Dharam Pal Etc. v. Estate Officer Etc.















!"!#$
%  % &
'

)
 *
#
 ("
+


("
, ("-"
"



(.
#!#
 ((!

(/.
'

#!0 ('
# +
 "1# 2$
34
2
5
5
,6.


5
34
2
5

44
( $
2(
5-(!# (
 #'!.
7

("
2(
 !7!(
5
'

!*.
7

(
( "1#

2(


8
5'

() .
7

(
( "1#
%
999

'

(
( 1(

("

* *
1 ("
) /
:

**;


"

<-0) =

%

:

1(

("
(
# =
5


'

<-0)
"'-*
:

1(

!0 =

999

44


'

"
:

!* 
!"
#
( (.


> 

?##
AB.
( 
:/

"



(.
.
'

#!0 ('
?( "1#
B.
7!

;'! '
*

("

"
-#
4!

#"!#0

 #
5!

(7!

"
!#
'

#!0 ('
5 '

.

?

(
"'( .
C
5 '

3B.
"
:

*!# 

;(!

)-"
!"
*"
1( / 
!(

"1#
;

**!#0
-#!

7!**
2 -*!
 0( #.
.
'

#!0 ('.

("
#
:(!

"

-
:/

("
!"


)!0(

()

5

 )!*
 -
#
'


"

-1
!(

% '-00!

"
?- "B
!#
5

D.
#

:

*#0 

'

#!0 ('

'

;

"
!#'


:/
) #/.
;'
;

"!)!* (*/
1*

#
;

"
8#;#
"
2 "!
4 :-(
*#/
'

#!0 ('
)!#!"

!#!

1(0( ))

'-"!#0

:!*!

!#
 #)!

**/
;

(
"

!#"

" !

/
*!7!#0
!#
"*-)
#!

!#"
!#

* :-(
*#!

"
#

1(7!

)

*;
"

5 '

E
F
             G
?

(
"'( .
C 5 '

3B
;

()-*



'

5 '

#7!"

*1)

*
"!

"
(

".
;'! '
;


:

:-!*
:/

'

#!0 ('
-"!#0
 (
!

1-(1"


!

<'-00!
;

** ("

*#/.

"-(7 /
;

"
#-


:/
'

#!0 ('
)!#!"

!#
(

("
;

!#'

!#0
!#

*#/.
/
;

!""-
1(7!"!# *
!

("
#
%  


?## "


DB


(".
!#

()"
 5 '

11*!

"
#
'!(

1-( '

"!"

1"!

"-)

"H I

*#0
;!

!(
11*!

!#"
#
%D 


'

#
( !"


:/

: (
1"!

(
"-)

"H I

'
#
> 

.
;

*"
)

;!

:/

("
#

'

#!0 ('
)!#!"

;!

7!

;
#)

# (
5 '

E
F 
                  G
;'! '

!#
; 
 

%
"
*

("
;

#
1( /
'

11( '!"
-( #
!#

#

;
 "!#"

;(!

!#.
:

(!#0

DDD


A.

1(


:/

(".
;

"
!"1"

:/
'!"
-(
#
H

A.
;!

!(

"1# 
#"!

(".
!#

;!

'
* ;.
;!

'!#

"1


#
**/.

"



(
?( "1#
B.
7!

(
:

!#0
!*


> 

?##
AB.
( <

("
'

# *-"!#
((!7

:/
( "1# .
!#
"-11(
!

"
( (.
(

'-"$




  
 
  
 




  






   


 


 
 






  






 


  


 




 





 
 
  
!
" 
 #
$ 
"


 #










%


 
 

&

&

'

 
 


 



 
 
 




  





 




( 




 




  
)  
(

  
* 
+ 
,
 


 
 

 


- 
 
.,
  




(
 /
 
012


 
( 
 
 
3 
,
 
 




 
( 
 




(


 
(



(

 

 
(  












 




( 






(


  
* 
+ 


 
 


(



(

(  



  









  

 ( 





4

,  
 


 

  

6

7


 





(
3 
,

 
(
  


 6


-#"

*

("
"-:)!

#*/
(

"#
""!0# 
:/
( "1#


( <

("
!"

/
;

# -#
( "!!#0
!#

*#/

"-(7 /I"1
!#"1

!#
!#

/

(


.
;'

#

*/

("
;

!""-
!

(".
:

!#0
!#'

"

2 "!
*#/.
#
"!"

"-(7 /
#-

!#

/

(



5
)- '
".
!(
# *"
!#
)

7

(3"
*!"

48
5 :'

!#
!#

/

(


?##
>B
'-".

"#

'

"
:

""!0# *!#

!(
* !)"
!"
1 *1 :*/
((# -"
 (
# .
*


-#"

*
"1# #

#"

#
-:

("
;

!""-
1(7!"!# *
(".
1-("-
"-(7 /
#-

/

(


.

!(
# @!"

7

(3"
*!"

/

(


.
:-

/
;

# -#
( "!!#0
!#

*#/
-(!#0
"1 !#"1

!#
!#

/

(


.
;'! '
;

"I!"
# *
#!

!#"

-#
" '

!(
* !)"
;

(!0'

*/
( <


#
"-11(
'!"
#

!#.
'

#
(

!#"1

!#
( 1(

 %

;'! '
!"

#
#
( (
(8




(
*


-#"

*
(-"

("



;

1(

(.
!

;-*
:

@1 
(


*
A?B
#
"-:

?!7B
 .
;'! '
(

'-"$
51 2
8 



(

#





  


   


 



 

(


(


9
&
12

12

///
///
12


 
(  


4 ( 






:
)  

5'



 



  
12
( 


(



 
@

("
;

# *!0!:* #"!


-# (
!#

()"

A?B?!7B
#*/
'"

("#"
;-*
'

*!0!:*
;'
;

:# "
 :-(
*#!

"
1(!(

  A>
'

("
!#'

*#/
)- '

(
'

.
* !)"


("
-*
#*/
:

#"!

()"
 
" '

 

%
 "-*

*/.
!

;-*
:

!)1


*
D
 
" '

7!

;'! '
"-:

?!7B

A

5 '

;

"-:"


;!

**;!#0$


 


( 








 
 

 




;


 

  
 
:
)  


 

 ( 












  
  

<



"  ;


=0

< 

% 

< 

>0


(
 ( 




 
 6

:

*/"!"


"
:

:(-0'

!#
:/
7!( #)
#
 

%.
(

*"$

& 1 2

("#
"'

**
:

*!0!:* .
1(7!


'

I"'

!"
:# :-(
*#/E
#
1(2
;'"

#
!"
!# *-
7

(3"
*!"

/

(



J-!

(*/.
'"

;'
)!0(


(
"

-1
!(
'-00!

"
(
"

(-
1"

.
;-*
#
'

*!0!:* (
#"!

!#
-# 
#
'"

.
;'"

# @!"

7

(3"
*!"

/

(


.
-*

!)

:

!#'

!#0
!#

*#/
-(!#0



'

@1( ""!#
F

 


( 






G
( K-!( 11*!


:

:#
*#/

I ))

!#
2

#!#0
:/.
#
#*/

#

11*!

)-"

@!"

"
!#

7

(3"
*!"

/

(


.
:-
)-"

*"
# !#- 
:

:#
*#/
!**
'!"
* !)
(- "

#!

!#"




@!"


#

11*!

*!0!:* .
'

)-"

)

: '
'

!

("#
!"
!#

#
!#'

*#/
!#

/

.
:-

(.
'

*#/
(
"'!

"
(
)7 ;

@1*(
:

(
1 !#".

!#*/
'!"
!)

;-*
#



'

!"
';.

11*!

()

"-:)!


!#
()
FG
;!

" '

1"

-*

"$



      ! "  # "         $    !  !#  $  "

  ////
  %  !" % " "  # & '$ !     ' !#  $  "

  6

*

(*/.
11*!

)-"

!#
1""

""!#


))

!#
'

 -1!

"
!#

*#/
!**
!

#"

()"
!#

))

!#

,!

(


>% D.
'!"
-( K-!(

("

1*

#
( (

1( !(
( '

#!0 ('
!**


-
# '!#0
'

"
:

#
1*


#
( (
:/

("
'

1"!

#"

(/"

**!L

#0 ()

!#0
 ?

B


"
;

**.
;'! '
(

'-"$
 ?

  
 
  



 

 


(
 ( 

! 
 





  9
&
1 2
,
  

 

(








 
  
(
 
  

( 
 
  
 
 




(




#

 
 ( 

 

6
@

!"
*

(.
# !"

!# :* #/
)!" #"

(- !#
#

()"
 ("#
'!)"

)-"

:

"!!#0
!#

*#/
#
!"
( K-!(

*
1'/"!

*
1""

""!#

'-
(
"

(-

'

!)"

"

-1.
# ;!

'"

#!#0


;# ("'!1
4!8 ;!"

.
!#

:"

#/
0
(
( !:*
)

(!

*

"';

("
!#


;

*
1'/"!

*
1""

""!#

'- ?'-00!

"B.
/
1-(1( 
'

"

-1
!#

*#/.
-(!#0
"1 !#"1

!#
!#
 :(- (/


(.

!(
!0-(
7

(3"
*!"

/

(


.
!"

#

> #"

K- 
51
!#"1

!#
( 1(

 %

?2 (8
B.

*"

#
'-
(
"

(- .
;'! '

("
-*
* !)


:

;# #
1""


:/
)
;

-#
!#
@!"

:/
# 
"


'!"
1"!

!#.
( !#"
-# # (7

;(!

!#
5
)- '
".

0(!

*
"

#
"

'
!#

;(!

'!"
( (.
'

"
#

#
( :-


!# *-!#0
:/
!*!#0

#/
-#

7!


#

#- "'

**.
1

("

:# "

*#/
11 */.

1-(1"

"-0'

:

'!


7!

" '

!#
K- !#
;

"I!"

1(7!

'-"!#0


"*-)
;

** ("
-
!

("#


;

**
!#

*#/.
';
-*
'!"
* !)
:

"

!**


#/
 (
#"

(- !#
(
!#

(1(

!#.

-(
)!#".


".
;-*

7 (/
1-(1"

" '



#

;

:7 .
#
!#

!"
;

@ ( !"

@ (!# (/
;(!

<-(!"!

!#
-# (
( ! *
%%&
 #"

!#

#!




!#
:

!#0
7!
 (!

!"
(!#0*/
!")!""



( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 29.01.2016 Rajan