Gurmukh Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
!!
"
# ""
% & !!
"'
( "
!"#$% &'()*% &%(# + &
" )!
*+++ ,(- $ *+
-( ,(- $ ' "+ *+/ "/ " 0,, % &+ *++ + ( 0,(- $ "'
( +1+ &%(# + & & ,- "
' " & $0 ( ( . 341 + ' 5 $ 6 +7879( (14+81+1711( . ":13, :38,:1:,:3 ; . :1< (( (0 = " (
0.
,/
, "0 ," .
> 00 "&" 6 ' " $ & "" " ( ( :7+8+171:; ? !1= "> 00 " $$( - ( (:7+8+171:; ? !
:=+
6 " > "
" (&5.
'0 ! "'
( +1 ( - "
.
. ( + > - , > - $ "' .
&0 ",$ 005 '
- ( " 0 ( 5 "
0- ( " ("' ,>." $ .
" + & "" $ "
, ' "- '
> $ "
&5' 5 $ " ' "> 0(& $ 0 ? ." $' . "" $ ( ", 6 "
00 "&" 6 ' " $ 5& 6 " ( " $%" . + " -( ( "( (@+1+171:( . ( '
& $ 00 *
" A 5*
" $ .
( "
", ".
( (& $ ( 00 *
" A 5 *
" > " 0"
( . ( " ( " '
+ '" . "
,0 (*, " "
'
( (9+3+171: " +B '
" 0"
? (
0"
" '0
% .." (A' "
( ( ' .
( ( 11+1+171: > "
$(
0+ & "" $ "
",0 (*, ".
.0( ( '
073 .." (' "
"
' " .
" $>. 051 ($ .
( "
" " $ > .." ( " 00 >+ "
$ ( '
" '
- ( " - 0 05 ( " .." ( ' " .
" ( ' "A .." ( - & ( .0 ( .0 ( $$ ( ".
" + - (0 (.
" 0$ '
",' " ( .
(
( '
" &50 (*, + & ' "
0 $"
5' -" $ 341+ ++> 0( " > 5 ". ( ", " 5& . ""
5
- $$ . 5 ( ( " ( ' - $ ' . ""
5 >" " . (" $%" . + . :17+ " 6 005 0 - $ .
"( ,>.' ".& " ' . ( $ '
( $ $$ . "( ( 0 ( +
/ ' - > $$ . " (05.
(
( $ . & '
.
&05" 0 ( ("' , $. 0' " . > 0(& $ 0 ? ." + C&0 ' & " ".0(
B.S.Joshi and others -"State of Haryana . /, 0(12,31,
$ > (&5 " 00 ..
" $41-5 .,( 6/ /, 7
(1 89 . /,:
- ( > ' '
" - 0- ( ' " .
" (" 0 ( 0 >+ $ , C&0 ' Gian Singh ;
State of Punjab and another (12,31, $ ( > "" ( 0 0 >" 0 (&5 ' $ 6
$ State of Haryana ;
Bhajan Lal:
(122 ( +
<8 $ %( (" "( )!
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
! !""!# !!
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(- (
. 0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 ''05 0 >" 0 (&5 C&0 ' '0
$%( " ( " , " > '
( " , .
$ ' "> 0(& 05 $' . "" $ (&5 > .. ' ' 5 $ ' "&56 > 0(& " . (" $ %" . , >."' 05 &% . $ 0 "0 . ( . 341+ 0 ' " .
" ' " $$ . ( . :1< 5
(" " "' - 0 ('
'
( 5 - " 0 ( ("' ( ".
.. ' " " 0 %" . "' $ &
(,'
. ( 5& > '
"+ " "0 , " $(" .
" ("6 05$ 00"
> & ('
"" 0 (&5%(. 0' . ( " ( . ,
+7879( ( 14+81+1711 ( . " :13, :38, :1:, :3 ; . :1< (( (0 = " (
0. ,/
, "0 ," .
00 "&" 6 ' "
$ 6 " ( 6 ' " & "" $ " + (0 "" "
5 '
"" 00 & (&5 " (.
( " $ .
" ( "
" .
( ( & $ .
& 0 >+
"
(" > (+ &%(# + & &'<%
0.5 B "'
A "
() "A
B '
&0 ) "A