High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/3077/2016dismissed

Kuldeep Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"#$ %& $$## '( "

*+ $ )(

",-"

./( &"&&.0%#"

#(&$$## ( $'(, .#1.)"

*+ $$## !"#$ %&3 (+4#( -"%.$# "(.1"( $"( 567

8 ( "

(

7(("% ) 4&($"+ . 8 :

&( (((( ; .)# /#0 . # (, *"%, <

.&3 / & ( & (3&&&3 += (, (($

& /(4.&3 "

(

/(4 >9

%(, $3(

$& ?4#

7). 8 :

(%(%("

,$( , ($( 4( $4

..9 0 #4.

"#$4,

"(&("

(%(%("

,$( , ( 4(

$ "#

?($($?4$&

7). 8 :

(%(%("

,$( , ($(

4( $4

.9 @3 4 @&"

#4. "# $4, "(&( "

(%(%("

,$( , ( , &

: *

"( ($&

7). 8 :

(%(%("

,$( , ($(

4( $4

.9 @3 4 @&"

#4. "# $4, "(&( "

(%(%("

,$( , ( , &

##& 3(((("

"(( #4 (#4 .& & $($( /(

(& 8 .$#$(4(,)# /#0 .

# # +4 6 &&$# %& &( ( ((( & / % %(96&#&$#

3& $(## %% %3( & &!&"&.>,($"(A 3& &$#$(4&(&"#/( #, ( (#/ !&.& &"

3#= % & & #, (A %&$#$(4.&(&(334&$#4& +%.

3&&&3 ((4 % & & A&"

$$(& & + "

$ & , &($("#( 3( B"(+".

3&&& # A + %&=.&$#4& +%.3&&3

&/:/# : *

# % 3&+#"$ "# 3&"#+# 3& $3(A $( $(# :/# : *

3($($( "+#"$ "# .

3 ,$# 9 $ "# 3( $( (, % $ "#

3( /( $($(# A3 ,$# %, &3( (3 (,& $3( (, % $3(

+ %3%&,"+ %, A& ,$# ( "3( /( $($(# .& ##& ?$(# ,$# 3 +"#=$(# 3( #+4&6 / % %(3&& #&/ %

($ A ,$# #&3 $($(A5(, 83 ##"$A & &6 / % %(#&"

&&("#+ , &( ,(# & $

&&&#%#(%& + (& $( %C((% (A&"

&3/( ($ & 6 / % % (A

, &"

((.3&&3 &",+,(=+4& "

A&"%&$( # (&&"

"&(( +" & % (, %3 (/(A&(/( (+ 3

= $#$

/(/(4,,A&"

(( & $(("# .$($( %(B" ,, & # ("

3 & /(D,0"+4 @& 6 / % % ( ("B & $#

&("%&D!"#* %&. &+ 3&&(,#563 (( )# /#0 . #@&6 / % %($($( ("%& $# &$#(/(4 (( , 3

< ("( &$# .&"

# %3&& $($(4 3

3($("+(6

$(! 3#$( %&.D)# /#0 . #.3&/(&

@& $($(4&+ & /(&D+4&6

$(/ ("

, ,,E?)F9D# %3&5(, 8 + % .

$(! 3#$( %&$"& 3 #&/ %,$(

##&$(# 3## 5(, 8@&D96 / % %( &=$& $($(4 & "

("+##=@& "

$" &#="$ :

($($((,&&,#E?, (.

!&(( ,$# / % &((,# .&##

$($( # &"( $( &&## &"(.$ &( 3( "$$#&"

( . / %"

( () @& + (/ %&$(,&(%( "

(

&3 # %

.&3

&(% &( %#4.3&&.&$# %"#4 #, (# "( %&"( / .&$( ?, &##3 %3

)F )D)(,* %&.3&&= ,$#$(# &&,#E?, (.)"

*+.!&((&$ 3&(%( ,$#$(# &/ %(, "

,$("( %&$(.& (, & "

4 )F )D1"( , %&.3&&= & $#($(

-"#% ( &%&($#( &(%( )F6&&$# %&.&6 / % %(&

$ 3&(%((/(4 (+ (,&$

3## / % "+4&,D$(/ /("

", # )F<6,0"+4.3

(/(4 "$$(& &$( (4 ,(# $

)F:6

$(9D! 3#$( %& 3( %#43(

)F $ (%( %& $( "

(#( @&$( (#"$ /(#", &

/ 3 # , &"

(("

( (). 3&&##& (, %(", $$( % & $( / %

&,3($" "&"

+"& &##%

%&&3

&+ # #4 /#/ &

@&"

# 4/ 0( (#"(&(,"#&##3 %$ ( (,

F&&( 8 +" $, &(/##% #/!&. #."

!"#$ %&3 "

%(, $3( $& ?4#.:

"( ($& D0.: /#

$ "# ?($($?4$& 3&" 4# ($(,G

F&&(&$( & + +#$(/ +4 &

&3( +#"+G

(&( %(%", .#( (#"( /

, +/.3&&#&,%%(/ &&#&$( $$#.3&&3 = "$ 8

3& 3 ,((%"#(&( % (/(4 3 (( (, 4"( %&$ 4&$$# $$# "

( 8 () &/ % + # +4 & $$## 9"

(

& ,$( , "( % & $ 4 $$#.& ,3 ##3

(, % $$## 9"

$ "( %&$ 4&$$# &3 ((+(# +# & "( & %(B" +# + "(4 + & & -9"4 % ( (

73&$$#& ,"$( #&( %

< 6&/&(#( "

#(&$$## H"

/.#( #1.(&)"

*++ % %&("%& &((

D( +& & 3

(/(4 ,#4 )F 6 &&$# %& )F<6,0"+4&/"##4 "$$(& $( (43&(%("

&/ %+ "

(+ %(, $3(

$& ?4#. : *

"( ($& D0. :

/# 3&& ( 4(, ##+#4 $(($( E?)I9

" # ,3& , && $ "# ?($($?4$& 3&" 4$(,(

# @&43((

?, # %& +&#&"

+" &4 "=&(%"

"# + &( ,(#$ 7 $(/"

,4+3 &, &"

H /& + ##% ($(/$(,$+43&&&4,%&&/ /#/&"

& 3( %#4 $ %

&, # #4 "( &

/ @&"

%/ +4& )F ,"+3(&4 (# 5(,& , )F )D)(,* %& )F

$(9D! 3#$( %&., "&& $($(4 (, "

4 ,$( % # &= $#

%$( E?)I9 E?)I9<(/(,&&,# E?, (.!&((# % &3&& ,$#$(# &(& &(3& # 6 .& ($( E?)I9 .E?)I9 E?)I9<% &3& + % #4C.& ,$# 3("

"+ .3&( (, ($(E?)I9 &

,$#/# #)& (, #3&& ,3& , &&

F&(%(+* +4#( "

#(&$$## +" * % $ 3

. /3 # "

+/.& + "

&&#3

&/ 4 ,43&&"

$(,$+43&&&4,%&&/ $# # "$ &"

($ %

&,3( %#4

"(& / / &(3 .&$

# 3

($(3&& $ 3

.&((&

+* " 45"(&(,(. $ ((+(

("#$(" (B"(, #36 3&($(/

4 "& $ ((+( ,"

+ &(.& &$( (*"(%&#4 &( $"(3(+4#( "

#(& $$## 3 & ,$# 3( 50("(4 .3&& ,4 /3 3&",( & , ((&& ,$#$(#

&(&&&,#E?, (.)"

*+!&((3& #

$(*" &3 &/+ "

( "# ,$# &/ %+ &&,#E?, (.

!&(((<4 @&((.& +* 3&",(

0( "

# & "(&( $# (# "$

*"%,

!! "" #$ % &'

( ) 63 3& $ 3

&+ * "( %& (& (/(4 (+ D&$$( 3

(& %&& % "( 3($("( +# = $$( 3& &&/ &$# ("

= "& 3 $ &# % &

+ +#/ &

",("

% "( /("

$$( &/ %( 3( ,(# "#+ % +43

+# =$$( @& , 4& 3

3 &# + "

(#+# 3 ( 6 & /(4 *"%, .(+#4#9$#3

( 3 + (/&3& &( ##% 4 ,4%

& $## # #4,$#&$$## &(3 (

(&,$ %

&$$## .&(#"(&(%&#4 #"& ?, $ 3

* (/(4+ %3 /(+4&"

( 4"+ & $(

@& $#4 %& ,$#& &,#E?, (3 # "

&# %&3& & ,$#

3( &&,#E?, (3& &"( .& $( /

+/ &%("

&( 3 $ $(/ & & (%( &

%(( &( $3( #4&%"# (%"# (#&( ( #3(= %7( (# "("

@&$( & $(/ &(%%

/#4 (,/#4 @&"

"# &(( ( ( +#($#"

+#?$# (& ##%# ,$# ( "#&"

( $

& "+ 3&" 4 # ( $(, &(+4 &3 % & & 3

"& (+ (%( & $(.&"

(%(%("

,$( , ( 4( &.3&& &, ,", $( (+ ( $

,,(# B" 4 & (+ (%( %(, $& ?4#E/ &(3 .& $$## 9"

($"

(4+ $$#43&#/ &#&$$#&(+4,= %&,= %("% @& ("%$#( &/ "

"##4 (4& #+("( 4 #4"&&3( %"#$&"&4$$(

+# 3&(,#4 ( #4 4,$&4 + &3 &,# &

&"# $(/ + "

( $("/ ( "# ( ("%

(= %@&((.& 3(&$$## 9"

+ /(4&%& ##( 4("

@&,$"% *"%, / (( $

+4&(#"((3## ( .+ "$ $($( $$( # $$( / (( ($( #3 @&( ##%#4( (,4&( @& *"%, /

(( ("$&#3&( &$$# "

+ 3&" 4,( & , ,

( %#4

< $$## !"#$ %& + +#%( &, +4 & "( D +# ## & -"# % (.

1"( $"( (

"(( 3(( %&,(( ,=&,"

(%&(, %

# $%&'

()%* $+!', &) % # *& $-.

&) %