Ram Kumar And ANR. v. Amir Singh And ORS.
!
"
!
!
# $ %
$ &$ " # $ %
$
%&
$ &$'
'
(!
)* +
,
!)*
!
- &
. ! */
*/
)* &/ &
& ) )*+
,
!
!
!&
!0
#
2
&
)*
)/
/ .
3 1 4 !
!
*
0 )
!
!
) &)
!
&
/
) * 5#67
()*+ '
$3
8( 1 8( / /
9:4
;
9<
!)
/ /=
8( 3
1/
.
) - ) & &
8( .
.
/ .
).
> 8( & ) ) / 9:4
!
& :9?&
/
/
&
/ 3 1'
!
!
(! :9?'
!
(
!
!
- & *
/ @A"
/ */
)* / @A"8 ' (!
)*,
*9?/
@A", "
: ' &
& (! :9?&
;/&
&/
* * )
)*
/ / ;/&+
,
(!
)* &
*
!!
#
' */ (
*/ )* !/ $ &*
! !
* ' &
*
) )/ $
1 $
#A
! !
*
1,
)/ $
!
)
*
1'
!) )*
)*
=
,
$&/
4
! & !
& /
) ) / / !
1' (! :9?
< '
/
!
/
;
!
! / )
)4 !/ 0
'
!
/
)
&/ / )4 &/
!(! > &
!
/
!(!
)* +
, 4 !
!
*
)* , 0 !
;
(!
-./0(1(2 -234 5+% -66( (47+48(9 4(20
-5-: ,'
&;9/6;20( 4(:(.(*4- (;
2;*479 5+% &;9/6;20( 22(./92( (1.(*4 &/1(9
,
-5-: , (20 -+4/207;
(9(-2 (20 (2;*479 5+% 7;372- (- (20 ;*479+
%-/
( !
/ )!
? > &
!
(!
)* +
,
/
&
) )
/ )*
, 9 - / )
)*
! &
C/
)/ / .
3 1
) 67 *& ; .) , A *
&4/+4- (1 (20 ;*479+ 5+ (8(:
-234 (20 ;*479+
;2:-27 )/ / )
* *
(
;
+
* ' ,&/
*
! (!
(1 4(9(2 !(++ 5+%
-9<(2(20-2-
, * *4
!)
)
/*
)
* ) ' , /
! # "....................In the first place once it is held that the transaction being a family settlement is not an alienation, it cannot amount to the creation of an interest. For, as the Privy Council pointed out in Mst. Hiran Bibi case [AIR 1914 PC 44] in a family settlement each party takes a share in the property by virtue of the independent title which is admitted to that extent
by the other parties. It is not necessary, as would appear from the decision in Rangasami Gounden v. Nachiaopa Gounden [(1918019) 46 IA 72] that every party taking benefit under a family settlement must necessarily be shown to have, under the law, a claim to a share in the property. All that is necessary is that the parties must be related to one another in some way and have a possible claim to the property or a claim or even a semblance of a claim on some other ground as, say, affection.................."
*& ,
(!
)*'D!8
&(:7 (20 ;*479+ 5+% !7./*= !-97)*;9 ;> ;2+;:-0(*-;2 (20 ;*479+
% - /
(! & )
* ) )* , /
(
;
+
* / 3.
1
'
0 (
/ !0 !
(! 8
/
!
0 / )
*B
!
)*+
,'+
,
!
! */
(
*/ )* !/ $-
!
! $ !
)
#A
! !&
) - &
0 *)
/
&4/+4- (1?+ )(+7
+/.9( & )
)
+
,
!
)
*&
/
) A
)
/
4
- , &?&/
/
)(
/ &
!
)
* -
) )* / /
' & /
/
(* * *& !
)
*' /* )
!
!
-/
*9<<&, !
& 4 ! /
*)
)
) #A
!
!&)
) !'
*)
/)* ,
(1 4(9(2?+ )(+7
+/.9(/ /)
&4/+4- (1?+ )(+7% ; &0 /
!
)
/
!
: '
!
)*+
,
/ ) )
3 $1 !
*
>
!
&@A"
$
/
)/ 3.
1&/ / 4 !),
,&
!
!
!
) * 0
!
< ' !
)*+
,
-
&C
7 !
& !
;/& A
E
.
) )* /&
- , &?&
-
&
*/ */ )*
/ '
)) )* /- &+
,
/64 (20(2 -234 7*)% 5+% (1-(* -234 (20 ;*479+
) '
,
* (! - &
!
/
#
)* & /
!
!
/
& * /
) * ! ; & (!
*&+
,
()44(**(9 -234 5+% 1*% (3-9 &(/9
-
(! &
) * 5#&
!
)
*- &
(!
)
/ (!
&4/+4- (1?+ )(+7
+/.9(% -*)
!
*+
!(! &
2 &2FG 2?
'
! )
!
H
!
(
!
/
)! &/&
!
/
'*
!
) 4 /
/ -
&
)
*& /&
)
(
!
)
? )
&(!
)* +
,
'
/ 9
!
*&
$ &$ 4
!
2
4
!5 I 5% 2 ) I 5%