High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/3098/2015dismissed

Joginder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2022-08-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages

!" "

#$% $' """(( )* * +

,- """* & +* " &+.&/ 0$(%&

*( '(( " " (% $' &'

.1.+

,-" 22222

*'((' *' *.**

*4 '

"!"

.(% 4+(% % 5 (%'&&-4 36%(% $'37'%(/((% $% % %(/'% (-% $6"

+ 8 9 7* 4% $ ((% $ & ' :% $* *% % * * *7%'% , %*&% '(% *% ;7'%('(% 4 7*'/%(($6%'(: '&7&*/%(($* *%&.

'3 %/&* % % '#$% $'* % $'*%& ' .+(% % ': '%-%*% ' *%&% $5 (% %4 *&-% $% <% 7& *%& &' *(('*(5 (% &&,% $/%(($*;

'&4.'7*-% $% $% <% 7&' &%$'% '%*

%-% $6"=8

.% *% :7*(%& -%&$* %/.' #$% $' (&- $'&' && ( $7%'% <% 7&;-(%/% $'% % -(%-(.

'3* >(% *% ' $' *-(,* :'7 % $'.

'-*%*7'% '(?37* &&;'(% 4(%& % :-%&$* %/.& % $' * :- &%. %-% $6"=8

% $' &%$'*%& 7**&-4$%/% $*%$ (; -% $% > %&.'&%/&%* (*& '%* *#$% $'* % $'.*%& ' .

' *%&% $5 (%;'3&%* (*&'%*%& %4'

*&.

*% $''% &&* ''%* &''

*&'&%$' $' * '& 41@&% $%*;'

*&&$'* '

&'3.*% $'' '&%'% '%;'3& * 7'% '7**%$ &-4 '3% 9 $(%*' &*&-47% ***;'. % '

*&7** '& &'4* -'% &'&%/% $*.

(*% -<7* /&; -% $ & & ' :&.%7*

% <% 7&;- ''&%/% $*. /( 7<7* /& & -% $ ' :&%7*

% *%*+/ **; '*% % $ * (*;' 3&77*(*7%$'% $ $ ''% <% 7& '(*% -<;'*(*7 % 7*(*% -<* 7'% '7 /&% (*;'% $% <% 7&%

'(*% -< -% $7%$'& A$;'*%&

<% 7&7* *&% '*(*% -<;%7*(*

/&% (.' 7*( (* &'- (: ( 7*(&-4'37%''%**('/% $%**% B6B;7*%*

* (* 7 : * *(* & /& % (;

% $ *%*7(* /&% * (*;((' (*7*(&-437%'%**(B6B;' % *47* ' : (% ****% /%& /4;*( * 7*' &&/= '% $';? 7*%((& ' *;' % *47*: (% ****% /%& /4*&-4+C*;'

*&7*((4*&%

'%* *; $'*%( ( /47*&; % '

*&7**%@&/%&* /4;* * 7% ***7 &&" '(% *% .'3&

*& ( $ 7%' * 4 & 7% *** - 3 * '*'

.=+(% % 7' 4% $ % * .*(& ' *47%''%*7 *('/% $%**% B5B &*& '* % *(%**% '%'3;' ' *47* ' &&/='(% *% &

*&7* % ' ( : "

' <&4%""

"!"

.36%(% $':

' *4='(% *% ;'

*&7* : (% ( :

*&( $7%' *4 &% / 47&

&-#3.;'

*&7*

&&, &% %(

*&4; '(% *% .'3 &*%&' *47%'=" "!"

. ((*% -< % $ $% <% 7&*(&7%'*(%**% B6D5B; ( % $ 8 *%* / ** *(& 7%' ' *( %**% 6D5;'*( (*7'% '%

( && ( (*% % $ % <% 7& & (4 *(& 7%' *( '/% $ * %% B6D5B. ( % $ *%/ ** *(&7%'*(%**% B6D5B7: (:' &&*%&% , &% %((:' .% &%% " "!"

. *( ( % $ $ <% 7&. ' *( ( % $ 7 *%* / **.-' (*& (4*(&7' &&/ *-( *'%*'5 &*%% $'*% '% ? *% %

0-4.'(%" 8"

*&7*&

&-' $%* ( $ 7%' ' '$'* 7'% ' 7 : % ****% -4'3" "

. :'-%% $'*%& )%(($(.* &'&

*(& % -' 3 7' : % ****% ' *. /%& /4 ; ' * *7% ***7 &&;'% (9<% 7* %/&. /'(** '(( 7*&.*% $'* 7' '?07* %/&.'*7 (&-&

' "

(% % /*%$% & ' (%%*.

'(( $% *'

*&7*& &%(&% ' ;

* % ' '(( .&

*(%& '% 7* (%& '

*& ***/%&&

& !"+"". ' % &% $% % *. '$

'6 % $* &+*4 '% -*

* . *' B' B7*&$% *'

*&.7'% ''(&& $ %(4 & (%&%(" "

% $ ' * *

/%&

. *

<% &+C = '% $'.+C *-(*'%*'5 .

+C3 6%( % $'. +CA -% % $'. +'$'. +C %:% $'."**%* .E% .6$.+C8=6% & % $'.+C!3 * '*'5 &'.'*

/%&

( &&" A"

*&7* &&

& "+"". % 7'% ' (( ' %

%% % $ %

* % $ %

/%&

$% *'

*&7 '%- '& %& '(($% * &% $''7*%

&'&- (*(4 %(% &% '%* *"* . /47* & '%"=*&''7*&%* -7 '% &'%*7%"

3 #$% % $' & 5(,% % $'. 7' 7* *& % =('

,-. (

(*'%*7%"3#$%% $'

'*% /(/&'%% '%* *(*(4"E'(% '&% :&'% '%*' * "!"

&' /(/&'%% '%* *(*(4"

% $'%*&

/%&

*&<% &C

'% $'.7'* &'%*&

/*% " 8"

'% $ $ *. ' %( . /%&, &$ &&

. /% &'

*&'

7'% '' '& - -:& & % * '& / &. '7* *

&$%$ *%%* 3%& 4* &4% *"

(:'*;% & (4 % . '

&$3 4"

?(% $$$%/&-4', &$ '%* /% &*

*&'*%(&'* (. % 7'% '7*$%/ '" 3 '/ '& ( &

*( ' (( D

*&.

( &

*(-*%&*$% $' $'' &" "

=+C36%(% $'. &+C = '% $'

((4 * & ' *

*4 7%' $& /4

- &'****%

*& '&.% &( **

/*% 7'% ''7* 4% $% '%* % -% $ 6"=8

" E'4 7 **<% & ( $'

-'('

*&- '4 (& -*'& 4%( % . ' '4 *

: '% $

*" (' $'.

&% $ ' *

*4.'

*&'&*% &(% *7%''%*7% '47% /(/&% (%%$% " 5(,%% $'7:% $% ?%(4 C( &3#$%% $' (

(*'%*7% &'4'/$'%% /(/&% '%* *(*(4- 3& % &'%*

* - /4 /%

$" % %( ' : ' % & % 1/ &(% % ' ,

% :3

-'% ( %(**:'( ( (% *'%7%*'* &% /(/

%% ( *(*(4"E'% /(/

(* *%*> %*% * &%'(($% *% '$&$ /&.'% &% %(% ($% $% *

'4 *4 (4(*'%,-*- 4'/$,%(/ "E'.'3 &'(% % %(*

&7%''% /*%$% '%* * 7 (& '/%*:&'% :*-4% /(/% $'

*&% '%* * (*(4, *'% *

3#$%% $''%*-'5(,% % $'" (' $'C '% $'.-''

*&'& * &'%*/*% '$&- '-% $(-''

*&'&(74** &*% '%*/ */'%

/% "E'.'%* *&7% ** &

'(%

-( & '%**% 4"

3 & * 4 * &%* & ' * * 7% *** /4"E'*

'**

** ((4/&'(% :

/%&

-4 &

$ * % % /%&

( &% $ <% $ +C! 3 * '*'5 .7'7**&*=+(% % 5 (% ' &4 /4 &-7''

*&( $7%' *4 &7% ***'&- &

& &7'/%4% $' *'&

'%*7 *('/% $%**% B5B ' (*" +C8=6% $'% '%*%&/%+C8D*&'

"!"

'7*3 '$(:' +5 (% & ' &4.3 * '*'5 '&&*%&7%''%' *4 ( $7%''% (* &

"!"

./%&6"

"A +.''&' &&/' *4< % 3 6%(% $'&

$'*% ' &

"!"

/%& 6"

A"A +. 3 6%( % $' '& &*%&7%''%' *4"='& '*%%&'

"!"

./%&6"

''&' &&/*( ( <% 7&7%$'% $ $. ' ( * (*/

**7%'*(*% ( $7%'*(*( '% & *-( *'%*' 5 &*%% $ ' * ' % % .?0.'(%.7'

&% $(4&%&* & ' && / %'%7'% ''&' &"= '*& ' "!"

. /%& 6"

' '& : (

% $% <% 7%$'% $ $& (4*(&. *( (

* (/ ** & (*% -< % $% <% 7& 7%$'% $ :$ $& (4*(&% &%% &*%% $' *7%'3

'$., &% %((:' ."37*

&% $(4& & %7*' &&/'%"=*%%&'*( $' * 4% &% '%*****% . % $7%''*7* & " +C *-(*'%*'5 .'*( %% '%*

%&/%9<"+(*&*&- *

*&4' (**( $ *'4% &% '%*****% "

E'% /*%$% '%* *'*- %& % % &%%(

"6/%(% 4 &4/%*% (7%* *'7 '/: ( "E'*

'&*

** ((4/& $ %('

( *%/(4 &%%/(4"

0 &

*( ' (( '* %*& /% *

*7'%(4% $% & (*7%''% $ &, &$ &"=%*%*$

& :7*'

*&'&

7%'

' % % > *% & ' /%&

& -4 ' *

'<% $+C %:% $'."**%* .

E% .'(%.% (4 *'%7*%$% ((47 &-4 ',%% $'* +%'%% $'.DC&6"8.5 (% &' % 7* *&% ' :'-%% $'* '% $'

D)%(($(.%*% 6$.'(%"E'

*& &* %$ *%$% (7 *.'.

-7

*& &' % > *% (&-*-(%*'&-4' *

" =7/.'%*$ &* '/ 47%$'$"*%* *-(%*'& &-4'*

-4-% $% $ $' $

$/%&

*&#$% $'7*&%/% $' % 7'% '' - &'&- /&"37*'% <(% *'7*

' - & -'% ' "='* %(&

'%* ****% ' - &. '.

&7% $* %

& * A & ' .%%*- : ''(( 7*% * % *****% ' - &"

*%(47*''%*' &*'*% $'''*

'% $&7%'' /&& $*.'' (%

- &7 %*''7*% * % *****% '"E'%( '* &(7%''%** % &%(% 6"

', &$ :% $

' 4%&/%<

&-4#$% $'

*& $&% $ '* /'% ( 7'% ' '& - : % (% ****% ./%& /4"E'37'%($% $'%** &&'&*%%&% '$&.% $'%&/%*:

B- '7* **<% & '% "(4- *'

*&&%& $'/'% ( *&% '%*7 .&* $ *'7'''* '% $&7%'' /4 - & ' % > *% .7'% ''7*&%/% $7' ' &&-4' (% "

$ 7&-4( &

*(' (( 7*7%'$& ,% $ 4% & & 7% **"

=7/.'%*$ %*7%' 4 "*'*- '(&-4 % $( # &$ '%* % *

!"# $$% &'

! ()*+,-.*/ .0/1+1.*% %*'% %(7% ***

4'*/%& %4/( *' 4'7% ** &'% * *

- &%* && *%(4

'% % %( &*%$ % "E'%( '*(*&(7%''%** % &%( % $' *(7 '% "

7% /%% * &&%*

%*% '* * *

7% ****% & -4( &

*(' (( & $''.*%

'& ((4 /& %* '$ $% * '

*& -4 & *'&7 * -(& -"*9<"+6. (4*%* (6"

.' $&% *7

&- &%' <4('4& '(%&' < "

F7*

&* &' (4*%* (6"

% $ (* * (* ( % *%(-(&*/

**'% $&% *<<4' '4& '(%&'< 8A"!$D * (.% (% '4& '(%&'< "8 $D * ( &+ ('< "8$D * (7

&* "E'*(&%' <4('4& '(%& * -

%(> %4 &7%'$& *%* * (*/

**<<4' '4& '(%&.% *

$"E' %( % 6" 8'*&(7%''%** % &%(.% &% $'

**4% $&% *

' /&"

E', &$ /% **&-4'%( %* > %&%(&.7((* &.-*& %*(/%&

& % % (7"E'%* %(($(%4% %%4 '% "E'*%* '(&*$&*' /% C%'$&*

.' - & /& '****%

* %(> %4"E'*

7&&'(( D

*&%*'% * %-& &'%*

* '&

"E'.'%**

%*(* '(&" E'(%*

&-7%' % &*%*'-4 &%*%**&"

E'(( D

*&%*&% &* &-'% # &% %($%*. $7%'% 7:&4.%(% $7'% '

( &#.7 (&%** 7 ***

'%**

* & '% ,%(

&$ ' % $ *

" 6 **4 %% - * '

& % %

!" "

./ C''*:% $D* & G* 6 C''-( G* 6