← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2500/2014allowed

Harwinder Singh @ Rana v. State Of Punjab

2024-05-18Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan20 pages





      

    

!"#$#%&'&()*"+!, 

-    .  //

0#'1'

 2 

 )

3/ 

 

4

-  

   

        



4

-5  " 

   ##

# 

  $% &' $& ' 

 

 ) #    * (

 

%&+ ,  " -+& .   / 0,1 2 $  $+ & $& 

%&+ ," #



!

 3   $

 

%&+ ,"

# # 

 &4 ( 

 1 &&&&56



 (  

# # 

 &%  %  #

*

6 *

#

8 $' &$ $&&$

&$ 



*9   $4 & $&

 #    ,

 )   )  '

   

  #   



5 6 *

# 

66 ( 

#

66 (

:

;#

##

  

 #

9  

  (  





9   '

< $4 & $& 

&=&& 

  

#6



  

# > 

9    

    





6

 9 )   )   

 #  ' $ < $+ & $&   6   9*  #

  

9* 

#  







 )   )  < #    

#

63

#

 

  #    * (  9*

 

' % < $+ & $& 

&+&&      

 #



 < #    ,

#

#       *  #  

 * 0,1 # ' '

  # ?

  

(  

# #   

 #      

 * 

6

  *

#

66 

#

  *  #    .@



=% " "   A=% 

  (

 

6   

  # &$

 ( 

#

:



     + &' $& $



 



% A "  "

+  #

 

 

%&+ ,"

#(    #



 *   (

  

=  

   > 

&  * -  6

# .B6 / 

  *

# #

    

#

#

#

#  >



66 

#

66

:

#

#

# *

#   

 9 )     *  



*

#

66 * @

  # 

*     #



6 





 $$%

$$'

,"  0,1 2 +% $&&'



# !    

    #

# *  

#  # 

#   

 

# 9 



 

# - $   

# .B6$/ ( 

  

9*    . /

 9 

 

6



   *  > 

  @

  



    

   *

#   9  

- % 3 D

   < "     .B6%/  $+ & $&  > 

(   :

  "#  > E  .C> C/  



#

 

 * 

 (   - '

 :

 3  "   .B6'/  $A & $& 

#  ,

#          

  

# - 4  ,

9*

# 

!

 3   .B64/  #   # $4 &$ $&     "





# "

) 

#

 "

;

*

# < &4 &% $&   ) #

#

9*

# .    #/

+ "  "

  

 



- +  "

.



#/ 

;

* .B6+/   

(   :

 #  $+ & $& & . $+ & $& /

(    "   ##    .C> "/ - = ) #

# .    #/ .B6=/   # 

8 $' &$ $&$$

 *   

#

*  

 66

66     

#

9   !  

 @

(

 

#

  

    #   

9*  # #   #     6 * (  

- - 3



  < )   )   .B6-/  $& &4 $&

&%&    

 ,"F

  

6  (  #    

 (  > $+ & $& - A ) 

#  "

.B6A/

 * - &     ,

# .B6 &/ ,# # < $+ & $& 

    )   )    :

. / *

6 





) 

 #  

  > <   

#  "

!



# "





# "

) 

#   *  #      ?

  .C> </

  * # # 

(  < $= & $&

 6  *

#

 

#

 

<     



?





 % % "  "

 * 

# 

 

   

&

6       :

 * 

#  * > 

3B6

  

9

* 

 

*  

   .

6

 / #

  

( < $4 & $&

&=&&   *   (#  (  ( #

  9#  

# < #  9    

 (# #

  #  

 ( 

 

# *  

6   * 



   *  

  #   

6 *

# (

#  

* 6 

6

# .

6 6 /

:

.66 /

?

 #    ( 

  

 $  

 ( B6

# B6$

#

B6= ) #

# #

6 *

# ( 

    *

 ,  B6=

6 #

    #

 (

      



   ( 3B6    :

 *

#

6 *

# #  #

6

#

# 6 :



  ( # 

 ,

  (  3B6  





#  

6 *

# 

 

(

%&+ ,"

%   *

?

# 6 

( 

#

:

  

#



#

( 1(#

 ( B6 &  ,

#6,# # <  #

&$ 

   *  

# #

 

# (    # 6 

:

'

  # 







# 



  

  #

8

#  $' &$ $&&$

( #

(  

#  

 &A (    # #     

( # #

 

#

#

# &- ( 



# &4 (  C

#

 

 *

 

(#



,  

 

(  

(

 

,  9 

   . /   

9* 

#

  



 

   *   

+

  

  ( B6 .   / B6$ .

  /

B6= .6 #

    #/



 





    ! (   

  (   

     #



 #

(



%&+ ,"

# (

=

  



  > 



      

  775

   

 

 

! "

# $ % & %

#&''$ ()

-



  



  

    

#  





   # &$  

    >

#

 #



6

,   

#( 

     .B6 /

#6   .B6$/

,  

 

 

9

*

 

$&   ( 3

 8 .B6-/  * &$  

#

  

 ,"F (  #

&%&  $4 & $&

  $+ & $&

$%&     " C>  .C> C/    ,     B6% 3 D

    >  

#

   , * 

 (  

 #



 #  " C>  .C> C/ !  

  #  

#

&$   !     ,  

 (

 



#( 

   

 #



 $ 2* ?





* #



  #

(

 



# (

G $$

&= ,"



 





#

#  ( # 

  #H  ( # #       

 ( # # 

  #  9   

  (

 # #H  (  (



  #  # # $%

%&+ ,"



  *  

   *

     

   

 * >  ( 

 





 $'

, * *6  



%&+ ," 

  

     

 (

#   , ?





 



 *     $4 E >  * # # 

# 

%&= ," 



      

6   775

 

#

* *

%&+ ,  " 



   * 

   

 

 # 

# 

     

E >

6

I>>> >>> >>> >>> $   * 

  # #



(

%&+ ,  "  

%&+ 

 

&= 



# !(

*  J           ,

   *

     

   

 * >  ( 

 







   

 

 #

# * !",# 

  #H 

#

"

C# #       

 ( # # 

  #  9   

  (

 # #H 

$

"

, (



  #  # #

%&



'"

  *

*   

*  

  *

  (

    



  

#

 # # #

%&



(" B   

 

 

(#   



    

#

 J

% # 

# 

 %&+ ,  " * #  ( 

 )

 # *#  

+ ,(-.-)).

-/(-.& 

0/.(-'#'(1

* $

%  J $   

  # #

   (

#  #

# ,   (

 *     #   ( # # 

  *

 

# # 

# #

# ?







#  

%&+ ,  "

% , #  23*4

5 6

     

>( 

# 

   



    # *  (      

#

 ,   

#  (  (   

   ?

  ( *

#

   

 >  

 (    

# (      



#

#

  #

#    

 ( J '

 7 8

*#  9,(.)) .

0:/(.)5'/.('#1  

 >

&= ,  " * 

* + J+

&= ,  " 



# 





   ,  "  

 #

# * . / # 

  #H  .$/ # #     

 ( # #H  .%/  (



  #  # # ! #

 



 * J# J  (   9 

# 

#



 

#



#   (  



  



&=

&A  



  ?





   

  

   #  J J

&A    

 ! 

 *

  #

  ( 9   J

K 

 7

9

#6 *#  ;

+ ,(1.')) .

1-/(1.')5:/.(1-#:(L

!   ( 9 *

 #

 (



%&+ ,  "   ( >  

  



 

 

   *  (

   

 

  ,



  

#

  

   

    (

#  * 

#



 >   

 *        

%&+ ,  "

+ , 

#

* *

%&+ ,  " 





  * 

     (

 

 # 

# 

    !





  # 









  



%&+ ,  " = > @

E

 

&= ,  " * * 

 ( > 

  

   *

 # 

  #



(  

(#



 (  (

&= ,  "

&A ,  "  



  

?



  

   #  >>> >>> >>> >>>M $+ E >    

 

 

! "

# $ % & %

#&''$ ()   



#   

 * *   

    



  ?



 (  ,  

 

?

 * ./  *   # 

    

./   E >    



%&+ ," 

  

    

E > 

6 I>>> >>> >>> >>> $&  



#   

 * *   

    



  ?



 (    

?

 * . /  *   # 

    

.$/      

(

(#    

 *

  



( 

 N  .

J

J / $ 0  C# *

- " )   A+=    * 

 ,  J  

( # *

 



.

/  

   

 



 ( 

#



?

 

H

.

/    *      



   *#    

     J

F

-.

/ 

(

*

* 

(#

(      #



 

$$ , * *   



%&+ ,"



       

 (

#   ,

 ?





  

 *     #  

 

 ( 



 >>> >>> >>> >>>M $=      

 &A (   #

 &$  

#

# &- ( 



# &4 ( 



#   0,1 #

    6 *

 

B6 #   ! > ( #  

 6

     ,  .C>  /  .B6 /  #

#

 



(

 *

# 

#

#

#  !    (

#  

#  

 6

# .B6 /

 (     0 $$ (   

9*# # 

 

* ( (  

 *  #  ##

    

  .B6 / 6>   



# #   

#

6 * C  



 , 6>    .B6 / *

 9  

*

 (    *

 *      (



#  *

 *       $-

  (

#

 

B6$ #  C 6>  *  #

 

      (  #   *

*   $A  6

#   



#   *

 

 

B6 , >  66

6  *

#

9

(

#  *     #



 .C> /

 * 0,1 # B   

>



(    * ,# # <  ,

# .B6 &/ *   .C> /

 6>   #

#      *  #  

# .B6 / #  

#   

(  # #    

     (

    

 # %& C  





 6

# .B6 /

 

#



$$% $$'

,"

 0,1 2 +% $&&'

#







 

  &&6 4& 9   # "

# *

#  ,# # <  ,

# .B6 &/

  

    * 

 *   





# 

  0,1 2 +% $&&'

C

#     :

.3B6 / * % (  

    .

6 *

#/ # 

  #

 ./ 9#   

# . /



    9 

 *    (# #

(#

 #    



#

  



 

# *  



# 

6

 *

   * &  

  )  C B6$

#

 6>     *

#   9   B63

 8 *  (

  

 6> 

 # 

.

/ 







6 9   

66 

# * #

6 9 







6 9 #   *

  

.

/

  #   %  #  (  * .3B6 / *

#

&A (  



#  

 * 

 * (  

# % ( 

 

6>  

#  

 # #  





  

 # ( $4 & $& 

=&&    (#  ( 



 # (  

9

* 



 

*   ,



  #  #   

*

 ( * * 



   

  (   

 * ! #  ## 



 ( 

 



     

*

 6  %$ !

   *

 9





#  

 *

   

##  (  

 0,1 2 +% $&&'

# 



  B6    6



  (#

"

 ! #      * 



 



##  (

#

 ( > (     (  

##

    !    

(6 9

 

 > &$  

  (      #

 *   ?

 



#  (



   

  



  





&= ,"

%% , *

 

   ,

    B6  B6$

B6=  *(  



 



 (

 

 # 

#

   

!   

(

   B6 .   / B6$ .

  /

B6= .6 #

    #/ 

(  * 



,

    

(  * 

,



  

# 

  $% &' $& ' 

 

 ) #    



 %'

"?

( 



*

# 

  $% &' $&$' 

 



%4 #  

  

(   

 



4

-  

  *"+!, 

'  *+'

,-  %*. ,-