← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/545/2020dismissed

Bhupinder Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-03-04Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur16 pages

   

      

"#$# %& ' (' '

)*+#%,- .#%/) ''''++0#"

% 1++00 % '

2-$*$

-3 %

%,

)-$ '''$+ %,% $'

& 56 '

. . . 56 .'

.

.72 7 '''''''

&  

  

   

      

  

 

 

  

 .*8)9#%,- *-

:

'

  

 !"      

  "    #$%&'(  )     

 *"

#+ ,+ -   .   

    /"

 0  

     1,  2   . 3"

   " . "    ,+4! '+- '5$ '5% '$  ,+ 

   ,+4! 6   #      "   , 7  "

       .  "    

 !"      

    8"  7  6  8   0   



+-+$,+ '

9:# . 8  68

  )  

     .;;  "    

 .

)

 

  .

    )      "   ".4 

          <    



 9:#     3"

1$'

=<  ,+ 2 8"   3"

     

9:'     +%+-,+ '   

  " )    ".4

   "   

    "     7 

 "

:"   )         8"  "   "    " 

") 

 

       /! 

)     " 

)  

    "  

    

 

           

 

 "   > 

  "          

      ,+ +      

    8"

 !) 7  6  8            ?

"   )  :"

      "  

    "  ,+ +  ,+ 2 6  

)  

       "

 )  :"  ".4

 6      4  .*   "  

   8

  

  

   

     .;; "       

 .    6  3"

  " . 8 

@     "

  "

     

  .;; > 522-2 4   

 . "  ".4

 



  ) .

)  "4 .

   .

 

 3"

  

( # <  .

  3"

  9:4$  =6> 1',$ +% +,+ 2 "    ,+! '+5 '+- ',+ 6     6

&9: (      8"   "        "    5     ?

" "

     

   )    .  

 

        )    

 

 "   )          =    @ . 

 

".

 0  

;  

    9: %  ,%+#,+ % "        '  "       "    $#    " .   "   

 "     ".    

 8

  

   "  8 0  

   ,-+#,+ $ 9:%#  "      " 8

 !

 

      

         3"

      . 

"  2        

     "    ,+! '+- '5$ '5% '$  ,+ 

   ,+! 6

  #      "      

  "  5  



  

     4  

    " . "    ,+! '+- '5$ '5% '$  ,+ 

   ,+! 6   #      "      

 

"



 



 $ 

 ##    :

.  "          "    # #      " 

 



   7 

 

 "           

  

  0"  0   

 !"      

 )    

""

    "

 "

 > #+++++ 4   0"  0 "      " 

   "     ,++24,+ +    

  ) :"

   " 

   "  .

      )

 . /9 8<    

  ) 88<  % " 8



  )  3"   

*          

  )    

  . /9 8< 

      .

       

 .        "          

"   " - "  .*       7    8"  7  6     

:"  "  )   

    8"

 

  

   "

 ) 

  . /9    "    

 + 6   

 :

84 6 "

  > 40  =  3"

<   )"   

3"

  9:8   " . 6 0

        "

 84, ?

    )    8  



  

   3"

  9:8,      " . 8"   9:"  <  A

 0      

 !"

 "    

   

      

 "

3"



  "        

.    

 *"

#+ ,+ - ,   .  

  

4!"           )      

3"

   

  1,  2 # @  "                "    . "   

   

 

  

> * 8    . 9  

> *   8 &!B>(   "

   )   .

     "

  "      

   " ."  3"

 

 "  ".4   "    "  

         

      .

 .

      4   



"  

 "      .;;   "

 > 52+++ 4         .    .

  "  

 "    ."

  3"

  .



;

  "  

          "   @  

 "   )         " .

    .     

    7   " 

    

     

 7     "    ." "   ".

   *"

  3"

  )   

  #  ## 3"

  9:4$ ." 

  "

.            .  . 

  *"

#+ ,+ -

.       . " 

    '      "  

           "    :

4 6 ) 0"

  

 

 =6> 9:

 9   9:, 4, 6     "    

" " 

 8

 & (  &9: ( 4# !"        

   8"  6  8   0     

      

 9:#

   9:' 

  3"

 4'

 .   0"

 *

 

    6  <  6

. *     ,$+5,+ 5 6  <  

 .*     42 6 > *  0"

 4 6  <  

    

 

     !8<

< 6



      "    5  45 ?

)  0"

     0  9  

 1

  ) 0"")    1$ -+5,+ #  > 5$%%- 4 

 "       . *   

   " 4$ @ )      "  

   8"     "

 

       > +++++ 4    .;; .   *  4% "    @ 

   

    8"    "

     

  

       

 ) 

"   .;; .      4- >

 0"

   

  7 6  8   0       9:  9: ' 

 

  )      .   *

       1 8  4 +  1   < )  

   

        

 

   

  9: 2  9:2 9:$+  8 6  4 /   0     C  !

)  6

 6  

 

  "    9:2,  9:2'    7  8"  8 6

    "    9:22 4 , 0"    /9 

> * 6  

 

    !) &!(  8 6

 

   9:25 9:2$

= 4 # > * 0"

 !8< 6  

 

  9:2%  9:5# 

       

8

 

     "  

 9:5' 4 '

 0  0"

 *

    8 0"     '+#,+ $



       . 8<

 ! *      8"

    "    9:52 4 2  > *  0"

 *

    8 0"  6  <   +-+#,+ $



  

  " . 

    "    9:55 9:5$ 4 5 "  /9 8 &!B>( 0  )

 )         8"

   > 9:5$ 9:5$      "

  8 6  4 $  )         

    8"    "

    ."

    8" . 9:  *          " :



"   .;;  4 % >"

   <  =@ 

".

  @ .  9: %  4 - 6 1         

  

   "    $# 

  

  " 4,+  . 8 *     

>  3"

 1$'

=<  2  6 > *       )      

   9:% 4, ? 

   





 

      !) "   

 .)  8 0"    4,, 6 / .

   

 

   

"

 . ?    6  <  4,# 

@  8  =  3"

   3"

 9:$       . 

  "   3"

 4,'

    

"   

    8"      3"

  "   

 .

     

   .;;    4,2 6 0

   

    3"

  9:$  6  * 0"

      )      

   9:$, 4,5

 ! * 8< 

> * 6 

     )     8"

    8 0"   6<

) 

  % %    . 

 

        " 

    )      

 9:52 4,$ 6

. *    



 .*    ,$+5,+ 5 4,% 6  * 0"



 

  3"

  9:$  6 0

  , +#,+ $      )

   

   9:$,

4,-  !

*          6         

  

    

  . 

 =@ 

".

    

   1 - 9:$# 4#+ 0"    8   6  <  



  "   

  " . 

  "    4# ) >  >

    /"

   6    "          ,'+#,+ $ 9:% 9:%, 4#, 0"."  !

  88< 0   "      9:%#

8



 4##   )

 !) 6  

 

   

 

 

 !) 9: 5 "4> 9: $ .

    7  9:,% 

 !) 9:,- ! 9:2$ ) >  9: %     ,5 ,+ 2 2       "   



"  

" *"

        

   

      " 

  " .     

 

  1,  2 .  . ". 5 "    "  

      246 > *  ,#4

@  8 #+40"    8       " 3"

        .  46 ) ,46    '4    0"

  '4  0  0"

  24  > *  0"

 ,+4

  . 8 * ,,46 / .

   ,246 0

   ,$46

. *    ,%46  * 0"

,-4  *  -46 1   

    "    $#  $ #4!"    54?

)  0"

     9  0"")  "

 

 .

-+5,+ #  > 5$%%- 4   :"   )  3"  $4 @ )  %4"   $4 )  ,'4

        

."  3"

  ) :" . 

 % <

   8    

"

 4   

   :

 -4>

 0"

 

  

 "  9:  9: '  +4  1           6   4 /   0     C  !

)  6

  " )  9:2# 9:2' 

    .

) "    7  8"

, 4? 

  "

 .)  " 9:,  9:2 9:5- ##4  )

 6 

"

 9:2  9: % 



   

  /! - 7         :

 ,4 0"    /9 

> * 

      !) 9:25 9:2$  #4> * 0"

 !8< 6

 "      8

  

  9:2%  9:5#  54"  /9 

 9:5$

 9:5$  )  .  



"  .

    6  ,54

 ! * 8< 

> * 6  

    

   6  )  

     )

     

   9:52 #,40"."   88< 0   "       9:%# 

8

 ,+ "    "   

 .    :

  %48 > "

     <    =@ 

".

   =@  9: %  ,  7    

.

 . #4!"  &#(

   4:

       0"  0 " 

 

    8"     ,++2  ,++-

 

"   

     " 

  



       #,     "   .

 

 

" .   "

 > #+++++   "     

 .   :   ""

    > #+++++ 4   ,, 7    

.     .

  3"

 9:$  " . ,#48 

@      "

  "

 "     

 .*

        .;; "

 > 522-2 4  

 . "    ".4   

)  

  .

 

 )   

  

3"

       .:

 ,#     



   4:

    "  3"

  

  

( ) 

     

 "    

         . 

  "  3"

  "     3"

  9:$     

         3"

  " . 6

    

  "  " 

 



 6 0

  

 3"

         7

 "       "   

 

  3"

  ,#   "   6 0

 ,# #+48 0"     6  <   

        =6> "   

      ".

 .

    

 

   9   

> * 8  8      ) )

   

      @ . 

     "   

 ,'  54"  /9 8 &!B>( 0    

    8"   ++ ,+ $

 )     "   9: 

    9:5$ 9:5$  !" 

           "     4:

    

      . "  )   

 .

   

 ,2  %4> "

     <  =@  



   4:

   .      

       $4@ )      





   4:

    

  "     

 7    %4"  "  

 "      "   +4  1           

    ,+ 5     



  4:

    "    

     

 

     "

  ." #++  "

. ,5 =  

  8 46 "

 > 40   3"

  ,% ,+ ' 9:8   6 0

           

  "  = 9:8,   ,2+5,+ '  8    ?

 !" 9:8, !  ++-,+ 2  8  

     8  

 

   3"

   8" 9< A

 0      "

    

   ".

 ,$         "  



 

 

 "      "       

   ) :"

  "       ) 

  @ 

 

   "     

 

    =@

             

 "    

 

 " =@  4  "  . 

"  

  .     

 "

  )  ".4

 .  "     

    "   3"

     

   .  " .  "  ,% 9   8

> *    . :

 "       

      ) 

  

   

  " )   

   !) )      

 7   " 

     

    !)     

 7    

 .

 . <  

 

> * 8     

  )  3"  

    . 9      !) 



 .          . :

.  "   "        "  "       " "  

      

  "     

 

4 !"   

         

 .    

   7

 "  "    

  "        "

      

"      "  . " "

 9:    8

 

 

  

 "          "  .       

    

  " ;

   

."   7   .   .    "

" 

   "  .        

   

    :"  )

;

)     !)  

 . "    . )   "  ,- 6         3"

    .

    . " "

     

"  3"

  6      "      "

  

"

   "  .  

  

 "*"

. .

 

 " >      .

  *"

  D.  "  "     

   

#+ @  "   

    " .    "   

  

" *"

#+ ,+ - #  1  "

 

  #, 6     .   

 "       



3"

     1,  2  

  

  ## 

 &(    

 

.72 7

. .



 ' (' '

   )  G 1   .E G 1