Samay Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR
!
"
!
# $ %
$ &
$'( )* $(+,-,)
& &
&
. / & #!
!" !"
"#
$ ##%%&'#(#)*'+ , !"
$ ##%-+.#(#)*'+ " $ ##%%&'#(#)*'+ /
0 , / 0 1111
0 # / '
2!
"
2 2 , " !
"!" '3*4)*'+ $
5'***&*)*'-$
5&')*'- 2 6 )
( " $
##%%&'#( )*'+ 2
#
7'%*.)**+ " # "
*'*.)**+2%** "
"
(2 , , 2 2 6,
, , , " " "2 89 "
"
!
, : ; :; 7 2 2" " ( !
<, 2 " , "
"
2 7 2
" =< 5)-* '%*.)**+ "%)% %)- 3*+< $ 2, !
7" !
$ ,
"" , " 2 " %)% %)- 3*+ < $ > $ ?
! !
2 2 "" 2
" !
2 2 2"@ " ! %'*%)*'- % =" $
##%-+.#( )*'+ 2 # $ # "
''*.)**+ ) %* , , "" ! (2 "" 6 0 ! ( "
" , , : ;
:;, "
"! 7 (, "
"" , ,
"!
, 7 2 " =<5+. ')*.)**3 " %)% %)- %)+ 3*+ %-< $, 6 !
7 " !
$ , "%)% %)- %)+ 3*+ %-< $7 "" 6 0 ! ( , "%'4 $ $ , " "
! )''*)*'%8
!
$97
! $"!" "" 0 6 " 2 "%)%%)-< $"@ "" " "!" 2 ""2 !
! /" 27"
- > " #
%'*%)*'- $$ 5)3* )*'% $ $ 5)+* )*'% A 6
! "" # " 2 " %)%%)-< $2,
"!"
1&
)& **(+( +)22,''( 3,-42('
",( ' %)%< $ > <
' ***B#
) %)-< $ > <
' ***B#
#"" 6 ( / 2 8, "
9 ! "
2 "%)% %)- %)3 %)+ '-& '-4< $"!" 1&
)& **(+( +)22,''( 3,-42('
",( ' '-&< $ > <
' ***B#
) %)%< $ , " '-4< $ > <
' ***B#
% %)-< $ , " '-4< $ > <
' ***B#
- %)3< $ , " '-4< $ > <
' ***B#
3 %)+< $ , " '-4< $ > <
!
3 ***B#
,
3 /
"
2 $ " , " 2 ,
""
" "-&) $ $2 $5%3*'3)*)) $5%).).)*))
"!
2
@
" " " %**&)*'& C #' < 2
'**-)*)%, 22 !
"
"
2 ,
> , "" "
2 $ 6" B/6" " , "
$, " 2 ,
+
$ 6" '**3)*)% "2
" # 8 9 "" 86 ( ! 9
2 $ 6" , !
2
2 " " 2 A " !
" !, " "> !
" < " "" / 2 "
"
" " # A $ 6" " " " !
2 ,
. < !
" " & > " !
" " !2
!
2 ,
$ 6"
2 " > " 22
2 $ 6" , " 2 " 2 ,
" 4 < " "!"
2 "%)- %)+ '-& " 2 2 "%)%%)3< $ , "'-4 < $ " 2 " %)* $ $
"
'4.% 8 $ 9 , " """
" " "@#" 2 " 2 " 2 @ =< " @ "
, !" ," " "
"" !!
" "" , 2 " " " ,
" " "
" "
< !
" " @ " 2"
"
@ " 2"!!
""
2" " < " 2 " " '* <
;2 $"!
"!"
%*. < $ %)- < $ 2 " ""
" "%)-< $"@
'' <
!! "!" ;2 $ "!"2 $ "%)% %)3 < $ , " ,
2 $ "!" !" ##"" ;2 $?
; !
" 2 !
, ! > ;2 $
" "@ ') < " #
#
$%% &!%'
"!" ,"!" "%.+< $ ,, "!" " %)3 D %)% < $ $ " "!"
"!"
"
;2 $ ;2 $"
" !
2 "!" " "!" " %.+ < $ ,
, "!" " "@ 2 "" " %)*8&9 $ "
$ '% <( ( ) ( * + %%!
, 2 " ;2 $"@
B"!" "3**<
$ '- <(-
%%.
/
, "!" 2 > $
" %)3 %)% , %- < $ >
"!" , 2 $ !
, 2 $> "!"
"
C$;2 $ #
!"#$ %
&!
! '!
( ) * ) +,-$.% '"$% ( ) . " " " " ' ") '/" ") ) 0
1) 2 ! ) ) . ' ' "
' 0 !3"# $ %
& ! (
! " "
# $4%
& 3'' ( '
3 ') 3 "!)3 5 '3 <
0 1
) %% !!' ;2 $ 2 " ""
" " %)- < $ "@
'+ < 2 - - 3+
%%
,,,' 2 " ;2 $ "!" "%)-< $;2 $ ! , - 4 %%,
% 56 5 -
-2 7 7-
%%-6 3
% '. <56 5 - -6 ;2 $ #
((!
6 ! 7
" "89) 1) ! :'/ ; ! )
6
0
" - !) . ' 9
)" ') " .
") ' ' )' 5 '& <8 2 92 5-0
%% /
/
" "!" " %)- < $ ;2 $ E> " ,
"
2 "%)-<
$ <! ,2# "8&9 " %)* $ $ "
" " %)- <
$ !
" "@
, , 2
" F '4 <" (
%
/// ;2 $"!
"!" "%)+< $ "%)3< $ 2 " ""
" "%)3< $"@
)* < ) % ,
. ;2 $
#"!" " "%)-< $ )' < )
) % , /. 2 ! " !
2
"
! ;2 $ # 6
1 0
' " ;')
04 0< ! ;)
;') )'' '
0 ! " =
3 91('%%% :
, '
6 !) '# >/ )!
6"" # : ' )"' ( 0
!) ' ) " ( 3 ( ? 04 0< !) " " . " 8 &)&&&@# #A ! ' . 5 )) < + ;
4 %. !% ;2 $ ,
#"!" " 2 "%)-< $ # 4
; ) ' '''
! <<4 ) 3'
&$4% !
) ' ?" ' " !) 3 ' ' :"
5 )%> $ , "-&) $ )- < (- < 4 - 02' %%., %! =!
6 ( " $2 !
$ , @ " " "
There can never be any hard and fast category which can be prescribed to enable the Court to exercise its power under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The only principle that can be laid down is the one which has been incorporated in the Section itself, i.e., to prevent abuse of the process of any Court or to secure the ends of justice. The compromise, in a modern society, is the sine qua non of harmony and orderly behavior. It is the soul of justice and if the power under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code is used to enhance such a compromise which, in turn, enhances the social amity and reduces friction, then it truly is finest hour of justice. Disputes which have their genesis in a matrimonial discord, landlord-tenant matters, commercial transactions and other such matters can safely be dealt with by the Court by exercising its powers under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code in the event of a compromise, but this is not to say that the power is limited to
such cases. There can never be any such rigid rule to prescribe the exercise of such power. )3 < 5 4 * - 02' % %
,%, ;2 $, , " # 6 B ' ; ! 3 C 8? . '
&! ' ''" ?' 'D9$%.$% "! ' '3
8 " ? ' ' " ;')?') ; ! " ; "/))") "3 E"
"
") " ' / ! "''/ " 9 " 3 -'"# " 3) "
) ) ) ) / " '") "''" ");!" 3') ' ) " / ' .?.' "3 ' ') ; !
''" . ' ' ' '' ' .) ' 3$% ) ; ! ''.
= ) ' % , ;2 $
"
, "2 2 $ "-&)7 $ 2 !
# ( ' F# G " ? '
&!
""' )
&
5
!
!) ' ? > ("
& !
) ' " ." ' / FG ' " /# H) .''/
& !
/'";! 04 !
( ; !) / ' . 04 !
"!@ .
( ; !) ) "'" ) 3 ? ' 04 !
) (;!" 3" " ) ") ) / ' "D " . . "
# ' # " ) " ; . "'"'" .'? '")
'/#) ; ! ? ' )/' ) ' )' ) ) ( ? ?#" ' !
'. ( ' ; ! . ' 04 !
" .) ' )" . 1)' ) ?) " " ! H .>?H"$ % ') ' " ") '?
& !
' ! 3" " '
FG ' " '/) ?#"'.;!
04 !
! !)/"
& !
H) ' '' ? " ? 3 )J$%H "9$% .") "9$%K" ' 9 L$%! ) @ 5 ). ,
"""""
,
2 < " " " "
2 ,
, !
, ( " G 2 !
!
! " "" , ""@ 89, !
! " = "" "
,2"
)**+ " !"
" " " , "
2 ,
> " " , " > " , "
!
2
"!"
C 2
!" " @ , " , !
2" >
" """
" " "
, !"
!
> " @
2 ,"
"
)& < " 2 "%)%%)3 " 2
"%)*$ $ $ , 2 "%)- %)+ '-&< $ , " '-4 < $ " 2 , !
" " 2!
"@#" 2 "2 " 2@ =<" @ "
2
" C , $ " -&)$ $
"
, !
, !
" !
#, "
&
< 2 4 5 + (-' %% !/ - = > = " ' %
. @ @ =< @
B"" , , " " ,, "?
< )
'> = " %
,',2 !
#
:/ 3D # (;! ''C
3 # ' "8H
# " #
A #H ) )06 ")'; !3C
3# 5 %* <! , 2!
"
" " 2!
" "!" =< " 2@ @
6 ( / 2 8"
"
9 ! C"
8,
" "
! $ )''*)*'%9 , "" 2> 22
""" %'
""
"
2
$ 2 $ "
%)
" 2 "
" " " 2 2!
#!$
& &
B
I B5
2
I B5