High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2586/2014allowed

Jagtar Singh v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2023-09-0113 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()*+*,

) -.

# $

///

. % & '# " ! " " () *+ (*%+ &, " "& -./ (%+%0 *1 (*%( " %2 /" " $ ,"

" & " " %)12 "4 " .

&, & " ! ""## " " %2 " " # # %*, %5 ,# # # 6#

( & ! &, " %0 *1 (*%( .

5 " " "

5 "

"5 " " "" " , " , & + 7*

! "

& / %(+++1 & ! &, "" "## "# ! $ ! " &&, 5

9 "

"5 ! " "

, & , !: "

,& "!# #&6& &

,& &"

, 5 9 5 .

! 9 " ! ! " " #

; $ "

8" " , " "# 5 , 5

, &

"#&2*5"

& # (5"

5 #"

,& , " ! " &, . 5 & # < = !.

#" #

, ! "& / %(+++1 5 ! "!,##

&,. &&

"" !"## " " %2

"&, %**5, 5 " & -. . #' " .

! 9 ""

"" ", ! # 8

9 " "" ", "&89 5 6

& # < = "

" #

"# ! "

"" " " (*0

" "# &, " "" "

" ! " " "## " " %2 " # "" "

"" , "" , # " # > " " 6# # ,

" ! " # "" " " 7%7

# #

" " & ,! " " ? " ! " 2* " "# " " "

& @A 9 " ! ! " 2( " !# " ) ? " 6 , + , # -? # !& -?

0( %* . &# "!, " & & " # "& "5 & ! &, "" 9 "

,&2*5 ,

! &# "!# &6& &

! " B6 1 B6

%% ", , , " &

!""## &2*5 "" & , # " " "!, & # . ' " # "!, #" !, " 5 5 &, - # !

6# ! "# .

! 9 " " # B! -# () %%

" " & ! " 2* " " " & "! # "5 & ! &, "" # "" . ! " 2( " !& ,"# ! , " # #!& " % %1 *1 (*%( ! &, " % " , ! ,&"" ", 5 " %( ? " "" "C "# # .

! 9 " ! "" ! " & &" ""& .

,+, # -? " " " " " ! " " & " , #

B! # "B6# " "B6

D2E ! #B6 & % B6 & ( & , . 2 %7 " " & " %+ ? " ", ! " 2* " "# # & "

& @A 9 "

&!" " ! " " "# " " # , " & "!# "& "5 & "

## " "B6

8 ", "" &'" "

" ""# "

&, &E! "E"" "" &, "

" 2* " &# "& %2

8 =&#

5 " '

" # $

" # % & !' ( # )

! & * +

+ ,

" # -

8 =& # !

"# $%% &'()*(5 "$ $ "

/ # (

# !0*!01 * " # 23

4 #

!0* 5 6

7 # 5 6

0 !01# 6

" # 23

1!01 # ) 6

7 !0 * !0 * !0*

8 !0*

8 6

9 + # &*1

*1 &

7 ' 0 7 # 7 7: 7 # ** !0* ' !0 * ' ##

"!0 * / " 7

# #

# !0* 6

(23

4 5 6

# 23

# #!01 " #!01

7 6

0 6

!0 1 !0* !0 * !0 * 8 !0*

# $ ' !0 * !0 1 6

# !0 * !0 1 5 # !0 *

# %! 6

5 #

- # / # !0*

!01 6

!0*!01

/ , ;+ -

%> " ! "" "&, " ! "" # &"

&,@A9 " # "

! # "2* " D%. 5 "6# < # # < %0

# .

! 9 " "# "" 2( " # " 2( "C !#& " & " "

6" " " ,& 8 =&# + , - .

/0 ((5 " 5

6 ! ,# 9

4 "

5 *"./ " 5 9 4 *" + ' 6 '

# 4 1 - %1 " , 8 =&# . % - 1 . / %>2%(*(7" ,%((*(7 5 "

"C ""

&! # " 2( /$ " & , "#

> $ : *"

" , # , ! 6 6 # 8 #

" # 9 # #

1./

% 2# " >?* . 2# " / 7 - %)

# , # , + , "

# " 6# -?"7>

" ! 9/ %%)11%2 *7 %)11&, /" " !# C & # "B6#

0( 9# , # .

! 9 " "# "" 2( "" ! 9/ %%)11

#,+, # & ! " " ""#, " , , " " 9 &, /" " "# " & 8 =&

# 2 %-

!/(0* 5 "

4* & ,

@ A8 # @".!/ A" C.*

>/ 4 ,, >*D , E%# "6$"C.*

,, D

8 #

, # #

# # - (* ,+, # # "B6# #5 + , ' .

) */. 3 %

!) 4 % ( "& " (%

" "# .

! 9 " ", &5 ! # .

&5 ! #

& , # & " "

& -# () # #

6# D%. 5 "6# < # < B6

8 "

## & .

5 " #& #5 "#6 "! # "" D7 8 & 5 "

-. "6# #& "! # "" 5 " " # " "

## B6

- 6 "# '

" ! ! "!, ## C ,! &, & "

(( . 6# " " & " , #" , ,6 "# 8 =&#

- " ,** .

! 9 " " #"!," " "

8 =& # 43 2 - '

/ ( ( "C "" " " "

& , & # " & ' !

(7 C" " ! " 5! " "#,# " # &, "

" "# " , "# " , &, & & , '# " ! " " () *+ (*%+ &, " "C "

# # 8 & & ,& "

# " " 34 ,

(2 ", ,#,& 6 , # 34 " "& &"5 &

"3!"45"60,

5'G 5 E F & F