P. K. Sarin v. Union Of India And Others

     


 



  
 

 !"# & ''

#+, ,$% &

-''

'.'

/(!,% ''''''''

),),$%!

 0! 1 %,$% %#,( $)2!

'''''''

 3$%#%)


& 4 5 '

/
 0 / 4 5 '

/
 .5  / ! %)& ),),$%!

3! $%'

!'

(6"

/2(!7(8 #"$+()8 ! 3$%#%) '

' ' .5  /8 '

),),$%!(339,+(%) ';' <

%%=1!>8 3( #
%)!(9 #7,%, )!(),"

2(%#,:(!2

%+28
2(%#,:(!28

2!,%(*)!

!*!!# 4)2 !,?1%(948 ",# A2,+2 (339,+(),$% B,%:

$#,*,#  1!#
(!!,!

!$:! ,$% /+27

2!,%(*)!

!*!!# 4
 /+274

#+9,%#

/+!%,%:

$77,)) #,!+)# !+$% ,#!

)

*1!)2!

#,!+)# *$1%# *,)8 2(99 :,"%

(!!(!

(!, ,%:

(7'

2(99 ,%)! ) 

#3$ ,) !() +$77%+,%:

'-' -

(+)1(9 #() (!!(! '

 $!#!# :!(%)# A,)2,% ,:2) AB '

+$%)!$"! @ 3! %) "!@ 2$!)'

6$,%#

1%,$!

%:,%!

'>'

< ?+(7  , )(%) %:,%!

+)$?!8

>-'

3!$7$)#  , )(%) %:,%!

' '

>- ?*$!

+$739),$%

!",+'

:!(%)# +$%# 
 (*)!

+$739),%:

- !",+ '>''


 (99$A# '<''

(33!$(+2#
%)!(9 #7,%, )!(),"

/2,79(

%+28

/2,79(8

A2,+2 (99$A# (339,+(),$% +$% C1%)9@8 :!(%)# +$%# 
 '>''

 3!

(!9,!

+278 $"!%7%) 739$@ 13:!(#(),$% +$739),$%

- !",+ 3!$",## 739$@ #,# :) (%@ 3!$7$),$% $!

*,%(%+,(9 13:!(#(),$% #1!,%:

3!,$#'

 ! 19) !+$77%#(),$% /,=)2 (@
$77, ,$% ' '8

/+27 7(# **+),"

%)!(9 $"!%7%) 739$@ '

'>8 (++$!#,%:

A2,+2 739$@ )2!

*,%(%+,(9 13:!(#(),$% +$739),$% 8 8  !",+'

!),!#

!",+

 '>' -'

+9(,7 /+27 '

'>8 ?1) (7 :!(%)# 3),),$%!'

@ A(@ (33!$(+2,%:

+9(,7 /+27

:!(# 3(@  '

<

+9(,7 D ,%)! )'

 3$%#%) 2(# )(B% )(%# ?*$!

!,?1%(9

/+27 :!(# 3(@  '

<8

+$% ,#!# )2$ 2(",%:

:!(#,%:

9( ) 7(@ (  # *,)

?%*,)'

 #,# *19*,99 +!,)!,( 2(# !),!# !",+  '>' -'

,)

39(## ,%+ #,# *19*,99 +!,)!,(8 :!(%)#

?%*,)'

!,?1%(9 $? !"# 3!1 (9 +2(!) !"(9 ?% +$% ,#!# ! 3$%#%)

A, +$77%+,%:

'

'>'

?% +$% ,#!# +$77%+,%:

'-' '-' 8 '-' 8 '-' 8

/+!%,%:

$77,)) *$1%# *,) ?+(1 #$ 2("

:!(#,%:

9( )

;

+$% ,#!# /+!%,%:

$77,))'

!,?1%(9 *$1%# :!(#,%:

<>    2("

?% +$% ,#!#'

/,%+ $7  (339,+(%) 7, ,%:8

 2("

?% +$% ,#!#'

$?)(,%# :!(#,%:

$%9@ !9"(%) (:(,% ) !C1,!7%) @(! '

%+8 +9(,7 )2, !,:2)9@ !6+)# ! 3$%#%) '

+$77%+,%:

'-' -8 2(",%:

:!(#,%:

'-';

' '8 <8

1) )(%#,%:4 :!(#,%:

'-'< '<'<8 4$$#4 :!(#,%:

'<'<  ''>8 :!(#,%:

 '' '

$% C1%)9@8 3( #'

 2("

2(!# 9(!%# +$1% 9 3(!), 2("

+(!*199@ :$% )2!$1:2 *,9'

+9(,7 A''*'

#7,))#9@8 1%#!

!19 8

!C1,!# 2("

:!(#,%:

;

@(! '

- 31!3$

+$% ,#!,%:


8 ,''

<> $%A(!# %'

=)!(+) !9"(%)

+2(!)

%%=1! !:(!#,%:



!3!$#1+# 1%#!

& !(#,%:

7(!B  '-';

' '

0!@ $$#  '-'  ''< 0!@ $$#  '-'< '<'<

1) )(%#,%:

'<'<  ''> $$#
$771%,+()# /2'

'.'

/(!,% >)2 3!,9  

'' < 13:!(#(),$% ?1) %$ !39@ !+,"# /2'

'.'

/(!,%

(!( /3(B,%:

!#!

- <'

 '-'>  ''

$) "(,9(?9  '-'

 ''  $) "(,9(?9  '-'   ''

$$#
$771%,+()# /2'

'.'

/(!,% )2 (@   13:!(#(),$% ?1) %$ !39@ !+,"# /2'

'.'

/(!,%

(!(

/3(B,%:

!#!

- <'

 '-'

' '

$) "(,9(?9 ' '

 ''  0!@ $$#  '-'  ' '  $$#
$771%,+()# /2'

'.'

/(!,% )2 (@  

3!

!C1 ) 13:!(#(),$%'

!3! %)# ?1) )2%
$%)!$99,%:

**,+!

13:!(## (7

(!(

/3(B,%:

!#!

- <'

 ' '  '' 
!),*,+() <''   '' 4 #7,))#9@8 >    '-' ' ' ("(,9(?9'

,''

; < %'

) +$7 '-' ' ' ("(,9(?9'

 ''  !+$!## $$#4'

+(%%$) ?9(7# $7 A!,))%'

) +$7 ' '  ''  <''   '' 8

39(+

; !+$!#,%:


 8 +!),*,+() :,"%'

+$% ,#!,%:

(?$"%$)# +2(!)8

; < $$#4'

'-'< '<'< ,''

9,))9 )2(% *$1!

7$%)2

1) )(%#,%:4 '<'<

 ''> 4$$#4'

1!)2!8

 '' 

,''

9,))9 )2(% ,= 7$%)2 $$#4'

:!(## *$1!

7$%)2 ,= 7$%)2 )(B% )$:)2!8 ,) +$7 (?$"%$)# *$1!

7$%)2

1) )(%#,%:4 (?$"%$)#

9,))9 )2(% ,= 7$%)2 $$#4'

(339,+(%) A,99 +!$ ?%+27(!B

@(! '

$% C1%)9@8 (339,+(%) A,99

$% C1%)9@8

3),),$% (99$A#'

';' <

%%=1!>8 3( # (++$!#,%:9@ 7$#,*,# 2$9#,%:

(339,+(%)

2(99 (!!(!

(+)1(9 #() (!!(!

,%)! ) 3(@(?9  #3$ ,) !()'

2, +$739,# A,)2,% ,:2) AB #() !+,3)

+!),*,# +$3@ )2, $!#!'

),),$% (++$!#,%:9@ (99$A#'

0 /

.5  /

    -''

6B

2)2!

3(B,%:

&  $ 2)2!

!3$!)(?9 &  $