← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11870/1998dismissed

Basant Ram Etc. v. State Of Punjab Etc.

2023-09-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari11 pages



           

 

 !"# $%&   ''(

!$%$)%*# $%& '  ''(   

 

       



 +& ,- +

. .. /

,- +

.

/-   

 !  "#$  %&# '(  )( ##*#(#$ %&# +(

,-

 #

 ($.$ /#

 )( ##*$  %&# '(  0#**'#$ %&# +(

12"

% 

.. /



( (( #

$(

,-( '

, #-&*#"( ( #+  5#&

* +

,-  #'#

 67 4779  

  (   %# # :#(

#  #

$((  (# "#

#*  &

 +'

#$& #& # 

&*##$

 &;8,4-+( /#'2"

% &$4788



,( #+ +(&#**

#( <&+4788<- ,-    &="# #"   "#

    (

 # "+"

,- +"( ( '(&(# && #=   # #**( "( 

( %# 1(

&( $(+   (#*#

1*2)13 1*45!$)%#

(##+&#

 &>?+( <&+4788<

&#"

#**  *(

46 477@# '( #+ '#

*(

4A 477@$# #+ '# *(

+( (

"

8;

477@

>



 4( ( & '

&+ 



 &;4,4-+( <&+4788<#&

*  &( +# # 4$ #4$ &B <)<$ #(#B # &( '#+#"

 2"

% 

 &8; # '( & 89,8-+( <&+4788< +&#

 &;8,4-'# 

4?

477?

;

+ ( #& ++&#,-, #-$( #'#

&#"

#

   67 4779$  #   (   &"

# #",-$

&+( &&,- 5 ( #&:

*#

$%2%26$% $7 31!%# *$)% 3 7$!

92626$%!: ;

@

,- * #

& *+(

,-& (# ( ( "+ &>9,8-+( <&+4788<$(#+ #& +& &  +( # & $&#'

**#%#*#

 +* / &' $('(#

 +?6 # +"( %& #+ # &

'

$( "(#(  #&(



   (  #%  #  %$  #"&(  #$    &

&"  %

( # (*

&& 

$# / &

&"

 %

   

 *$  (  +&#  

 &>?+( <&+4788<'# *(

 ' #

 ( *&#* + 

#

#

%#

,- ( $& '

 %

(



  (   / &  '(  

&    (  &"

#  #  (

+*



* ( #"

 ,- '

$  (

,-  &*#" (#  (     &   +  "#B  #&:,-  +  (  *#   #  +  (  #

#&:,-# "#

( %

#* #% (

2# #(

 *

 &8?# 8A+ <&+4788<$ %'( +# 5#&

( #+

     



 

    

                   

                                

                       

           

         

     



  

    

    

   

   !"    

                  

 

  

         

     

  ! 

 

  

                 

#

   " #     



        

                  

 ,%-  % $#*#% 

'

$(#

(#%

 #&& %  &"#$ #"&(#$(

 # #&:

*# %1#1% ( "*#* #

# (*

$'( #$(



/ &(

*# #&:$( (( < "#B "

+&#,-$(&&

"

#'#

,%- * #

& *+(

& (#$ & #'# , #-'#"#

#+ " (#' # *#  $ & #& ++&#

 &;8,4-+( <&+ 4788<4?

477?$'(&(&  &?+( C#

&:&$497;,( #+ +(&#**

#( <&+497;<-$ #"&(#$( #

 #'# &

67 4779$   #&(&#

( "# &*

 &441+( <&  +  497;<$  %  '( +  # 5#&

 ( #+ $  #

*#* ( "

#'# %#

$# #"

:#(

#  #

2

+( "

( *  # /

 #

 ()&# *

# $

 % 

&  '

 (  $



# ))*+,-./0*) 1 ))2+ -./32)!# #/



<* 

)$



24778,)-884;

:!$"6 6$% $7 .*26$%

':;

$7 ,*2 $7  '',;

* 4      +,-#  

$

                  

       

      

          

                    5      6   + -    

  +,-      

           

       

7.          

  

     

           

     2!8, :!$"6 6$% $7 .*26$%  $7 ,*2 $7  ,;

7%  "!""



& # %       ,,             

              5      1 .         

          

       /

5    + 

 -     ,9:*  +!:    ,9:*-          



   "     ;             

      

        

  

    %    

 8 ,%- ( $ ( &  (#   + #" *  ( *#&(

 #&: 

  '

 *#'+*$    (  "# #

%$#&# &8?#  &8A+( <&+4788< #(  &"  #&(

$#"&(#$

 #  %

, #-"#B *#:# 1(

,-$ (

++( # #  %$#(  "# 1#

$ 

,-

,%- 2

+( & $( "(## % &(+()$&# *

#<= ## (#"

 (#  # + /## ( <$



#47A;1

C18?6$(#

&*#

$(#+#&# &%

  &8?+ &$(  # 

( 1' $ %

*   *#&

# +( (##

*

( 2"

%  &"

1(

$# $&# (  "#1#&&

$( &( +#"

2"

% #( &#  &$(*# ( &( +( (#*#+&(  *#&

#(  +#"

,%-  % $( & (#( ( +( # (*

 5

(

*# $ ( *#&( + #&: 

$  (  $  (  #"

 +"

#&:

$!

!1 $% 2$ < 1 65%# 8!6%172!

1<$"

!16 # *$%2%26$% 6% =!62 92626$% 1!

<!72 $7 "65$!

1%# 28!<> 28> 1!

!?*2#

?

 #

 *# #  

#&( "#

( "# % &, #-$ %

 +#&"$(#

 # % &, #-&# $## /&$ $( #&: #( '(' #+( "#B %#

&*##$("#B #'# $'(( # #'# "# 1

$('((

 + "

#'# %#

$#( #  '(&('##

/ &

( (( "





 #/

 "#

<* 

5)24778,)-884;$'( $ (#

 *#

$(#( %+( <&+497;<# #"

 #

*&#* (

 #'

( <&+4788< +  &  +( #' +##'#  )** &  && 

$  (  '(  '  #  +"  (  + #& +#

&*##$"#



 &;8,4-+( <&+ 4788<$#$&  &?+( <&+497;<$#( '# :

 &"

*

$(+%#* # #'#

'

$   +  #" *  (  #'#     

"#

#

 +' #$& #& %#

&*##$ ( "#B #'# $('(" (##



' # *#  & "#B %#

&*##$#(

 %# #'#

# &"

&"



+#&"(#$& 

* $#++ #%$+(

( '

$"



$ (#& #

%

&( $'#

#

 *##*#

# +*# $'( $ &#"

&*

#*( # + 

,-  % $& (#

+( 

#*



* $ #++ #%$(####"1

 4( $

 #&%*$89 477?$'(

#  +( %#

+*# $# $'( # # /&'#

%1#1 %

 489 477?#(  1  

$+"

*# $ 5&

#&& #& '(*#'

2#

$& ( (#

"#

>4 477?$  #+ #  /&  '#  "#

 #*

 ) * $    

'

&

(#&  * (

 4+*

#( $ 6;

477?$'(

# (#&:

*# $# #& 

"#

2"

% $( * #

#*) +

 # # /&   *#*  (   %#  #& * +(  *#   +  (

 4$ &#"

/ &

*#'+*#&:,-

) * $     &

(#& + (

 +"

 

*#  "#



* #$(  $ &

 &#"

#

+"#"  % #&:

*#  *#* $'( ( #

 $(

 * #$ :

 5&*

$# =(

 && 

#(  &#"

 #*  &*

$'(#

 +'

#$& "#B %#

&*##$("#B ##'#

"#

"

 ( * #

& *+(

#%#* * "#

"

 # (#& '(#

 +' #$#"#

%##

 

*#  "#



* #$(  $'( ( # 



 * #$($ :

 5&*

&

$+"

 +' #$#"#

%## $#( + "#B ##'# $& #& #



&*## 4>

) *  (    "#B   +  #  #'#  '( #* "#

 +' #$& #& #



&*##$(& #* # = :

 &

$#( %#&"

 +#&$( #'# &#

 "

 %#

( #'# &# :#(

#  #

 4;

( $( "

'(

#  %& +& ( # (*

:# *&#+( +&# , #-$"

1* $# %

# #

* $+(

(

(

 (

$(#( # & '



*# ' # #* &#"

%#* *  %

#**+(

( $( +&#,-, #-$##

* $ &"

*  *(

   (   ' #

 <2 # 5 <  #   <###<

&% * 4A 477@$8;

477@# >4 477@$# $(# '

*& '# % ( +&#,-, #-$(  $(( %#  "# #  #  %  +  (  <&  +  4788<$  (

&"

 #&(

 4@ * #

& *+(

#*#

(# '# &   "+ &8A+( <&+4788<$"#B

%+ 1( 

$#( #  + ++( #  %, #-$#

 "# # $ ( "+ &;8,4-+( <&+4788< '

$( #

& *+(

&#'

**  ( & 

4?

# &"

 %

+#&"$(#(

* $#++ #%$(#

"



(# #

*&# '#"

#( +( +"*#+# ( &(

+ $'( # +( #   '# :

 "#

+ #( && 

$'( #$( #

 &" "#

#

 '#% ## ( # &*#"

 *#* ( 

 # $(#( '## %*#+ &8A+( <&+4788

4A

 # "

  , #-  '(  

#    $  +"

#&:%1#1%(  5 ( #&:

*# (  #&:    #*  #"

#*  +   / &  (   #  &"

&"



+#&"$(#+"# # + 5 4=4#



#

 '(( #

B$   #*

(#( $(#**  % ( #+  5#&

& #( + &""

+ 



,- %#&# *(#**

,- 5 +* 

 (#** #**'

 &  %  *'!

- .                   -

<        

  = - )!

! !

&*%*



) * $& ,-'

#&& #* * &*#<<&&,-$'( #$#

#*+(

* $ #++ #%$    &"

   #*

$  (#  (  & =&&,-

* (

$# "

* 1)*#&&,-$# $ '( ( #*+#**$'(( #* "

+( # $( ( &&

$#( +# ++&#&"

#+( &(

+ $  #* (   %# 

&* ,-$  %1#1%$  ( &&,- 5 (

*# #( # '

**+

$ $( %#&,- ($(

,-#*&#

B ,-( *#B

'

$+  "+(

* 

89 6@ 8644$ +(

( '

 (

$& &

&# )D 1A67614779$(  *#'+*#%#*#* (

,- & 1( $

"# 

  *#'+** &

( # &*#"





6%13 $!#!

$7 $)!2

2#+ "#($()+ "

( '

$ #"

&"

* +%*$( :

 "

'(& + #"

 "

'(&+ @6$666=1  #&(+(

 +('(



"'((  #   +  ( @)%?1< 1%# 1!>1%1 658 $)!2 A93$> 371!

 $*6126$%B

"

+&#,-# & (  #'# "##

# #++"

8>

& "#&#  *+(#



&

$($#**(

#

*&#,-$+# $#*# ,-  

+

:.. /;

  :/-  ;

'  ''(   B#%

 ( 828!

9146%5 !1 $%# &

$ 828!

!9$!21<3 &

$