← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/69/2023dismissed

Pr Commissioner Of Income Tax -1 , Jalandhar v. Sham Sunder Aggarwal

2023-07-25Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra8 pages

      !"### $## # # #   ,%

))    

   

 

  !

#/   23 /4)"4  #   23 / 4)"4 /#4## # 

"#$ % & '

!(

  



 ))) #  5")  

    *+,-*,**    "#        "

     ./   0"

12 '+,3 3*,4  "# *4,5*,4    

* .  #0 12  

 

46./ 012"

  

    *     

   %3 78 #   

 # 9    

 :

    #  

   

# .;2*,,4, *5,4*,

! -*6<=3( 5,,5*,6

+-

  

.(2

9 :

    

      

      



  : ;   

   : *4**,6"# ( 

#          

 "  

 :

  

?

  

 

    " 9     

        

     "

  #  

  



 

           ! +,==<5,+3      @ 

     "

9





(  



  (        #  

   #         



5

 

  



   #      

 

"#     

"#   

  # 

 #  

*4**,6 ("#  *4,5*,4       (     9

#   #3:

  /

        

 *4,5*,4 

   "

"

         :        *+,-*,**     



  

  *4,5*,4   ?  

   

        

        



*+,-*,** 

    " #  

   

      

     "#    :

:

 :"              "  

  



  #  

*+,-*,**  " "

+

  

"# 



 

    "





  :  :

  :

# :"    "



 

   :

                  



    "#

  3 "# 

  "

"#

@   

( #  #   

        

           

  

   "#

@

    

     "#     



 #    :

  "# (  

  

 #

      B

"

"     





*+,-*,**  " "

   = :

 



 

:



#

   6

     





 #

   # (3 (

 

 # #  

   A          

 

   #

    

    

      

  

*65         

 9 

"

 #  

 

# 

 (  

    

!

  

 /6 71  &( 83 & 79) .*,,,2* <-  C D"

 "

  

 

*65.2   

 "

      #.2 (  "

:  

E .2  A  

 "

 



*65.2

   

 "

    0

1 "

    #           

   < ' 9   ":

 

 

  "

   

 " 

  F    #"



    ;*,,4, (

+5.52  *5,4*, 

 ! -*6<=3C 

#



+-   



5,,5*,6

   

" :    #      



+*.2   

    (   

                   : #

    *4**,6.

2        A  

*65 

  





  # ( :   *4,5*,4 .

*2 :

  (    9

#  "#"

:   (

@

 *=,*,*



     "

   "#    

      

 

! +,==<5,+3 "



 "



  (

 "

       

       "

  > 3    "9  

 :"   @ 

  :

 

 "#"

:  "

 A  

  (  :





" 

       

 "



"

 (

+- 

9 :    

: "

 9

*

- (

    

"

: 

      #   : (   :

"#

  9



"

  :



   "   

 :9

 



 "#    (  "#      

9   :       

     #"

 #C     

  

(  9  :





  #   





"    ( 

   



+-  

   

 

 "

:

      @       ?

      "

9"

"#

 (   

 #

"9  

 :            G 

   "  

"

  (  

   

    

#              #

    

"#  :

    

 

 #"





 

 !

      9)4 6&#

& 7.*,255* !6<.?

2  C  



"

 #("#    9  

      

  "

 "    

 #  "



   #   :

 

 " #!

  "

  9)  1

 ;%13 & 7.*,*2<+?!.?

2=5    "

"# C      #:



 ( "

 

   

   #"

 

 

   .

2  (     

    :



  "9  

   

"   

"

   



"



     

(   



  # 

    

"

   

"

"

  

@

  "

(  

:

"#

 "  



"#



     

     





("#9    :"   

  

 

"# 

     "

 "#   #     

  (    

     

     :

<



"# (     " #

  



 

"

A

    

*65     

   :

"#

    #

 #  



         '     4  

 . 2 #     - # 0 -/#4## #0  "

"

  )) 

B   9 3  

;

3' B  "

;

3'