← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5295/2003dismissed

Saviatri Devi And Others v. Dharamvir & ORS

2016-11-04Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan11 pages

      

!" "#$%$&' ( ) *+!* ,$!-$ ",$ &.!/"-%   00"11 &!% 2%

/ - +3$- &.!/"-%  "%0&."&!% '

4 5 *5*  

      

   

      +1 !! &*$&6/7  !""    $ " % "#!"$&   '" ## "  $       !"$&   "    "#&         #&    ()*+,,-.

! "# "  &  "&$ "    .

    (    /  "   #  "  "     '      ,

))0 ! "#"" "& / . 

1" )002" $ 3 &

// (

!  "&"" "#""  ' #"#&    ""  $  " !!4,*"$ "" " 5.(/. ,++" 6 &

" "" $" '"$ 

!  "     "  $    

  #"    $

 ( "&$ 

&'$" "  #   $ ""  """  $""$ 

"  "#  7 &  "$" " "   &    "     "          "  &  "&& "& ""8&" " "&&  &&#$" 7    "&&"&  

+,,,-.#    "&  " ""

"9 "

"" " " # "

,,,,,,-.

" "$"&" "#"" 

("     " +

!  "&   #   "

         ""  $  ""  "  "   #   '"  "#"  $8"  "& "#".8"

! "" " "& :"

$  "#" ;" """ " 

( 7     &    $    "&   #   

 "  " """" "#  " /

!  "  "&    <&   #  $   !"$&  .

:

=    "      &  $    

#"  "  ""  &.   5.(/. ,++  " &""  

" >? (

=    ""    "    " 

# " #& 7#& ##> ? =  "#"" "  # " " $" #>?

="" & "" "">? +

="" "" "#""" &""

(  7  >? /

=

 "  " """""&  "# "  7 >? *

" ; *

! . 9 #" 

=   " #  =("# """&""

$&  "

( " &"$"  #      9 &    "  "  & &  "    "8&"  

"" 

 8"     #    #  5"   

"  ' &"$""" =

   " 4,   $$& " " &"&""  $&

,, # ,

))0$

!

"  "&""8&",(

))0  $&4 +  # 2!"" &" & """ 

""3 !"&""  "  " "     ##" &@"@ "  "" # #%& "" %"A&""



"    """  "#" # ""$ " 

"" "  "

 '""&"& "(*)- ,4.7% !" &  ""       5?  "  "   "     $  '   "" #   & +/2 3% %"#" & $&$#"&" 5? " " B7 ""     5? 7 #"  9 #"

  =+    "  "  ""    ""          &  "  " "" " "&. ""   "&"&'" "&

& "  " ""&"8&" "

!"" ""   # &'$"

"  # " C9 + /"

!"   "$&&   # ""$ " . & ( %&#" )0/$ ""%&# "&  B&# " $ B&# C9    "

 !  "&   "         $  

  &# " C9 4

)

"" " "!"$&   "#"" "$"& / .

1"2 & //3"""""  $ "      ' " #" " ' "" "<&" B&" $$ "" 8&#"%& " $+ 1*$&6/ &. &!/"-,*! !"  8 %!/ & &.!/"-%  ))4%A 44* " ""$ "$&""  " ""&" $"

$"   """ C&    "                 #  " && #" """""$



$  ( "  $  """$ 

 $

) ""$9

,

""     "       $    "     

" 4,4(   "#

+,,,-. #    &#

+,,,-."&    "" & "  $$&

&"# & $ '$   "

D (4,,-.# (00,,-. &#

-  $ #& &$ !"$&    ""9 $ " &   $

)(,,-.

 " #&"" +  " #& "#   & $ (00,,,-.

7 "" $ +,,,-.   

" "&#    " 4+,,-. & 9   !&  &# ()*+,,-. ""D)E

&#&&"# "" "#"" "   " "      #&             .

  B&""  "&""" "" $  

F( "& # "

  "

$"#"   

# " #&G 

""   "" " 

&"& " " "   "&  #   "

$ 

# " $&   "  "# ("

"&"

(

H"%& & &$#" # 9"#&# & "#$ '  "  """& / ." 4(,,,-.  & #  (4,,#2(4,,9 (I(00,,-.3"&  " & $ ""    " #""&"#" """" J &  &&$#"  " #*+!* -1 2"-+  &.!/"-%, "1/$- &%0-!-0- !$& &.  &!/"-  2(,,)3  /  %%  (

    &"        9  "9& $

-4 J &."& #   &$#"  "#"" "& "

/ .    # "  &"    &     $       # " $ 

5&&$#"  "#""$"&

/ . & // )00 &

#   # "$  $"  "#( & 5&&$#" "  ""%&# &" # "  "$ 

:

" $ !"$& "& # "

    &  $  "  # " "    <&       #&   # ""

7   & " B" """"& "" "&

/ . & // 5& "

 #$ !"$& " "&  "#&" """&"  $' #"# "" $ "#

/ . ( &" $ #& "" 

))4

/ .   .

"

"" 

## "&& #& $ " .

                 

      !"

# 

$  %  &'( ) *+, - *+,

+  . 

$

  /        

    

,  0)1 '    213    4%

+

!& &$."2 3 / .# "" $ "#( &   &   4,.4+   "  2  $$4,.4( 3#&"" $ "" +  & "#  7   "#$  $!"$&   

"&& ""0  #"  "

+,,,-.#$ 

 "&& "# 5 " "&&   $ !"$&

%<&     !"$&       "#           $  (4,,-.# '""#$  "   

""

,

))0

   #" $  "#7&   #&"  #""#&# 

$ &'" $&"5

"  ))0 " $& /,,-.  $&#""#&# 2"  $ *() +4#  '$ "%&"# "" " 5

 3 5  "# ""  $#""#&# ""$ 

5

&" " &  " 



   "&& "" &"$  " $  """##7  "" ## $  !"$& &  

/

  #& +,,,-.   "&# (+,,-.   (,,,-. & 97 &"  # "

&  " $ !"$& ""    "" &   / .  

& 1" #" 

))4 ="& &$@$ &#%&";!! ++  &.

!/"-% <5 - = & "..= &. &!/"-2(, 3 + %%4+  & $#&'

$  " " %& $ ""# "&% &  &      "  '     "      #     & #" 5 $" "    & &&$ "& #" "&  '  <&"" "" #&# ""&7 """ "

"  "$""" " &#"" ?&""    "         $    !"$&   &    # "

#&  # " "&$$ "& "  "  "



*

%<& ""&""  !"$&   ""#"$&"   5* ,"+3"- (7 )       = '"-  K = $ K