High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/4304/2013disposed of

Karnail Singh@ Kaili v. State Of Haryana

2015-12-02Mr. Justice Arun Palli5 pages

!"#$#%&'&() * +!,(!&-&(./0+!&-& 11#--!(" 2#,'3'

"!"#!,4!(! #'1($#("

) 5 6 6

,#'#(") , #7/(8$2%!"#8 ,"/#!11#--!("

'+&,"& !-!-8 8!,4!(!

68 ,!- 9 * * 6#!,(#$ "!"# %3('#- /!' 1-!%#$ ( ,#%,$ "/# %3'"$4 %#,"&&%!"#&(,#'1#%""/#!11-&%!(":!11#--!("8'/;&(."/!"3""/#3, 4#!,'#("#(%#&<1'#$31(/&<=4"/#-#!,(#$$$&"&(!-#''&(' 3$.#8

!"#/!=!$8,"/#%<<&''&(!(#(%#13(&'/!=-#3($#,#%"&(> "/# %"8;/#,#&(/#;!'3($"=#&(%('%&3'1''#''&( 7.'1&3<8/#/!'!-,#!$43($#,.(#!%"3!-'#("#(%#"/,##4#!,'8 &2#<("/'!($"#($!4'!'( */#'!<#&'"!7#((,#%,$ 6#!,(#$%3('#-,"/#!11-&%!(":!11#--!("'3=<&"'"/!"8!'! <!""#,!%"8$#"!&-'1#($&(.%!'#'.&2#(&("/#%3'"$4%#,"&&%!"#!,# !-'&(%,,#%"8&(!'<3%/!'8"/#!11#--!("/!'=##(!%?3&""#$&(!--"/#3, %!'#''/;("=#1#($&(.!.!&('"/&<8&(;/&%//#&''/;("=#(=!&-

#3,"/#,'3=<&"'"/!""/#!11#--!("&''3#,&(.,<;#!7 #4#'&./"!($&'@4#!,'!.# A&"/"/#%('#("-#!,(#$%3('#-,"/#1!,"&#'8"/#<!&( !11#!-&"'#-&'"!7#(31,/#!,&(.

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

&(!"&!8 &'",&%" !"#/!=!$8!" 3'"!($+!<!(! 1('##&(."/#1-&%#1!,"48"/#!11#--!("&''"!"#$"/!2# =#%<# 1#,1-#B#$ !($ ",&#$ " "3,( =!%7 /&' <",%4%-# =3" ;!' 11,#/#($#$!($('3'1&%&(8/#!($/&'<",%4%-#;#,#%/#%7#$!($&" ;!'3($"/!"!=-!%7%-3,#$1-4"/#(#=!.;!'7#1"=4/&<("/#3#- "!(7 "/# <",%4%-# =#";##( /&' -#.' 1( ?3#,48 "/# !11#--!(" $&'%-'#$/&'(!<#81!,#("!.#!($1-!%#,#'&$#(%#!($"/#,#!"#,8;!' '"!"#$"/!2#=#%<#1#,1-#B#$!.!&(;/#(!'7#$!

1-4"/#(#=!.%%,$&(.-48!("&%#B &''"!"#$"/!2#=##(.&2#(" /&<8&(,<&(./&<!=3"/&'-#.!-,&./"".#""/#'#!,%/"/#1-4"/#(# =!.%($3%"#$&("/#1,#'#(%#!(4!C#""#$&%#,,!!.&'",!"#8!($ /#.!2#!;,&""#(%('#("B

8'"!"&(."/!""/#'#!,%/<!4=#<!$#&( "/#1,#'#(%#!!C#""#$&%#,!< /!.!"&'"/#('"!"#$"/!2# &(,<#$/,& !.$&'/+3<!,8 #13"431#,&("#($#(" -&%#8;/%!<# ""/#'1"!"#,!=3"(#/3, /#!11#--!("8/&'<",%4%-#!($"/# 1-4"/#(#=!.;#,#1,$3%#$=#,#"/# !($(/&'$&,#%"&(8&";!'

%/#%7#$!($1&3<;!'3($%("!&(#$&(&" ; '!<1-#'

.,!<' #!%/ ;#,# '#1!,!"#$ ,< "/# ,#%2#,#$1&3<!($"/#,#'&$3#;!';#&./#$!($3($"=#7.!($ >

.,!<'/#'!<1-#'8!'!-',#'""/#1&3<8;#,#1!%7#$&('#!-#$ 1!,%#-'!($"/#'#!-"/#(2#'"&.!"&(.&%#,D 5;!'!&B#$("/#< !($"/#'#!-&"'#-&''"!"#$"/!2#=##(,#"!&(#$=4"/# /#<",%4%-#=#!,&(.,#.&'",!"&( *E 998!'!-' "/#'#!-#$1!,%#-';#,#"!7#(&("1''#''&(2&$#,#%2#,4<#<B

!($("/#1#,'(!-%/#%7&(."/#!11#--!("8'

: &(%!'/8!<=&-# 1/(#!($,#.&'",!"&(%#,"&&%!"#"/#<",%4%-#;#,#,#%2#,#$!($ "!7#(&("1''#''&(2&$#,#%2#,4<#<B * ,#1,"B ;!''#("""/#1-&%#'"!"&(!($!,<!-

;!',#.&'"#,#$=4: ##"&(./ ,3./'&"#1-!(B &'!-''"!"#$"/!2#=##(1,#1!,#$ "/#1-!%#!11,#/#('&(!($!,#1,"3($#,#%"&(**"/#!,%"&% ,3.'!($ '4%/",1&%3='"!(%#'%"8E>*/#,#&(!"#,"=#,##,,#$" !'5"/#%"58;!'1,#1!,#$8;/&%/;!'-!"#,#B/&=&"#$!'B @:/#

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

/-!&(./$3#",&2!-,4$#2#-1#$&("/#2&--!.##-#%"&('

!2&(.!11,!&'#$"/##("&,##2&$#(%#(,#%,$8"/#-#!,(#$ ",&!-3,"3($"/#!11#--!(".3&-"4=#&(.&(%('%&3'1''#''&( 7.'1&3<;&"/3"!(41#,<&",-&%#(%#!($%('#?3#("-48%(2&%"#$/&<

* ,!(#(%#13(&'/!=-#3($#,#%"&(>"/#%"!($'#("#(%#$/&<" 3($#,.3,4#!,',&.,3'&<1,&'(<#("8!'!-'$&,#%"#$/&<"1!4! &(#'

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

-,#!$43($#,.(#=4/&<"&'8"/#,#,#8,$#,#$!%%,$&(.-4/#&(# &<1'#$=4"/#",&!-3,"&'<!&("!&(#$!-(.;&"/"/#$#!3-"%-!3'#"/!" #' ;&"/ &" 11#--!(" +!,(!&- &(./ 0 +!&-& '/!--8 %('#?3#("-48 =# ,#-#!'#$,<%3'"$4&<<#$&!"#-4831($#1'&"&(#=4/&<8,!"#,/# /!''#,2#$3""/,##<("/'<,#'#("#(%#8&($#!3-""/#,# /#!11#!-&'$&'1'#$!%%,$&(.