High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12788/1997dismissed

Central State Farm Hisar v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2026-01-13Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari15 pages

-1-

"#$

%&'

() *'+,-,(. /001

= 2

=#"

1&4 ($ &" . 30&" 1& 5 3# & $. "6 7777

8- 9& % " .*:!&

& " . " * * ;<-% . < ! ;+-

! ;!- $ %& .& & " % . " #!

:;%

&&) . $ % & '( ) # *+ & >& . *+,- 0 ". 1 % & &

" 1 % & (

&.& " %( / & . & $ 0.& &

& " & ( & 1 & & "

-2- % ( .$ % & & ?.@ %& .& %

&1 " ? ( & @E$ & . & " & & " %1 & % &%/&& %E

&%% '.&1& &

"$ ( & & %" %1 . ( .& ( & .

" 1 & & % & . " . < < & " .&1 & (

1 1 ;""4;* D;

+- 1& . * & '( 4( ) . +* " %& .& & 0.& "%&

1&% "

(& .%(1 1& . 1& ($ & A $ 0 .& &

& .

& $ % % & " % 9& & &% & F &

4 . & " (

& & . *+& ( $ & .6!

!&'( ( 4() ) B

!- . * * & .

".&(

9& &&" %& .& " %(&5$ % & & "$ % &%?( & @ (& .

" . *+9& . &&" .

-3- .$ & G " 18.- * & >&. *,-.. 1 .& 1& "$ && $ %& & .. & " ( 1 . % " . " % & & "$ &. *+%& .&" & + )& & 1& (

.& (% &" 1&(1&& " % %1&$ ( ( & " ;. "

% %&%/& & E ( &) (&& && ". " " .&1&1& & " . % / & * ( & 1 F %1 % "

D &&

&"&& ..6& $ &

". E

& % ..

.% &&. *+. 1& 1 1 &

" % 1 ( & & %& . 1 & " " & " %1 .. 1 &

% % " ..". ( 1 &

". "& . * . &" ( " ..' (

. * % &$

".&

"1 . &" %.$ & .

".. (.$& . % % 9& & "

. * %

-4- . & &.&" .

. . " 1% &&

"1 . & $ & (& & . . * . *+ " && " ;. " ( 1 .&&"$ & )& 1 & " .. .

. -&. *+ 1& ". % .

& & " .. .. 1 1 E & " & & .. & " .. &$ ( . % &%& .& &(.

& (

& & & " ( " & . "

& %& .& E (" ( .&

% " ((

! 9& & & & $ (

$. (& &" "&. D .

" & . & " " . "& "&&

"-% ( &A $

0.&&1 &

. *( $ & .

!% . (&

1H 19& %( "

" $&.

. * 1&" .& " & 9(1 % &" . -B& .

".C&

1 %?( & @ (;

-5-

! !" !

# !"

# ! !#$+ /% . * % % & "" .( & .. ( & 5$ ; %& ## ' ( 5

) *$+ " & . . & ($ . & & "" .( " & ( & 5$ 5$ .$ (;. -

-. - . ) & &

( ( $ . + & . . *&(

; < % * # # $+ .E.& ( & & (( ; %, - # #

! # ! !

* .

/ # 0)1

)

0)1 # !

2 # ' 3 2

-6-

! # # ! # # !+ .' "&( $ . & . / $ $ && ."%>( & , & ( 1 %& .& % . . "

. 1 ".

. & " %& .&

% % & & 1.

-. . & A ". ! . .&" .

( & % & &

1 '( &"

G( & . +D %& .& " " 1". 1 1 & + & '. " / & & " G & 5$ & " ( &"

"".

"$ $ " & . --'.&,%55<!

-;+9

)%23- 4'

'2'

+(33'2+,%5 (26%.,8%&,(.- -!

%.* 9%* :''.

2;..,.6 %- -

*'7%2&3'

'.&%5 (26%.,-%&,(.- %$ &5$ & 1 . & .

. " & " 4% %& .& & / $ &

1 1

( " .. 1 1& " 4

&( " ( & 5$ & "" % & $ &

$ $.&

& " 4

% ( & " - "( & " ;

; " % &

-7- %& .& % & ($ % ( & " 4

$ # + ! * * * &1& & ($ / . & & 5$ $ 1 & & +(33'2+,%5 (26%.,8%&,(.-

& & 3 .

& " 4

. & & $ ('. 1& ( .& $ & $ ('. 1 & . & (%; % $&# # #

# # # !

# # ##

6 ( . 7

2 8 2 8 9 8 2 :

: !

$ *$ & # # # #

# #

$ ;$& "# # 6 '# $ )$& "# # # # # # # $ 4$ & ##<# # " #

-8- # "

# # $ $ & "# # <# # "

$ 1$& '# ' ( '# '5 # # $

$& 5 !

'# $

= $ & 2 2 >5

$ & # #

# # "

$ *$ & # # 6 6 # ! ! 5 <# ## '# $ ;$ & 6 $ 6 # !"5 # # 7 6 # # $ )$ & 6 # #

6 #

# '# # #

2 '#

'# ? $ 4$ & 6 # !"# ! # ! 5 ! ! ## #

# # #

-9- # !

'# $ $& ! '# #

'# ?## $ 1$ & 6 "

" ! # !

# # ! '# 6 # ## # # ## '# $

@ ! ( 1. & ('. %& .& & ($ 3 . "& && "

. %&

.& .". 1 ( ." " .

." $1( % %&." $ "&.9& " . $$ . $ & . & "$ % ?

. 1 ".@ .& . $ & 1 "./ 1 %& 1 . 1(/ 1"&% % 1& " $ "9 $ " & %( $ &$ 1

" . /- & . . D %& .& .

&3. 1. ; @A #

@ # B #

# "

! "

# !

-10- !

# #

## !

! !

# #

# # # ## # "

# # #

$+ D $ (. &($ . & && ($&&" . % & & ( % > ., & ( & (& & . & .

" . & . .. 1 . &

. * %& .& . & "" .( . "(;. -

- . - . % &$( ( 1 $ % & ($ & " . & .& " &(. " 1% % &&"$ &. * ( 1&&" $ &. *+ &

"" .(" % &""'.

9& ( ('. & . * . ( 1& "

" ( " %& .& % . E "

-11-

( & % & .

&. " & / &%/ %& . " . <- & & . "" $

( & %& & & %/ " % " &". 1%$ &

& . - " & ?

? "@ & %

( & %& .&& . &

( 1""

. " . .-(;. - .

. !& . .

1&.4 /%

1 > ( & ,& ( (;.- - . %& .&; % % +

* C 0;

7 0)

<< << << <<

<< << << <<+ /% . " % & & . . . 1.. 1%& .&& 1 &(.

. ( &"$ & $ & .&"" .(& ( & & &

1&% .

% &&"$ & . &.&.&&% & ( & ("$ &.; %)$

$55

-12-

! ##

# EE$+ & '.& ./ "/& ('. &'(4() . *+ -%& .& &

" ( "$ &. & .

1 . $ " % % ( & '( .. 1.&. $ . &"" < 9(1 % & . - - >" .. , & &&" & "

% & % % (.

1 %&& ( & .

. &. . 1%1 1(1 .; %

,# - # # !

;F! D ! !

! #

# # #

3# 7

04*+

. <

" ( 1 " & 5$ . &4() & &" .. ("

&0%& .& &/"

" .. &.

-13- "$

. & ".

(;. -&( " & ; %;$ C 7 5B

& ( 7 G C 7 !

! # # = ! "# # # 0 #

5 * # 7>5 ;$ C 7 5B

& ( 7 G C 7 !

# # = ! "# # # 0 #

* # 7>

* &7 I

# 7 0

= (

FHD

*-F D # #$D

-14-

;

5 *

7 # $ H< << << <<+ +> +

$&"$

.($( & . "& "& . & (& & . & . * &. *+& 9&$ & " / 1 . " . & . * . ( ($ ( 1 & .&. *+%& .& ($ 41 * 9/ 1& & "&& & & ". " %& .& ( 1 "

. & . " " & 1 & " #!

:;%(" "A. ( D . . %"" " &($ % && )

% & $ ! 9&. &" && " & (

F&%&%/ / ""( &.% %& .&( 1. " ( & % " %1&% ( " &..& ) . ( $ . < & . *+ E & ($ & (. & " & & & & / ". ( 1 %& .& .E

1 &

"1 . 6 " & &

-15- " &((" &. " & E (

"1 . D & %/ & ($

. & &

$ ( .. &.(.& & % " *,-3,--'*

& % " /00 / & 1

)&&"/ 1: )&&"( I I:6