Nishan Singh v. State Of Haryana

- IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH
&'&'() .

/ - '0 & )* &'&  



        1     + ,

    





      2   
 


 !"#$
 $ #
1
2
3
1
4"

$


*
-5
6 6.
Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Ha aryana.
1
6
1
4"

$

*"
7
8$(*   $  #%! 


5

*

)
 "
)0

*
"
$ $



 




7
'9'
""
/+

 /

  
"
"
$ 
/,
/
"
+/,



  $




!"
#$
!"
 
%


$
 "
 "

& &'


"

"

 


(
$



%


 
)
*$"
  
("
(  2
$
 


**

"*


* 
*
 


*$


$(* 
 "
)0

$(* 
 "

+ +,-'.


 
)


%"
"
"
""
'/ /+ / /

*"
)0 0

!"$
1


!"

*

%
"

/+

/

%

%


"
)0

* "

& "
7
8$( (* 
(*


/

 / 

*
"
 

 (





( 
//

0"

(


 $" 

 , +/ ///8


*$

%
6"
1
 
%
 "
)%

* 


(

 // / ///8
% "
)
*"


*

$
 "




(
 

+/ ///8

*
% "

$ "


(
0
)


%
 
 "
$$

 
)

* *$


"
( 


(
"0

$(* 
*"
 
(



+/ ///8


*

$
7
'/

9,
" %


$$


2 

 
- %

2

".
"

(
(
%
"
 
)
*"
)0
'

/'

/ '

:

(
  

*
""
  

* 


"



$(* 
5
$(* 


"* "

(

 & ///8 

$$


* 
)0
)% 

(
(

)
 
5
$(* 
*

( 



'/ / ///8

 


 
<
 
*"

(
 


// ///8 
*


*
(
'

'/ /

/ '

/, / / '

<% 
$

 (
%



$ *
%
 
)0

*
 

$(*  
"
*0(
("
 
(


/

/'

/ '


$(*  
"

(

  9/ ///8


*
 
5;

< % 

(
(

* *
("

$(*  


% 

) 


$"
 

 


$(*  
"

) )$

0


"
 




(

(
 
*
"

$(*  


% "















(0
) )

 
*"
)$
 
(
$ "
(














$(*  
=

$(* 
 "



(0


3 "

*
>""
(



( (


"

5
$(* 
*0"


 
$


* 
4


 
  
*$"
%
"

5 5
*
%
>""
) 

)

4 
$(* 

$0
 "

( 



 "

& &'


%
*"



"
* 0




 '

5

*

)
 "


"
"


) )
"
)0

$


* 
)
  0
(* $"


$

5
"*
)%

*

 0

* 0

$

5 
"

> >$


 
""
%
'

/'

/ '
"

*"

( 

$ (

(





$ 0


(0
"
*"
 
'

/'

/ ,
"
 

 


$ 0


( 0


 $
*$$
*($

 (




$(* 
"
"
 
 


*

 
(
%

*
 
$(
* $
5
1
$$ $"
"
"


"$ $

 


*

5


"
" 0

(
 













'
?
0

 

$(* 
)

1
5
*
"
 
 "

*
)
()
1 1 & + / 9
%$
%
"("

%"%

& /

/ 9
 

$
%

("

"
)0

<% % 

*

$
) 
$"
 0
"

/


)0



=

) "
)(


"
 

*
* 
" 

)


%"
 "




 
% 



) 
*$"
" 

)
"

"

$
 "
)0
"
$

* "
7
8$( (* 



"
 
"





 
*$$






 

*

$
$(*  


*>





 

(
5
*
"
" *"
(

 
& 9& ///8
#
  


)
"

 (
*0(
%
("
)0

$(* 

 $$
("

%


)0
$ 
"





 
*
 
)
    
) "

"




)("

$ $




"

$

 


 / /
*$
%
/,
% 
 
 "0
)
>( "


$0






"


*
$ 
)
"
 "
 "
)0


 

**

 " $
*"$"
) )

"

$

)
( ("





5 


"

"


*

) 

)
"

"("

+ 
 
"
"
$
 

*

$")  
"
 
 
*"

(
* $"
 
$"

, 4



%

)
) $




$*
()

 
@
*%
"
$ 




* 




 A"$
* $(

<@) * (


%


"
< <

5 
%

 "
**


%



>$

 
*%
 "




< 



>*$"

 0B


$ $
%$

* $"
)
 
<

5
*%
$ "
"
 
$

0
*$$
"
 
$

"

A$
 

* 
 
)

*$



 
(
0
$
"

(0 0
)
$0

 
$

0
"
 "

"
$
*%
$ 
)
>$"
 
* 
)

*$

 
5
<@) *(
 

"% 
*
(
" 

( (
$

$
)0
%0 0


 

$$($)

>$
 

*%
"



 "





* 
)

*$

 0



$

"


A$ 


 
$


 "



4
$ ) "
*$ (


*


$
$ "

 

 ! 
   

   
% 
 
" 
 
)

"
"% ( (

(
%$

  


**

"*
 

*
* 

*"$"

" "-.
%



 
("



( 
*


$(* 


0




$


"
$$*"

 
0
"

*(
 $
$
0
$

( (


$


$$ "C
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -$.
%

$  "



("


 

$(* 
"

 "$ $
$

$"

**


 (
"

"$ 

$(( 

0
$
"
(
 

$


$$"C >>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -.
%




( ("




$(* 
 

)"
"
 0
(* *)) 


)

%$ 

*"
*
$
 
 $

A
$$ 

 

$
"

*$ "


$$"C >>>
>>>
>>>
>>> -.
%

$(
*$ $"

( 0
""
% %
( 
"
"8
% 

*$"

( $  0
"
%

 
( 

%
$ 


$$"
"
%

%

*
(
"

* 
*
"

& $
$

)
( ("

"# #$!

   



  
%
< @) *(


)  "


* %


<


 

$(
$(* 


 

>$ 



A"$

"

"$
"
"
(

* %

 /

 


$(
$

$(*" 

$
"
$
' 
" 
*%


%"
*  "
%

0
( 
)



) )
>$"

$$"$
% 

" 
"

 $
*%
B C
-.

$

"

A $

-.

* 
)
 

*$
 
0

$
$
  
)
("

&45% ( %&&  ' %(

 )

#    %&&  & !   

  *+
%

%
) "

 

*%
"



$ 
)
>$"
 0
%

 
("0

  ) 


 
"

 


%

*$$
 ("0

* ""
)0

   $
$ $

)
* $"
*
 .&! & !

"# !

! ,! !  & ! /  #(#
0 0 1 -**
%

4 4*>


**""

% 
>$ 
A"$
"



 
<

% "

" 0
()
*

0
% 

 " $



 ) 



%


 ) **$ 


$$
% "

) 
"




$ 



 



 
%

 "
** 

%


>$ 

*%
 "




 
*$"


>$*





2,#3)(& !

 

&!  

-  -  +-

4*>

 
**""


 
A"$ 
"


 
%"


)
>$ $"
* 0
$

0
"
%
$
 0
%
$
>$

A"

"
)0


 *$$

0
"
"%


$
 
"
**$ 

"$
 

*() 






*$"

> $


* %
5

*%
"
 
$

)0
A"$ $

4 (# *

< <


$
$$"
 
%(
"
$*$

6(

5!

 , &!    %% #(# **
< E)

*(
 

 "




$


>$*


 
$ 
*$
=

 $

 
)"

0
"



  "
)
(
$ "

*( 
$

*$
 


 




5
 


>*$"

(


$"
% 

%

"$"
"() 0 0
"
 ) 0


"$( 

$"
) 


*
("
*(
 $
=

$
" 


 $

)
"
"%

$ 
 "
)
 $
"
  "

 



*$"
 


*(



%
" 
 

)
"

"
 
**

)
"

 

)

$(* $
%

( 


$



 
%

 "


 
*
"


 
)
 "




  



 0
"
 
)
$""

"
%

$B) 
$

"$ "


<% 
% %

( (


%

$ ""
 "$

$

$"
"

"

$ 

 "

$$ 



80

(
 "


" 

"

 

"

$"

( 8

"$
$

$"

  
D 




< <


 
"




( 





"8
 


( 


$




>$ 

**


A"$
 "8
$"$ 




"

>(
 

%

$
$ 



" $ 
0
$B) 
$
 


<

$
$


  
$0

$
>$

*%


**


$ 5
"
 

"

)
>("
*

%

$
 


0


"
* *(
$
(

0
 
0
*
4

 <
 
$
**$

 "$ $


%

$
"%

%
$
(

$



"

(
 "

 5
**$ 

 "$


*( ) 




 

*$" 

>$

*%
"



$
 
"
$ 
 
)
("


)  
("
)0
<E) *(
 

)7 #$!

 

&!

! / 9# - 2! ( ( ,#&! 

   ,! ! /    

#(#

8+
%
<E) *( 


) "

>$ 

*%
 "




 

*$"


>$* *
"


 

A"$
"




%"

"


)
> $"
* 0
$

0
"
%
$
"
 0
%
 $
>$
 
A"
)0


*$$

0
"
"%


$
 

/ 
 
$""

$ 
"
)0
"
$



* 


%

) 
"$ "
*

%

%
 

(
"
)0

*

( (

%$


* 




"(

% 




("
 

*


"
()
"
 
) 

)
"

:
** 0


 
%

"
"%


 ) 
$"
$


$
$$( $


*
$

(

 
$""
*


$

 




$
*$"

(

)
(" 

*"
7
8$(* 


$(* 
"

"
*$$





*


*


*> >





"


(
"
"* "
(


& 9& ///8
5
 
$
 
 




$

 
*

%
"
 


5 "

"$
 

1
$$"

:

)





("




$
)
"


$

$((

 $
*) 
"
/



) )
("



*  1

 



"

$


 

 /
*$
% 
/,
% 
 
 "0
)
>( "
)0



5 

% "
)
* * (

0




 
$

("

 

*
 "





) 
)
"





$



 
"
%)0
$
%
( ("

 
*
"
/
 


$$"





*
 "

 

 
* 

$

$



 (
)0
%0

  

*
"




)0

  

** 
("0

*$)"
"

%
1

 
%

*





"

 (


$""
*
  


 "

$


) ) 
"
"

)
("
 


 
( 
%0



$ $
*$* 
%$

 
)
$""

"




(

$ 



 


 $
(
(

$"



$

"$ 
>$
 



"

"
$

$


"
$
(
)
("


"0

$ 
*



(
 



   
$ $
(
 
$"
(


$

$((


$
5 


 
$"

%


$ 0
"

$(( 

$
* ) 
"
/


"

)
("

 

* 
5

"

) 
("



% 

"
* "
)0



(
$ 

-' 

 3*

%

$
 "
$$($


$

"

"

"
% 

 





 



%


$
*$"
( (
(
5
* 

$$"

0
"("

5




"$"

$
% 



$$ $"$
%
%
"


% 
(

'



% 
$ "


) 
("

) ) 

  $


(


$ 
"


 

)

 

5
(
 
$"


"$

 
*
*


14.08.2024    (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE


 Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes Whet ther reportable Yes