Chand Rup And Others v. Parsanni And Others
! " #$%!&' ()* + #,-,
./0$10"$2
33'-* 4 '-* ).5 63)
! ""
!
#$ %&' (((((((
1
"" ) "!!
!"
" " !!
" * !"" ) +,
!
-
!
"
!!
"
.'/'/ "
%.'/ %0'/ - 1"- 2
" "" 2 "!!
2 ")
""
" " " *
- 1"- 2
! ! "!!
"
!
" !!
"!!
! "2--! 2
#/$) ! "
2
! ! "!!
,
!
3
! *
3 " " ! 2 "
! ! "!!
"
! "--
"
1 ! 2"
! "! "!!
!"5 .
2"
. ! " "" " "
! "!!
" !
!"" ) 6 77777777877777777 8 8 9"* 87778777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 888888
! " :
!#/ "!! :
"!! "!! 7777777777777777777777777877777777777 8888 * 6 :
6 7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777 8888888 *"
0 9
! "!!
2 #/! !9
!" ';1"
/;"
2 /! ""!!
! "* ! 6
!
#/ - ! ))"
" " "!!
" < 2 < !
"
9 " " - /=%/ "" >!"-
"
2
"!!
#/ ! !"" ) + "!!
"" " " 2- #/ "!
:
#/ ""
.??@) - ! "!!
"!
>
"!!
"""
"
!" ! "!
:
#/""2 "
" "
"
2- - ! "
"
- - "!
9 ! .??@)""2 #/ !
--
5 ; 9 !"-
"
/0?;/=%/ "!!
/ ???@) #/
!! -
!
!
.??@) - 2- - ""/='?2
:
#/!"
" - /=%$ !
""
/
A
1 ! "2!"
! !"-
"
/0?;/=%/ ! .././=%$
2-""
A9
3
! "
! 9 ! !"
" ! 2A
A
1
"! /@. "2 2 #0/$! /=B? 2 ! 9 ! !"
-
1
" ! "
! /@. - "
1-
" !
"
/0?;/=%/ !"- 2 #/ $ :
1"
"
/0?;/=%/ #/ " " "
?%?./='/ ?%?0/='/ #. ' .?
! ! ! ;?
???@) 9
-
2"- ! "-
"
#/
! "
6
! 2 ! 2
"
-" 2"
" !"-
"
/0?;/=%/ "
"
.'?//='/ ! ! : ! !
#.?
! !.?-
2 - !
! " "!!
9 ! "
2 "!!
,
! !"-
"
/0?;/=%/2
"!!
" "
"2--!
% :
#/ . 0 *
" )" "
"!!
" !"
-
!/@.
/@B /@/% ! #/ . 0 "
"-9 " ""*
1 "
"!! #0
!
""
C" 2 #/0B!.$?0/=B%"
!"
!
! 2
!.$?@)2 "!!
2 ! !"
9 ! "!!
!"-
"
/0?;/=%/ ! , "
"!!
.??@) - #/"
2- ! ! #.' #.?
"
!"
! ! :"2 2- #/ 9 - ""
"!!
" ! ! ",! - 2
"
"
9 !"
2-
#/2 #0/$ /%?;/=B? "
"! /@. "
2 :
#/
!"
"
" 2- ": A
A "!!
!"
"
" * #/
-
B :
#;'.?
.?
*
" ! "!!
"
1 2- #/0 "
2- #/ "
" " ' :
#/= .? $0 $% !"
"- "! "!!2
1
"! = :
#= /; /'
./ .= 0/ $.
$B %= !"
""
!"
2- #/= .?$0$% /? "!!
)
" "
"
!!
!"" )
/ D "!!
/ "
.! " ! !!
EF
. D -!"-
"
2
"!!
/ ! !!
EF
0 ,!
#. !
!"-
"
EF
; D "
%.'/ %0'/ ! ! .'
@ "" 2 "!!
/./0! "EF
$ D "
.'/'/! ! .?
& /$! " "" 2 ! "!!
EF
% D "!!
! " 2 ! !"-
"
EF
B D "!!
" !"
E
F:
' D 2"
!EF:
= D "!!
! !"
E F:
/? D 2! )* !
-
E F:
// D 2 EF:
/. D 2
"- " !
!
* EF:
/0 D 2 "
!
* EF:
/; D "!!
! !
!!
EF:
/$ D "!!
!"
!
!
- !
!
!!
EF:
/% " ! // ! ! !"""
! .'?$/='0) / D "!!
= !
! !!
EF /. G /=?;/=';
#/) ! "
!"" ) / D "!! 2
! - 2--!
! !!
EF /0 " !
2"
. ! " "
2 A
!
! ! "!!
!!
F
#.0 "
2A "
"
/0?;/=%/ 2
2- #/
!
2 ""-
"" !!
! " ! -2- #/
2 " ! -
/;
!6
/=$%
3 "- "
"
2- " "
" "F
#% " "!!
! " 2 ! !"-
"
C4/ "
2- "!!
- 2
! "2- - !
! !
D"
#'/$ "
2A "
!"
2- "!!
2"
2*
! " !"
2- 2
!"
!
!!
2*
! 9 "!!
#= "2 "
" ! !
#/
!!
9 ! "!!
" "-
/; 9 "!!
!"
"
"
#
! "!!
!"
"
" /$ , "
"!
)21
! 2 "
/%
"! "" 2"
! "" 2 ! "
" ! " " "
"
))"! #/
" "
" " " ! ! /B > ! "1 2
2-"
" ! ""
""2 "
"1 "
2- "!!
"
" 2-
#/)
, /! " "!!
2 ! !"" ) +/9 :
#/
! """ '; "
/; "
#0?
#//0 //'
/$B1"
//" #/
2 /@. 2 #0/ #//= //=@/ 0. "
/. " #/ 2 /@B
#;.
#/0'
.? "
/. " #/ 2 /@%
*2 ! - /=B')B= ""- " !
2- "!!
#=.? #./%=
A2 5
, 0! " "!!
""
! ! - 2- #/
, $! "
" ! " " "-
"
"
/0?;/=%/
>
"2
"
/0?;/=%/ "!!
" "
"2--!
/' H 2
"!!
""
! - 2- 2- #/! /=
"! "" "
!"
2"
4 )/ !"" ) 6 77777777777777777777877777777777777777 8 8 A
1- 777777778777777777778 887777777777777777778777777777777 6>888 7777777788877777778 * 8 88
I " 98"*87777777777877777777777777777 :1 8888 > 9>>
.? ))"! "! !9 #$$ /;?%/=0B9 H 2-@ /=0B"
2 !
! )
"- #/ - /=;% !
!6
/=$%F ! -
!" "
!9#=. /$?%/=;% ! ! "" ) "!!
2"
! D ! )
- ! "
" 6 D J - /=0B " K ! /=0BJ !
/;?;/=0B ! !9 H 2-@ /=0B !/=0B !
- "" ) "!!
!"
" 2 ! ! ""
1 ! " 2 "
2- ! "" ./
" ! "" - " "
! !
"
!2-9! ! "" ) "!!
.. :
!
"
" ! ""
"
"
2 2--! ! "
! - /='/
"! " 0$ - - !""- !""-
"
"
"! ""
"
"
" 2 !
! "" 2
! !
"!!
2 "" " -2 ""
" -
- - 2
!"
! "
!" # $
% & ' '&
'
% % &
% "( ()" *#!
+ &
%',!
-
% ."( ()"/.
#'+ 0 % 0 * "( ()"** # 1% & & " 2 3#
4 + 5 0 '
% ."2 * # 2 '6 7 5) 0 "233# 58&%%& '
% 3 "2 .0 " F % "
/B !"
2- "" ) "!!
2- ! "" 6
"! !"
"
2 ! ! "" ! !" F !" ! " .$?0/='$
"!
!?%?;/='$
"- !"
!4 ! ?0?$/='$ ! F?0?$/='$
"! " "" - * !4 .B?$/='$! " 9
"2 1 .B?$/='$ 1 ?B?'/='$ * ! " !/??=/='$
" ""2
* "" !""-
.////='B " ! * ! "
!
"" "
" ! " ) ""
! "- !!"
"
#.$ '/$ ! "! /0! *
!"" ) +/09 "
"!
! ! ""
" "- ! ! "
"
#.
;
$ '/$9 "
"! "" ! !
#; $ "" !
#.0
! "- ! !"-
"
) "
#;$ "" 2
!! ! "" 6 !
! !
! ! "
"
"" 2 "9 ! ! "
"
"" " 5 .;
"
"! "" " "
" ! "" 2 ! ! "" ! "
2
/02
2
""
9 ""
" ! ! "" !!" .$
2
1
2 2 !
"1 ! " 4
"
" "" 2 "
"1
2- ""
""
"
! H "- , 1 "
2- ""2
.0?;/=%/D
-
""-
,! " !
"
!
- 2- ! ! "" 9
2-"- ! "!!
"- 9 ! 2 - "- - -- -
2 "!9 C" "!
C4/ " 2- "
" ! ""
!"" ) +,
@ "* A #2@> @ " ! "" > " A : " %? >
" ) "! "" > 2- L7
17
)7, 7-
- #38,19 +7-7#-7
:+ -
,;,
; #+++< =,7 $<0 -7 , - 2 2 " "3
" 2! "2 1
7# 1,+,--++ , +7 =, 7/+ +7+ 7# -7 # :+
-
,:-, ",7-;,9+,=+ 9/:5 7
:/9 +7-7
)7, 7 -! /???@) "!
$??@) !!! - !.?/; .?/' -! ""1
- .??@) ! "!
!
- - ! H - !"!" ""1
" "! "!
,
!" - !
"" "
"! 2 "" 2 "
" " 2- - ! "
--- "
D "" - !
- "" 2
,
"
"
- ""
!
"
""
"!
. 9 ! A
! "" >
- 2
2"
"" " "" "
"
- "
2--! "
"" 1
! I .??@)
- - ! H 9- ! /???@)
! ! ! - !.?/;.?/'! ""
!H ""
,
- 2 ! .??@) ! "" 2 "
" , " !
3
! !
"2 2 1 - - 2 ""
0 ! "* - "2 , 2 "! ""
D *6!"-, 2 ! * 6 !"- 9 !
, 2 "! "
"" "
!""- "" "" ) "" " - - !
2
!2
1 !
2
"
D 2
""2 22- !
/0;/=%/ > 1 > 9 .?/'5 .% " ! 2
"
" ! " 2- - ! .??@) - !!
"9
"
"" " ! " 2
"
"
!"! 2
!
/; ! 6
/=$% 2 " ! - 2- 2 -
"
"" " " -
"
" 2 " "
" 9
! "!!
"-
"
"!!
"
> "- *
"
2- "" ) "!!
.B 9 !"
"! "" "
2
2- - ! ! "
!
! " 1
! "
"! ""
2"-!"-
"
"" "
2 2--! ! " "" ,
4
! "" ) "!!
" ! ! ""
" 2- "
" ! "" .' >- - ! "" ) "!!
!
! 9 "- ! ! #$$ /;?%/=0B ! ! - !2
!" "
" "- !
.= :
!
"
" ! "" 1
2
!
-!* ! - "
" 9
!
2"
2 "2
1 - 9 *6!"-
- -9 "
!
2 "1 ! - !9
"!) 3 - 0? ! !9 !
! ! "- ! ! 2 6 2 ! !
! 6
/=$%
! 2
" "-"
"!
9
!
2- ! 2
6 3
! H "- !!
! "
" 4
! ! 2 ! !
M
"- !
- " 2- " "
" " ! " !
! 2 0/ > 2 3
" - 2
!* ,! : > * !
! 9 ' '%( & '
% 3 5 8.*
! 2
!
/B?;/=$;! ! !
")
" -"
!2- 29!
!"
2- "" "
! !
! 6
/=$%
!
"
""
2- "" "
D"
4 " : > ! B '
' '> " !"" ) +B # / " ! < "!
"!
)
!
"" ! -"" "
! " "
" ! > ,
! "- "-! ! 2- ! !
2"- 4
")
" - ! ! 6
"1
2 ! > - -- ' 9 6 2<
!2 "!! 2 "
! 2 !"" 4 ! > "!""- !
3
! !
- 2 " 2 2
) 2 ) 3"! 22 ! 2 F ! 2 - "
"
!
9
""
" ! F
4 ! !"" - : "!
"
"- 9
"
! 4 ! " "
" 9
- 1 "
F <
2>"" "
!
' ! "
#22 ! !
! - ! *2 "
!
!
2 !
! 6
"" "
" "
" - )
" - " 2
2 " >
;!
"
*2 -
!
!
! '9
!: " .3 ( ,
" !"" /=.. :
<
/=0% "
2
" "
" " <
9 "!! ! !
" ! 9
" -
-
2- "!
/=.. /=0% ,2
"!
1 "
9 6! ,
/=.=
H 2-/=.=
9 ""-" !
!
"- < < < -1 4! ! < ! 2 ! ! < 2 9
"
!
" "
!
"
7 >-+,
+7+ : #
,-,
, +7+-;-;7+7+7 = +,
#+7 +,-
+7 :,- #+7;,
;7: =,, $% 2;- = 9/ #---,
-- ,#, 9/ + 0 #$%0% , ;,+7+7;, # , $%00;7 7:-1+7-+# ;
7 , + ;- 7 9/ +7 ,, ::,++ # +7 ,=/ ,+7+. N "!
!
6
2
"- - -
" " " 2 4
"
" "
! 6222- " 2 !""!
N '29 - "! 2
M N9
! 2 " ! <
O -
" 2
!
2! " ! 9
! 2< !"" 3
!
- ) "
!
-
!""
2
"
! 4 -! !"!
"
9 !6!
"
"- " " !"" 2
"
, "!
-
2"-M
2
2"- "" ! 2 " 2
! 9 ,
"!
! !
"
*-
""
"1 9
< "!
! !
"
"-!
1 2-
- 2 "! ! ""
! 1 ! 4
!
N 0. 6J2"
: > "
1 ! 2
"
1 ':
& 35 8.* : > ! "
! " "
"
! !
"
!" "
" 00 6J2"
4
!:
- & :% " '&2
'
%: 0 .";%%(' ( % "
" "3
%! * !"" ) +%#!
"
!
"
"
2 ! " "
" " ! "
D<
" 2
2 D /=%0 ,
" 2
2 !
' ! 6
9 6 "
2
2- !
"
!!
'! 6
"-
- " 9
6 "
""
2 " !"" - , " 2 2"
"
" 4 " "
" ""- "2 !!
,!
"1 "-
! " < -! "1 "-2
"
! " 2"
" " "
" < "2 " !
"!
! " !"" < 5 0; 6J2"
4 "
1 ! "
"
2- - " $! * !"" ) +9 - 2 , "- " 2- - "
' 0'
) 0% 0 % 2 * ( 7
3
" N
6
! 2 !"!"
2-
P
) && 7 % ''%< 3. /)
1 "!
)
-9 "
!
2 " "- !
!"-3"!
6
"
2
! ))","
2
- "
!
"! ! 2>
"
+,+7+:, +,
#,+1,+,-,:
--,9+ -/ ;7 +7 -
-;7 ;,9 +,+ + - - 7,- #+77-9
! 9
! 2 " ! <
+7 +:, +,
# +7+ -++ +7 +/ -
- + +7 -;7 ;
7=9 +77,-++77-9
,# 77 ,= 6+
, ++7:
: + #7 +7
"N , 2
3
:( ) 0 .3/ ( " - " 2
N "!
!
6
2 - ----,
,-
"- --
+7+ +7---,
;
+ + +,+7;,
; ,
"2 4
"
" "
! 6222- " 2 !""!
, 2 !
"
"
N-
N
!
2
< ! 6 2 *3 "
; 3
!
!
-
! ! 6"
7? --,
:/: -@, +7-
#, +-+/ #,
:N9 "
!!
+7 :+,- , + # +,: 9, +7 + ;7 +7 ---,
-1 :/1 +7 +7 # +7 ;,
; F !
6 2
4
2- >! ! "
!A
5;
0=% ) 5 * . " 2
, !
" ! <
2"
- "" 2
"
2M A+: +7,= 87 #7,=%)B %' *+ 2"C 7 ---,
-
+ + +7 7,- # +7 7-9
+, +7 +:, +,
# +7 ;,
;6- -++
,+- +:, +,
1 +7 +/ -
- + +7 - ;7 ;
7=9 +77,- #+77-9
#77 ,= +
, + +7 :
: + # 7 +7D
' 0'
)0%-0'
- * ."
*.N , " 2
- " N-
N "- N
!
-!6"
N "
!!
9
- ! ' 9
- 2 ! % N "
6
!
! N6
"
"- ! ,
' "- ! !
-9 " !
2- - "
"- ! ,
- " ! 6 ! ,
/=.= 4
! 6
/=$% !< 9
! ! N-
N 6
9 N
"
6
!
! N
% 2
'
4 "-
! 9 !"" /
! " . " !
"
5 0$ , !2
"
!" 2 3
0?2
! "
2- "" 2
"-
2 0% # 1 ! !
9 ! " !
! ! "!
! ! 9 :
- & :% " '& 2 : >; ?" - /=;%>- !/=0B !
0! 2 !"" ) + = +,
# +/E'$*D 6 2-# "!6"
"
- - 6 2- -
" ! 6 " 2- - "
"
- ! "" "" 2*
2)
0 2 "
! -
!
$ !
"" "1 ! !
"" "1
J ! J !
$ %&
"" "-
& & !
!
. D 6 2- -
" !
6" # "2- - "
!
6*!"- - ""
2*
2)
0 -
"!
0 -
" 6 !
"" 2 "
1 6 J
"" ! " "
; 9 !
"" "-
2- - "
!
2- ! " 2"
"
- - ,
/=.$ "
5 0B
0 2
! )
"" "1 ! ! )
2 ! )
!9 - !
0! !/=0B 9!
! ""- #=. /$?%/=;%! ! "" 2
! #/0% .??'/=$B! ! -"
!2-9 "1 2*
!
0 0! !/=0B ! !
6
/=$% 2
2 " ! - 3 2- 2 !
! 2 9 " "- " !
/;
. " 2"
- 3 2- 2 !
!6
/=$%9 3 2- 2--!! D""-
! " !
2
- 2
2 " ! -
! ! 2 "
Q 2-
/;!6
/=$% 0'
" ! "" "
: > *
! 5
'
%9 82
'
% * :%" * !
3 2-2 ! !
!/=0B " "
-! 2
/;! !/=$%9 2 2
2
2- : >
2
"
2 !
!
!/=0B "
!:
- & :% "
'&2 : 0 ; "/
!" "
" ""2 " "
! ! "
2
2
" 3 - !
0! !/=0B ! ! - /=;% 0=
" ! "" !
! - "
/;!6
/=$% 2
2-6J2"
4 :% "8-2 '
%$ &
'
% . "(( , 2
"
2 2 !
! ! /=0B9 ""
!
- - -
- !!
" " "-1
! ! ! 2
2"
! ! !
9 3
!
!
2!" 3 2-
0 ! ! /=0B 2 "
/;! !/=$% ;? F 4 ! "
2
2- - ! ,! "" ) "!!
"
2"
"" "
"-
"! 3 "2 "
""- 2
4 2
""
*
-!
"! " 0$- 9 2- ""
" ;/
2
2- "" " "
!
!
,!
,
! "" ) "!!
! "
! "" 2!
"" ) "!!
#
"" - ! 9 ! 9 !
!
! 9 "- ! ! ! "-
2- "" -
""
!
!9! ! - /=0B""/='$ -
"
! ! " ! "! " "" 2 " "-
"
! , / ! " -
2 ! "9 -! 0! " ! - 2- , - /=%/
"!!
2 ! - "" !"
"!!
"-
! -
! - "
""
"
;.
3 "!-2
,!"
"! " !- * ! 2 " ""!- !
;0 # 2 "3
!" 3
"
:
'
* /0$10"$2 √ @% % '8%%,%% ' %%;' %AB%C'