← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2933/2016allowed

Salwinder Singh @ Shinda v. State Of Punjab

2024-05-29Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu14 pages

   

  

 



 !"#$%"&'('#)*!+ ,-  

 

 !"#"

   &#'(

"$

 * ./  0    &" ) 

*$ &  + ,$-   

"

'$ .#+ /+ &#'(

  -0 &" 

( % "

'#1 -$,- $ $ " -  

""  *#+ - $# + 4 4+ (3 -$,-  #  5-$ - 6#"

&"3- $ $- #(" -"

- +

27 %$ "

$ 8- 9 " - #$ :

$

3"

3 % "

;

%# " # $

"

$"-# $+ $ - "

1# '#1 ""  - $# +  $#- #)

        

 

!"

 !# #    

##  $%  

&  

' %  

 

   # 

 

#   



 



#     $      $  $    

      #  &

& !"

 !#             (     

     !

 !#  !  & !#   )   *

"

 +

'

 & &    $

  !

 !#

 # #  

 $   '

, 

 "



  & &  

- , 

     $ 

#  

# 



 .-"



  & &  '

 

 , 

    ,   

#



#  "! 



  /!0 

 

  #





 '

+)  !#1 !

           '

 



       

2   '

 -  4   

 +

'

!

 !#  !    

 ,     $ .

- , 

  

 

5

55167&! $

#.

- , 

   (

 &

!  #&+-8 !#.9    

  /:

 #

 "



#               '

 

   

 !     '



  "







  

 

       

      #

#'

#       $   

    





#

"!       

 !5!+4-  !#    #        '

            

  

  



 #        

$ 

 '

#     !5!+4$       ;

$    $  ."



  #  9   '

 !5!+4-  !#

 #+<

&2 =+ +#    #





$     ;

$   '

     !  8

2  !#          

 '

4 !"

 !#   #    ( ;

# "

  4     $#                      ( ;

# #

 



#

  "!  -! #

/!0    

 '

  (     #'

  

#0

 ( ;

#  $  

$   

  '



##-, 

 

 '

  

 #



#  &!   '

4 

  



#  "!   '

 

 #$    

  #/!0    





 

)  ;

#  

   2         9    

# $  4  '





#

"!  -!



      '

      '

 

##-

#

&!  "!  $

##.- 

#

&! "! # /!0    >  !5!+4 & ! & "



?  !5!+4  $

   ;

$  #  $  

   !!& "

"



<    $    

      ;

$  "



9? 

 $    ;

$   '

+!$ !#

'   5     

  /!0;       

'

    

           "



#  '

#       

          '#        

@, 

   



             7 ,  +  



 

        

 "  $ - + -$"

$-#1 "

 #$

$"-# $ $

$ #

=  &  "#

--#" -$1- =  &

<

>    

-"+ --#" - "

  # 

- -

 $  # 3 -1 

: $ $,  "

-"+ $"-# $ ?1 13

$"-# $  """+ 13+ &@

:

.#  &@ :

4$-   &@ A *   &@< :

.'  &@< #;

'



 + &@7 :"- $ /# 

  1 --#" -$ #  & -



-1  1  ,-

1+ (#



"1  %" 1- $

=

: %- ,-+ A ( 

?1 6@

% 

 ($

""

,# 

,- ($#

$ -$+  - -$,-  " -

$ - ($,

> "" "%

1# '#1 $+ " 

( %

:

$"  1 $



#

-3

" +

 1$,  - $  <

= "#""$

1 " -+ -

, #3 $ $

(#-

 - $"

$$  - , $   

" $ -  (%$ A$B(

#1 

 5$

" $# C&  5$

<=

2+ -

$

%$$ 1")

  #    #           +#  

        

   >  

     9      

 # !0&A B6 5   !0&A B6 ?5  '

  

   '

 # 

  

# 

(  +#  ,  

#

    

  #

 '

  '



  #   

   # 

C ! $   =

+

$$  -

"  

"

$(",



-""

, (

 ,#3 " 3+

$ ? - 

 ($)

 AB  

  

    

    

'



   "



  '

 

 '     

  '

    '

     

  

  

   

   #   2   ?9 9C

5$  $ ( %

$

 -$"-# ,

 "

D#"  

*$ &  + ,$-  E

5$

&F 7 F

7 """

$ ( %

"$

C  

-$ "

(%$ %%-  -$,3  -$ (+ $ $%% 1"

- ,

 G

#"

 -$,3 (-$1"

1""( 

"$ -$ "

 -$,3 %%-  $

<

1+ (#

"1 " >C $

=

< $ #"( ? $

( ,

$"-# $ ;

-$ (

1 "#-

$ $ $""( 3 1

"1 "$ -$ ( # $#

>#  -$ "

1 3+

- $" 

$%%- 1- E?1+ .

 $" ( #;

'



, $  

<+ (#   &@<+ $" ( #;

'

&@7 :"- $ /# 

$"

-

 ( $" 

>C+ $  #

"$ ($

($,  """

 -

$"  $ ";

&#(- &$"-# $+ (# >C $ E?

&@F

";"

"

E, 6@

A (  & 

 3 & 

" %

-

 ( $" 

>C+ $  ($#

$ -$ $-#1 "

E?

6

6

" $-#1 "

"$ - 

"1

 ( " >C+ $  $ >C+ .

G

-

1'$ "--3 % 

$"-# $ -"

  %#  -$ 

-$,3 %%- 

($ 3 

13 $  "

- -$,3 1  &@ A *  $

-$,3  ""+ " 

$"-# $ % '$ 3   ""

#

 -$,3 $-"

$'$   ""

- "

$#(

$"-# $ " $3

=

< : "#$

-$  $"+ -

( - #$   

  

   !

  " #        $%& '(  

% ') !* (  +( ,,-.

$' ,,!"$

 +/,,

% '  )))!  "  * %%  0 '               /'

1  % ' !"%

  ( , '-  )!" '2  *'"  *   % ' 33'4 ,2%"2 ''"  /  

'' &  5&  4&&  '  2  , 

% '6,!78 #  , '-  16, !72'. 

#2''3 & #

%     ( 

9:9 9:2(;$

<

&      -$#"

, 1 3 $$"

-$  $

"#(1 

-$,3 %%- 

" -" - - -$,3+

%$+ $-$1-

- $ % 

-" $"-# $

4$ (# ""

 #1 +     -$#"

- - $ '#1  A$B(

#1 $%& '(     '0%  11

 6

<

"$ "#(1 

&@ :

4$-  

" %

" -"

-" $ 3 #

$ 

"1 -#" $3

 $ ( 1

- 3 "

"1"

11 

< >#  "#(1 

$'$   ""

"

 $ 1;

$"-# $ -" $#( %# 3 1 (-#" $3"+ $($3  "

(-$1  ""

$- $-"

$

,$ %# # -$1- $

< C" 3 "#(1 

,"   $%%-

 

, ("

'$    ""+ (# $ -1 %$ '$

-$,3 $-"

A  -$#"

 "

#" ($$;

:

-" $"-# $

$

<

&$-  3

 :

4$-  

$ %$1 1 $;

&  " -$1 $ %$$ %$1

" & - 

 "

&$-  3+

# (-;

 ; $# " - -; %$1

$-; + (#  

&$-  3

 " - -; %$1



;  $ $""""$

"H $%%-

I$ $

"1+ %$# (  $?- $

 "1

1  $  1 +

1 D#  3 -1 $# (

1"

-"

 "  "1 ($?"

"

" (  "

J4B

 "  "1 " - >C %$1  "$  $

"$

 " %  #"

 $, A *  

:

+ , 

?1 $ - % &@ :

4$-  

:

 -$ (%$  - $#- #)

;&        $#

   !

 !#    &  #    #  

 $   , 

 '

 /  '

 -

    

   #    

       4 

##   #  ,  

 .-, 







       



 C

>$1

($, ? - +  3 -

 -$,3 %%-  :

4$-   (# $ $%%+ 1#-

""

, $%% ,

( "- 

"- /H  %%-G $ "  

=

- -" "

# 3 $

1$ $%%- %$1

--#"



"-

1"

-

%# %$1  --#"

,#( 

$# 

"-

 (-#"

"#"- $# $ ( ( ,

$ - $ -

(# 1- "1 #

-

 " "$+

"%# ,"

- $ 1 %$1 3G   -$ 

 $('- ,$ %" 1- $ "#-

-""

- $,"

"  #"

1 "

$%%-"

-$ 

G

#"+ ",

$- + -  "%#"

, ( (" $ #$

--#"

" # # - $

$,"$ 1 $3  #

A+ $# ( $% ( 1; %-

$"  # $ -

*#1 A$B(

#1  (   2'"

 <<<=

&"

 7=

"1 ( ,  $#- #) >, +

'

(   ' !

1

         

  ,     (  > 

   

$#    ,

    

  !

1      

  "



 , #  

 '!

1

    

#       # 



    '!

1

 

'

 #            '

# #    A 

 B  

 A B                   !

1  #   ,   #   (  

   #     ;

#       

 

    ;

#    2     '

  

   ' '     

' 

        

'

 #

  '   ' !

1 "  '

      

 2  

       

   ,   #     '       "     '         # '

 

 

  #        ;

#

     

(      

 D 



    ,    C

) 4  

#    '

 #  ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, AB"   ,    

  !

1     



 

,           '   !

1

              #  # > AB!



1   '

         '         

    

C

  %# + $"  # $ -

A$B(

#1  

$,"$"

-  

   ?

 

=<? 

8     (   

>$ %-+ 

5$"

< 

'#1  ? -  #) >1 # % %

'!#                 ( 

 !

1 67&!

        

  '>  AB    !

 1     

'

   



    C     

A B  ,   #  

(   

   #   

;

# F    C   

,     #    2  

       

  #     ;

#

 '

         '

      

    ' '     



' 

                       

'

    #

   '   '!

1 67&! "    

   

   (  #'

 !

1                #     

          

  

   

,   #

   # 

     ;

#

     (      *

       

    '   '



#

       C ><'

  ## 



   2     #

!

1AB 67&! 

 #

 

  

      '3    $  

 

 '     

 # #

    

          



'

           

   

   

  #

   #     ;

# *

'

          #        

#      > AB   !

  1      67&!      

        (       /      '   '

      ' '

     '



       #

"



     

,     #   '             'C &#" ($, ? - -3 ,"

1 , $



1$ $%%- "

"$



( "-  (%$ H  $%%-G $ "  

$,"$ 1 $3 -

D#"

" - -$1-  $$,+

-" $"-# $

 -$ (   $

"$ $ "  "1 ($?"

1 $ -

1

1

$ + $# , 3 $%%

"-

( -$#-  (%$ 3 H  $%%- $

3 1"  

:

$  $(",



#

-$#"

+

"   

" - ( 

 - -$,3

, 1

$%%- 6# 3 #  &$-+ &   #(6,"$ "  + &  ""

 ;1

 $      -$#"

%%-

: "#-

"-$+

 $

"   ; '#- $ -

"-

1   " - (  ($, -"

-;$ ($

""

"

3 $ -+

-$,3  -$ ( %%-  # ($ 3 

1

1$

*#+

<G

%$+ 3

$$ # 3

"-

(%$ H  $%%- $ 1"   "

 1$# -$1   $

1 $3 $,"$"

-



  +

 $ ?- $ -, $# #

-

%%-

"H $%%- -$# 3

,#( 

"-

(%$ H  $%%- $ 1"   13 - 

(

8   '

9+ 

$-  3  

+ -3   1-  $

1 3 -$ "



 $#     -$#"  3 #$

'#1 -" $%& '(  3?

(#

$

%#

%$$ "$") 

: $%& '( @  3+

$"  # $ -

'#1   

 @ &  3 $ ($#

$ - -

-$""  $ A$B( *#"



:

-"+ -$,3 %%-  # - -; """

 , -; ""+ (#

-"

<

+ &$-  3   "- 

( 1 "

$

-""3  #"



:  

 @ &  3?

 $ ?- $ -,

% $-  3  "

3 "#"- -3 -$ ( ;

" -" $+

 $ $( $3

"H $%%- -$13

$,"$"

-

<

: ,

($, "-#""$+

-$" $$

&@ :

4$-    %%- 

 -$,3 -$ (+  $ 1; $%%

"-

(%$ 3 H  $%%- $ 1"  G

#"+

 -$1   $

1 $ 3 $,"$"

- G

- 

 -$,3 1""( 

7

"

"#

($, -$-#"$+

 $ $ $+ ?- $



$"D# 3+  $G '#1 -$,- $ $ " -  

""  *#+ - $# + 4 4 

(3 " "

 -D# 

- "

%1 "

1



-

A"

(F"# 3 ($"

"  "- 

= " $ 3 ( "$" $%% --$-

 % 

?3 $ 1  $

2

& - $"+ % 3+ "

 "$ "  "$" $%%

!+ ,- 

 

  

  3B

C  D 8 C4  3'D 8 C4