(O&M) Pala v. Vipin Kumar

 

    

!

 "#$   %  &

''&& 
 ('

)*

























#' +
,$+-./0,
1230
1,+4 

 
 


 








 
 



 

 

 

         

   

   

   

   

, 51 !











 
 "


 
# !$ !#%&

'


 (   
)

*'



 
"
 
 
!+ !#%-

'
'
)
.
/ 


*
 





*
 "







 

  
 " 
#

!,
"


"' 

 !#0+102
  


  

 
3
4  

 
(   







*

1




5 

6



!#

2
"




* 

) 

7 
"





 
*

*
1

" 
6



  



*

"



*



 
 
 

8 


  
"
9
 




6




" 


 
   




&$$$:1
 
  


  ,+ & !#0,
"

 

 
" 
7
  * 

 


*


 
 

  


"
*







 
 


 

+$ !$ !#0&



 


 


  
 

9  
 

  








"  
; ,,+0  
+ !#0-
 


' 

5

6



* 
7 
" 
 
 
* 

 "



*
; 2!2
  

 
3

4  

*



 

 




  
"  
*


'




'
 /  
/

.
*

'

/  
/






  


7 

 


!,$$$:1

<
5
 

 

+

)
 

  




5
  




"
7
 
  
 
 
# !#0-


 



%$$$:1   *

 

,& !#0&



 





5



'





7

 

'
7 

 
 "  
; ,,&%








 

4




'  
'


*

 


  
  



'

) 
 7 
* 

*



7
*

"

 
 




4
"


 
/
*
 



 






*



4 



 
+$ !$ !#0&
*
"   

 
9='
 5
/




 
*  

 

"

 
'
*

  


 

*


'


 
 


  

 

-

( 
  




 
 

 
 
   

1 





( 





" 


'

"

 


 



 "

   

( 
 





" 

'





 

  


 
* 

 " 





 


( 




 5
 
6


 

" 
!#

2 "
* 
7


!,

,
"

5
*  


*
5


"


 

  
*
 

 
*
 '
'

  
 






*

!,

+
"


* 


5


"
7

7 
 

5
 # !#0-

6


!#

2
"


* 
 

5
"




 




( 
 



*

  






' 
"

   






 
  

'

"
* 
 


'<






 
"
7 

 



!,$$$:1



  


"




!$$:1



' 

 
* 
  



4
 
 "  "

'
'




  

 *
  


  

4 

  


4
"  
 
 
*

 
"  
 5
*
 "

'
  
 

&

 

 

   

*

 


* 
 >!

? 



 








@
A ? 

 

*  "
@
A( +
? 




'
 

 
 

/


   
@
A(

? 

 
'

1 




@
A( -
? 



 '

'
 
 

 2


* 
  "
@
A( &
? 



"



 *  
' 
; -

&
@
A(
? 



 


"

 




@
A( %
? 

 


'



  
.






@
A( #
B 

4 
/



 
"

  

!+ !#%-






*
1 

5 

6



 



"'  

!#0+102

*

 "'
,!:!2:012

,!:!-
"

:,1%
 
 
/
 


'
 





 "'

4 
/




*
' 


5

 

+ !#0-
 
 *
 



'


*


'
*   


 



 


  *
 



*



'
'


 

; %

%

.





'

  
"




'

 
/
*

 

'

*


  /
 
"


 
# !$ !#%&
9






'

#

.














!$








"


* 
'  
< 

* >!

? 

< 



5 *

'
5
' 


 
 
  

 
 
"

  
+$ !$ !#0&

'


 
/ 
* 

 

'
 
 

9='  "
/
@ ? 

'

 
 
5 * 

'
 
 

9='
 " /

'

 
 


  1   
*


 
'



9  
;*
*
*
 


' 
@ +
? 


5

" 
 



 




 "


* 

 *

 

 











 *


9
 
;*






9
 
'

*
 "

'
" 
@
? 


5
 
 
  



 
 






*

"  




  1 


'

  


 1 
@ -
? 


 



*


  /
 


 


; !

 
 
/



 '

'
  
@ &
? 




 

'






 


 


 
 
 




 *

  

 

&+





@
? 

 *


  

 
!!



/

/  


   
< 5








'
 


'<


 '
'
  

 *


 
  
+$ !$ !#0&
* 

'
 
 
 9='
 "
/
@ %
? 





 


 



; &
*

"
*
 



 
" 
*
 

 

@ #
? 








*

"

+ !#0-
*
 
   1 




'
  '
 "
@ !$
? 
 



'
"



@C !!

D  

*
1


5 

6 


#

!,
"





 
!#

2 "

*
; !%2
  

 
3

* 


) 

7 
"




 

7  " 



) 

7 




 '


9
 


 



&$$$:1
    


 
,+ & !#0,





 


 
9
 


"
*

 +$ !$ !#0&

  

; !20

!#0+
D5 1!

4
  "

  

 

  


) 
 7 
"





  

 



  ,+ & !#0,
5 
'
 
" 

 
'

 


*

  



 





 
 
 



5 
' 
*



'

 
 
"

1"




 
+$ !$ !#0&
D5 1!
* 

'


 


 










 
,+ & !#0,
*

 
 





*



 
 
'

 
<
"

4
 
  

; #0

!#00


'



 
*

'

 
/

!!

!#0% D5 12

3

; 2

 
 

*
 


 

/  
/



  

; !20

!#0+ *


 

*

'

 
 

  



9
 
*



 
; !




'


 
*
*


 
 
,+ & !#0,




 
*

  
;

!+

 

  
"


  !!

!#0%





*





 




 




 
/


5 


 
"




&$$$:1
'

"







 


"



&$$$:1
*

'


 "
 
 "
"
'
 "




* 

 
/ 
 
"


 
,# !#0#  "








'


9
 
  




 

 

 
"
 



 

* 
"

 "

!2

( 




 

5  
6



 

" 
!#

2
"
* 
!,

% 
,
"


7 
*
; 2!2

  ; ,,+0
ED5 10F
*
 

+ !#0-
'
  


* 

'"
*

!,

,
"
 
*
' 7 
*
; 2!2
*
7
'"
*

# 
!,
"


6







<

7


" 
#

!,
"
* 
 '  

5
"



 
 

  
# !#0-
ED5 (1!F

  
; ,,&%
ED5 1#F
*  


 

,& !#0&

!-







" 
# 
!,
"

*
; !%2





* 
5
' *
 "

7

"  
; ,,+0  
+ !#0-
*






 



  # !#0-
5 
'
7 

  
*
 

'



 



 







" 
!,

,
"
*
' 7 
*
; 2!2


 



!,$$$:1

"
"


*
  ' 


 


   *
*




"

!&





5
*


'




 



+$ !$ !#0&
D5 1!

  5
*


'






 
"
 
 


 

'


  

 '<
 

!0



 


 


;
!20

!#0+  
*

 

4

*
 
'







 


 
*
 

 
*   
' 




 
,+ & !#0,
5  '
7 
 

6



"





  !#

2
"



( 
 


  "
 
 
 


' 



  # !#0-
5 
'
7 
 

* 


 
 
'



5

!%

*


 
/ 
 

 
,2 !$ !#%- 
"

* 







  
"

 
/ >%1
? 



"

"

7


'
+ !#0-


"



!,$$$:1


@
A

%17

? 


*
"



+ !#0-
 
@
A %1/


? 


" 
5




* 
"

7
*
*


  

'

 
 




@
A %1(



?
"

 

' '






 
*
5  

*



@
A( !#

.

 
 
!# - !#%&
'"


'

 

/ 




; %1

%1/
*
 
  


 



 
 


 5
*

'

 
 

 


*


 

 







 
*
  
# !#0-

.
*











"
7 

  



!,$$$:1

 "
'


.
*
 

5 ' *



7



; %1'

* 



*

"



+ !#0-

A


"


*


 
/



 
 '

 
/




'


*
 "



,$








 
 


 

<
5




   

 




 

5
   

 


 




 

 
'
  

'<
 

.

  






 
*


 

  
 
 "
  


' 


  
# !#0-
 

 

 


1 "



*

'

 
 

 

9
 

 

  
*
 


 


4

  


 

 
9
 
*
 
 "
 
*
  


*
 
 
 


' 




 
,+ & !#0,
5 
'
7

 



"



* 


6



  
(  *
 
 
 
 


' 


  
# !#0-
D5 (1!

4
 

'

* 



  
 




'<
  


 

*

 
* 

   
 

 

 * 

4


 
*  

'


.
*






 7
*







"


/

 
  

D


* 
*







"

 / 

 
 
'

* 

 
  
'


'<
 

 
* ' *

"
 ,!

 
++


D 

*
"

 

 


*
<


 '





( 
*



 

 
 




;   

  
*


 '

)"

  
+$ !$ !#0&





*


'




 


'<



'

  
 
"


 
!!

!#0%
ED5 12F

,,

.
 *

  
 

*
  

 
 "

5
' *


7 

 5 
' 
 

 * 
*
< 

'
    
 



' 

 



  

' 
"

 

5

 


'


  

G 
; !

" '






'
 


' 

  

 

G 
; ,

2




'



 
 

< 


 

,+

*


 
/

  
 

 "  

5

; ,,+0
ED5 10F
*
 
 !

!#0-
'

 *

*
 
'

"

 



+ !#0-



  "


 
*  


 
 5
*

* 
 

(?1!, 






"  
*
 








 "


5
*
 


4
"  
*
 
' 
 




' 


* 


*

7
*





'
"
/
"'


 

A 5

 

"

 '

A
 
-2
!$+
 !,+


4 

  


 



 

*
"


 '

 * 
  

'

4 '
" 

 
!!%


4 

  

* 
5 

 
5
 

""'

  


< 
"


  

4
"


* 





" 
!,
 ,
"
*
'
7 
*
; 2!2


' 


1  


 
"


 



 '
 '






 
5

' *



B

D5 ?1-:

'



 

 

 

4 

*


"




!,$$$:1


 *

 
-2



4 

  


* 
 
!0

 B   
 


 ""'
  

"



!$$:1


'
5 
'
  
 "

  * 

D

 

?1-:
*
*

 *

" 
'



5
' *




4

" 
!,

,
"
* 






5


*





* 







"
" * 

 
5

* 


  
'
 "

5

,2

*


 
/

  


"

' 

 


 


 
5


*

"  

 


 

4
  
 

 


3

 
" 
5

 
5 
'
7 


 

 


 

 

 


 
   






  
'
' 

/



*


'
*


 
 
 

 

*
 "   '

.
  &    9#   ." 


: ; /
# # %%: ;7 5

*

 *


 









*



 
 

* 

* 
< 
 


"

? 







   
'












 

*  < 
 
 
.

 







   
"



*



   



* 
 




,-

 


 
* 
9
 


  "

'<


'
'

1 

 


9
 

7
*





"

 
 


 



  

5
' *
7

 " 
'
 '



7

 




4
<
'



'

 


' *





 






  
"
7
 
  


  # !#0-
D5 (1!
 
   
 "
* 


 *

"




  
;
,,+0
*  


7 
 


* 

 

5
"






D5 (1!

4
*

 
'
"  
; ,,+0
 






 
*

'
  


*
'



 

,&

.

 

  
 
< 
; -

#
 
'
*
 





.


 





*




 


'






'
 

"



' *
* 


 
 



* 
 




;
< 

" 
'




 






4
 

'







D5 1+


"


 
- !#00 

'
*


 



"  



,0

9 
 

 
  


  
/



 





" 
  '











5 
" 
5
' 
'

*
 *


9
 

 
* 
7 


 
 




'


  


 

  
"
'

4



' 

'

"


 
&-







'


  
 *
 
 


'


4





*


'


'
*

 



 
   
 

*
 "   '

4

'
" 



*   

 

*










 
*
  


'
'


'


 *


 
/

4
5
*



'
  




 
-,


4 

  


 



 


'




 



 


'

' 
/ 
'*

,%

.
 *

  

 
/




 ' 








"

   "



:
1,+4;

12!40 <  5 %