 "3& !-/ "
./ B-? "
.!-"!?-@ 1!!
" ' "& @$ / *
- & !/.
.!-"'.
-3" "3%77./ 2 3! .
/ "32 3-7-./* %"3
7. >-/ "/32-> "
!/2-//2
7-33 !/2 ?7%1"
!.!
..
/.
> "1++9,-"-&3&-"! .?/2 02-?&-/ = /2%/-
.! "1-"77./%" /' .3..
.! "1-
"! "1/2-/ 33&-"!2-!6
"-&&// 02-?&-/ 23.
1-.!3/2
.!
.7-33 !6'/2 !! / "-& .
%"5-6* / "1/2 / / " 2-&& "1 "1/2 .7-33 !6'/2 "3& !-/ "
.*3%
3/3/-/ /2-//2 !! / "-& .
%"5-6! !"/! 3 ."/2 %"!-?
"/-& ...3 "/2 7-33 !6'/2
. "3 A% "/&'* /2 =. / 7 / / "3 -.
-&&= !* /2 ?7%1"
.!
.3-.
3 /-3 !
-"!/2 .3-.
? // /.*<-"!
.!3* %"5-6*-&-"!-2-./-!5%! -/ . 1 "-&7 / / " !6'/2
7. >-/ "/3 "- .!-"
= /2&-=- . "3 !
. "1/2 A% 3/ "
&-' " & "1/2 / / "%"!
.0 / "9+ / 98* B-? " "1 -&&.
>-"/! %?
"/37.
7-.
!!%. "1 "3& !-/ "*-"! " -3 */2 3 -"' 32./ -&& "/2 &-"!-&&// !/-"' "/3* "/ '/2 &-"!="
.3=2= -&&// 33&-"!-"! .? 33 6& * 7-33.!
.3 "- .!-"
= /2&-= 2 7-./ 3-.
! .
!/-77 -.6
/.<-"!
.!3* %"5-6*-&&-"!2-."88+(=232-&&!
= /2 "/2.
?"/23
;-1%//;