High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/794/2012dismissed

Arsad And Others v. State Of Haryana

2019-10-16Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu26 pages

#$%&% '(

!) #$%&% '( !!"

* #$ +,#-./&/%&!

(- 01( / (

# $%

& '"(

'"( ' ) **** ( 2/

+ ( ( + +

, "

( & -.-//0---1-//0--' ("

'" +('

("(

(.21.3/ # 4 '-560

+ $% !

-000)% .21' #4 "

( /10)% .3/' #4

( # (

+ + ( 08--/0-0 9:7#;' < 4 9#=%.;'

# #

" >

< 08--/0-0 -/$.0 '

((

( -/$00 '+ ( 7"

(

+ 100)%

%? 9#=%3;+

(

( ( (

'@ 9#=%-.;+( + +

+ ( ( ( & ' '+

+ -'26'000)%' ' "

(

( /'06'.00)%(

-0'.00)%

+ '

/1 '+ + 30

+ "

( + (

+( ( " ( ( +

A (( ( # # '( "

( + " ( "

+ ( ( (( '

( B "

( ' (

9:7#C;

+ ((

&, > /1/ 08--/0-0 9:7#>;'

(.21'.3/ #4+

(/1 ('-212

# < 'D(

+ '"

( (( +

# + B08--/0-0'

( + "

# +

( &( (( ' %( '+

,+ 7 , ('+(+

B' ' +

(-0/4#4 (9:7#<;+"

!( ' +

' " #

+'( + ( " # '

+ 4 (4 + ( '" 05--/0-09:7#,; 02--/0-09:7#@;+

!( ' + 9 &; "

4 (4

&,'# < + ( '" 9:7#4;

+ ( 02--/0-0 7?

(

' ( ( '+ ( '" -5--/0-09:7# ; 4%(( )("(

?& 9

;> -58 /0-0/0-0'

(.82 3/0' #4'

+ ( 0.-//0-09:7# ;

" + (%(( ( +

( ( + (( ' + (

# ( -5-//0-09:7#!; ( ( (( (%(( )("( ! + --0-/0--

' ' (

--0-/0--9:7#;( ' (

( (( +

( ( :7 B/:7 B. +( 9:7#D;4

) "(

9:7#:;'" ("

9:7#B; # 9:7#; (

(( # ( ("

4 + :7#, (

# 020//0--9:7#4; ( ((

+ D 'D B /.03/0-/' (%(( )("('

' + D & '

(

" (

( ' ( ( ((

' ' + -308/0-- ' ("

( 9:7##':7#E:7# ;

" ( ( ' (

( (( '" 9:7# ':7#:7#F;' ("

31'

' !!"

+ 0105/0--.005/0--' ("

' (

9:7#?:7#G;

" (

( ' ( ( (( '" 9:7#=:7#H;' ("

+ + (

(-6-4#4 (

(-8.4#4 + 4 ( &( ( +

(

( .21' #4 +

4' '

( (

' + +

4 (

' (

(.21'.3/' #4 +

(/1

(

+ (

((

'+('

(

' ( 7 -6+ + $%

# $

%& '

)

-- . $"

&0 ! "

! "

4 ! "

0 "

! "

7 !

) $ :

* 2-- $ ! "

; #=%- 4' (<

(

> /1/ /0-0'

(.21'.2/' #4'#

< ' ( /001/0-- #=%/ & ' '4

4' +

( > -58 /0-0'# '

(.82 3/0' #4' 05-//0-/ ( " #=%.< 4 + # #

" >

+'<) &? @ + +

B 08--/0-0 -/$.0 '

%? "

( (

( +

( (( ( -'26'000)%+

( ( -0'.00)%

%? + +

( 7&

= + ( # #' + "

(( 4 ' "

( 9:7#;

/'06'.00)%

( ( +

/0%/1 +

(+ 5)-0 ' +

+ B05--/0-0' "

( ' (( ( # '

( # ' + + (

(( + ( # <

+ # ' + F ( '

+ # #'+(+ %( '

( + (

( 9:7 B-;'

( ( (( ;'+(:7#, + +

4D < + ( + 9:7#4;' + +

& 0

(

' <' # ' + B -5-//0-0' ( ( /0'000)%+( + 7 ( -@ " + ("

)

((

+ ( :7#>4

9:7#:;'+( + + (

( ( :7 B/:7 B.'+( + " (( + , + + ( 08--/0-0

+ ( 05--/0-0'02--/0-0 -5-//0-0 D (% 7'+ "

(9:7#;+

%? <@

( # # -1

? < ( + "

(' ( " ? #

+ ( A

> &

& +# #

<'+++ +

'+ (( + +

' ' <+ " # #' + +

(

/3+7

+ (( '

(

( ((

( (

%B# 6 # B'

+ # # 6#

( # # -$00 08--/0-0 # ( "

( ' +

( (

' + ( # 6)8 "

(

%? ' @ <

D < ( (( ("

( # ' +B

' 4D < + # ' +2$.0 4 ( -/ 05--/0-0

# ' + '

(( ( "

(4 D(44

7 + ( (( (

( (( ( ( +" ( ( ( ( '+ ( (( '+(+

( # < # ' +.

# 4 (( +( -5-//0-0'

B ( & "

( -308/0-- ' (( + ( (

+ ("

(( 4 #=%3? 08--/0-0' +

+@ " >

-/$00

' + B ( >

(

+ ( ( ( ( (('+

100)% "

(

= + ' + "

+ (( "

(

'++ 5)-0

+" 3.00)%( '+(+ ( + ( 7"

(

+ ( + >

+@ D

(( ' '+( &

+ ' + (( -'26'000)% + ( /'06'.00)%+

( "

+ + 7"

(

-00 +

+ %< 4 + 7"

(

+ + #

+ "

(

' +( +

((

(( ( 4 D (% 7'+ (( ' 4'+ " + (

(( 4

((

++ # # (( + ( 6)8 08--/0-0

&+( '

' + (%

7 ?

(

' +

# #@ "

&' ' + (%

7 ( .0)31

+% "

+ #=%1 +

& " >

B06--/0-0 ' + # #-/ + ( # #' ( 7 "

(

+ (( +

%? 7 "

(

( '+ ( ( ( (( 7"

(

( + (( ' 4'+ + (%(( D (% 7'+ +

& '+(& " >

'+ '' +&

--)-/ "

(

-1<

' '

' (

+ +

+ "

-)/ (( +

(( 4 (( '

((

( .0

#=%6 D &' ' # < 08--/0-0' + # < ' (9:7#; +

4 D <' ( > 9:7#>;

9:7#;

( 4

<' 205 ( +

#=%84

< 08--/0-0'

+ # < + + ( ( "

( +

D (% 7

( +

#=%5

4 <'# -5--/0-0' 7"

(

%38%,%//26'+(+ ( ( (+> -58 /0-0'

( .82' #4'# + ( 4 + (

'# #<

9:7# ;'+(+ 4D <

+ + ( "

B ( #=%2

,< -5--/0-0' +

+ "

( ( "

' "

(

%38%,%//26 9:7# ;' ( > -58 /0-0'# '

4 < 4D <

( + '

'@ ? '+ "

(

" (( D (% 7'+

( + '@ ? + +

(

%+ ( #=%-0

# -5-//0-0'"

( + '(( %

+ ( ( ( ( F ' (( %

(

9:7#!;' :

D' " ( D (% 7' + (( + 44

7# # /%/I' + +(

( (( + # #

( #=%--4

< 08--/0-0'

+ & 0

B#'

B'# '

+'+(+ (

(-0/4#4

' + (

:7#<'"

B'# ' + + (( ( B02--/0-0' + "

( # #< + "

( > /1/ /0-0'# < '

(.21'

.3/' #44 '

4' +'

:7#@ + "

( # < '" 9:7#4;'+(+ + +

< 49#=%.; +

+(:7# 9:7 B-;'+( + "

( ##<'" 9:7#4; + ( #=%-/

)

B <'# < 06-0/0--' (

(( '

(-8.4#4

D (% 7' + "

( ? "

(

( ' (( + (

#=%-.@ +

" >

'+ < H"? (%+ B 06--/0-0 -/# ' +? + >

'+ 7"

(

? + (

(

= ?

' +"

((+ ( 7"

(

'( ( + ( + "

+ 6000)% +

+ (

( & ( ( 3.00)% ? < ( ( (( 7"

(

++ + ' + &

'+ +

( + ( (

+ -00 ? + + >"

+ 7"

(

# '+(+

(

((

9:7 B-; D (% 7'+ (

( ( +

( (( +

(( + "

+ ( +(( (( .0 + "

7 &J +

+ '

+" ( +( ' + (

7 +" 7 & ? & ( + %

(

'+ + >

(

( % + " " (

( ? +& .

+( "

++ +( + +

( ' (( ? +( "

(

(( #=%-3

?&# 0.-//0-0' +

) "

B ( '# ' (( %

( (+> -58 //-0/0-0'# '

(.82'3/0' #4(( ( 9:7# ;

" (

( '+(+ 4

D D (% 7'+ + +& (( %

+ (+

( ( ( 9:7# ; #=%-1 4 & < --0-/0--' + ( (

'(( % ! + (

9:7#;

" ( (

( '(( % ("

( (

" >

( +( @7D " 4

4' + + ' "

9:7#B;' + 4

:7#:4 :7#D+ ( ( :7 B/ :7 B.> -308/0--'(( '

)) ' 4'+

' ( 9:7##':7#E:7# ;' ("

( " (

+ ( ( '(( '

( ( (( " 9:7# '

:7#:7#F;' ("

+ B0105/0--'(( ' 4'+

(

9:7#?; ( '(( ( ( (( '" 9:7#=;'+( +

+ ' .005/0--' (( ! !"

4'+

( 9:7#G;( ' (

( (( '" 9:7#H;'+( +

+ D (% 7' + + + & (( J ("

+ (+

( ( (

)

9:7##':7#E':7# ':7#?:7#G;

( ( (( + +

( #=%-6

B ( ( --0-/0--'(( % + ( 9:7#; ( ( '(( ("

( 9:7#:;'( 9:7#D;+

( ( " > :7 B/:7 B. @7D "4

'4'D( +'

+(+ '" :7#B' 4 & < (

# :7#4 + ( (( ' 4D 'D '+( +

+ (

( -6-4#4B-308/0--'(( ' ) ) ' 4'+

4 &< ' ( 9:7##' :7#E' :7# ;' ("

( ( ( ' ( ( (( '" 9:7# ':7#:7#F;' ("

B 0105/0--' (( ' 4' + ' ( 9:7#?; ( ' ( ( (( '" 9:7#=;B .005/0--'(( !!"

' 4'+ ' ( 9:7#G; (

' ( ( (( '" 9:7#H;'+(+ :

4 & < 4 &< + (( + (

(( ' ''

'!!"

' 4>

# 9:7#;' # ( ("

( (( 9:7#,;'+(++

&,' (

# #<'

:7#,'

:7#4 :7# '+( +

&, : 9:7#C; (9:7#; +

+ +

'+( # ( "

#= 4 <' 4D <'4

&,':

4 & < ( +

(.-.4#4' ( (

( '+ '

" +

@ 4' (

(.21K.3/' #4 "

(/1 (

(

" ("

(

' "

("(

(& ( > ( (( ( + '+( ( +

( ("

(

' ' ( ( "

" @ ( ( 4("(

( '

( " + ( ( (

B '

(

( ("

(

("(

(.21.3/' #4

(

" + (

( (

% ( ('

%+ ( '

'? ' @ 9#=%3'#=%1#=%-.;'

(( "( '

( + ( ( 9#=%.;' "

B ( 9#=%-6; +

+ 7"

(

' ( ( "

%+ '

+ (%

(( ( " >

'< 49#=%.;' 7"

(

06)08--/0-0-/$00 '

100)%'

%? 9#=%3; ' + "

(

( 3.00)% (

%@ 9#=%-.;+ +

( 6000)% +

(( (

+ & + -'26'000)% "

(

'' /'06'.00)% + (

+ " (

( +

+ (% (( 9(%("(;"

%+ ((

(

' ( ( '+

" > -58 //-0/0-0'

(

(.823/0' #4#

'D( +' %+ ("

' ? '

9#=%3; ( (

+ +

( (( :"

@ '

9#=%-.;

4 ' + "

+ ( ( +

+ ( 9#=%1;

( + ( ( (

' 7"

(

+ # #'

'< 49#=%.; ( ( ( ( 4 (4 :7 B-

' "

B ( 9#=%-6;' "

( ' (+

( ( 9:7 B/ B.; (%(( )("( ! '4 9:7#D;' "( )4

9:7#:; 4 ( ( ('

( % < 4'+(

( '+ ("

(-0/4#4 +# ' + ( "

02--/0-0 9:7#@;'

' +

4 + ( + ( +

( ( + " >

' ("

(%(( ! '+ "

( ' "

" >

' + ("

" ( ( ( ( ( ((( 7"

(

%38%,%//26'+(+

+ (%(( +

( ( ' + ( + (

+ ( ("

(

+ ' " //--/0-0'

4' + 4%(( )("(

+ > -58 //-0/0-0'

(

(.823/0' #4# "

(

'+(+ ( ( (

?&# 9

;

" (( +

( ( ' + (+

#' ( ' :

< 4 9#=%.;

( ( (( (%(( )("( ! + --0-/0--

9#=%-6; ' ( 9:7#; ' +

( ( -00)% /0'000)%9:7 B/ :7 B.;( ( 9:7#D; "( )( 9:7#:;+ ("

'" 9:7#B; B (%(( )("(% +

D &/.03/0-/ ' (

" ( (

' ( ( ((

' ' + -308/0-- '

( 9:7##':7#E:7# ;

" ( ( ' (

( (( '" 9:7# ':7#:7#F;' ("

31'

' !!"

+ 0105/0--.005/0--' ("

' (

9:7#?:7#G;

" (

( ' ( ( (( '" 9:7#=:7#H;' ("

(

%38%,%//26'+(+ ( '+ # + ("

( ( + (

' (( '( (( + ( + &( # + +

(-0/ 4#4+

+ ( ( + "

# < ( + '" 9:7#,;+ ( ( +-'26'000)% + (( (

( ( +

%( ++ ' + ( 9#=%.; ( (( "

<'#

" + (((( '( "

' 4 ( (

(+ '

( ("

(

' (( +

4 (

" % "

('4

+ ( + (

" + (

( (

(

'4( (( " + ( + " +%%' +

(

( /3+

(

( (( '

(

+ "

(

' "

(

+ L

4( %&&3.)20 45** #$ ** 6 ,70'+

+ ( ('( -250' '//' "

$% <

(

;

; -

- .

= - &

0 :

0 '

= -

0 ;

; =

= : ;

(3*

-> '

(

%!!"

94 % %2.8% ,% /0-/;+ 4'" /1--/0-.++ ' " ( '

%! !"

' (

4 !( ' ++.0 ( B '

4 !( '

+ ( ( ("

( (

% !!"

+*#4 .2%&!

( 0 ;7 ?