Suresh Devi v. Baljeet Singh And Others
!"# $% &#'()($*
+
, -
. /-
! " # $
. /-
% & # !
'# ( ) # *%( + ,#"%-%."( ( # ( ( # # / ((012 ( !(!#!!!#
, ) # ( # "
##3 ()(#") ( !
#! #! %% 4 ( !
#!! ( ( # ##" #(#( " ,! ' " ( # #!
"
# #"# # # " ( ##
"#! !# #"
# # *% ( + , #" %-%." (!
#
(#( # # ( ! (! # (# ! 5 #) ###( # ( /2 # ( ##" (#! '"( ( #! # " ) (! "#!
#"# #(
#
)" ) # ) !"
"'#!(!
( # 55 & ! ## )
) (# ! ' !
+
#!
# "
( ( 3#( # & (#""
# # # "! ## # # # '!
( #
!
6 $ 7( # "# "## # "
(# !# # ( #" ( (
!#01 "1 # #
( & ,& (#(!)7
!
# ( # ! (!
#
6% & # (# ! '" ! #
(! "#!
#"# #"(!
( ( # " ( ( #!
" # " ## #' (!)7 ( # ( # !
( 3 ") #
!
!
" # $
! " #
$%&% ₹ ' %%%%() ₹ &%%%%%() *
* ₹ *
%%%%() +%&% * " * ₹ & %%%%() # , %$&%&
" - ). %&%/&%& - , *
*& -0* 1&%%$&%&
+- - /&/&&&%&
"
,
%
* 8 #( #( #
" (9%"
) () !"# " !
# !
"# " #(#(# :! "
) !) '#" #! #((!
4) ((") ) (#7 " # ( 9%; 7 ) #
(9%" ( "(
) (95
9*5% <.<=5<%5") 3 ( (96!
9%>5>55%%5<%5& ) (" ' " (#(# *%
(956" ) !" !
# ! ) (( (9%& # (95)( # ₹ (!(9%( %5"<?"<<<@ # (96" ( # ( ) # & ! %=<.5<%% ) ! ( # (# " ) !
! ? 8! #'!
( "#!
#" !
#
#( " ," '# ( # # ")
(!
# #( # (# (
# !") #
1
% A (( #(# ( #(!#( ##%=<.5<%%) ! B:++ 5 A (( #(# ((# 9*5%<.<=5<%59%>5> 55%%5<%5 " ! B:++ 6 A (( #( ( B:++ * A ! (!B:+
? ( 23"4#30 %$55$6(*7 !&&("($*!5 ())2# 6!) %3!8#& 9:
"4() $23"
;(&# $3 &!"#& + 6 A ( 95 6 ( # ( B:+
= )((!((#
##!
# ( #
# !8 #!
( # " (#!
(#( " ,
C /
2" , 7 " !# ( ( (() 0&" # & ' '(
#
)*+,- .
+
#
#
<
#
)
- !
!
)
- " + "
1 =%
!
"
# $ %& 3!, *
* * 0 & %'&%
)0
4
&'+% 0 - . 56
7
> $ 7(## !
# (!
"
"( ( # " ( ###) ( & ,"
%
% & # # "
!
" ! # #
#
>% & #!
D (# !"
#(
(! " #!
#" # (!
( #" ) # # ( ( # " (
)& 7
#"#"#'
(!)7 ( # # ( # # ( 3 ( !
"()
! /
+
0 1 "
" 2
. ) %-
₹ ₹ /4
56#
# '
56#
.
!
7 #
+
" "
'4'
/ 4
# $ '
!
!
"
%
=
. 8 #( #" (# # ) ! (9%") !
# !
"# " #( #(# " '# ( !" # ( ( E # ((" ( #7 " 7)
! ( # 4 ) ( ( 9%" "
( )( (955-<?5<%5") # (9655%%5<%5 .%
(956" ) !" !
# !& # !
( # ( ) #"
#3
( ( # ( # 3 ( # ) (! !
- & ((( # (( !
!( # ( #
(; 8 #( # ( "#!" !
(#" ,"
# # "(! () # ( # 3 # ( ;# !"
) # % A ((( ! 5><-5<%%" ( ((#B:++ 5 A (( ) ) (! (##5><-5<%%B:++
6 4( 956 ") (( ( ( ( # ( # (!# ( ! 5><-5<%%B:++ * A (( #(# # ( B:+
? A ! (!B:+
= ( 23"4#30 %$55$6(*7 !&&("($*!5 ())2# 6!) %3!8#& 9:
"4() $23"
;(&# $3 &!"#& + 6 A ( 95 6 ( # ( B:+
%< )((!((#
##!
# ( #
# !8 #!
( # " (#!
(#( " ,
C /
2" , 7 " !# ( ( (() 0&" # & ' '(
#
! /
)*+, - + 0 1 .
+
#
#
+ 3 8
'4'
/ 4
!
!
" + "
1 %<%
!
"
# $ %&
3 $
9 4 /
# # 69 #
#
37 "
/ '
29
"8 :;< 9 %
%% $ 7 ( # # # ! # # # " ( (0 ((1 0("1# ( & ,& # # "# " (!
#( # %%% & # (# ! '" ! #
(! "#!
#"# #" (!
( ( # " )& '
#"#!
"#' #(!)7( ## ( # # ( 3 (!
#
"
# ) =
4>
/ ' " 2
3 . -
+
₹ ₹ /4
5>#
5># .
+ # +
& "
"
'4'
/ 4
# $ ' "
!
!
(
"
" #
% %5 8 #( #" (# #
( ) !
+
%5%
( 9%" !
# !
"# "#(# " " '# ( !" ( !
! )## ( ) ) )E# ! )( (95
5-<?5<%5" ) " " #
(96
55%%5<%5E # ( # ## (#(# %55
( 95 6" ) !"
# (!
#7(#(# "
'
#( ! ) (( (9% & (96 )() "
( # ( ) #( 3 ( # (#& ( ! !5-<.5<%%) # ! !
##
!
%6 8 ! # '!
( " #" !
" ," '# ( # # "(! () # D # (# !
( ;# !" % A (( #(# ( #(!# (!5-<.5<%%B:++ 5 A (( (! # (B:++ 6 A (( # ( B:+
* A (( #(# ( B :+
? A ( !
( # B:+
= ( 23"4#30 %$55$6(*7 !&&("($*!5 ())2# 6!) %3!8#& 9:
"4() $23"
;(&# $3 &!"#& + 5 A ( 95 6 ( # ( :+ %* )((!((#
##!
# ( #
# !8 #!
( # " (#!
(#( " ,
C /
2" , 7 " !# ( ( (() 0&" # & (
#
/
)*+,- +
0 1.
+
" #
# +
#8
'4' / /
!
!
"
+
"
1 %*%
!
"
# $ %&
3 $ "
# 6 9 3
" # #
69 # #
7 4 /
"
/ '
29
" :;<
% %?
!!#
$ ," )" 7 # ( , %= 4 #( #( ##!
'
# !
#" ## ) "
#"
##( ( , )& # ! # # D '!
!
) ! !#(((! "! "
1
()) (#
, '# ( # #
%> F#( ! #
, ) ( ! ( ( # @( ( # ( # "
#3 ) #( #!
# ! 4 , ) !
# !
#
## #"
( ((# (9% !) (( %. 4)( (!@( 95 7)"###
"( ! " ## # (#(9% '#
)( ! !,3 "
) !
(!95"
# ( "()(# " ) # ( # # !" # ## ( # )" ##( #
( !
# (
# %- 8! #'!
( #" ! 3
# (( ( ( !
!!
( !(!
"(#' # !
( ) !& " #
# " (! ! (
<
" ) ((" "(!95 (
4 (# #7" , ) ## # #
(95 ))( !%=<.5<%%/G'+ %2") # # 5< & '# ( ! # ( !
(9% ##
! (+A%E "H 7"( ) " +A6 " #) " () !# # ; ! #& ((( '#
# ! ; # !
(( ! ( !! ((!
" !! )
" , )"
) # #
E;
!, *($* $% *&(!
;
>) 4!"2394!( !"#5
$ 0 =<1 <" (! # ( # "
) # (# # ( 5% ( # " # # E "H 7") )) !/G' +%2" ) ) 3 55%%5<%5"
'# ( ( @(" ) ) "
+" ( @(96"
& ( (! ) '"
/ A*2# !
# #
# ( ## !)! # 5%% & " /(952"(!) !
# ! # "#
( "
# !(# ) # # # ! !" ( & ") ! ) +( # !: "
( "! # !"# !
( !) ('# ! " ) A5 ! ! ₹ # ( %6"*5"?<<@) +; # ( "+"E "H 7 5%5 , # # ) (!
# ' (### (
) , ) ) (# (! 95# # ( ) #& ( # ")"((!
5%6 4
) ( ( " , ( 3 () (# ) !
(# *%( + ,#"%-%.""( ! " !
!
=
55 & !"'
G'+*" # ! (+A*E " 9!
) !$ # !(! ' ! ( $ G' /G'+A?2" ) ##
I%" I6" I* G'+* ( (9%" :# '# ( #! "
3 ( (9% !)# (" !
" ## # ! #"#
"#
#
#"! (( 56 E) " ( 9%" " ( ) ' ((9! #
# #! ## & # ( !G'+* E " (
# ()( !( #! '# " !
! ! ; /G'+A6@,2"##
# (( 7&
# # ( !
( !( "( !
(( 5* 9 "E ( #!!) ! 3 '# ( ( "
# #
((; (
5? # !(# " ( #
# # (#
#A A6 ! # ) #" "
+A?"# # # ) #
( & !) ! (# !& # # (# ! ( #
( (; (# # ( ((;# '# (!#( ! 5= & '# ( !/G'+=2( !
# ! (+A*E "
9!
) !") # # (( ! !) '#
! ) !('# E
#( ( # (! E) G'/+A>2") "# ( # '!
"##
((9%"
!" %" 6" *G'+=") '#
!:# '# # ( " (
(3 ( (J ) "# ! #"#"
#
#
#"
! ## 5> 4 #" (( ) ! !" )
# ( 9%" !" ( ) ' & #(
! ! E " # # ( !( # #!E !
! ! ; /G'+52"
) # ##
! !)#
( !("
(
) 7 5. " E " 9!
" ) !/G'+=2 3 ( ( " #!! 7 ) ) # E # ! (# ( 7)( ! ( # " "E
/+A*2 ( (!(95" " '
#( !" #'# ( "
(# ##
#( # 5- ( # " ! # # (#
# A6 ! # ) !") A?
( !(₹.<"<<"<<<)! ( & ") ! !# # # 7 ( (# # #
( ! 4 ( " ( #
,
) ")"((! ( !
") (# #
5-% 4 ( ( " " ( ( #" ! (# " ("
!
?
K 6< # # !/2 ( # ! " !
# # " ( " ( ## ")9( # #(
)( ( ( ! # 6% # ( ! '# ( ## # ( # # ( #" (#
(#" #! # ) ( # #
. /-
!23!;
$3$"
Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No ' ( )*