High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR(F)/535/2022dismissed

Renu Devi v. Shyam Lal @ Shyam Sunder

2024-12-16Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

"#$#%&

'()' ) * +,$

& -. ) / / .

!"#$% "! #'

& #'

((((( / .

) )

#"#!** #'" !*%

# !,, )) ,-,)'!./#

!* '!* 0 $1!+ 0$ !$ "!.! 2 34,3,-)5

$!* ## + $& *'

667 & ,-)5 .& # 1!+ */ 2 0 0 "

),8 2 # #0.! 9# '

:$ ;

!" !% #'

#!#+! . #'

! ! *+ < -8 -6 ,-)) #"# * .

0 &# * ";

&#+ "# *$ $ $ +!'! # '

.& #

1!+ 0 #'*!

&#'! "* #!## "# * !&+!*$# %$!'0!* &#"

"*! &/# !0 &## "# * *!

#+!

!"' " , #'

.& #1!+ 0$#'

!** #!!#0 !+ & =*!" !'./#'! #+! #'

& + #!&#+! $#

!0.>" "0*/$+!*!+$!! "

./ #'

!# &!+ */++. &0#!** #! -8 -, ,-)5$ # '

$ !* # # + $ ! # 0 &#+! !*# +$! "#$#'

!* ##+ #!%.* % '!!*/ #'

!#!#'

!#+ !* % ! !""

++ !

% **!

!* ! !!$!#'

%!.* ++ %!.*' '/ !/ # 0" & +

#*& 10#$ !** #!#'

!!.*7 .

' # ))!" && *!

"0*0!**!! ! =*!"'!0+ !* % *% #.0 .0/ !** .0&&!* !0 !+ *;!

/$& + # "## ! 6-$---'+ # #'

!#!#!#

?0 ,8$---'+ #!+!

!"& # 0!" =

& *!'*/ #"*!

+.& # 1!+ 0$ # #!+ #&!" &#+! !# .

# &"# * %$# #!** !

&"0*/!

/+!+!./#'

!#! #'

*&#+! !*# + # $ # 0!/>0 "!0$ ! '

&& +! ./ # +$ "*0 "

% !

'!"#!/! . #.!";$# !#! #&!* +'* "!

"! # '*/$#'

!* !** #!#'

!0 !.!0/'!* 0!! )-$---'+ # # ))!" &!

"0*0!**!!!*

. % *% #.0 &!

.0&&!* 0 !+ *;!

/ %$ !& & * # '*/ # +!

$#'

!''! #' " ! ! ' "!

@7'! #'

!0"% " *

##'*!

#"*!

$@!+ #*&! A7)$ !0.?0*/"* #% " '!& +#!&& !% @!+ !

7 72# &$ # "0+!/% " !!0"

.#!*&

# # &#% "*./#'

$ # "# 0.00 #'

. ' "!

@7'!!# !."0 " 7@!+ !

$#1!+ 0 #*#!#'

'!!*/& +#'

0 #!" &"0*/"

++ !

#./#'

!&0##*#!#'

!0!.* +!

#*&

#& $ % &# !'"#!% ."

&!% 0

$# !#* * ;+!

!" & +#'

#!'" &#?0!0+ &+!

!" . ! !

$#1!+ 0#*#!#'

#!&!

* !0"!/% " 0''

#!** !

#!# ! 6-$--- ' + # # 1!+ */ 2 0 &0# #!#'

#! ' % !/% "

' % # '

C # ' & !

"0*0!* *! #

% *%+ #.0&&!* !

/.0 #& $ !0+ #'

C + .?0 %!* #+ +0+ ! !0;

***!.

$#1!+ 0! !! !+ & =$---'+ #

! )$8--' # !"# &# "# *9'

,!=:! +!

#1!+ 0

; &#!+ &!". #'! #!#+ "# *$'

,!=.& # 1!+ 0$ ##'

*/0 *1.0!/,-,) !$#!&$& +!"#,-,)$

##'

% &# $#1!+ 0#*#!#'

! * "

%+!

!"& #+ "# * */0' 1.0!/ ,-,) %$ # '

! #* * " % +!

!"!#! & =$---37'+ #& +#'

0 *#+!

!**/$ 8$8--37 ! ! #

%./#!+ &+!

!" !./# 1!+ 0

$ # "##"

!?0!$#

#!& *#''

;

#!"+ &# !

+'!

* ##'

$!"

'/ &#!+!.!

#/!,-)B7)D$ **!

#0+'!E!*!$ # *

! $ " F# ! $ !* & *!@0 7)$ 0.! !#"*!

+ #'

C # ' &!

"0*0!**!

.#!*&

$ ! 0#!#!+ 0 ! !

!+!

!"$. !'!*/0+$ 0&& "

& #0!" # !.* +!

#*& #+!

0+ & =---'+ # %$ "0+ % "#!.& * #'%

' %# !** ""0'!

&#'

! 0 #.0&&!*

/.0 #!+!.! 9@0 7):& * # #'

! "0+ % "$.& # 0.* !#0$#% !/%!*0 &#!++!

0' % %$ !%!"#"!0 &>0 "$# 0

; "

# !

!+!.! ! ! '0.* "

"0+ #!+ &#'

!!"

7#! #*!+!0 5B;!!*!5+!*! %$ 0 &# !* *!+

#!+!.! $5B;!!*!6+!*!!# !G!

!>0!

..!$!#6+!*!!# !G!

0+;

#!*!%

&#!

!+!.! & * # #'%

$#/' &*! +

!HG!

!;.

>!I$ # "# !''!*/! !*!

&HG!

!>0!I 0"#$ % & # !0 & # *! +

# !+!.! $ "! .#*#!#*! ./#'

"0* %!.*$ ! !""

*/$ # '

"! . !

. ! !/!+ 0./"0* %! #!

*! )- ! # ! 0+ !

" #

!?0!"/ &#!+ &+!

!" !

$ % " ! # + & # '

#! . !0" "

#& $ +/"

$#1!+ */ 0"

"*/ !#+!

!"./%!*0! # + #'

?0 %!* #+ +0+ !

&!0;

** *!.

#+!

!"! ! .

0 ."

++0! # # +!* !.

* &#'

!!+ "! #'! #! &#+ "# *$ # !**/+!

0 "

),82 2 ./#'

$#!% "# & #"0 / &#'

#'"/ &#' " .& #1!+ 0 F #!$## "# * &#'! $ $#+ &+!*"# *$ !*

'0+ . #"0 / &#'

$!##! . +!!'!/ #

0 "

),82 2 .& #1!+ 0 #'%

#& $ % &#&!"$#'

$. ! # * % $ 0''

% + #"!! **7. &#+ "# *!# #'

* * & #& $ %

# &!" ! "

"0+!" & # ' "!$ # !+ 0 +!

!"!*!/ !

./#1!+ 0 "! .#* . !?0!

%#!0!! &# )) % &+/!.

%& $# ** !* / '% / # +'0 '!./#1!+ 0$ !

!! !/ &" ./ # 2 0 ""

*/$ # ' " !*%

+ & . %

&+ ),

!''* "!

9:$ &!/$#!**!* ! '

&!""

/ .

"+.)B$,-,6 A##'!;

3! 3

A##'

!.* 3