← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-COM/8/2022dismissed

Chetna Jain v. M/S Arvind Medicare Pvt. Ltd.

2022-04-04Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil15 pages



    



  !!

"!   !!!

!  #!!! #!! 

           





           

!$    

 

! "# "$ $%$"

 &  

'!('(!'!)* ' +

+' ,''! 

!! &



   '   ' '&  (

( -    .

 ' 

 *  '

- !'/ "0"120#3-(

!

 45  '%"

%1 $%$%

 '



6  7  '    .!       '

  *       

   * ! &+' 8'  

(    '   '  !

  

(  

!!      

   



!

!&'

 

(    %2 %# $%"# (9&:,  !"# %4 $%"#  



79 (9&:,  !"# %4 $%"2     %2 %# $%"#;)* (0< (

 '  * '  

(  =  

     '

       !      & -!

! '!    !

 

( 



'     



 '!   

(  

 

 79 (9&:,  !       %2 %# $%"#    *    '&8'       %0 %3 $%"2 !!' &  '  !

$$ %$ $%">  = ''

"0 %4 $%$" !    

    

!   &        &   

(  &!!!

!&! (    3"

%2 $%$% #3#

 '

&

&+' &            (

        (

  

  

        !   

 !   

(    

 (  %"

%1 $%$% 

'!  %3 %1 $%$%8'!

(  '

 

 

?

 

'!  !

 '! ' ' !!

-   -'! '!     



   '    ' 

      '     '  '



!     '

  ' +

' >    +

'  "$            '  

&'

 '   ' 

!

! 

!



 

@

   

' 

 '' ' ' $;"<;<+

+' $%"#  !    ! &8'

 &     '    8'

 ' '

 &'&   !   '/ $"4120#3-(! '

 / "0"120#3-( '/ #%%%%%%-( !

 / $#%%%%%-(

' & (

 

  &  '!   & 

 '

! 

'  %2 %# $%"#   

  &'            (

    !

 

"# %4 $%$"  

 (



'&  

(

 

 !

  +

'>  &



! 

!   $$ %$ $%">             !          @ &

 !'       

   & !'





 $%$% ' (

@ &'

   ' &  

 $%$% '  & !

 (

'

(  =



&'   



'



9 !

  !   

 !  +' &  

!' "> %3 $%$"(   

        

   

    

        !   "      ! " # 



    

"



 

$   

    

%    

      $'$()$'*% + "    , -    

        

'     

   "     & *$$ +    "     *$$ +  # 

*         



%

  

.

/  

           

 

.

)     



     

.

(  !           

 

     0 1

 1 $ *

.

 & 3

* !

!



  

  '!('(!  '!  )* ' +

+' ,''! 

 ' !   '  &'  !            !     '

- !*/ "0"120#3-(

!   45  '%"

%1 $%$%

 '



6  ' !&   (

&!  '! &!

!&  

&

 !! &&'

'   !      !    +

'  "$  

           '

 

 ! 

   

  '8'

 

  +

'#'* '  

!! !

 '!  "# "$ $%$"  (



 +'&  

'"3;"<+

+' $%"# . ' 

   

  (

!

 &&   %2 %# $%"#'

! ! & (

 ' 

7 +'&    !

 '

 

    '&

&'  !    ! !    & & 



     ' 

!'!          & 

  !  '  !'

     '! 

    '&   '!

& &!

'

+/  ' 6 



 !   !   !

A&$%">   '



  '&  ' ' ' !'



'    

 !'  

     ''  &

$%$%  '  &  ''

!

 '

'&&



  '

 &   %2 %# $%"#&



'  

( 



 '   &

 ' &!

 !

8'&! &



'

(  &'! & @ &'

&



 

'   %2 %# $%"# !

(  !  

"# %4 $%$"   

 '&   

( 



 '

+

'>'

  ! !

  ! &    . ' 

   +' '! 

!  %2 %# $%"#&   &'  

    '

 ! 

(   

,  !

                )          



-        %2 %# $%"#     !  '



   %0 %3 $%"2 '&8' $$ %$ $%">'

(    & &&!

'

 + '! !' +'  

   ' &  

 $%$% 

(  '& !

' 



&' 





'  



'

  



'

'

 ! 

   !

'  $$ %$ $%">  



  !'

& 

(  



!



 

' 

 $%$%

'

$%$%

!  +' 

  * ! '

&

  !

   +

'  *!  +

' #> "$  '(  * 

 45 6      &  %$$ + 7& 0  89 0   #:      

  #  " *7:$ *7:$ *7 :$ *7:$ *7:$ *7: ; *7":  $ 



"5 7: 1  # 1" + 6

.

  # "

   9  &  ( + 7& "  #: 0 "        -      

"   #    





" 7: < 1 9 1  + &  )* +  

     # # : )-  = >    #

.    # # 7: &  %$ + 7& #+   #:  

#   # # 0





 

 "      7: -  ?"  ;

      "   

  # # @ . 7: -   = &  7= >  "  

#

 $    $      :

"    

; A# "# @ .

. 4      " = & $ 

(

 "

   

    = & 5 7: B  C

    7: &   =@1D : 2  

  >#   7: &   

  =   

2



 @ . 7: @B4 D    "

 @ . # @B4





 7: 2#    #

.



7":

     7": 2#   #  #$  # " 

 F# >



5 . "    # 1     1#$ #      #

  

   #  1

<      #  

. ; # F 1 < A" 6    9 # #+           ""  #   



 "    # 1     1#E 

 E0      + =  #        "   #  $ 



  1      @   # #   

 $    " #      #    #   G

   

  7



   1  *   :          E &  !+

'# 

  

   

/ "3"%%%%-(  & '

!#;

<#;!<! '!









( &' '

  ! &'

!

'

 

 '  !  !  9 ' 

'

 '&9



(  ''&' 

+

'>  (    %2 %# $%"#;)* (0<

 '

 '!'   (



&

      - -

*  

9   ) +  7,''!    

'

"0 %4 $%$"

   &  +

' "$ !   

    ! 

 

 &    

    

    ' 8'

 

'* '   / "3"%%%%-(    *+

' # 

@ 

'A " $ 8'   !



&+'&  8'&' 

 & !   '

- !

! '!&* &+' 

 

(  '

  '/ $"4120#3-('  '

/ "0"120#3-(

&  +

'"$  %2 %# $%"#;)* (0<

!!   (

 

'  ' ' / #%%%%%%-( &'!&

  ! 



(  ' !

'   '

 ''

!'!    

&'

'!

 '    !

 *  '!/ $#%%%%%-(



           '     (

        

(  

 !

 ''! '  

'



6 '  

 !

& (

 

 $%$%

'$%$%  !  '!(   3"

%2 $%$% !'    $%$% &! 

 !

'  ' (



(







  %2 %# $%"#;)* (0<

 

 !

   B'!

&' !!

6 

  (   %"

%1 $%$%

! (  &" " # "   +#  CA$

 C $ # 

  #

 C :   #     2 $ #  #      #   #   $



 " #    ;  

"         # $  "   

 C  6  H   G  

  +    C

 .

  ; < .

    E C      '    

      

(    '



  

'$%$% 

 '  '



 (

   !        '      

   '&  A        *   D   

  



   &   !'            &  !

! E

,!'!(*   C("  !

     

'

!

'!    &   8''! &' '8'  !'! & 



   

'  *  '' !  A''       & (*   * &

!  B' 

'



  ,'

    @     !!            

(     &  &

'  

!+

'"$  

 

  '8'

 

  +

'#'* '   7   %2 %# $%"#;)* (0<   

  &



(   +'   !! 

'!

& &  !  

! ' 

 '/ "0"120#3-(



  8'

'   

&!'' &    !!&' & 8'  '

 !'&& 

    +'     

   '

 !  & '8' '&  &   !

   '23 20+   "12$& 

   '& (   



    

  



          

    

        

        





  



  



  

  

 

    



   

  



        

 



      

 



   

  



  

 

 

     



     

  



 

     

         





 

 

  



     

  

    

 

 !                

  



     

    

 



    

     







"#

 $ 



  















 

   #

  

 

 

  



 





     

 

%

 

 

       





       





  





 

      



   



 





  



  

  

     

  

  

    



  

   

  



     

        



  



  

 # 



  





 



        & "#

 '

 

      

 

  

 

 

  

   @ ! ' &  * !'

  '! 

& 

'!('(!'!)* ' +

+',''!  "# "$ $%$"45

&   '    

'

 !     '/ "0"120#3-(  (

'



' !   +

'#> "$     

%

 !

* / "%%%%%-( !



 / $#%%%%%-(

 & '    &

' '   

&

+' 

A' & &+' 

&  ! &  

&!

  

  &

 !



'

 ;<  '''  ! !!  

 "

 9 "   6 =   6 =