← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12058/1998dismissed

Manju S. Gupta v. State Of Haryana

2016-04-12Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih14 pages

 

     

    

   !" # $   % &'  #("               

   

()'!"*+, '" 

")-.&*+.+!*% & ///  '' "   .."" 0&1..2'

304  51

' "   4 6 '' ' 30'.1 " '34 /// 

  +2 '     "

& 7'   8

 9+:

;*  1&'< =

 * %>+* !

3 9 " ;* , 2'' '

.  ..  ' "  2 0         9+:

 ;   

8 9+:

 ;* 2' 1&'""..' ,"

1&'" 3'  0"2 0 +1  

 '',.'" ' 

32.1:" % & > 1 ,."0 +' & 9%>+;*  ' &   * , "".  ..0  . 

  '

3' 2 .   *!

3? 0 .  ' 1 '

0"". 0 9+:

 ;* .& ' "". 2  .31.  "".&* 2'   2  . '@".  !

3 > 1 <  '@'  0    ' 0 & ' " 0.&001 A *'"  2..  '  '1 2  .31.  "".&* '& 1' 3' ..01&0,32" "".-'2 .   .  '  2   . '. 1& ' '  . @  2 ..  ')  '&0 !"* '1  '" * 0.. ..02'0       2 .. ". 88@ * 1 ' .1'..0. * '..2 1  0    .3 %2, * " .0   '  "* 0...0.  8  9+:

 ;* 2,'" +* 0 . ' '

0"". 0* '

'  

,     9+:

 6; 3 ' '   2 &

. '@".  '  0    ' 0   &   ' " 0.& 001  -* 17.& " * , 00  6   * ) ' "   . ' '1"" .  &'2'&1'2 .

 2 "  . ". ? "* "   ' '1"" 1 ''  .  '  0   ' .31.& .    ' 1 '

0 "". 0* '& 2  .31.  ) ..0  '

", 0 A *  2 ..& "  '

6 ' *1'2 0:* 3' "  1-..*'&2 .

  '".*

..01'''1.'2 2"

" .& 3' 0 ..0A ' * 0.&9'1@2 " 0.&001 ;..&1..". " .  > 1 < +* ,     8

 *  ..'" 2 0+""."

3'  0"201&'""..' &*    ' ".& ' :  ' &    2 .''" . '.. '  '1 ' .

& 1 ..  ".  ' 0 > 1 <



!" #$%  %  & !%' ( % ) *+% *" , -'* "% .

( .

! /0))1 '*&) $/% && )) *% '(%

%% //'"

'%(/0!*'( "#1% && )) *% *" !

0(# *" !  ( & ! % !-( 2 .$*"'%'$*( $/ &&)'.

%'$* /$!-3 ))$%- *% ) %% !  1 !  *$% " & *" *% $* .

$% ! # .

0(  % 1 !  !0**'*+ % '! $4* #0('* (( *" #$% !  ! +0) ! *.$-   , (( ((  /$! %  ) (% 56 !( % ! /$!  % 1 !  )'+'#)  %$ ! % '* #$%  % &)$%(7 !

(%  &0%1'(%!'.%%%$!* 1$*#

)/$/  (% % "%

%%  ,'(%'*+&$)'.1$/ "$ (*$%

))$4 " & *" *%/ -')1- -# !( *"(&$0( %$! % '* %4$ &)$%(  '*+ +' *  .$*('" ! " % $0+ % %$ % $)  - %% !  - $/ %  $&'*'$* %

% % $0+  /$! % #0('* (( &0!&$( ( % 1 8 0(# *" *" 4'/ 9 !  ( & !

%  '*.$-  % , (( ((  #0% '% '( )($ / .% %

% # '*+

0(# *" *"4'/ % 1 ! - -# !$/$* / -')1 *" ( & ! '*"0 *"''" "

-')1  4( *" ( & !   &$)'.1 " & *" *%/ -')1- -# !( *"(&$0( .

**$% ! % '*%4$&)$%( ! /$! % ! (0-&%'$*$!" !("

% "

 :;<=> & (( " #1 %      0!+ $* !  .$!! .%

*" (& !&$)'.1$/ ? B)2* , ' ,. ' & 0 '

,  

 0 '     0" 5' . 

, '



!" #$%  %  & !%' ( *" +$*  % !$0+ % ! .$!"$/% .

( .

! /0))1 -$(%&$'*% ! %$ #  " .'" " '( 4 % ! 0(# *" *" 4'/  !  " & *" *% $* .

$% !4 *#$% ! & 1'*+% , (( & !

% )1 *"

!  /'* *.'

))1 ($) *% *$0+ %$ /0*.%'$* '*" & *" *%)1  * '/ % 0(# *" *" 4'/  !  '*" & *" *% /'* *.'

))1 % 1 !  )''*+ %$+ % ! *" & !% $/ %  ( -  / -')1 '* % #( *.  $/ *1% '*+ .$*%!

!1.$-'*+$*! .$!" &0!&$( $/ ))$%- *%$/  '(%$ ))$%&)$%%$ & !($* ( 0*'%4 '.

.$*('(%( $/ 0(# *" 4'/  *" -'*$! .

')"! *  '( '( % " /'*'%'$* $/ / -')1 % $0+  /$! '*.$-  % , &0!&$( 

0(# *" *"4'/ .$0)"# '*" & *" *%0*'%'/% 1& 1 % ,$*% '!$4*'*.$- ( & !

% )1/ )4 ( $0)"*$% + % %$$ -0.

 '*$) " '*%$ %  ) + ) .$-&) ,'%1 $/ % &!$#) - #!$ "$#@ .%' $/ ( $0)"# A &%'* ' 44 ')  ))$%%'*+&)$%%$% " ( !'*+& $&)  * %  '*(% *.  .

(  *$ !+0- *%

( # * &0% /$!4 !" ( %$ 4 1 %4$ &)$%( !  * " " '* $*  / -')1  '( # .$- ( ('+*'/'.

*% ( '% %!

*(&'! " %

% %  &)$%

))$%% "%$! "

0A !0&%

(# *%!

*(/ !! " %$-% *%$(  .

"

$*:B::==C '(( $4(%

% % ""'%'$* ) &)$% .$-'*+ %$ %  / -')1 #1 ( ! +$$" )0.A

( # * 0%')'D " /$! /'* *.'

) + '*  '( " / %( %  !1&0!&$( $/ ))$%- *%$/&)$%(#1  *. 

- *$% &! & ! " %$ +!  4'%  % !+0- *% $/ %

&& )) *%..$!"'*+)1% && )'("'(-'(( "?

  5''2*1,*'" 1 '  ? ' 2  0* .  1'.

   '

"*0' 0 '".& %>+* '1  2  13 "  ' '   001    ' 0 0.&*  ' "

"   ..0  ' > 1 < ,." 1& %>+* 2   .   ,. ". A ' * '1* 2   " 0.& 001 2  ' . ".="" &

  '".2

' " 2..' '1*1'&: ' "5'01 , ,."0 > 1<2  .. . ".  '0. "  5' *  ..'" 2 3'.& 0 B . '" 10' 0 '.31.&.*1''" 2..' '1* 2 ..& .31.  "".&  ) ..0  '  ,. 0*  '& 2 ..& "  3 ' "  1 '    '0 2  . ".@'!

3 & ' " 0.&001  2 .'@' 0'> 1< ' * '1   ' " * 2' '""  1  3  <3

0 ' >    +0 *    ,3  &  1 * 2  ..& 33  ' " 1 * ' * . ,  1   1  " 0.& 001    ' "  B)2* , '

 " * 2' . '.  3  3   + * ' 2 ) , .& > +   3?* '  '  " '  " 1 % 10 ' :"

 C" 0.& 001 D   . 

..& " " % . 10 ' & 17 .   ' .31.&    ".&* , 2'' ' "". 2 7  

'  

, ' ' 2& .".> 1<*!

3' ' 0@" '0 & ' " 0.& 001 *2.

'.0 '" ) ..0A ' .31.&21 0 0 ' '

1&'' '&  ? 3'  " 0.&001  3' *3 1 ..&"*"".&. ..0* 2'3''@' " 2 .".*' 0. .& ..&"2 '...1.31.) ..0 5'*'10'  ' 13. 2'..&

   *. . ' "0 .&

 ' ' 01 '  13. '''1'2 0  ', '  .  .  ' "   " '   - 2"

 0E2'' '" 2@. ..0 . '..*  '  '1  ' 1 ..  . ".  '

8 0> 1<   *!

3*2.1""

1 '

0"". 0 '  "

" '23'1',,'..0

  0!+ $*%$4*

( %%!

.% "#$% %  *%! &! * 0!(

*" %  ( )% ! ( A !( # '*+ (')1 .. (('#)  *"

'*+ .) * *" &) ( *% *'!$*- *%(  )$% $/ -&)$1- *%&$% *%'

)'(# '*+.!

% "'* *" !$0*"% %$4*( ! (0)%% ! '( 0+ " - *"/$!! ('" *%'

) &)$%( /!$- %  & $&)  )''*+ '*   %'$* )  &'% ) *" /!$- "@ . *% (% % (    !1 * !# *   )$&- *% 0% $!'%1

( -# !A " 0&$* * -#'%'$0( &!$+!

--  $/ "  )$&'*+ * !

 $/ E666  .%( '* %  (

&  $/

!'$0(! ('" *%'

)'*"0(%!'

) *".$-- !.'

)( .%$!($* -$(%-$" !*)'* ( 0%$/E666 .%(5666 .%(

)!

"1 # * /0))1 "  )$& " *" ($)" $0% #$0% C66  .%('()'A )1%$#  .F0'! "'*% * !/0%0!   >>  .%$! >> '( )$.

% " $*  ) ' 0!+ $* !$ " % "'(% *. $/:>G(/!$-

) -'!&$!%$&&$('%  !0%'

"1$+ %" *" * ! "1$+ '

! *"0(%!'

) !

 G &'*+ '* ' 4 % 0+  " - *" /$! ! ('" *%'

) &)$%( * !% '(*"0(%!'

)$-&) , .%$!>>

(# *% A * 0&/$!"  )$&- *% *"% &)$%($/C !) .

% +$!1%$ :E !) .

% +$!1

 # *.

! "$0% &$(( (('$* $/% ) *"

( )!

"1# *% A *#1% 0% $!'%1 *" "  )$&- *% 4$!A( % %  ('%  4')) (% !% ($$*  &!$'('$*$/ ))% -$" !*/ .')'%' (3 - *'%' ((0.

( % !(0&&)1(%$!-4 % !"!

'* + ( 4 !

+ H ) .%!'.'%1

*" %  ('%  /$! !'$0( &0#)'. *" ! )'+'$0( #0')"'*+(H & !A(H( $&&'*+.* %! ( $$) %.

(# *- "          

I  8 * !

) .

% +$!1 ! ( !  .

% +$!1 $/   7 ! 4'"$4( *" ,J( !'. - *  *"'.

&& " *" " / *. & !($** )3,J( !'. - *9

  ! $  % +$!1 $ $/ &)$%( /$!  * !

)  % +$!1 !* (% -$* 1 K :6L$/% %$% ) % *% %'  &!'. 8 (9 : :E !) :B= := J >>;6C CE=E66 $ $/ &)$%( /$! " / *.  & !($** )3 ,J ( !'. - * $ $/ &)$%( ! ( ! " /$! 2,J ( !'. - * 2

*"'.

&& "

%  & ! (F -%! (9 > :6 !) >:5 >C J >>;6C E==B66 5 < !) ::C :E J >>;6C 5<<566 E C !) >B> EB =B >6E5C >;B=66 ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,, 

   :: *)1% $(  &&)'.

*%( !  )'+'#) %$ &&)14 $"$ *$% $4*  ! ('" *%'

) &)$%3 $0(  '* 0!+ $* !# * (% % '* '(3 !* - $!'*% * - $/ *1" & *" *% / -')1- -# !(* //'"

'%%$% '( // .%( $0)"

%$# +' * %% %'- $/'((0 *. $/ ))$%- *%) %% !? <: *    ' ., .   ' '

*    1,* ,. ' '  ' 1  '3 0 . ".

0 ' "". .,3   . ". 

0    0 . . '2 ' " 3  ".

00 .'  * . ' 01     ,.1.  '   ' 3  ' * ' 01    ". ' 2  ,  * -*  22  <: ,0 3   

  "

"   1   '   , & 30   ' &+*'.31.&  .*

  1,*  '    "". .

& 2  . ".@'  ' 0 > 1 <  '@'  0* '@' '..1.31."".&* '"

" ..0

 203''3"

1.0B)2* " 0.& 001 * 2' '..   .& 1 ' '. *  

..&@0..& " " '  " * 2 

. ".@'*  ' 0 > 1 <* '  2.

  '  "  .31.  ) ..0 A * '     . "

0" ' '& .. 2. '1 3'   ' 0''.='* .3'22'&  "* 1 '  '1    2 * 2'    "    ' 0 0.& *  .0  " '   5' .31.&..&3 '..0 .'0 "

,3'0''0. 10  "

 31&'2'.

&',' '   '  0    ' 0   '  " 0.& 001  A 0 @.2  2  "

,   '  . '.3*"

7* @,."' 1 * "

, '0 "

 31 "1. "

" >1.&* ' :"

 M(&$0(    :"

.& 0 "    ' .31.& . %2, * .  :. "

2.. 3F'2' '    013& 2'  '  0   01.  2 03E2 

2 *'' 0 3,

'2 1&  3'". .   .':2'''&  .2 .' 01 0'"

" '0 , &, 103,

'"

"

    0& ' 0'        2''   .2   "

, 5' *'7' 1 E2'' ' .31.& . 7      "

    '* 2''  2. .  0.".&3 ' "

1.0   '3   

'  01.*   2  7   "".& ' :. .  "



' '"

"  ' ..0  + 1  2 "



' * 2  ' 001""

"

  1 ,01& ' %D1. "

0    ' :*    , !) ((  * !

) '* *.  *" * (%- *% $ %"*  89;   * 2'' '

*% !&! % %'$* -0(% " & *" $* %  % ,% *" % .$*% ,%  1 ! %  # ( ( $/ '*% !&! % %'$* *  - 1 4 ))( 1'/% % ,%'(% % ,%0! .$*% ,%'(4

%+' ( % .$)$0! '% !.

*# '+*$! "$% ! '-&$!% *% 

% '*% !&! % %'$* '( # (% 4 '.

 - A ( %  % ,%0 ) '*% !&! % %'$* - %.

 %  .$*% ,%0 )   (% %0%  '( # (% '*% !&! % " * % $#@ .%

*" &0!&$(  $/ '%( * .%- *% '( A*$4* 7'%  % '( A*$4) "+  %  (% %0%  -0(% #  !

" /'!(% (  4 $)  *" % * ( .%'$* #1 ( .%'$*.) 0( #1.) 0( & !

( #1& !

(  *"4$!"#1 4$!" /  (% %0%  '( )$$A " % '* %  .$*% ,% $/ '%( * .%- *% 4'%  %  +) (( ( $/ %  (% %0%  - A ! &!$'" " #1 (0.

 .$*% ,% '%( (.

-  %  ( .%'$*( .) 0( (& !

( ( *"4$!"(- 1% A .$)$0! *" && ! "'// ! *%%

*4 *% (% %0% '()$$A " %4'% $0%% +) (( (&!$'" "#1% .$*% ,%7'% % ( +) (( (% .$0!%-0(%)$$A %% .% ( 4 $)  *""'(.$ !4

%

.

( .%'$* .

.) 0(  .

& !

(  *" .

4$!"'( - *% *"" ('+* "%$( 1 (%$/'%'*%$% (.

- $/ %  *%'!  .% $ & !% $/  (% %0%  *" *$ 4$!" $/

 (% %0%  .

* #  .$*(%!0 " '* '($) %'$* % %0% (

  %$ #  .$*(%!0 " ($ %

%  !1 4$!"

(  &) .  *"  !1% '*+'('*'%(&) . ?    3F ' :    .'3* '3'1& 0)? * 2''  0 '3  * ' "   3 " '3  13 "

05' *'2) , 233.

12 ' 3 "".  ' ".3 '3 

  )* 2   0"..    .  :..& +* ' * ' :"

 C"".D '.. . . 

"

  M(&$0(   '&    2  ' "

"  ..0 ' .&* '1   ' "  2 .. 

. '0> 1<*2'' '17.& .  5' * 0 .*"  2. '2..'  ' '12 3,"

  ' 2 * 1 '&   5' * ..   '  ..'" 2'.&,1."1 ' '  +*   02'@0.    

*"'+ !

$0('*+ $ !" *" *$% !   !'*" ! G 0!  A$)

96; ((9,.; 69 ;*)33F ' '' 2

. .    '  .     3  . 00 . ".* '  . '" '. ' '1   '

" 92 ; 2  . ' 2' ' 0

  

 &  ' ' 2  .31.  ..0   '

. ".  +* ' * ' 2  G . 'H  (3. 9; 0 1    .3  .   1, ' 00 . .  3 "'     ' 30  '

:> * $0! $&'*'$* '* ' 4 $/ % "-'%% " / .% %

% % ! '( ! ('" *%'

)/) %'*% ( .$*" *"% '!"/)$$!( $/% +!$0*"/)$$!.$-- !.'

)&)$%'%-0(%* . (( !')1 #  )" %

% % 0(# *" $/ %  ! (&$*" *% $4* " ! ('" *%'

) $0(  4'% '* %  % !!'%$!1 '* F0 (%'$* *" %

%% ! /$! % ! (&$*" *%84'/ $/% /'!(% ))$%% 9 '( *$% )'+'#)  /$! ))$%- *% $/ *$% ! ! ('" *%'

) &)$% /!$- %  ( '" 0% $!'%1 % -0(% #  !

)'D " %

% % (  &)$%( !  ))$%% " '* .$*. (('$* ) # ('( %$ % ))$%% ( #1 %  &0#)'. 0% $!'%1 *" %  ! ) *% ! +0) %'$*( -0(%% ! /$! # '*% !&! % "'*(0.

- ** !%$( 8('. ( ! 9 % '! !

) &0!&$(  ($ %

% %  &)$%( ! 

') #)  ( / ! ( &$(('#)  %$ %  ) !+ (% *0-# ! $/ & !($*( *" /$! &!  *%'*+ %  ( -  / -')1 - -# !(

0(# *"$!4'/ $!" & *"

*%( (% .

( - 1# /!$- + %%'*+ -$!  %

* $*  &)$% $! $0(  /$! %  ( -  &0!&$(  7  !  $/ %  ' 4 %

% %  4$!"( M! ('" *%'

)

$0( '* +0) %'$*C8:9-0(%# %!

% " ('*.)0"'*+ /) %.$*(%!0.% " #$ % .$-- !.'

)/) %$*% +!$0*" /)$$!  '( 4')) #  ($  * '/ $!'+'* ))1 %  &)$% 4 (

))$%% " /$! .$-- !.'

) &0!&$( ( '/ '*.'" *% ))1 .$*(%!0.%'$* $/ ! ('" *%'

) /) % #$  %  +!$0*" /)$$! .$-- !.'

)&)$%'(& !-'%% " (& !% &) *(*$% ! 4$!"(  *% $0+ % &)$%'( ))$%% " ( .$-- !.'

) &)$%'/'%'(& !-'(('#) %$#0')" ! ('" *%'

)/) % #$  % .$-- !.'

)&)$% *"'(($.$*(%!0.% "% *(0.

! ('" *%'

) /) % 4')) .$-  4'% '* %  &!$ '#'%'$* '*

+0) %'$*C8:9?

6 5'  30 ' ' 1 , 1& .  .  ' " * '    " 0.& 001 * 1 ' 3' *31 ..&"  ..&"001 ' 0.&*.) ..0* , '3' '@'  "  .

& 2  . *''2"*2'. ..&"*2. 1.31.*..),+" 0.&001 * 3 ' 3   0 &* . "    '@'   '@'   .       0*  '  .     ,*  ', '@'  2 0.&  "  '.  +* '  0& @ 7   "  ''.*  2. ' 1 .31.  ) ..0 ' * ' "".'@' " "

0'13'  '0''.%12 .,3' . 3 +.'3'* '   '0 0& 1 ..& "* '&  "'' 7' 2..3*' 0 0. '0   3 '     ' '0* ' "&

' 2' "' ".,  ' 2..3  2 1& ' '     ' 0

."& ' '0 1*2''" ' '1"".* ,2" "".*1'2 .31.)..0 5'"

"2''& 7 2"* '&2 .," .&*10".&'' '  2'*. '0.3". .-'&1'''.3

 +      ' 10E ' ' .31.&    ..0'3

000 '&  ""..)..0, '@' .

& '    '@'  0    ' 0   "

0.&001 *'&

*&,..',0 '".'0> 1<2..,'  '" 1 A *2'2 '  '"

,.  " .  > 1 <* 2    &   3, 0* 23 2' *  .31.& . 2 0.*    1   +&*22 .& 7  "

.'

0 "    ' 1 '

0"". 0*   ' &   ..0 ''> 1<*  !

3+2',.* "

",  * ' :"

 C"".D 2. . 

"

E '@'  " 2'3 2''  '@' 

..&"  ?'2) '"*)'1,*2     

 2' '   :  1& ' '    + .    '    ? 5' "13, 0  3.&0 ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 12.04.2016 Rajan