High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCREF/5/2012disposed of

Institute Of Chartered Accountants Of India v. Vivek Kapoor & ANR

2016-03-18Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan23 pages

#$%& !'( ) * +,-.

%+ / 0% 1 1 !0 / 0% 1 !1 1!

* (+ % 2 3 '4)

'( (35((

*5 )

% 4)

'( )' % ! *3 6'4)

'( *5 )

7 '8*3 )' 3* ) 9)*5 * (3

*:' ;

) - ) < *((2( 3' ( )

(* )' # *3 (4 /(3 *((2(/& 2 ) 1 #& (3 3' ( )

(* (4=7=# *3 (4/(3 (/& *5 )* 5 ' 6'

('> ';' *( *5 ) (

?@> A'5

4 ' 5 '

(* ; 3' ( )

('(< (*' ( 5( *('(< ( '*4

9'* **2) ( *5 )

43 9 4(9'* 5 ()(3'(33');

')43

(:* ) 2<: (*9 <')(3 '( * *5 )

4:2('')3 ) 5'**) B,-*3 9*(3'( 2* *5 )

9'* )( :

>)3

**1 9'* <)(3'(33')* )3*3 2**CD* < (3*';

)3');

(

* <2 >

3'55 *2:*((2()* 9'*' 9) 3* 9'* ():6'C'( )2 (3 :652: (9

9*5'5 * # ;*3 '

) 8':& !*5( (3'(4

'55' )

*5 )

- 0'

)

* (35(( *2:<(()(3'()* 5 ' 6 ';' *( *5 ) (

9'* ('() (3

<5' ( )'() . ) <(3 <<**

<'C?4< (*' 3 ';'( *';' *( *5 )

9 (3'(39'*<'*( ?< ) * '< 5 ) ; '

<< )'( ( * ( ' 2*

* '(

3' ; ;

<<** '

; ; <E ( -E3: ' *9 *3 5' ( * ' 2*C5 ;

*:69 ( ; ;)5' ( *35 ))*1 ':'

(*9 5 )2* ;'> '<*453 ; '53* ) )2 **5 )

3<*9'* 5 '( ;': '<:'

(*( 5( (3

<5' (45

) ;*9 ('()';' *( *5 )

56 (3

<5' (9'** (( *5 )

) (( )'().. *5 *43 9 4(3

9'* ):'

> ) )9(35 *(' <' >*F(

( 6G3<'(( 9'*

*) ) (3<( ; (3!* 5 ' 6

(*<( ;3)

<: 4 , *5 ) (

9'* ) ;2(6 5 ** ' '

) (3 <*

)2 (3<'(( 9'* )( (3!* 5 ' 6 <<((

H2 6 )2 ; (3

2 * H2 6 : (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<((4)*5(:*( (*4 *5 )

(:* )3 !* 5 ' 6 <<(( *2:<(() (* 5 ( .4 93 3 9'* 9' ))( *5 )

'*9'*(3

<5' (369 <)(3'((3 5 (*3':

*) ):6(3

(*<( ; 369 '(: (6( '

6 *5 *(3 ( (

*) ;(3 *2:<** * (3

<5' (4(3

5()(3 5 (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<(( *5 ) (

9'* 3) ;2(6 (3 <*

)2 (2 ) 1 ')9(31 (3 (3

4 ) ) )'()7B4) ))(

<< )( (3*

2 ( < '

(3 '< *5 )

<(3 ;*( <<: * '5

6' *

- 7 3*2:<** '

)

* (35(( *(3'( *5 )

3' ;: );2(6 <*

)2 ('

)33' ')( '' (3 (2 (6 3' ;' ))'() (*(';*4

6(3

<< )'( *<'):6(3

5()4:2(* ;(3

)2 *5 )

43)* *( :5 '*):6 < ;3*

'< < (3 ;*( <<: * : ; ' 3' ( )

(9'*:

)( )* 3' ;3*)2(**( (6

9(3 '943 9 43

6 '()(35 * *:2( '2*) ** 2 (31('(( (3(2 '

* 25* 3*2 )2: (2 (3 *2:<(()(3'( *5 )

3')4 '

(4')<(()3*;2(: (3

<?('C'2(3 (*'( (

<<(( ;(3 '2)43((3

( 6 0'

)

**'55' ; )''

)

<?('C !5' (< (*255 ()(3 '* (35(( . ' )'

)

* (35' (*'

)5 2*)(35'5 :

> B 3 2;3(3 ' <'

6 '2)* 93 33' ( )

(* ' )4:2((3 ' 69 '** 93 3(3

<5' (*';' *( (3<' 52 *2)( (* ; ' )'

)(3 *((2(('>)* 5 ' 6'

';' *((*<<: * (3 '* 3'

)4(35

**';' *( *5 )

9'* ('()9(3'

<5' ():6(3 <<**

<'C?

4< (*' .4

; '2) *2( ; ** '

* 25*'* 2 ( (3 < ( 3 '

( 5' (* (3

<5' ( ' C( '

(): 9+ F 13 @>A'5

93 9'*'93 (<5 '

3' ( )

(4 5 '

; <' 6 '( < (*' 4 9'* ;';) (3:2* ** ; ;'

<< )'( ( *( ' 2*5 * *'( 3' ; ;

<<** '

; ; <( -E)2 ;(35 )==B?=,( ?3*')3' ( )

( 3') 5 )4 ')<(()6 :'

> '

(* '( < (*' :62* ;'> '<*453 ; '53*'

) )2 * 2*)( 5 '('(3*:

;2*'

(*(3 2;393 3(3

<< )'( ( *9 2()'*39'* :(' ) <

7 (3 : ' * '

) :'

> ) '(*D 3H2* 9 **2) ( : ' * < *( (3 '**4 (3 : ' * 9 *3 '*5' ( * ' 2*C5 ;

*:69 ( ;) 5' ( *35 ))* *2 3 '** (3 ) '(*D 3H2* ):6(3: ' *9 '<):6(3<'**3' ( <*2 3C5 ; <* 9 (3 '**(3 ( * 9 '* ; ( (3 : ' * :6 9'6 #& *'* (2

4 #& *3' '55 < 6 '

) #& * ( ))( '

(3':

*'):2* ** * 74.74D? 9'* ) :6 13 @> A'5

: (3 1((< ( <<** 9 ; H2 *';' *(3<

'****< (6' ==,?==( ?- 3':

)2 ('< (*( 5 ** '<*

)2 (

'( ( 3' ( )

(* 5 '

'*5 5' ' (3 *(1 3)293 3*('(*(3'('3' ( )

(

5 '

*3' : )<) ( : ;2(6 5 ** ' <*

)2 (43 ;';* 6:2* **

25'( (3 (3'

(35 ** 3' ( )

(*2 **5 <(() :6(3

* ( ;'; -CCCCCC 7 13 @>A'5

3' ( )

(<'))25 '( 5' ( *35))*45 ('

) **'

(*'

):''

*3(*

(3:'** (

)*93 9 ; 2 C5 ( * ''': 9(3 3< 3* 5 ** ' '5'

(6 3') ')<(() (3* '

( 5' ' - (3 *('(< ( '

(* #

C2 ?D& *2:<(() :6 3< : 1((< <<** 3*'

(*'* ) ( <(3')'(* 13 ' ) ' %3 ' '

) 13 13'3* ' %3 '

C2 *-'

)- &'

)(35(( 2D*B- I2:

A32 '

'4>'A32 '

'4@

)A32 '

C2 .4B ),&'

)(3;'

** (:6I2: A32 '

'4>'

A32 '

'4@

)A32 '

'( 13 @>A'5

C2 . 4 B 4, &

#&13 @>A'5

9'*')* I2: A32 '

'4>'

A32 '

'4@

)A32 '

'3*5 * *3'* (;'

3<#

*)'*

C2 . 4B 4, &493 3*3 9*(3'( 3))

()* *(3( 2*('(< '' * #.& 3 '

<< )'( ( * ; :6 3< ( ' 2* 5 * *'*')<(():63< (3*('(< '

(*#

C2 ?& '

) *('(< (* ; : (3 *(;'( J #

C2 4 '

)&'**2 313 @>A'5

')( 5 ('<'( '<*?*('(< (>

( 3< #B& 3 '<*

)2 13 @>A'5

; :

;2* ( *4 '2)2 (65 5' ;5' ( *35))*45 ( ) **'

(4:''

*3(( '*)(') 3*

*('(< (*: (3 *(;'( J ;4< (*' '

) 3* '55 : (31((< ( <<** ' ;:

2((3'(13 @>A'5

9'*;

**6 ;; (

)2 3*5 ** ')2(*G , ( 5( (3

<5' (4

56 (3 9'* * ( ( *5 )

)(( )'().. 3* *5 *))

*2:<( '

6 56 3 <'(( 9'* ) :6 (3

( (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<(( : (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<((4 *5 ) (

( : * ) '* 3 ( (3

( 6 3 !* 5 ' 6 <<((*2:<(()(* 5 .3 ) ;*'

2* *

)) :6 (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<(( ' C( '

() : 9+ F

3 <<((

*) )(3*2:<** *<'):6(3

<5' ('

)(39( ***93 3')'55' ): (3 <<((3 <<(('* 5 2*)(3)

2< (*5'

)

):6(3

<5' ( 3

<5' (9'* ))26)

<,:6(3 <<**

<?('C?4< (*' '

)(9'*

()(3'( (3 *5 ) (3'*: 2(<5 '

'*'3' ( )

('(< (*' 3 *5 ) (3'*')( *2:<(

. 3*9 (( *('(< ( *5( ;2' < ) *3(( * 9 (2 )2 ) )9(3(35 *(' <' >*F '5(>' ('

)*3 >' 3'';'6'3'G 3 <<((* (39(3'((3 *5 ) (3'*

5 ) ' 2* :'

> '

(* 2* ; '> '<* '

; '53*9'*'* 5 '( ;'(3*:

;2*'

(*(

2((3'

<< )'( ( *3 '*39'* :(' ) < (3: ' *'

)(3:'

>) '( (3 3H2*9 **2) (3: ' * < *( (3 '**4: ' *9 *3 '*5' ( * ' 2*C5

*:6<'> ; ;) 5' ( *35))*3 3H2* ):6(3: ' * 9 ; ( (3<'*(3('C :

)*) ) <(3 C5 (* 9 (3 '**4(3: ' *9 '* ;

:69'6 *'*(2

4*3' '55 ) *(3* 3' : 6 9 ')<(() :6 (3 *5 ) ( (3 *('(< (; :63<: (3

<?('C'2(3 (*'

'* (3'55 <'): (31((< ( <<** 3 <<(( '* C'< ) (3 9( ***4 '<64 13 ' ) '%3 ''

)13 13'*3 '%3 '93 3');

(3*('(< '(3: (3 <<**

<?('C '*939( ***'* )5 *): (3 <<(((3'( (3 *5 ) ( 3'* <*;2)) (3< :6 C5' ; (3'( (3

<93 9 2):*3 9 2)

(:('C':'*(*

(3 < C5 (5 (32*4(3 *5 ) (3'*5 <) (3'

(*493 3'

(C5 () '3' ( )

( - *) ; (3 ' '

(* *('() '* ':

4 (3 <<((* (39(3'((3 *5 ) (3') )2;)

5 ;'

) 5 '( ; '

;2* ;'> '<*'

; '53*4 ; ; :

;2* ( *4 5 5' ; '2)2 5' ( *35))*

($0 **

) ''

13( )3'*(3 :6) 3'( ;9(3 (*'

)3'*35 (* ) '2) (3 2 :6 35 ; ') ; 'C* '

)4 (3 4 3'*

<<(() '

(* 93 3 ' 2 :

< ; '

B 3' ( )

(3 <<((*(32* (39(3'( (3 *5 ) (*;2(6 F(3 %*

)2 (G2 ) 1

')9(31 (33' ( )

(* (4 =7=

32*4

2* 4 (3

*) ) 5 (3 <<((4(3 *5 ) (*;2(6 F(3 %*

)2 (G ) 1 ') 9(3 1 (3 3' ( )

(* (4=7=G = 5( (3 5 (3!* 5 ' 6 <<((4(3

:* )'*2 ) + F

*) '( (3 5 ( (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<((' ;9(3(39 (( 5 * ('( *)'()B(3 2;2*(44(3 %'

344(3 5 447(3 %'64 '

) -(3 4 ) < (3

<5' (?

!5' (< (4 (3

) )) ( '

5( (3 5 ( !* 5 ' 6 <<(( '

) '

) ;6 3) (3'( (3 *5 ) (9'*;2(6 F(3 %*

)2 (G2 ) 1 ')9(31 (33' ( )

(* (4=7= 3

'* ) ))(

<< )( (3;3 2 ( (3'((3 '< (3 *5 ) (: < ) <(3;*(

%<: * ' 5 ) ( 6' * 93 3 *3' 2

2 (6' ;9(3(3*'<52 *3< (

<< ))

(3 (9 '**4?#?&D7'

)?#1?B&D ';' *((3*'< *5 ) (G 3 '*';' *( *5 )

9'**(':*3) (3:'**

')<** *<'):63<:

<?('C'2(3 (*3';'( * ';' *(3<9

() ):63<'('

6*('; (35

) ;*4(3 : (3

(3!* 5 ' 6 <<(( : (3*

2 (4 *5 ) (

<' )2 5 * ())*5(* 1 < (3 ')<** *<'):6 *5 )

: (3

<?('C'2(3 (* 3': ) ( :6'

)

* (35(( 493 3' C( '

(): 9+

, F1('(< 13@>A'5

)) K

) (66 2 *

* '< @> A'5

) '< 9 > ; '* 3' ( )

=,'<)2 '()25( '

)'* *('()' 3') '<5 '

;'*

< ('C

*2('

( (3'*(6' *'<5 '

; 6 '(< (*' '

)

693 * 2('<3'

2(*('( (* !3 64

93 * K (3'*:

()(3'(6 23' )2 )(9

(* (3 '< %D* A ( 5 **4

5!5'>A2<'

4 2(;3' '

) % 13A2<' 4 0 *!

6 2'

5((3*

* (**2:<(()(3'(: ;';

) (L )*

* 2**'* 5 > ;<9'

(( (6 2 ;

)* (393 *( 6 (2'69'*: ;) (3:'

> ( 6:2* **:613*39'

%((''

)13'8A2<'

25(' <( % '8 A2<' 25(' *( ' ) 3 )2 )<( 13*39'

%((''8A2<' 25('

* *) "'<2 ' ';' '

)*5 '

;(3 *39'

%((' * (3 9*

( 5 '

) * *) ( ';')3' ?A3 ' 'L' '< 3' ; 3* (53 2<: * 93 3 ' =,B,,. #< :&4 7B7# *)

)7B-# &36 '<( < '(< (*' (36' ==B93 13'8A2<' 25('

3')

< * <:'

>'2)(!2 ;(3<( ;(36 '*>)<( '

(* ' 2* '<*'(< (*'

* (3'( (3 '

<< )'( ( * <'6 : ; '( "'<2 ' ';' '

) ';')3' 369 '( ;(( (3 ( * C5

*3*9'*: '2*(3 C5 (5 8 (*('C 1

9'*3' ;* <C5

*9(3<9'*2 ):6(3< * ) ;(3 C5 ( ( * ( (3 (* '( "'<2 ' ';' '

';')3'

= ( < (*' 9'* 6 : ; * ( (3 '*3 :6 (3* 5 * 4 4 *39'

%((' J3 (3 '*3 : )(9'*(3 )5 *() ' 2*:'

(* '(< (*' 93 3*3'*('('( 3 '*39'**

(3 *( 2 13 *39'

%((' 9(3 (3 ) ; 6(3 '<:'

)(3'< (3 ) '(( :5 5' ) '

(*39'

25('* (3 ';2 9(3 (3

' * '( "'<2 ' ';' 93 '55 33<'

)3(3 * )*(3< 6( < (*' 3< 6 )'(< (*' 9'*)5 *():6< 9(3(335 <6<5 6* (3 362*)( 5 5' (3) '(* <(3:'

)* (3) '(*( "'<2 ' ';' '((3')) ** *39'

%(('4A3 'L' 4 ';')3' :6

2 *

*( ;3(4 2 ( ')45519'<% *4< (*' 3)(' (3:'

(*2*)'(< (*' *'* 9*+ #& 2(;3' (3 '< A ( 5 **

5 !5'>A2<' 4..

#& 0 * (3 '< 13A2<' D

- #-& ' 'L' (3 '< A ( 5 **

5 !5'>A2<' - #7& ''

9'' ';3 (3 '< A ( 5 ** #& 0 * (3 '< A ( 5 **D

=7- #.& 1 '*(% 3'

';' (3 '< C5 (* )%D*A *'* #B& 1('( '

> >'

) '52 4C5 (*4'8'

' 4 ( '4 '

C5 (* #,&

1 1 )3)'6''6' (3 '< '

C5 #=&

1 '

)''': (3 '< * #& '))( ( (3':

(*'* <)(3'('*5

<6 (<'( *39'

%((''

)3*'**

'( 3'

5 )'

( (3 '< * ( ' > )'"'<2 ' ';' ';')3 (3*'

' ; 9(3 (3 '

(2' 5' ( * (3 93 * ; '53* 9 5 5' ) :6 < #9(3 2( (3 >

9); (3'

(2'5' ( * *&% 1 ' ;413'225('4(2' ;( 9 5' ( *'< *2556 ;6 2(3)(' (3*'< #& * (* (<'()(3'((35' (*3'

6('>

> ( *:2('* '*3 ( **( ';3(9'6'

)'< 2 *3 ; (3

56 (3 '

( (3* 5 * * 3*5 * *3' '*3 ( * <A *'* #9(3 2((3>

9); '

(2'5' ( * (3:

(2'5' ( *& #& (3:'

>*(3 ( 6#*&' '* ( * (3 *('( * (*2 (3 *2:<(()(3'('(353 *C 5( 13A2<'

' '* '*3'( ) 6(3 ;: '2*((3'((3*9'*

( ;3( (3 ; : ; ) :6 < 9'

( ( ' <6

* 2* **'

)

< 2( '

: (3)5' (< ((* *2:<(()(3'( (3 (3'

(3C5 ( ( *( (35' ( *4 * <*3' '55 < 69'*'* * ( ' 2 0*2 $* (* 0()'

)'* * << 69'*; ( !'*6 *(< (*9'6L( ')4!3 ( *9 (3. '

*#'55 C&9 ; ( (3< (3*' ) (3 *( 2 ; :6*39'

%(('J3'( **('()':

*( 2( :*( <6>

9);'

):'

)3'*: *('() 2 (' 69(3 2('

9(93(3 (3 ( *93 39 : ; (3 2;36 2 :'

>*9 * <

*) '( M

* "*4 (3* 9'*

*) '( ) 93 3 '

;) :(9 ( (3 5 (93(3 9 ( * '* 93 3))

(;('

*) '( '< ')6 5'6 ('C* ( %6 '* <'6: 9)

*6<5'(3( '63')* 2**) 6(3 ;'< ')6 5'6('C**2:8 ((

5 '(6'

)5 * 2( 1('(< 13@>A'5

)) , CCCCCC K-

( 93 * !5'> A2<' 4 (3 5 5 A ( 5 ** (3'

(.. 2(;3'

* (2'6

)6 (3 '< !5'>A2<' C(*

6''':53 ; '539'*'(('

3)3*53 ; '53 *

( < 9 (3'

(9'* 5 '() :6<'

)2*)( *;

'*!5'> (3 3H2* K7

(93 *!5'>A2<' (3'

5 < D 2<: - ' 'L'

* 3*'

(9'*'* 5 '():6<'

)2*)( *;

'*!5'>A2<' 9 (353 ; '5393 39'* 5 >) '

<6 (3* '*3'55 ( :(3'( %'

5' ! 'H((4 19'9 %'

)4 < (*' 3'55 )( : <6' ( * 1<' (3 ''

9'' ';3'

( (3 '<

!5'>A2<' 5 5 A ( 5 **(353 ; '53 * * <:

)6* 2((3'

(9'* 5 '():6< :6 *;

; ';' '* !5'> 3 53 ; '53 9'* ' '

;) '

<6'

))

993 *(35 * * (3'

A ( 5 **

5!5'> A2<' # ( ' '

> )'& 0 *4 < (*' (353 ; '53* * <:

)6*4'

)9'* ' '

;) '

<6 9 ';' (3 '

( 9'*

5 '():6<:6*;

;'*!5'> (3 ( ''* (3*;

'(2 !5'> A2<' ' ) :6 < :2( (3 53 ; '53 8'6 A2<' 93 *9 > ;'*'

(9(31'

8'6 J' ; @ >' K

(93 *1'< '*;

;(3 3H2* C5 (* 1 '*(% 3'

';' 4< (*' '

)93

**;

;'*@ >6 (3A *'*

* A *'*'

(9(31 (3'

(9'*

5 )'*'5 5 (' 6

)2*)( *;

'* @ >6 (3 3H2* '

) 5 '( (3 *'< 3

56 (3 3H2

=.-)'()=, <'

-77 A *'**3 ( <3'* : '**;

):6<'

) (3 * (3 3H2 (3'55 (3**2 )<'

)) '(' 2 12*325('3'*'* : 9 (( :6<(**2:<(() (3'(

((3'((3*

9'* 5 )'* 5' ( *35

9(3A28( 1 ;3'*5' ( '

@ >6A28(1 ;39'*'*3'< '<'

)*;

)'* A28(1 ;3 3C5 (*9'*'* 5 )'*'5' ( *359(3 1 '*(% 3'

';' 9(31'< ''

)('

1 ;3'*5' ( *3*;

'(2 *' 1'< )(' 1 ;3:2((3*'

6 '5 * * K.

J3'(':

2((3'

C5 (*9(31('( '

$ '52

* 3*9'*'

5 )'*5 5 ( *35 (3

'< '8A'

(393 9'*'(65*(9(3<* 5 * (69 > ;9(3' )'6'1 ;3$1 *4'

' '

')4< (*' 3 2;3 33'* *;

) ' (3

3H2*:2((3*'<3': ) <6 *( 2 * 1<' 6 (3 '

( ( ' 9'* '*

5 ):6<'**('()' 2*)( *;

'*!5'> )2*)( *;

'* 2353 ; '53 (3')6*

* <:

)6>

( <:2(3'*: 82*(' '

;) )5 ))( (3:'

> * (3'

'8'

) '

C5 (*9'* '* 5 '():6<353 ; '53 (3 '

(*(3'( 1'

)51 ;3 *) 3'%'

) )(353 ; '53 '8'

- * <

( >

( < '

) 3'* : '

<6 5 >) CCCCCC (3 )9 2)>( *('((3'('(3 ( *2* (3 '<* ' 2*C5 '<6A *'*4 C5 (*4:'

C5 (*4 * ( ' (3 '*34 3H2 ) '('

(3' ;'

6:'** 3** 6'<(3 )

( ;(32

() :'

>< 6 (3: ' *'*;(<'('

() < 69(3 2((35'6<

<('CG *)* (3*4 *5 ) (

) '55 : (3 1((< ( <<**

*((2()2 ) (3 ( *((< 3*

<('C '**:6*2 ) ;2 )* *)

< (3*('(< '

(**2:<(():6 *5 )

: (31((< ( <<** 43 ';' ')<(()3*

3*'<' C( '

(): 9+ # 3 '55 ( * ' 93 (< 5 '

; 3' ( )

(5 '

; <5'

6 < (*' '

)3' '9 (*9(3 '

3 * !3'

)A'

''* 9 3 '55 ( 9'* '* '2)( ; (3 :

(3 9 ;C5 ( <*2D*77 (3

( %D*C5 (*4'

' '

')4< (*' %D* '

(C5 (*4'

' '

')4< (*' -%D*A *'*4'

' '

')4< (*'

7%D* *4'

' '

')4< (*' %D* ( '4.? 3'

)' );4 < (*' .%D*'2 ' '4.? 3'

)' );4< (*'

B%D*A '

( '4'

' '

')4< (*'

=%D* ' 12 8'4 ';3'<'

)4< (*'

*' ')6*('()(3

'5 *( (3'55 9'*H2(9'>'

)(3'))) ** 3* )5' (*

7 9'*5 ;:2 ) * < - !2 ;(3

'6' ==B?=,4(3'55 (<(13 *39'

%((' '

) ' 3' ( )

( 13 '8 A2<' 25(':

(3 "'<2 ' ';' 493

5 ')25 3<( ( (3:2* ** ;

<< )'( ; ( *3< )2* 5 '

)*2;;*() :6(3<9'*(3'('55 (9 2)5 )(3<9(3( 2

5* (3 ') ;4

($0 **D ) ''

13(* (3; 2 C5 ( * 93 3(3'55 9'*(32)( (3:'** (3'

(2':''

*3(*

*2 3; 2 C5 ( *4 (3<9 2)5 5' )25 '( 5 ( $ ** '

(4 :''

*3(* '

5' ( *35))*9(3) (*( 5' ( *'

)

'( 5 * * ( *() :26 ;'

<< )'( ( * ('C C5 (5 (*3'55 (9 2)(3 5

(* ' 2*:'

>**5 '6 (3:'

>D : '

3*93 (3:'

(* ; 2 C5 ( * C*()3'

<< )'( ; ( *9 ( : 2() (3 2;3(3*'):'

(* 52 *2'

(3*') * 3<4(3 9 ;:'

(*9 5 ) # $ # 40 *41 13A2<' D

- ( ' '

> )'4

A ( 5 ** 0 *41 D

=7- 4 2(;3' 4< (*'

A ( 5 ** D

4' 'L' 41

A ( 5 ** D

. 4 ';3 ''

9''4

A ( 5 ** 1

.,- 1('( '

> '(''4'*( C5 (*D

--, % 3'

';' 41 1('( '

> '(''4'*( A *'*D

-77 % 3'

';' 41

:$1 ) '

>4 C5 (*D

)3)''6'

4 241 ( '

1('( '

> >'

$ C5 (*D

'52 4%%% ') 1('( '

> >'

$ ( '

'52 4%%% ')

=7 1('( '

> >'

$ '2 ' 'D

-.=

'52 4%%% ') 1('( '

> >'

$ '8'

'52 4%%% ')

-7

:$1 ) '

>42 )'

*4D

'':41 ( ' '

> )'

A ( 5 ** 2 2 'L' 41

(3' *')'

(*9 (3 '< (3 '55 ('

)'**2 3

(3)5 *(* <(('

* (3*')'

(*: ;)( (3'55 ( ( 5 5' '( )25 '(*(* ') ;'

)

( $ 0 ** D 4 '5(' ' 3' ; '<* ' 2* ( *()5' (*'

):''

*3(*4'*9'*)25 '( 5' ( *35))*3' ; '<* ( *()5' (*'* 5' ( *'

) 5 ; :'

(*4(3 C(*(52*) :( **2:'

>) '(* ( *()5' (*3:'

> ) '(*D 3H2*9 **2)2 ) (3) * 13 *39'

%((' "'<2 ' ';' 3) '(*9 **2) <' 6 2(*('( 5' (*:'*) (*>"'<2

';' 4 5'(4

('1'3:4 ' )':')'

)!3( (3 '55 (> 9

(3*')5' (* .

3( ('2 )*)5 *() ' 2*:'

(9 ' '

;)'

); :613 *39'

%((' "'<2

';' 3) '(*9 <') (3 '<**255):6 3< B 3 9 '* ( '

* * < (3 (3 :'

>* '

* <(<* '*39'*9(3) '9 93 39'* 2 ))( (35' (*'*) ():613 *39'

%((' , 3'55 ('* ;' ('

<< )'( ; ( *( (35' (* < (*' 493 39 >

( 3< 6 3 '55 ( '* '

)

<<** :6 2* ; 3*

( '

(* 9(3 2( ' 2* (* ' '

; ; *'* (2

3 '*3 ):69'6 *'5

)*9'* <(()( (3* *(3 2;3 3H2***2) <(3 ' *'):'

(*95' (*9 '* ;

<< )'( ; ( * :6 9'6 13' '55

< 6 = 3'55 (3')<5 6)*(' 3'

) ; '*3'

;(( ;) '(*5 5' )3'55 ('*

2 ) ' 2*C5 ** (3 '(2

4*('( ' 64

56 ;4:'

5 ;C5 **( 3'55 ( *()(3*' ;* 2(

<<**

) C))5 *(*'

)'* ;'5 '( '*3 * 3 ( *('

) (3*')< < (**'* :

) ('C #% & ****< (6' *==,?==( ?- % 7==B( --

))2' '()* * '(* $(( ((

3'55 (3'*: 5 ) ;'

<< )'( ; ( * (3 < C5 (5 (*4 *4 '( ;(2 '

)*3' '55 < 6 % *( (3 (<4 (3 (9 5 * *

'<2 ' ';' < )':

9 2) (35' (*:2(4

B * <(<*4 (3 5' (* )* 2*

( ; (3

() < 6 '

() 9 2)

( (3 '55 () (63 '(*

<<** ' )(9'*E

(3'< (3 ( * *5 (3 '** ):6 13 *39'

%((' "'<2 ' ';' '

)-E (35' (*

;) (695' (*< *(6 '(*9

3' ;)'

<<** 3'<

<<** '

)9'*5' (6*5 (:2(9'* < *(6 *() )5 *(* *<''< (* ( '*3

( *( ( (3 ) 5' (* J3

<52( ; ( *(

*(< ((3'*: 5 *2<)(3'('(3''':2 )*D *' ;*9 )5 6) '

; ( *(NE (3 6' 3 '55 ( '( ' 26 5 2* ; 3* 5 ( '

) **

(): (3

<('C)5' (< ( (3" ==,?==( "?43')) () (' C5 **(3'( <'6

(3':

2 ) (352 5 *5 ** )3'* (3 )(3*'<( ('C: (3 /:1((< <<** 3'55 (3')'* )( ('C '

3 (3'****< (6' * (' '< (*93 3<'63':

):69'6

<<** *( 93 3

)*' ''': ) ( *2 (3'((3 *

* '5<

< (3 (3

<<**

(3 ( *(

) (3 2;3 *(< (* 9'*

)) (3 ;2' :

(*3 *'*

) *2 3( '

* C 5((3:'

(* '*) (3 ( * (3:'

(*'

) (3:'** << 6'

)(32

() ( 9'(34(3'55 (3'*5 5' )(3 *)

<52('(

< '

3 (36' *3 *)

C5 )(2 '

(*'

)(3:''

*3(*(3'(' '

C) 55 )C( (3*'55 '* *255 ((3<*)

)C5 )(2 '

(*4 '5(''

):''

*3(* '

3 (36' *' '*5 '55 )C3

* )'()2(L'( *('(< (*'*5 '55 )C +!( !

!( 3 '55 ( 3'* )* *) '))( '

< * 74.74D? '(36' * 93 3(3'))( '('C

<*( *-4-4BD?'*5 (36' 6

<52('( *;

(3'55 ) *3*)* *2 *' '))( ( ;2'

<* (3*6' *' ')6)* *) (3 ;2'

<2 *3) <(<( (<

!( +$( (++ (

!( < (3 *35 (3 : '< :'

(* '

) (3 '(2 (3 )5 *(* '

) 9(3) '9'* (3 !( < (3

< *5 ( '

3 (3 '****< (6' * <==,?==( ?- +('

(++ ('(+ ( *(2 ) ' 2** * (3

<('C'

(*3 2)

(:) <'6> )6:9')'*(3 '*<'6: '(62 ) ' 2** * (3

<'C (=. *3 2)

(: 3' ;)'

)*3 2):9')4'*(3 '*<'6 : -<<2 (* <5 * 2( 2 ) (3 '

(5 * *

<'C (4 '()* * (3 '

) ( '

(*4'*<'6:'55 ':4<'6> )6:; '

() 7 '

( *('< (* (3 5'6< ( ('C* '* '

*H2

(3*((< ( <** ( : ;(32 )* *)

< (3:

( .12 3 (3 ( (3'55 ('*<'6:)<)(:6 (3 /: <<** 3' ; ;' ) ( (3 '

(* '

2<*('

* (3'55 (/* '*<'6> )6:' 9) ((+'

% + 3 '55 ( '* ' ( '))4 '< ) < )6 (3* '55 65' ((3

= ( ++('(+

3 *) *('(< ( '' * '* '( -- * '( 55 )CG 1 (3 (493 3* '

(4* 5 )2 ) 3 2 ) + F1

)2 H2 * '( ; ( <*

)2 ( <<: * *((2(#&J3 5( <'( :64

<5' (<')( (4(3

*5 <''

(3'( '

6 <<: (3 *((2( 3'* : ;2(6 '

** ' (3 <*

)2 (4(3

*3' (3

'* ( (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<((4 '

) (3 !* 5 ' 6 <<(( *3' (3 25 3 ) *2 3 H2 6 '

) *2 <'

'*<'6:5 * :)4'

)*3' 5 ((3 *2( (* H2 6( (3

#& 5( *2 3 5 ((3

)*(3'((3 <<: (3 *((2(*

(;2(6 '

65 ** '

(3 <*

)2 (4(*3'

)(* ) ;'

) ;6'

) ((3'((35

) ;**3':) (3

<5' (*3' :)*<**)4'*(3 '*<'6: #-& 5( *2 3 5 ((3

)*(3'((3 <<: (3 *((2(*;2(6 '

65 ** ' (3 <*

)2 (4(*3'

)' ) ; '

) ;6'

) *3'

) (3<'

')) (3*2

) ;*2:?* #7&J3 (3 ) ;*(3'('<<: (3 *((2(3'*:

;2(6 ' 5 ** ' <*

)2 ( *5 ) (3 *( 3)24 (3

*3' ' ) ( (3 <<: '

(2 (6 : ;3' ): ) *' 5'**)';' *( 3< (3 '*4'

)<'6(3 '( <'>'

6 (3 9

) *4 '<6+ #'& 5 <'

)(3<<: O #:& < (3 '< (3<<: <(3;*( *2 5 )4

(C ) ;6' *4'*(3

(3 >*(+

))(3'(93 ('55' *( (3

(3'((3 '**

93 3(3 '< (3<<: 2;3(( : < ) < (3 ;*( ' 5 ) C ) ; 6' *

5 <'

(64(*3'

(<'>'

6 ) )( '2* #'& '2*#:&4:2(*3' 9' )(3 '*( (3;3 2 ( 9(3(*

<< )'( *(3 #&J3 (3<*

)2 ( *5 93 3(3

3'* )'

6<<: (3 *((2(;2(6*<*

)2 (3 (3'

6*2 3<*

)2 ('** )( *2:* #7&4( *3' 9' ) (3 '* ( (3 ;3 2 ( 9(3 (*

<< )'( *(3 #.& 5( '

6 '*2 ) *2:?* #7& *2:*

#&4(3;3 2 (*3'C')'( (33' ; (3 '* )*3' '2*

(3)'(* C)( :; ( (3 <<: (3 *((2(

)4(3

)( (3 ( ' < (4 '

) *3' ' ) *2 3 <<: 4 (3

)(3 ( ' < ('

(2 (6 : 3' )4'

)<'6(3 '( <'>'

6 (3 9 ; ) *

'<6+ #'& ) ( (3'( (3 5

) ;* : )4 )*<** (3

<5' (4'*(3 '*<'6:O #:& 5 <'

)(3<<: O # & < 3< < <<: *35 (3 *((2( (3 5 <'

(6 *2 35 )'*(3;3 2 ((3 >*(O #)& (3 '*( (3

2 (3 H2 6'

) 5 ( #B&#,&

(352 5 ** '

H2 62 ) (3** 4(3

)(3!* 5 ' 6 <<((*3'3'(3*'<5 9 *'*' *() '

2 (2 ) (3 )

)2 4=,4 *5 (3 9 ;<'(( *4 '<6+ #'&*2<< ;'

)

;(3'(( )'

65 *

C'< ;3< '(3O #:&(3)*

)5 )2 '

2< (O'

) # & ;)

')'(G - *5 (3* 3< (3 (4'( 9 ;)25

)2 '* ')) 4(3

('>'

';' *((*<<: *(3 < '

'< '<<: <(3 ;*( *25( (35 ) 6' * '* (35 '(65 *)( :<5 *)* '5 )< (3'

6' *4(3

(3 <'(( * ( : ) ( (3*

2 ( ( 5( (3

<< )'( * <(3

4(3

2 (*

<5( (( 5'**'

6 ) ( <* 5 9 *

)2 ) 1 #.& (3 ( 7 ) (3 *9'* )2 ) 3' ( )

(*4(3 )2 93 3 ')*'*2 ) + F !

' *('(< (* '

( 5 * )5 ( (3 * <

'*(2'( (3 ( 5 * '5' ( 2'

5 )D'('5' ( 2' )'(3 <'( (3**('(< (* ' ('<5

'' ;* (3*

(6493 )' 9(3 (3'( ( 5 * ( <'6 : *255 * <'( '4

2*( < *4 *( *4 '

>*4

' *((2( *4 *2 *4 < (4 'C 2(3 (*4 <5 6*4

'( * '

<5(( *A5 ; 9(3<5

(3* *('(< (*'

)(3' ;* (3*

(693 2*(3* *('(< (* ('> ;<'

6(') * *4(* **' 6(3'( (3**('(< (*' '((*():6* <5 * 93 *C5 (

(3* ) * (3'( (3 :8 ((64 (; (64 ':(6 '

):(6 (3 <'( *'**2 )( '' ;C( (3* 2

'((*('( *) :65 ** ''

(*493 ' 3' ( )

(* 2

( 6(3'*: 3 9

:* )(3'((3 3': ' 2<: '** :'

>*'

' *((2( *93 )2( (3 2*D'<:;2 2* ') ( ) ) :6 (3 *5 ( 3' ( )

(*4 :

9''

(*3'3')( '

H2 >< ('(6 *2( ;

** (3 :'

> %'

6 ' (< (3* 3'* '* *2()

'** : ; ('() 9(3 (3 ';'( *

D<'')D;

** ;;

: ;'(( :2()( (3

) '

> '*

(3*2

** (35 ** '

6'*?

<5 *) ) (3 **** ('(

<<'

)(3 *5 ('

)

(3; '52: 3' ( )

(* (3 * (3 '' * (3 * 3' *5 *:(* '

:;'( *( (3 *93 6 (3 9 >G ( ' ) '(

(* (* ) (3 * 3'); ; '(<5

( 52: ( *((9'* '<)9(3 :8 (*

):(645 ** '*<4H2'(6 * '

)

>5 ;

92 )'< ('5

5* (; (6(

<(3'

(*4

)':

4(* ' (3'( *5 )

**6 '()(3

) (3 * 3' ( )

(*')<(() 3*;2(: (3

<?('C'2(3 (*493 3 *2() ) '2) ;(3 23 '( 43((3

( 6))

('' (3 (2 (6 ' ))( 3<'() (*(';*( ) )(3 '*';' *(3< ** '493 :3'* (3*<'

4)* *( :)'(9(3*( 6 2 5 4(3

)2 *5 )

*93 62 (36 '

3' ( )

(4 93 * C5 () ( <' (' 3;3 *('

)' ) ** '

)2 (352 *3< (5 *):6(3 *((2( (3*

2<*('

**H2(;3( 12 3'5 ** ')* *( :):' ) <5 '

4 C * 5 9 *

)2 ) 1 #.& (3 (49)<('55 5 '(( ) ((3'( '< *5 )

: < ) <(3 ;*( <<: * (3 *((2( ) )'

) ;6 . 3

*' )*5 *) '

) ;6 #'8*3 )'& 2); #' ) 1 ;31)32& ,-.D<># ( 5 ( & 2);