← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8596/2023allowed

Gautam Kumar v. UOI Through Ncb

2023-08-01Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl16 pages

      

!"#$%"&'('#)

* *



  

         



  

  

  ! ""

  #$  

! 

  "     %&    '

(   

   "

 )*+     

   ,  

 - .  /0   01 1+ 010'

    "

 2 '2 0+ /1 /0   3 

4 

 ",  # '+25 6    73 " #89 

"

    ( 

      

     #:

 "

   %         

            

   &    "

   "

 2 '2 0+ ; /0 3 " #

 <

"

   3 " # '+25

  #

 

    

 = 

 '+ 1+ 010'

   12 11 ! ,4 ":

$    %  = =   =     = 

    

"

 &

 = $ $  > 

    =  , ,      

  $   

&0*&(&'1)' 

>  ,   =      "

  =>  =&    , =

 1+ 11    '1 11  

 01 1+ 010' # 4    =         "

   =

,$

 "

 = = $   ,



=    ,4      =      "

 = 4    

  =   =

   0 /05 > 6    ? 4    

    0 5 >9 %         "

 

     

   

 =           02 

  ,

    



 

    "

 /@ 3 " #      , #:

 "

   %  0' 1+ 010'

   

 = 4   ,>    , = 7(A%%8 =       )5 111.& =   = 4 

,   #:

 "

   %  (  

  

=  *      

  ,    

 =      

   4  4     ,

          ,    

    =      

&0*&(&'1)'

=      =  4 ,

 

 ,4  &  

        02   6 0/

>9

        0' 1+ 010' , #:

 "

   %    

  

     )5 111.&   $    %        

 

        )5 111.& =   4   ,    

 ,

    4 ,        ,4 

&    =      =   ,

   4   

 ,

    ,   

   

   $

    

 %         

 

   :    ,4  D,  

   7

   !!"  # $ %&' 

   ()(**  + #

$ *

   ,4 

       '@ 1/ 0101  ,,*()-*,()()    ."/ 

   !!"  0& 12'   

     '/ 1@ 010'   , ,*(334,()()     .5$1 ! 

   !!"  +6 '       =

   

    4

,        &    4  4   ,

       

  

.    ,     ,       

  ,

  4  0' 1+ 010'    / = 

) =     

E        > 4  >

        

  $ $  4  

3 " #  

 ,   

 =    = =   

 '5 '' 0100  



     ,         

  

   ,   

      4 

 

 =  ,





  #  0'

 

   B      

+

  

   $

  D,

=

4 ,  4

 ,   ,



  

      F,

      7447,()*3

,5,*38,5 ,()*4

   9 &:"

%"+

  +;!

; !+$ &+"&9  )           &

 

  

 

     ,    ,     4 =   ,

       "



&  0 /05 >

 =  =   = ,    ? 4       ? 4    

    0 5 >   ,       "

   = 4  ,

    

       

  =  

 

           4   

      "

 /@ 3 " # =

  

   

 0' 1+ 010'

    , #:

 "

   %    

  ,   =  )5 111.& =  



   4     ,    

$ $  

 

/2.'@   '' '' 01'@   "

 *)'

*)0

*0* *0) *05 *1@ *5) ))2 *)       "   6<>9 2).'2   15 '0 01'2   "

 *)'

*)0 *0*

*0) *@+ *)       "   6<>9  

0/.01   15 15 0101   "

 ')* *)'

))2 *0* 51) 51/ *)      "   6<>9  

 

  $

   ,  %   $

=

   

     

  ,  ,       0/.01   2).'2  

   4 ,

          ,

     G    

 

     

  

  :  C D, .&$  % # +  % <  !!"  0  %  !"+' 

  ()*( (  78(        

  

 =   ,   

   ,  

   , :

  4    

$ $    ( $ 

:    

, = & 7  

   

        

   

        

 

 

 

   

 

 

 



    

            

  



 / (              

  

   ,

> @ (

 =      

 

 =      =      =  =

 

 ,4  &     "

  ,$

 "

  $ 

  

&0*&(&'1)' =



=  ,4    "

  ,$

 "

 = =   

 (

  ,

   

,      ,4    "

 

    = 

=  

 

     "

      

4  4

    ,

        4

  

         "

  =    =     =  4 ( D,  

69 

, $   &  !" #     

 

             

 $"  

 !%  

       

 &'() 

        



 "! 

 *    

       

 

 

      

 $ "+,%-  "



 

+ # 

      "/ 

69

    =  & 7  #  

  

  .

 

         

   /0 & %%   "$ "+ 1  )

 " &'()  (  )

2

 '



3  " 0      4 (  )   (() '

)  (  )5'

  ) .  '

 3  ,0-    

  5)    



.  % #  

   5  

6

 ) 

 

    7 8 9  : ' 

  



         





   

  

   ;

  





$ 2  

 

  

    

      

  

     

 





! < 

 

  )    

.   

    

 



  

  

     

 

 

 /0 &$%   "$"+ =  )

 ! "  "" &'()  (  )

 )  2

> /0 &!   ! "+"+  )

 %+7 ?= %%" %!% ""$ ""! $"7 $? $1 ( ( 

)

)  2

@ /0 & 1%  1%  "" "+ 1  )

 ! "  "! "1 &'()   (  )

8  = 

        

 7 

  

 

     

  

     

      

    



     

     

 



 

        

 



  

 

  



              





  

 



 

?   

       

  

  



 

       

       

 

   



 



 

        

 

     

 



  

A



 < 



 

   





  

  

   



A



 <        



     )

$%?

,"- (

1 

 

 

 

   





   





  A

  



'1 #  

      5$1 ! 

69:    

, = & 7(

 .   

     )

$%? (     /0 & ??   +?+$"+"+    )

 ! ? "7 "1  &'()    )

 $+ ?? " = $ 1 $"+ $=7 $=? $7  $7$ (   )

 =  <   )  (  )

 (  '



8. 

(

      

        5 

 "$? .   . 8 !++     8 .

 .



 

/0    

    



 

  

 



;

 

&

  

   "7+!"+"+ 

   



 

 



 







<  "7+!"+"+



  B5

7<    .   5 1

 

  

. 



   

 

     )

 $%? (    

  

 

  /0 & ??  ?$"+"+ 

   )

 ! ?"75"1  &'()  1?!

(  )

(  '



8. 

2  

 

      

 

       

   

         5 

   "$? .   . . !++      11 . .

 .

   

  

  

   

   

 

 

 

 

  

 

 

  

 

 



 

      



 . 

   

 /0  ;

 

 



   

      

    

&

 

 +7"+"+ <

 .

 

   4 ) 4   'C

   

 4

 

     





  





  A



 <  <

        





  

A 



   #  

   





  

        



   )

$%?,"- (

(4)-()()    5= #  

           

) 

#    

 )

 

  



  



        

               

 

2 )          

 

 

 

 5      .  

   

   5  #     



  )    



   

     

 D





(

   





   )  .  





  

     

 

   



    

        5  6   0 

 

  

 < !!"  # $ %& + #

$ ::"$ *-(  ()*7



  

  

  

   )

 !%  &'()  

    

    )

 "! 

 *          

      

 )

 "! 

 *    )   )

 =7  &'()          

   &'() 

     



           "7+!"+"+

  







<   





  .  





  

 ;     

 



 <       

 

     )

$%?,"- (

(

  

''

#  ,  :  :

 C F,  

>  69 =   =  =      

          "

 )0  "

 5* #

  ,   $  

   3 " # =  4   =  , 

   

 

  #   ') 016*9  0'

 

  #    02

  =   =   = 

 =         %  0' 1+ 010'   

 )5 111.&  #:

 "

   %  =



   4   

  

 =     4 =   4  

4   4   ,  ,     $  

 (    

   =   4  

      =  ,      =  =  ,

  ,4     ,  ,4  

   

     4

  ,

  4 0' 1+ 010'    / =  ) =     

E       > 4  >  

  $ $ 4    3 "# '0 ( F,   

 4      = $ $      ? 4    ,  ,  ,4 >   



  4



   4 ,  :  C F,

   1) 15 010*   :";

$ "<" ! ::"$ +$  7((*?()(7      7  &11#  % !"+   "

!!"@" ! "

$'

=  ,

 , $   & DDD DDD DDD DDD #

 





 

   

    



%

E     

 

   

 $

# 



  >   

   



    

   #     



 .  

  

  

 



 

 

   

         #  

  

       #  

 

   )

%7

&'()  !

     

 D     

  

      

 

   

  

   



#   =



 

 

 

 

  

   

  

 &'()   

   



   

      

    

  ;   7

#  

  

     

 #     

 

        .     ?

# )  2 (

 



 1

         

      

#   =   =  ,  

 4   = ' 4   )    = >   

  $  

  ,

     =    

   =  >

F,  =   

  ,  



'* ( D,      9##% $# 

  A   " !!"  =&1+!' $

  00 12 0100   :";

$ "<" ! ::"$ +$ --7),()(( =  , $   & FE     

 

     



  

        





. 



;  

 D     

   

  .

   

     

 



   

   

 

         

 



   

 



)  3A  #  

#     

      

 



(   

,-

      F

( , &   =    3 " #  -  ,

      "

 269 0'69  0+ # (



 =   4   

 6

9 =      ? 4 ( D,

  , $   

 ,  = ,

   

 6

9 4        ,  =   4  

  = >  

') D,  + #

$ ::"$ (B-?()()    9 !!

/ $  &2   " !!"  @" !

"

$9

  1@ 10 0101 =     

 ,  

6

9    =  4 =  ' 4   @     4 ( $ 

   1@ 10 0101    & F2  

#

    

   <   %+7"+ +  





04 &=7?7 "+ 1

#  

      

  

  )

 $%1 ( .

   

   & $=  "+ ?  

#  (  )

      )

 " 5 

 &

 '  (    )   1?!

 

 



 

      

    $= 

                 ;

#  

    " +7"+ ?  

       

  +

    D  

   

 

    D 



 D     

      

       

        

           E

 

   

 B

,- )

 

   

   0" .

  . 



 



 

 3 )    &'()  &

8 



   

,- #  )     

 

 

   

   



 



    E

    



    F '5    

+ #

$ ::"$ **C3  ()((    

9=:$ +

 0!+ D =:$+& #   

  % 9 $

  15 12 0100 D,  =   

, $  & F2  

#

   

      "!+ "+""

 

 < 4  (  (   ) 3

 40 & 7A"+"" #  

     ?+="+"+ 

     &6   &+"A"+"+  

     )

 ? "+ "75 "? 

"1 

&

 '  (    )   1?!

#   

 .

         





  

E   4  . 8 (  )  

 

   4 ) 3   

 )   C 



  

         

 

    

    

     

E

 

,- #      

 #  

   

 

,- #  #    

     





 

#  

  



,- # 

 

 

 ,-  

   

  

  

< # 





F #  , &  =   =  

 4 =    4 0 4  '    '@ 4   =  3 " #    4   

 4  4

 ,  =   

6

9 '/ ( D,    :";

$ "<" ! ::"$ +$ -4C3?()((     9 !

 % A+6 D :   "

+

!!"  @" !

"

$9

   1' 12 0100 =   

, $

  & F 

      "1+7"+""  

   

 

)  2 (

 

 )    

 )   E 6    

   

 )          

  #  

 .     /0 & = "  "+"+   7 +"+"+    )

 " ,-  %7 

 &'()   

(  )

6 E

6

' 

  

    



          +   +7 

   +1+="+"" #           

   D  # 

  

    

#.

   

       



  

 

     

 D   

   

       





#  

            



 





#  

# )  2 (







(   

,-

     F

#   =    =    

=  3 " #  

  "

 *@ 3 " # = 

  

 ,  =   4 ,4    

 6

9     4  

 1'4 1@  4 =  ,

 E '@  ( F,

     &:"

%"+> 

69      

   , >

  =    #  0'

 

 

,

  4   $  

   ,

     "

*@  3 "# '2  # 

      $

   0) 1) 010*

  ,,*3C(C,()((     7: 

   !!"  0& 12'

   

   ,   

$ $   4    ? 4 4 > =  4 =   

 '

 /    0/ 4      

   ,

  $



   

4      #  0'    

    '+ 

  $

=  , &        =    =    = , &  : 

 =   

       ,      , . 4 ,    

    .34 !   ,:

     ,

  ?  4 (

 , ,4   =  

 & 9  (

 =      =  

     ,9  (

 =      .





=  69  9  (

 =    ,   

          9  (

          



 =  

 

    

 = 

9  (

     4  4 > 4

     4   ?  =                4

    =  

 

 ,   4 , 





  ,   4    

    

 ,     0'

    ,  ,       E

     =  



 4

, $

 

  =  

4  

:    , 

-./012  343(!

5

'  8 G  > . . G 

,

.