← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12985/1997allowed

Haryana State Coop. Labour And Construction Federation Ltd Chd v. Commissioner And Secretary To Govt Hry Cooperative Department And ORS

2015-01-07Mr. Justice Harbans Singh Rai10 pages

   

 

 !"#"$%&& &

 

  



  

    

   

 

            

  '%()'*++    !

" #  $ %  

   &""

$ %  

 '

( ++ $$ $, ) * +

"" #            

 &   

 ,  - 

  

)). %* 

  $

)/0( 1  %  %    2$)/0(23+     +

    $  

       "       +  

  

 '

4(*    "      "   

 %  + 5   "     

 '

(+    "  " 

%+ 5  "   "

% %%  

  #  "     

 '

(+  "     #  

" $$ +

     %+ 5 6)6.)//.    

 %    676.)//.        + 4)68)//79 %)/   %"  )8 % +   "

  " '

:7 %      " "" #  + 5 ## +     "    % ""

% + """

  %  %   %   

   *  +   "  +     "       

 '

(+ "" "

   %):  %" ""  , " '

) ))):9  ""  

% # #   " +  %  % 

 '

(   +  7.

).8;

    "  

 '

(* +  # "" #   %

"  

))(



  $%   #   +   "

#  " # ++ 5   $      "% 5 #

   #+    -

+ +      

"" : *    

%"" # +  # % ++ 5     " 0.

   "  %)/0/ <    +    +  #     + -  <        + "" 5  * 

""   "  +   <    ++ <        5  * 

""   " 

+  # 

    +      %  +  

     "   %   "  $      "% *5 #  - 

 # #   " "    " " 

% + 5"   %     

""    " $ +-#  %  < 

 %%"+ % "

   -#           % * 

""      #   #      # )/:7 #   - 

* $

5     "    <     # $ + %    % -#   "  $ 5   

 "    =

5   1 =3 "    $ 5     

   

 %  

  

 '

(  

 %     + 5"        "      %    +   ""         %  +    " #  +     %   $#     

 % "   

)). % 

  $ +  %    #  - 

5  

""  "> +   +   5 #  , 

%       $      " + +   ?#     @  

 % "   "   + 5+   

" 

%     - 

5    

  

"

           $            "%  

- + #  "    #   +       5 # , 

%   ,

 % ,  +   % %  +  +#   $ +""

 4 = %     #   #    +    "      "

  "% %  

 

   +

 "%

  "      "

 # % % +

   A   " B,   B#     %  +

  A   # #&   % 

 

  

 % "  +

*   " &""+ " %       

  %    

      

  

"   5  #  

  !  % :66)1)3  :6(

 # 

"% "     % 

  

+     +      A       # #  &    +     " C  -#  * D=# 'A

"

  ! 5"   )/0)8/  #

   "   "

% 

   #    % " 

"  "%  

"        "% % 

  *  +   #     "

 #    + % "  

"%  

     % 

"C+   ,     

  

    -        % +

     ""+  +

    646/)//8      #"""

#*   "   +

       % "          

     



    

      #   #    # # &    9'

0)/ :%"

  -  #      # %   #+  % " "

#+  +

##  B,   B#  + A   #""

 5 %   

   *  "  

   '

(        %%      

          

   #   

4/ % $)/0(  "  5  - 

 $ " ::7::8 % 

 

%C  " %     A    "%  ( *    

  +                  

.

% 

%    +  # 

     "

 

    "" #  +C        

 ""  # #&   +    

    C%   

     "

  "" #  + + "      

%*  %   # %   % =  %&    +   # " ):60)//8 +  +  0

   " #  # #&    B,   B#  *

  &   E&D   +  "   

   #   "

+ "" #   

      #   $%  B,   B#  + A   #      "  

 " %  B,  #9%%    #      +   %  + 

 % " +

 %  

  "% %     # #&     +        %% ""  + " <      A

  *   

          "      "

  "% %  

  %     

%   # 

"+  

%  # #&    -# 

  



" 5  #  

   1 3* 

  "       %  A

# #&      + "    * &

= +    #     

+    # # &   +    #  C     * D =# 'A

"

   1 3 

"     %            %             # # &   $#   +   +  +  "

   # "" #   

C+    %  "

+%      " C%      

   "

 #    #"" #  # +  

  *  %         #    "  + #          % +

 . $ #           %           # #&     "  % " 

C+ "" "" "

  "  #" + "" # 

#   "



 "%  

   # #&   C% 

+  "

 % "   +

    %    

   

4/+ "" "    %     + C%  +# +  

  % #  #  %  5 # #  &     %%   " #            #  *

  %  # #&    

+ %

  "

    

4) % $ %)/0( 

4)1:3 

4)//"$ 0$ ,/12#, 3$!

"$# '

$ 4"$4"2!

2 1:3 *  # #&   

    

1)3 "" ,   

+   #      "+  " #        """

# ""%

  +   "+  #           ""

+ 5        " %     *  

 

+   # #&     # ""

 %

+   #            ""+ 5        " % 

    

4)143 

143*  # #&   %

  ""

 

" ,    %%  $""    %   ""  %

    %                   " *  # #  &          %   

"  B,  9%%  ""     %    %

 

      "  

    

"B,   9%%  + """     

+        +  

  C+ ""

  % %     # #&    # #  % # 

% "    *  - 

       #  5      

   '

(     %

 -   7     "

  "% % 

 



 

+  ,       %     

#   "%+ ""      ++   - 

*   "+ " %    % ++  +    

)6: 

"" $     

+ +  "   5   

)).

+  

)).

*    

 

%FG ##     H  ""  %     ,         %  

  #FG  $ " %    H

+  

""

       

))(     

  %   % #   "%        " #"

 

 % 

  %   ""

      

   "  ""          

% # #  %%    

   #        %  8 *  #       "       +     

" 

   

))(   

"

+  "  ,   C%   +

"

 "   

))(  

)).  "%   

 "+ " %    

%  2"    



* 

 # ""  ! "  

    %

   :6681)3  470   "+  

 % 

)6:

))()). % $)/0(C +  % =  %&      #   %   + +-  %   % "   

)6: % $)/0( & "

#+    

  2"    

 "

# '

)4)(% ""

+

)4  

)6:  %   



 "    +  % %    #  

 "

  #       %

   +                         

%%    #              %%    #         " #"      %     %%   #  %    %       ""  %    

%  %  

  "" - 

         #    %   C    %   

  )64  %       $     

+           "% % 

   +         +  

+   "% )(

  I!CCC % $  % 

" 

  

))(  % 

"  "

  

+   

)64 % $$  " 

"  %   4  

 +     $

"  " 13 %  

1:3 % 

))(  

"#  

   $

"     

1)3 """

      :8 *    ,     

"- 

%

"

   %     C%    

"  "

    

  + "     "

 $  "  4  

   %  

" %  

 

"+ 

    % "  %    = * 4 

  

 5   

  %   

  E          %              %%      +         % "  

   

)6: % $$

"   "

# + % $  %    9 # "

   

+   "  :0 C%  



+   "

2    

+  " "   ,    0 * #   

"+   "     +   2"    

 "  * 

 # ""    1 3 C%   

 2"    

  < "

"    %    

"- 

 ,           +

   

+    #       "5 - 

   * +

   ""

+ 

 #  / C "  ,     # #     %      $      "%+ # "  #   +   C +   #" * +      "    " ) )4% 

 ) ):%   

 C %    

 +      # "   #  C% "  #       

%  -

C

"    %  " -

      *   %      %   - " *   # 5   $  5  , 

%   ,

 % , *  

% $



  "    "

  "% %  

   

      % , 

  +#   4)68)//7 + "         +    #      % , 

 ##  C%     %     %""     

    "  " #"" " *   +    #     , 

%  9    

%%   %  +  % " $ , ) +  ""     < %  $ +  %    " 8

%  #  *      :(68)//7       %         %  

   %    $   +

"" ,   4667)//7   )86.)//7+   $ 

     ""

        #   +      "    ).67)//7       "" #    , 

%  %  # #  # + 4)68)//7C%    #  #     %  , 

  "% "    C     <   ,  

 %     ,   *   "" ,    

+   

)6:)64 % $ %)/0( ,    "

+  4)68)//7C%   +   :(68)//7       + " 4)68)//7 % +     $     +     "



% #  $ 2++ " ""

            #    *   

    %   "   #  %+ %  )6 *  %  "  #   "    %        "%  %    

      $ + 5         %"+* #   " 

 %   

""  + ""   %     %     %

   "      %   "

#   )666 #   5 ##

  "  % #    $ "   %   

    "% <      

      +%   #     B  %   " 0.    

 " %   "   "     %  %  C  2   

"  "-   #   % <   "%+  

" 9

       "  +  < +                 "   # +        

    "  #   %   $ *  <    % +     + -  < #

        , "

   #%  "   "

*    ""5       2"    

  5% !  $""

C !D

%C :6681.3).:

+ +"   % 

% $  

  $ %     "

 

 %  2"    

   -  %+   5 #+ "  "     " ).% ""

+ ).*     

   

   "5   +

%  %     5 #+  ,  ""

  *  

     "   % $  *    "    

 5 #

+

             2 #      +  

"

    2   *  "  

 %  2"    

    "" 

   5 #+   "  +    - 

+  +5   

 C  ;

  "



  !  %D :66(1)3$""E :4

  2"    

 "+   ++ 5  $   "

   5 +" # # +   +     +   

 ""

 %  +  +  " - 

5    

& 46 % $

$ %)/(6C "

# %  

 %  2"

   

   

    "

  "%  

  " C+ ""  -#  %   

J#  #!  %-J:8/  "     %        "       

  ..    .7      $  )/0(

$ 2+    *

+""   #   

%   %   " C " 

        %     <  %   $ +  +%"+ "5 %

          * -#  

""    )) *     "      

          $        "% 5 # "

 

C + ""   %-   %+  "

 -#     $       %+ 5C    "    "  "  -    +             % "    

% "% "

 "  * 

 "

, 

%

 

    " "-     "  

   ,    

+  5  "

"

    "            ,       # 



 

 

 $J#  $ +     % 

 %  -#  #  "%   >      "  5 #     % "

   $  +  

#" 5 ++ ""#       +   C% ""

 "" 5  "  #  %-    #

 ): *   " #"#     #   *

#  < % ""    %     +     :.

666;

"  ( 

  )4 * +

""

+  +     

 6++7 686):6).

 K