High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2593/2026allowed

Sonali v. State Of Haryana And Others

2026-05-12Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya31 pages

-1-

" !

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

! "

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

-2-

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

($)*)*+,$%-&.

$%&'&

($&/+,0$,)-&.

! - .

# - .

/ - .

# " ! "

# "

1 &"" #/

3!#

$% % &!# ' !( &!# & )&!# * "

+&!# ", %&!

% &!# & , +&!#

# % +'

" &!# &

% &!# !# ( &!# ( 2 &!#

-3- $/ %

&!# (!

$ &!# 1!

%&!# % "* &!# # " ;: (

" & &! # ' 5 ,

'&!# % $ &!# <

% + '

" &!#

4 "

" / " #

# <##

# 0/! # !/ #= =.. . #/

! .3 - -? &

6 / # " 45 / # %! # =

& &

6 / % '!

! ! ! ' = ;

# &"" # &# # %

= #%

9 # :(

-?; A -?(

/ % "=

@1%=?

& & #

" ! # " " >

! ?

/ " & ;9

: 5 9 #

$" !/ !

-4-

0 # # / " % '!

> # .

" & ;= = : 9

5 9 9 # $" = @ !

> / =

"" #

/# /# " "# # " !"" " " & # /# "#4" 6 >

# "" %#

* " #

/ ! " / #

6 # 4% / # , "! #

!"# + / % / # , # #

/" /# ! "! #

!" # + /""/##

+ % / # , ! 4! !!# #4"

%# #4 96 %#

;

! "" #/: :

/= 7-- /: 6- #: +-- : &> # > + : : 666 666 66 : =

/ ! " #

/#+ # /# 6 # "#"! !#

+ D #

-5-

: @ #

/"" #

/ ! " = ! # # # / # +

+: + / / # #

/ / #

# / # +

% / # , : 6 - /: +- #: 666 666 666 :

/ # / #

! / #

/#+ #

/ ! " "! ! #

# + D : / # + / ?3D

@ !

4) !)# !

! / D /"

""/

+ / # +

! 4! !!#

" "" %#

-?-.

6 # "

-3 !

## % / # ,

3-? <

" $ % # "## ! /

! !

-? (

-6-

(

/ "" " # 8 ! =

> > " > # "! 0 # # & # " > (

> # & 1 "# # # # # # / / " # ##"#

&"" 6@@;/ *: #

/ / " # ! $ # !/ "# " $ 19#"

/ # #

6" # % 1 @ ! # (

# # (

. #

"# ( (

- $ # (# 0 $ # " & =# 5 # E %# %# # %# # E

E / %# # # # 9 # 2 = =

# @ & / ;&*: & & :

& F D D+; > !

" # !

: # # 4! 4 / # @ 8 !

> ! ##

! :

: *

! > # #

!# 1 9 9 / ;19:# # / 8'= =%@( ## / 8'= + +%E94%9 !

!/ $$

-7-

## # 8 ! ' = ;

% # &

4$ $ :

: ( (

--G -. #/6" 194%E94%9

# $ " " 2 --G/ ! / "! 6

C #4*

# # $ # / 6 6" > 194%E94%9 # "" & & > !

" 8 ! 4=

4@ / #

# :

: $ # /

< /:

: $ / ! / 6 6 6 < #:

: & " $ ! ! !# # # /

# # < :

: = "

/ # "" 4 $ + # #

< :

: # " ""/

4 $

# #4 "

" 4

4 "" / 8'=4@=%%(4=%@( #

1 194%E94%9 / > # # " #194%E94%9

# # / 8'==%@( ( ## / 8'= +%E94%9 C

-8- * $ / * /

! 4 +

"-- ! ( +

; :

: #> % ;7%: ; :

: 5 9 #

; 59: ; : &# # ( ( +

8 ! ;& &(8: %

8 ! ;%

+)$2

5$ <60$;*< &<+%$ 6& &/ /$<*:*$0 *, //$,0*>

6=7$ $

:+%

,*8$%&*)*$&4 6,0 //$, ,0*>

6=7$ !.

:+% +77$@$&4

&5 =$ <+,&*0$%$0 :+% &5+%) 7*&)*,@ +:

)5$ <6,0*06)$& :+% %

*, ,)$%8*$9 +,7?4 6,0 )5$ &$7$<)*+ +,& &5677 =$ =6&$0 +,7?

+, )5$ $

/$ $%:+%;6,<$ *, )5$ *,)$%8*$9

& &"" 6@@ / 666 666 66 / & 666 666 66

6=7$ !

%*)$%*6 :+% 5+%)7*&)*,@ +:

<6, ,0*06)$& :+% ,)$%8*$9 :+% )5$ $

/+ +&) +:

&&*&)6,) %+:$&&+%& *, +77$@$&

% 1 &# #(# ' ?-D &/! I

' ?-D &/!I %# H I .-D ?-DI G D

DI- .-D ?-D I

D .-DI.

D ;-D # %=4%4C*= ;

# :4$:

.-DI - H :

.-D /!I-3 $

19 2(0 - 19 -? %E94%9 - (# / # ;

+ # # "

/ # "

/ (! 8'= 2 : 3 D .-DI- . -. 3 #

4 $# 96" # ;

+ #: - ? & @ 41 ! ;& ! / @ C 4 '! @ 4'! @

-9- #

1 E!* : % E! ;&

! / % '! : (

-# # #

# ! / "# / # > #

# " & = #

" ! #

= # = " # "5 $" 4 # # ) # = # / # 6" # # @

%# = ="

" @ @)666 666 666 ) ) & = #

! = = = ;: %# = " &

= # #

! #

= #

" : = " '!

* # 4

/ '!

/ / = " = : # " = :5 $"

4# # / # # # = !: ) ) #= #

! / / # 6" @ # # 4# #

= " # " ! "/

# / ) #= #

! 6"

-10- / ! / # / / # 6" v: / # 6" #

# # / / = " =

/ " ! # / ) #= # / # 6" ""! / ! /

! # # @ ##

4# # @

/ # 6" #

8 !

/ = " '!

* = " !

# / ) #= = # / # 6" ""! / ! / = ! : & # # "

%=4%4C*=4 4 4 4$ / # # # /

# # "" # /

/ ) #= # /! / # # /

# ;/: 0 ! / #

/ # 6" # > ( (

# "# # "

# #

. - %# # @ ! #

#" " / # ! # / / # "" # /

! "

# #

! " 4"

" / &"" 6@@ / & * @

+ # /

! / #

4#"

-11- # # # # "# # #

# ! "# # / / # # =&% " ! # # "# / (

( (

(

# " ! !

! > +# ! " #

(

# " -? (

/ ! ' =

;8'=:

4 # 4 1 (

# & '!

= // = "# / % '! / 8'= (

" - K

- $ # (# 0 $ # " & =# 5 # E %# %# # %# # E

E / %# # # # 9 # 2 = =

# @ & / ;&*: 666 666 666

+)$2

5$ <60$;*< &<+% %$ 6& &/$<*:*$0 *, //$,0*>

6=7$ .

:+%

,*8$%&* *)*$& &5677 =$ <+,&*0$%$0 :+% %

&5+%)7*&)*,@ +:

)5$ <6,0* *06)$& :+% *,)$%8*$9 +,7?4 6,0

)5$ &$7$<)*+,& &5677 =$ =6& &$0 +,7?

+, )5$ /$%:+%;6,<$ *, ,

)5$ *,)$%8*$9

! %$ ! "#$!

-12-

" & !

! "

" - "! # # #

# !/

# '! = = + # ##

# # ##

# 5 '!

K # !/ / #J - = %# = '

% # # %# = ="

" @ @)666666 666 ) ) & = #

! = = =

# $ ) (

$ * %

( #

# '

(

+,-, , (#

" .- # "# # "

'! = #

K # !/

#J . - %# # ! #

#" " / # ! # / / # "" # /

-13-

! "

# #

! " 4"

" / &"" 6@@ / & * ( ( .)

# '

( # #

# $ ) ( $ #

# " # #

# !

# ; : # 8'=(

% '! # "#

/ "" # #

= @ #

/ ! / / " /

# "

! / &# > # # " #/

# "

/# #! / % + '

" #

# " / "

/ ! $ )

! ) .&@(%=3 -5 " ""# = " " # "

# "#/

! # ##" "#@ #/ "#

" !

/ ;

-G: -%== = 31

/ / / "

-14-

% #

(

" # -?

? (

"" #/ % % '! ! / " #" (

! "

C ##

""" # 4 / 1 "-# ;:";

;): ".-;@: (

"# "# #

# ! # '!

'! = '! " & # ! #( " & L L 5 9 9 # ;= =:'

"*%! #( G?.; A G?

?.( B:!/

/ 5 9 #

;= = :' "*%! #;&

:( &

6 ( (

# # # + 8'= / @ ! 4= '! + # # + (

# '!

# # ,

' #

= # # ! > !

"" # " & ;= #: .

. / # # "# "

" 3 / # / #"

# '!

" C

-G / #

# ! M%#

% / # , , !/ # " < / #

! -15- %# # ;! G : %#

/# < / # > ;! ? :

: " %#

% / # , ! ! / # # " !""# # =

% / # ,

# /" ' + =

: "" # # # @ # %

/" 8'= = (

/> 6# " & "

/ / #%! #= ; A %=B:

# "# !

(

# " # # " ##

+ /

0 / "

A/ " B -? (

! /

A" B . %

/ / #

" !/

# # 3 & &"" # ! > - -? < #" ! " & / # # "# "#

/ # / #" %#

5 5 ! " ! # #

" ! ?4

/ " & ;9

: ! / !

!" # " -16- # "# # %#

6 # 4% / # , " #

/ ! ' !

/ " # #

# ! / / / = #

" -?(

/ 8'=

! # / " " " (

" '! # ! / / " + #

! "

# /

! # (

# "

"#/

# / ! "

! "# " / = ! # / # / " #4" 6

/% / # ,

! /

/ " + +/ / #

% / # ,

! "# -?(

#> # / " # # # ;/ " " #

" $ $ 19 # "

/ #

6" # # # : "# &"" 6 @@ @ / * = # " " #

! 3 & &##

# . 12+3 4 '

' .

) ' .

-17- )

) # ' ? / #

" -?(

'! / "

# ; : @ """ # @

# % " =

# / %

/ " &

E / '! $ = ! ! 8'= (

@ 2

/ '! > %= # G

" & -" E / < .-" & 3 " E / # # / = C -G $ " 5 9 #

%=B # "

" #

# %=6" / "

= / "" '! " !

3-G ""! # " & E /

" #

# # 8'=

! %

/ --G "# #

# # / / / #

# / " #

# % 8 ! @ # -G " ;G N.

.-: & .3 " ;-N3: E /

# / # #

"# "

-18- ""! / =

- /! / /> "

"# ""! / =

# # ! C G- !

" 6 ##

# #

# ? @

" #

! / = +1!/

/ ! 8'=(

# " / %

--3 - & #

%= ? @

/#+

% " = # " # / #%! #=

& #

- =

3 3 C "

/#+

/ # %! # = @ / % ! " M "

" / # !

! " / # # / " / " '

'! " ! " # " # .

; #/ = :

: = !

> '!

& #

:;:A #

# # ! ! # # ! " B @

= * #

! ! 0 0 G3 %== C

%= # #

!/ /

/'! "

! = /!

-19- @ =

0 #

" # (

" ! & #

: = #

# /"

(

@ # (

# "

! 6 #

/+ +

/ / #%! # = = ;E 0

# : (

G 0

" ! (

% + # " "

! = = & " & / $ =

" "

! = # " "

! % = =

" ! # # /

% G(

;/ "# !# :/

" G G(

" + "

! = &

/ ##"

# # #

"# !

# # @ #

6 6# '! # " ## !/

/ =

& & #

- = @ ? "" #/ 8'= (

= # % '! "

--(

! --3 -

" # "

# " & &@ #

@ /! ( (

/ / "

/ #" /

# -20- ## !/

# 9!

" --(

/ / > -?(

"" #/

% =

# -?(

" / % # #+ " # # # /

/! = = - - # --8 8'=(

/ " /

#" / # " -- - ( (

/ 8'= (

-? "#

"" #/ --(

/ /

# # & # "

$ ! * # % % " -? 8'= = ( (

% #

" # 8'=(

# 'C

--3 - +

# " & & &@ %# / "

"< # " / # ! " $

- - (

# @ 2

> #

& -E E / / %

! =

# 3-G #

.-" & 3" / ## "

. '! =

# + ! " "

! / # %! # = = #

# /

$" %# =

# ! /!/

-- (

3 3-G O

-21- 3-G ' !

--(

# ! " "

! = = = # # " # # # 6# / # / ## +

# @

. @ " # " # # / /! !

8'=

" # # > /

#" ! !! # / / 6# ##

" /

& # = = 5 # %

2 #+ +

# "# $ ! * # =

# # ? @ "" #; :

8'=(

"" #/ % # "# # @ # --(

/ " / #" / %

> !#6"

& # " & #

/6#

" "

! %= "# #6# * # # / / "

" # # > #"

! !!# #

# "# /

- -(

# # # @ ! # "# / " B "

+ 8'

-22- '= (

'! # # ! ##

# (

) G -? (

# #

# ;: ;

: /# ; : %# . %# 8 ! ' = & &# G.; A 8'=& &# B:

/ #5 #!

# ;

%==3G #

" ) #= # ""! # % 8 ! &# #

/ > # "# / -?(

= (

% ! / / & #

/ " ! &#

"" ) #= # # #

? (

# / " / % % #

8 ! &# ! # ) #= #B ""

/! / / = # / - - @ #

/ "

8'=(

# / 8'= 6# "

%# .;:;:

.;:;

: 8'=&# G.9 9! " 8'=&# !

&# / / # 5 /

/ 8'=(

/# #" &# @ #

# # / % = = "! / ""

-23-

4" # ""

# & # = = / # P # # P = # E ;E E @@@: %! %# =

"" ) #= # ## "! 8'= (

# / / ! "!

> G ( (# # / % "=

# ; : @ # 8 #

6# !"

& # . %! %# = # ## # ! &# -G; A 8&# B: # / @

- -@ "# / "# "" ) #= #

%# &##"

# # ## # # E '! "" "" ) #= # 8 ! ! 3 3 ""

/ 5 = #

;: 8 &# # ## #

# "" ) #= # @

(

3 - ? (

# #

# = 8'= / = #%# ;: 8 8&# ##

# (

3 "" ) #= # &

! % " = (

# # 9 .. E @ = /

8'= &# # /

8 6# 6# !"

/ # 8

&# >

-24- " # # (

+ ""

) #= # /! =

- - 8'=(

- ? # # 9 ..

. E @ # (

!/ / 8'= 6# " #

.;:;: .;:;

: %# 8'= &#

# / # / 6# 6 6# ! !#" #

9 ..E @ = = ! 8&#

> " # # (

3 8'=(

+"" ) ) #= # "

%## % # = # # = 8'= # 8'= /

#" "# /""

# !

+ # !

( (

@ " #

%# # %# = # # = 8'= # (

3 8'= = ( (

-?= > %# ;: 8&# 6 "# / # " %## % # = # 8'= = ( (

-? / # 8'= = ( (

-? # ! /

# #/ 9 ..

. E @ # ## " "!

# G & &##

B 6# ! # #

9 ..E @8

E %! %#

= -25-

" A67 '

B -?(

#!/ "

8'=&# # / 6 ! " " # < #/

% # /

> # # "# "" " # # #

# #

" 6 " > # # #

"/#

! #

+ 6# / > /

# !

# # #

+ @ @

# / "# /

> > # # # "# # E

/ #+ "" # # # > # # "

/ # #

6" # # "# // 6"

/ 8'= - ?(

" # 7 # " # #

# # "# + "" < #" # #

# # /

# " > > # # " > #

-?(

# # # #

"# ( > # #

# #

# # "# #"

(

-26- . # #"

" /

" # / 8'= # & " #

/ !

! # #

/ @ / / "# /

# "

" = # /

% 8 ! /

# / "

+ #

# = !

! 5 ! 6# / / "

# "# > / @

(

.- " !# "

4 # "# "

! G 6"

-? (

# 4

(

867 7

# $ (

$# $ ) # !#$ $ B<

( (

- A67

# $ $ ) (

$ *

(# 9:

(

.- 867 .)

# '

) %

( # -27-

# $ ) ( $ $9=

"# /

# 6 +

# " #

" " /

/ /

" #

# / / " + / # + ! < !

# / "

"# / = / " "

-? (

= #

# #

"# " # /

# ! # # "# ##

(

@ #

# 6

(

% # #"" & "# /

(

# #

# # # # # "# /

" % '! / /

= #

9 ..E @ @ %! %# # / "

# > # "

"# > /

! #

/ #

/ "

(

'! " " #

"""

/ /

" # ! "

"" / # # # !

/ '! -28- / " #

"! # G # / / ! ! # .

;

: - %==

"= 6 ! #

# # " / & *

1 (

-?(

" # # &/ 8

! ! "" # " &

/ > # "# / -?(

! "! 1 (

# > # / / # ## "" ## # / &8 ! * * =

" C

" #

6" # '

0# " # / #

> 6" #

# 3 / & #

/ ! 8 ! ! " B #

6" # #

(

- ;: ;:; : / /

"" &

" * 6

% " = " # " / 8 !

1 (

# # / 8'="" "

" &

! =

- ?(

& # ! # / # / +

6#" /! #

-29- 5 ! #

3 ""

/ "

"" # # ! #"

/!# # !

! / / "&/ 8 ! M # /"

/! / # !

6" #

M # "#

# (

- - / &$ !

* #

!/ # +

"#/ #

6" # /

/ #

! #

/ & *

# # / 8'= "

"" " &

# = 3 / & *!

# (

# /! $ ! * # 5

= # / /!O G = # # # 6 #

# / 6/ 8'= 0

# "# /

" 6" #

" # /

+ #

! < /! #

" # " # / /!# # / "" !#

/ " # "

! " #

"# // " ! 6# ! !

# # #

" / # ! < ! " "# / / # ! M # !

# "

# # @ ##

-30- !# / +

# #

# #" / #

/ /

# "! 6 6# ! !

& / /! "

B # # # / (

! "

"# / # #

6 / -?(

&##

# >

# "# #

# G. @

-?(

! ' - # / #

" " / " # #

" # " #

"#!##" #

# =

" # "

" # "# # ##" "# / " # # /!

3 3 5 !

" # " # /

" # " #

" # ##" "# # / "# @

# # # #

# > #

/ # /# # "

" + # # # # # !

" /@ # # !#

-31- # /

"! = =

4" # " # "# " #

/ "# #

# "# * @

! /! "

6 ! (

. -?

? (

/ 8'= / #

= > # "#/

# / " #4"

! > ?4 !

! " # # # "# # " -? (

#" 6" "

# "" # ;: ;:

: " & &" #" /"# # #

# !

;*& <&=

; <&=