High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3927/1994dismissed

Bachan Lal And ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ANR.

2024-05-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra14 pages

!""#

$ %

"&!""# ' ("&((#) *+

! '!""#((#

* ,-* . .

.' /

,-* . -- $ %&' "()(&*( +(,- ./(0+ "*(0(, &(,- ./( "1 ((- ./(( "+((+&(- ./( 2+ ' ("&((#+ " ($- ./( 2+ '!""#((#+ ""( $+- - )(% "().- ./( 2 34 )(%"( ( .

.' /

0 6 /%++0(27/77+ 2/( /82+( /9 /- 6:;8+(22+/(,, (+</26:;8<-% (,

" (27/77+ /,(( /=2+ </26:;8< +2-%++0((7(%,2 %/7$ / + $+(/77. / ! + ( 2/( %/(7 /.,& !!>?6;;6( 6>>!6;;! 3 +((7(&-+2(/2%++0 ((&9 %((,& ,( 1%2 3 ' ("&((# 8 + 1 + 9 (+$ 2 + (/9 2/(+ +7-+(+&( $ ( (07,,.+(/9 ,( + - ,+(/9 2/((9 (+ -+%&+&0 , % . 2+ ,& / 2,.,+ ".

- (,/ +( + % , $( ( /2+(/9 ,( ( ( ( (,, 9 2 + ,.( %,/ + (/9 2/((%( ,(0-+2-+&%9 (+ ( +,( %,( 27(/9 1%2 3 '!""#((# @ + 1 9 (+$ 2 + (/9 2/(+ +7+(+&+(./ / % , $ +(/9 ,( %& $+ $(7 ( ((, $ +% +27+&(($+% -( /+ +&/ +(2+ %)/,( (,( 27(/9 + -+&0 , % . 2+,& /2,.,+ ".

/2+(/9 ,( ( (((,,9 2+ ,.( %,/ +(/9 2/((%( ,(0- +2-+&%9 (+ ( +,( %,( 27 (/9

$5466

32781 % $ 83 2792626

)+ = +,( / ,2+ %7+( 0 %,/&0(7( 2+(/9 2/(0.- ,($ (% + (7- + 2, %)/ % &2+($0($.+7 +&2 +/ +(,, (+((0((% +2(2+%)/ ? +/ ,2+2 +/ +(+ 0+ /7,&$+7( (&.7% / @A 2 + </ 2 6:;8< (+ +(. (1 + /,((B2/( ( 6>>!6;;! +2- + ,( / , 2 + / +( + (/9 2/(( 9 (+ %)/,( (.( ( ( /+ (9 %9 (+ ( ( : # 2+($ 7-+,( / ,2+ +(.,(/ ,(/() $7 %&+C /(, (

# $%

& '

() * + ,+-.

+ ,.((($(+0+2(C(/ +(2

! !

# " !" # " $ %

## " ##

' '

# # # (((( (((( ((((

)

" * #

# #

" ##

# "

! ) #

# %

+,, - )

, % !

% $ #

#" "

% !

!" "

! #

./ 0

1 $ - "

% " ## "

% !"

# # $

# # ! "

# )

! %

" 1 $ -

(((( (((( ((((

) ! % !

" #

% !

# ' !

# # #

2 ;

+-,(/+(%7( () $7 %& +C /(, (<D7 /( ( (+ (2(&((( +<-0+/+.,(,88@?2 !>63%/(7($ +,.((($(+2+( . /(

! C(/ +(2 ) /.0 -

-0

+) & -

3 ) #

# #

" # #

) " ! # " $ " #

% #

% "% 4# #

# 4 # # $

(# # "

% # ! "

/60 "

- " !

# # $

# -

# #" "

## # &

! - 7

) "

# &

) #

8 "

## # &

# % "% " -

/60 "

5 9

- # 1% ## #

##" " "

# ! " -

$ "

" 8

# # !

# " #

" # " $ % ## "

" &

'# " $

# # /0 " #

% !

/ 0

: ! #

# #

" # #

# $ # #

# ## # &

# # #

## # &

/0 )

" 1 $ -

/60

% #

1 $ - $ # #

# #

/ 0:

# #

# :

% !

;

( #

# /0 1 $ - " "

% " ## "

% !"

# # $

# # ! "

# )

! %

" 1 $ -

(((( (((( (((( 2 6> #9 ,-+,( / ,2+($ +(/20(2(,+($%$$( + %&+ - $+/ 2+ // - 7(1$ ( +($ + %)/- ( %/(7 2 /@A2+</26:;8<-+ -+.,(2+ /,2

# % +%&++(. % ) 2(%,&/ 7 +( 66 #/9 /- %7 %2+ +(+ (%.%(/+7( +/,2

# % + %+2/(2(/9 0++,,/9 /2

& + %$ .( ( +%& + %/7$ 9 % (+ ( ( $ )04

) 5!

! 6!

%)/ (,/( + (/9 / $%/(7 %7 %&+68>:6;;6 +( %)/-(%/(77( ($(+ (/2/8 2/(-+( /9 ,,/-,E((7- )(%. ,*B %(+(A6;:3- ( >;>;6;;6( / + %)/ 7( + 22/ "(1 77(66"!>>;6;;6( 0+(7(+(+ %)/-( %/(72, %& +7+(,, % / (+ (+( /-84+()) (7/ + /!>>;6;;6-2+7,2(0,,(%+(,22++ ( /(,,&+( (-++($2+%)/ 0(7( 0.

-+%)/(%/(72, %&8A +()) (7 /@A2+</26:;8<2+7,2(0,, (2++(+, // -+ $+%/(7/ % 0 )/ %& + ( /9 ,,/ +(2- + /,(( /=2+</26:;8<%/(7 %,+ 00(( +,( (2 %,/(2+ /,((+ $,+ % 0(!=>!6;;!

+-+(,2, /,(7 /;2+</26:;8<8%/(7 %2+( /9 ,,/!:6>6;;!( (, 7( ((7%+(,22(,,+ +(2-(0( ( !8>!6;;8 0( / ( + /7( (7 %/(7 + 2 + (/9 ,( %/(7

; ( 7 + $+((!!; ( !8>!6;;8 $ )04

) 5!

! 63 !=-6>63( 6=+(.2, %)/ /@A2+</26:;8< +-0+ 2, %)/ 0 $. +($ ( + 7 2 +($ 2 + %)/%&+( /9 ,,/6-!-?-:- ;-68( 6@0!>>;6;;6-(+72+($2 %)/ /@A2+</26:;8< +%)/( %/(72, %&+0 ,&/ ( )/ +(2-+ /,(( /=2+</26:;8<%/(7

%,+ 00(( +,( (2 %,/(2+ /,((+$,+ % 0(!=>!6;;!

+- -6-3-@6>-6!-6@( 6=(,2, /,(7 /;2+ </26:;8<?-:( 6=%/(7%2+ ( /9 ,,/ !:6>6;;! ( (, 7( + /. (7 +(2- (0( ( !8>!6;;8 0( / ( + /7( (7 %/(7 + 2+(/9 ,( %/(7( 7 + $+((!!;

( !8>!6;;8 3 % 3276

$2 68

+(%($ +(2-+($ 7 ( %2+ %&+/ ,2+()/ ( +($ 7( %2+ %&+,( & ./( (,- )(%(0,,(+/( +,&2 + +0((// 6@ $2/(,&-AA2((

// -

( +/ ,2++( 0-+(./2 ,& %7 -0+,,&$ +C ,(2,(0 (( /( +) $7 (7( %&+C -+ 9 (2 0(2(,+($%$$( +($$. A(+, // -.A(A.+%)/-+(/9 2+ %)/ ,( -+%&+/,2

# %/(7%(/+ % +%& + ,( , // - %/(7 / 7

+( ,(,&-+%&++(/ +(+(/9 2/((.( ( (9 %9 (+ ( ( 6= 0.-0+(((/,( $2+ ,&(22 (.-% +$( &- %7 %&+ ,( (/ ,DA3;!?A6;;8-+(/6A (/+((, /( ( 8A+()) (7-+ ( ( + 77 +7- 7( + /. (, (((/ %2 + ( +& // - 2 + %/7$(,,&+( %&+ $( ( +&-% 0+ (,.

(( $2+( &-+(+&+7( ( ) $( 0 (7- +( + 0 %)/ % ( % + 0+/+ (,, (,,& C 9 ,&-0+6A(/+((,( 8 4+()) (7- +$( -(7( %&+7 !>>;6;;6-+ ()$( (77( %2+( /9 ,,/- +%& +& ( 7 % 7(1$ (7,&2+7,.% (,2++,( , // ,(,&-$.

// - (/ 77 %/7$ +7- + +& ( 7 0(.B(%( + ( (22 &+7-(,,&/ +(((/+ (( + 77-% +&(, 7 (//+) $( (7 7( %& (/+( (, ( ++()) (7 !>>;6;;6-+ %$(,(77( +%+(,2%&+ (%.".-(,$%2 -+(72+ (77( %&+(2!>>;6;;6-0+%&+$( +-% C +(+( (7(7( 2+7,. (0,,(2++($$. (+, -9 ( /+(7 %$7( %&+$(// -,&2+7,.

% (,%+(,22++(($(+, // -0+ +0. 7(%$7( +7+ /( + /. (, (((/ + ,.( ( %2 + ( +&// 6? #+0 -+0+%/(77( 2 + ,.( ( 2 + (, +($ %$ 7( + %)/- 0+(- + /( $ + /. (, (((/ %2 + ( /9 ,,/- +%& +& /(0/ %2+ +(+&+(.

+( 6: (,&- +& ( 7 0(. (%( + & ($ +7 7(1 + /. (, (((/ %2 + ( /9 ,,/- + ( 7( +72+($2+/.%)/ 6; +((7(&-+$( (77( %&

8A+()) (7 /;2+</26:;8<++( 7/( ,&1+-+(+( (7-+(%7( ,&2+7,2% (,2++,( ,// 0.-+7(1$2+( $( (72+7,2( 2++(% %&+%7( 0+ (&( +E( +2-20(2((.7+ ( 22/-+( 7 (//+(+$( (77( %&8A+()) (7!:6>6;;! /;2+</26:;8<0(,&2+7,2% (, %+(,22++,( ,// ,(,&-+%&/( (,%( +(+0(+(&%(/+/( +/,2

# +%/(7/ 7 +( !> # +,,+/ ,2+/(/ +((& %(/+%/(7/( +/,2( (, ) /+/ , ($ +((// 2+%/7$ / 7 +( +(+%&+2/(2(/9 2 + %)/,( -%/7.( ( +(+&(9 % (+ ( ( !6 $ 77,(+(( %&+/ ,2 +DA3;!?A6;;8+(.%( %&+/ ,2 + )6 '!""#((#+0.-&(( $2+ ,&(22 (.2 + +0-(1$7$+( + (( + 77!>>;6;;6-0+/+%/(7. +-&,&6-!-?-:-;-68( 6@-+ /( +/.(,(((/-%2+,,/ // -0+(-++B%)/(+ /(

" +(,(((/ +2-/,&+( /(+%)/ /@A2+</26:;8<( (, 0++&0$.( &2+%$(,,&+( +%)/- &0+2%/(7(%( %&7- +%& /( % ( +( + // - 0 / 7 +( /(+&/ +(+0((&%(/+ +72

# !! +((7(&-/A!=-6>63( 6= (12%)/ /@A2+</26:;8< +%&+272%)/%&+( /A- (+((7 +(%( $0(.$( & ( %)/ + (/9 2 + /. (

,(,&+%&+&(2% (+%,( ($-+ / %2+ +(+&0+$.(& & 2,%)/ /@A2+</26:;8<+&/( / +((,+($%/(7$( +7(+($ 0++( /9 ,,/// / 7(1( 7(, +%)/-(%/(72 ,&%&/A 6-!-?-:-;-68( 6@ $27%

)+ 32781 % $ 83 2792626

)+ 1

3 <%26 =2714 !3 +,( / ,2++(.($ -+( /+(0( +(% / -%& ( 20&( /+7(1$2( /,(( /=2+</26:;8<- +2-+(0( .( !8 0.- + (%. ($ 7 7A,- (

/( +,&(22 (.-+(+ %(/2+2/( ( 6>>!6;;! /=2+</26;=6<0(

%,+ ( 0($.(0 %,/&+ $+( + ,/(,&+ $+7 ( +,( (2 %,/(2+ /,((

/=2+</26;=6<0(!=>!6;;!+$,+ % ( +(0( /66A2+</26:;8<0( ( / !8>!6;;8 + -+%&+(0( 0(7( 0+ +/% 20&( !@ #( -+($ 7(+(,,72(,(. (,B/77/(, + (22/ - (, $2/(/-(++(.%(0( ) ( ((%, /7(( +(7%/7$(.(,(%,2%$,( +,( ,// -% $.+2+(/9 ,( %/7$ ( 7 %& + (/9 $ ( +& + $+ (( !!; ( !8>!6;;8 +2- + ,( /+ (/9 / $% +(.%/72 ,,&( ,(02 ,,&//, != ".

-+ (2 +2/(, 27+ (%.+(-+(, 7(1(& (, %2+ -+((,($ /,((%7( 72/ !8!2+</2!>63<(+(/9 $( +&72+ .

# 0).

(+ 4 #

)

'' " +( ( / 22/B/,/+$ /+($$. /-/2+ ((7-(7 /+(-9 (((%$7( .+ (/9 ,( -( -9 (+/7(-(%/(7 7 %& + ,,/ // - %/7$ 2 +%&

# %/7$(.(,(%,2%$,( +,( ,// ".-0++( .. ,&+( %2+/7$ 2/2+</2!>63<-+%&-+/,(7( %&+ +(+&(, (,($ /,((72+ . (-+ .)/ !? / ,&(,/+(%( -+,& (22 (.2 + +0-+(+ %)/,( ( ( $(, /7 2 + ,(& ,(- +%& 0+ +& ( 2(/,($+,.( %,/ 9 ,&-0+ %,/

+(+,, . (,/2+-(+ %2 + ,(,&-+ 2 7+( -( -/( 7 6 18 3276

$2 !: # (27(+- + 2 7 + 0 -( -0++(%.%.(-+(7( 7 +7 $ 2/(-( +/9 +(0( ( 7(( ( (227 !; (/ 3> /+7(/(,2+(.% / -+ -(,, + $(,/(-2(&-(,( 2 ).

.' /

+ )-- + "&!""# 1(.$+ D++(1$B( '

FB D++(%, '