High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/359/2016dismissed

Ram Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2017-03-10Bench- 49 pages

SUMIT GULATI 2017.03.21 16:29

!"#$ %& !&%' (%" (%))#*+#$ ,(# -*./ ,/-* %*$ "#*,#* #0%""#$12,(#,'/%) -!',!*$#'# ,/-*3'#%$4/,(# ,/-*5 %*$# ,/-*56 %*$# ,/-*3%*$7-8,(#'-,# ,/-*-8 (/)$'#*8'-& #9!%) 88#* #" ,:8-'"(-',;

,;<

, /" ,(# %"# -8 ,(# 0'-"# !,/-* ,(%, -* 7 = -&0)%/*%*,!>(4/*$#'/*+(?!>(%4%"/*"#%' (-8(/""-*%+#$3 2#%'"4(-(%$*-,'#,!'*#$8'-&,(#" (--)-*,(%,$%2 (# -&0)%/*%*, 4%"%*%!,-'/ >"(%40!))#'

*"#%' (-8,(# )-,(#"-8,(#./ ,/&>#0,/* ,(#(-!"#%")/04/,(,4-&-1/)#*!&1#'"4%"8-!*$ =3/,#*$#'/*+( !* )#-8 -&0)%/*%*,!>(4/*$#'/*+(&%$#% %))8'-&(/"0(-*#1#%'/*+ -1/)#- 77@@,-A@33@64(/ (4%"-*#-8,(#*!&1#'" 8-!*$/*,(#")/0 (#'# #/.#'-8,(# %))/*8-'&#$=3,(%,,(#./ ,/&4%" 4/,((/&%*$(#(%$*-4)#8,8-'(/"(-!"# (# -&0)%/*%*,%*$(/"!* )# >#0,-*"#%' (/*+8-',(#./ ,/& *,(#&#%*,/&#,(#'# #/.#'-8,(# %1-.#"%/$ %))&%$#,#)#0(-*/ %)),4--',('##,/&#",-=3/,#*$#'

/*+(%*$%""!'#$(/&,(%,,(#./ ,/&4-!)$'#% ((/"(-!"# ,%1-!,6 & -*,(#"%/$$%2,(#./ ,/&4%"8-!*$ -&/*+8'-&,(#"/$#-8 %) !,,% !'"#'2 *#*B!/'2&%$#12,(# -&0)%/*%*,(/""-*4(-4%",(#./ ,/& /*8-'&#$(/&,(%,% !"#$ %& !&%'!"#$,-,%>#(/&,-(/"'--&%*$(%$ %'*%)/*,#' -!'"#4/,((/&&%*2,/&#"

*,(%,$%2%)"-(#4%" %))#$12 ,(#"%/$% !"#$,-(/"'--& (#./ ,/&/*",#%$-8+-/*+,-(/"" (--) 0'- ##$#$,-,(#'--&-8,(#% !"#$4(- -&&/,,#$ %'*%)/*,#' -!'"# 4/,((/& !"#$ %& !&%'%)"-!"#$,-,('#%,#*,(#./ ,/&4/,($/'# -*"#B!#* #"/* %"#(# (-"#,-$/" )-"#,(#/* /$#*,,-%*2-*#

(# -&0)%/*%*,4(-/",(#8%,(#'-8,(#./ ,/&4%"#9%&/*#$ %"=4(/)#(/"!* )#/,#*$#'/*+(4%"#9%&/*#$%"=3 (#",%'

4/,*#""4(-4%",(#./ ,/&4%"#9%&/*#$%"= #(%"$#0-"#$,(%, %1-!,,4-&-*,("0'/-',-,(#- !''#* #% !"#$ %& !&%'4%"0'#"#*, -!,"/$#(/"" (--) (#% !"#$%">#$(/&,-1#8'/#*$(/& (#./ ,/& /*8-'&#$,(%,(#4-!)$%">(/"8%,(#'%1-!,,(#"%/$0'-0-"%) %&#4%"(/"

'#0)24(#* ,(#% !"#$ %+%/* /*"/",#$ (/& 8-'&%>/*+ 8'/#*$"(/0 (# % !"#$-88#'#$(/&%*#%,%1)#*%&#)2 (-4&#/* 8,#'3$%2"-8,(%, /* /$#*,% !"#$4%"%+%/*0'#"#*,-!,"/$#(/"" (--)%*$0!))#$,(#./ ,/& %*$,-->(/&,-(/"(-!"# (#% !"#$1-),#$,(#$--'8'-&/*"/$#%*$ %">#$,(#./ ,/&,-,%>#(/"0#*/"/*,-(/"&-!,(%*$+%.#,4-")%0",-(/&

#%)"-%">#$(/&,--0#*(/"0%*,"

(#./ ,/&0)#%$#$,(%,(#(%$,-+-,- (/"(-!"# !"#$,/#$(/&4/,(% (%/'4/,(,(#(#)0-8%'-0# # 8-' /1)2-0#*#$,(#0%*,"-8,(#./ ,/&%*$(/"0%*,"%"4#)) (#% !"#$ &%$#(/&,-)/#$-4*%*$%,,#&0,#$,- -&&/, %'*%)/*,#' -!'"# #,'/#$

3 ,-0!,(/"0#*/"/*,-(/"%*!"

(#'#%8,#',(#% !"#$,-->(/&-*(/" 2 )# 8-'$'-00/*+(/&%,(/"(-!"#1!,-*,(#4%2=&#,,(#./ ,/& !,,(# ./ ,/&$/$*-,$/" )-"#,(#/* /$#*,,-(/"8%,(#'%,,(%,,/&# #$/" )-"#$ ,(#/* /$#*,,-(/"8%,(#'%8,#'-*#$%2-8,(#- !''#* # (#./ ,/&%)"- $#0-"#$,(%,%")/0&#*,/-*/*+,(#&-1/)#*!&1#'"-8,(#% !"#$4%" (%*$#$-.#',-(/&

=6 -*",%1)# %(!)8'-& 21#' #))%&!*%%+%'4%"

#9%&/*#$ #"0->#%1-!,,(#0'- !'#&#*,-8 %))$#,%/)"-8&-1/)#0(-*#" - A@33@6 %*$ 77@@ 8-' ,(# 0#'/-$ 8'-& 7 ,- 78'-&%,%- -&-%*$-$%0(-*# -&0%*/#"'#"0# ,/.#)2 (# %))$#,%/)'#0-',/*'#"0# ,-8&-1/)#0(-*#- A@33@64%"#9(/1/,#$ %"9 %*$,(%,-8&-1/)#0(-*#- 77@@4%"#9(/1/,#$%"C

(# 0'--8/*'#"0# ,-8&-1/)#0(-*#- A@33@64%"#9(/1/,#$%"

9 %*$-8&-1/)#(-*#- 77@@%"9

= '

/"(! -#) #$/ %) 88/ #' &#$/ -)#+%))2 #9%&/*#$ ,(# ./ ,/& -* 7 %*$ /""!#$

9 # %)"- "!1D# ,#$ % !"#$ %& !&%' ,- &#$/ -)#+%) #9%&/*%,/-* %*$ /""!#$

=E%*$-0/*#$,(%,,(#'#4%"*-,(/*+,-"!++#",,(%,,(#% !"#$ 4%"/* %0%1)#-80#'8-'&/*+"#9!%)/*,#' -!'"#

*,(#",%,#&#*,!*$#'# ,/-*33 '

,(#% !"#$"#,!0% 0)#%,(%,,(#./ ,/&4%"8-!*$8/+(,/*+4/,(%*-,(#'1-2/*,(#0%'>*#%'(/" (-!"# =(#*(#/*,#'.#*#$,(#./ ,/&(!')#$%1!"#"%,(/&$!#,-4(/ ( ,(#% !"#$+%.#%")%0,-,(#./ ,/&%*$'#0-',#$,(#"%&#,-(/"8%,(#' 4(#'#!0-*,(#./ ,/&;"8%,(#' %&#,-(/"(-!"#%*$" !88)#$4/,((/& #

7 0)#%$#$/**- #* #

#%'*#$ -!*"#) %00#%'/*+ 8-' ,(# %00#))%*, .#(#&#*,)2 "!1&/,,#$,(%,,(#,'/%) -!', -&0)#,#)2/+*-'#$,(#$#8#* #"#,!012,(# % !"#$/*(/"",%,#&#*,!*$#'# ,/-*33 '

,(%,,(#./ ,/&(%$% 8/+(,4/,(%*-,(#'1-2/*,(#0%'>)- %,#$*#%'(/"(-!"# ",(#./ ,/& '%/"#$(/"-1D# ,/-*,-,(#/*,#'.#*,/-*&%$#12,(#% !"#$(#")%00#$(/&

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

*)2%"%*%8,#',(-!+(,,(#./ ,/&(%$ -&#-!,4/,(%",%,#&#*,1#8-'#,(# !$/ /%)%+/",'%,#,(%,,(#0#*/"-8,(#% !"#$4%"0#*#,'%,#$/*,-(/" &-!,( (#-88#* #!*$#'# ,/-*3%*$7-8,(#

,4%"*-,&%$# -!, ,/"(/")%","!1&/""/-*,(%,/* %"#,(# -!', -&#",-,(# -* )!"/-* ,(%, ,(# % !"#$ (%" -&&/,,#$ ,(# -88#* # (%'+#$ %+%/*", (/& (/" "#*,#* #&%21#'#$! #$"!1",%*,/%))2 @

#%'*#$ -!*"#)8-',(#,%,#'#1!,,#$,(#%1-.#%'+!&#*," "!1&/,,#$12,(#)#%'*#$ -!*"#)%00#%'/*+ 8-',(#% !"#$ , /" (/"

"!1&/""/-* ,(%, ,(# ,'/%) -!', (%" '/+(,)2 #.%)!%,#$ ,(# #./$#* # %*$

5 '# -'$#$,(#8/*$/*+ (#"#*,#* #/&0-"#$-*,(#% !"#$4%"%)"-*-, $/"0'-0-',/-*%,#,-,(#+'%./,2-8,(#-88#* #%,,'/1!,#$,-,(#% !"#$

=4%",(#./ ,/&%+#$32#%'"

#4%"%" (--)+-/*+1-2

=!>(4/*$#'/*+(4(-/",(#8%,(#'-8,(#./ ,/&/"%*%!,-'/">"(%4 0!))#'

=(%" %,#+-'/ %))2$#0-"#$,(%,% !"#$ %& !&%'4%"0'#"#*, -!,"/$#(/"" (--)%*$0)#%$#$8-'&%>/*+8'/#*$"(/04/,((/& =(%$ /**- #*,)2'#"0-*$#$,(%,(#4-!)$%">(/"8%,(#'%1-!,"! (%0)#%-8,(# % !"#$ =(#*(#%+%/*'#0#%,#$%1-!,(/"/*,#*,/-*,-%">(/"8%,(#',- &%>#8'/#*$"(/0 4/,( ,(# % !"#$,(#% !"#$ -88#'#$ (/&%* #%,%1)# *%&#)2 (-4&#/* (#'#%8,#',(#% !"#$(%$4%/,#$8-'3$%2" # %+%/*#&#'+#$-!,"/$#,(#" (--)%*$0!))#$,(#./ ,/&%*$,-->(/&,-(/" (-!"# 8,#',%>/*+,(#./ ,/&,-,(#(-!"#,(#% !"#$1-),#$(/"(-!"# %*$0!,(/"0#*/"/*,-(/"&-!,( #(%$%)"-")%00#$,(#./ ,/&,4/ # (# ./ ,/&(%$0)#%$#$,(%,(#(%$,-0'- ##$,-(/"(-!"#1!,,(#% !"#$(%$ ,/#$(/&,-% (%/'4/,(,(#(#)0-8%'-0# #(%$8-' /1)2",'/00#$,(# 0%*,"-8,(#./ ,/&%*$(/"-*#%"4#))%*$(%./*+&%$#,(#./ ,/&,-)%2-* ,(#8)--'%,,#&0,#$,- -&&/,,#$ %'*%)/*,#' -!'"#4/,((/& (#'#%8,#' ,(#% !"#$,-->(/&-*(/"1/ 2 )#8-'$'-00/*+(/&%,(/"(-!"#

(#%1-.#,#",/&-*2-8,(#./ ,/&/"8-!*$,-1# '#$/1)#%*$ ,'!",4-',(2 ,$-#"*-,%00#%',-1#% -* - ,#$.#'"/-*#&%*%,#$$!#,- "-&# #*&/,2 1#,4##* 8%,(#' -8 ,(# ./ ,/& %*$ ,(# % !"#$ * &2 -*"/$#'#$./#432#%'"-)$" (--)1-24-!)$*-,(%.#'/">#$,-1#%',(# " %'8-'(/"#*,/'#)/8#% #$/*+,-,(#'#B!#",-8(/"8%,(#',- -&#-!,4/,(% 8%)"#.#'"/-*-8 %'*%)/*,#' -!'"#D!",,-4'#%>.#*+#%* #12(/"8%,(#'

6 %+%/*",,(#% !"#$ !',(#'8/*$,(%,,(#$#8#* #0)#%"#,!012,(# % !"#$/*(/"",%,#&#*,!*$#'# ,/-*33 '

(%"*-)#+",-",%*$ !0-* *-,(#'4-'$",(#1-24/,(4(-&,(#./ ,/&0/ >#$!0%8/+(,4%" *-,#9%&/*#$12,(#$#8#* #,-1!,,'#"",(#0)#%"#,!012,(#% !"#$

# -*$)2=4-!)$*-,(%.#/&%+/*#$,-8%1'/ %,#% %"#4/,("! (8%)"# /&0)/ %,/-*%+%/*",,(#% !"#$12/*.-)./*+(/"/**- #*,32#%'"-)$"-* D!",,-$#&-'%)/F#,(#% !"#$ *&2 -*"/$#'#$./#4,(#% !"#$(%"

-&#-!,4/,(% - >%*$1!))",-'2,(%,,(#8%,(#'-8,(#./ ,/&4(-(%$% B!%''#)4/,((/&1-->#$%8%)"# %"#%*$0'-D# ,#$(/""-*%"%./ ,/& (# $#8#* #0)#%(%"1##*'/+(,)2'#D# ,#$12,(#,'/%) -!',

(#./ ,/&;"8%,(#';"!* )#4%"/*8% ,/*"#%' (-8,(#./ ,/&

=%*$=3(%.#"0->#*%1-!,,(#%*9/#,2,(#8%&/)2(%$-*% -!*,-8 ,(#&/""/*+-8./ ,/&'/+(,8'-&3 0 & ,-6 0 & -*,(#$%2-8 - !''#* # (#&-,(#'-8,(#1-2(%$&%$#%"#%' (-8,(# )-,(#"-8,(# ./ ,/& (#,!&1)#$!0-*%")/04(/ ( -*,%/*#$&-1/)#- A@33@6

=3/,#*$#'/*+(,(#!* )#-8,(# -&0)%/*%*,(%$&%$#% %)),-,(# %1-.#&-1/)#*!&1#'4/,((/"&-1/)#*!&1#'1#%'/*+- 77@@

(# %)) $#,%/)" 0'-$! #$ 12 =6 -*",%1)# %(!) 8'-& 21#' #)) %&!*%%+%'$#&-*",'%,#,(%,,(# %))"(%$#&%*%,#$8'-&,(#&-1/)# 0(-*#-8=3/,#*$#'/*+(,-,(#&-1/)#0(-*#-8,(#% !"#$ (# % !"#$(%$%)"-'#,!'*#$% %)),-,(#&-1/)#0(-*#-8=3 (#%1-.# %))$#,%/)"1!,,'#"",(# %"#-8,(#0'-"# !,/-*,(%,,(#8%&/)2(%./*++-,,(# &-1/)#0(-*#*!&1#'8'-&,(#")/08-!*$/*,(# )-,(#"-8,(#./ ,/& -*,% ,#$,(#"%/$&-1/)#0(-*#*!&1#'%*$'# #/.#$%0-"/,/.#'#"0-*"#

(#'#4%"*-0)%!"/1)##90)%*%,/-*8'-&,(#% !"#$%"'#+%'$",(#%1-.# %))$#,%/)"4(/ ("!00-',",(##./$#* #-8=%*$=3

= 4(- 4%" ,(# ./ ,/& 4%" *-, ,(# %!,(-' -8 ,(# 8/'", /*8-'&%,/-*'#0-', ,4%"-*)2(/"8%,(#'=4(-(%$)-$+#$% -&0)%/*, 1%"#$ -* ,(# /*8-'&%,/-* 8!'*/"(#$ 12 = (#'#8-'# = 4%" *-, %*"4#'%1)#,-,(#$#,%/)"+/.#*12(/"8%,(#'/*,(#8/'",/*8-'&%,/-*'#0-',

*2/* -*"/",#* 28-!*$/*,(#8/'",/*8-'&%,/-*'#0-',4-!)$*-, '#%,#% $-!1, /*,(#.#'"/-*-8= =(%$ %,#+-'/ %))2",%,#$1#8-'#,(# )#%'*#$!$/ /%)%+/",'%,#%"4#))%"1#8-'#,(# -!',,(%,,(#% !"#$(%$ *-,-*)2&%$#%*%,,#&0,,- -&&/, %'*%)/*,#' -!'"#1!,0!,(/"0#*/"/*,- (/"&-!,(

*&2 -*"/$#'#$./#4,(#'#/"*-&%,#'/%) -*,'%$/ ,/-*/*,(# ",%,#&#*,-8,(#./ ,/&4(-4%"#9%&/*#$%"= !',(#',(#./ ,/&(%"

%,#+-'/ %))2$#0-"#$,(%,,(#% !"#$(%$ -&#-!,4/,(%,('#%,,->/))(/& /8(# (-"#,-'#.#%),(#%88%/',-%*2-*# (#8% ,,(%,,(#./ ,/&(%$ '#.#%)#$,(##*,/'#/* /$#*,,-(/"8%,(#',(#*#9,$%2+-#",-#",%1)/"(,(%, ,(#./ ,/&4%"/*,(#+'/0-88#%'

#%'*#$ -!*"#)%00#%'/*+8-',(#%00#))%*, /,#$%$# /"/-*-8 ,(#-&1%2/+( -!',/*

!" # *% %"#!*$#',(#

, ,(#,'/%) -!',$/"1#)/#.#$,(#%))#+%,/-*&%$#%+%/*",,(#% !"#$,(%,(# %">#$,(#./ ,/&,-,%>#(/"0#*/"/*(#'&-!,( (#'#8-'#,(#-*;1)# -&1%2 /+( -!', &%$# %* -1"#'.%,/-* ,(%, /8 ,(# ,'/%) -!', (%$ $/"1#)/#.#$,(%,0%',-8,(#",-'2,(#*,(#'#4%"*-,(/*+,-% #0,,(#-,(#'

@ ",-'2,(%,% !"#$,-! (#$,(#1'#%",-8,(# (/)$ *% %'#8!)'#%$/*+-8 ,(#%1-.#$# /"/-*/,/"8-!*$,(%,%",'%/*#$'#)%,/-*"(/01#,4##*,(# 0%',/#"(%$1##*%$&/,,#$$!'/*+,(# -!'"#-8 '-""#9%&/*%,/-*-8=

*$#'"! ( /' !&",%* #",(#,#",/&-*2-8,(# (/)$4/,*#""4%"8-!*$*-, '#)/%1)#12,(#-&1%2/+( -!',

* ,(# /*",%*, %"# ,(# 0)#% "#, !0 12 ,(# % !"#$ /* (/" ",%,#&#*,!*$#'# ,/-*33 '

4%"*-,#",%1)/"(#$ (#'#/"*-)#+%) #./$#* #,- -&#,-% -* )!"/-*,(%,,(#8%&/)2-8,(#./ ,/&(%$",'%/*#$ '#)%,/-*"(/04/,(,(#% !"#$ *,(/" %"#/,/"8-!*$,(%,,(#% !"#$4%"% ",'%*+#',-,(#8%&/)2-8,(#./ ,/& (#'#8-'#/*&2 -*"/$#'#$./#4,(# %1-.#$# /"/-*4-!)$*-,%00)2,-,(#0'#"#*, %"#

#%'*#$ -!*"#) %00#%'/*+ 8-',(#%00#))%*, '#8#''#$ ,-2#, %*-,(#'$# /"/-*/*$%

& '

( ) "!

(%,4%"% %"#4(#'#==%*$=34(-4#'#,(# *#/+(1-!'"-8,(# -&0)%/*%*,,!'*#$(-",/)#,-,(# %"#-8,(#0'-"# !,/-* %*$$#0-"#$,(%,,(#2$/$*-,(%.#%*2$/'# ,>*-4)#$+#-8,(#- !''#* #

(#&#$/ %)#9%&/*%,/-*-8,(#./ ,/&$/" )-"#$,(%,(#'(2&#*4%"/*,% ,

"%'#"!),-84(/ (0#*#,'%,/.#"#9!%)%""%!),4%"*-,0'-.#$/*,(%, %"#

!,/*,(#/*",%*, %"#,(#./ ,/&;",#",/&-*20%""#$,(#,#",-8 '#$/1/)/,2

(#'#4%"*-'#%"-*,- %",%$-!1,-*(/",#",/&-*2-''#D# ,,(#"%&#

(#'#8-'#,(#-1"#'.%,/-*"&%$#/*,(#%1-.#$# /"/-*4/))*-,(%.#%*2 1#%'/*+-*,(/" %"#

-&/*+,-,(#B!%*,!&-8"#*,#* #/&0-"#$12,(#,'/%) -!', 8/*$,(%,,(#%,,#&0,&%$#12,(#% !"#$,-(%.# %'*%)/*,#' -!'"#4/,(

A ,(#./ ,/&(%")#8,%0#'&%*#*," %'/*,(#0"2 (#-8,(#./ ,/& (#,'%!&% ,(#./ ,/&(%$!*$#'+-*#-*% -!*,-8,(#!**%,!'%)1#%",)21#(%./-!'-8 ,(#% !"#$ %**-,1#)-","/+(,-812,(# -!',4(/)#B!%*,/82/*+,(# "#*,#* # (#%*/&%)1#(%./-!'-8,(#% !"#$4/))(%.#,-1#&%, (#$4/,( %"!/,%1)#0!*/"(&#*, !',(#'!*$#'# ,/-*"3%*$7-8,(#

, ,(#&/*/&!&0!*/"(&#*,0'#" '/1#$/"2#%'"-8/&0'/"-*&#*, (#'#8-'# /*&2 -*"/$#'#$./#4,(#,'/%) -!',(%"'/+(,)2%4%'$#$"#*,#* #8-',(# -88#* #!*$#'# ,/-*3'#%$4/,(# ,/-*5%*$# ,/-*56 %*$ # ,/-*"3%*$7-8

* ,(# '#"!), -*8/'&/*+ ,(# D!$+#&#*, -8 -*./ ,/-* %*$ "#*,#* #0%""#$12,(#,'/%) -!',,(#%00#%)",%*$"$/"&/""#$ %' ( ! "

!)%,/

#$ =(#,(#'0#%>/*+E #%"-*#$ #"

=(#,(#' #0-',%1)# #"