Gurpreet Singh & ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS.
#$%$&$#$'' GURPREET SINGH AND OTHERS
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS "
#$ (&)# !$) VED PARKASH DHINGRA AND OTHERS
STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS * +,* -. - " /////
!" #$$
! % &'()*+,+ -
! % &'.*//( "
0
1 2 $ " !" 0
3 ! % + . * &'.*//(
0 4 !% $ 0 4 ! % 5 ) + &'()*+,+
-266666 . - "1 2 345 Raising an issue as to whether the seniority was drawn in terms of Rule 11, 12 and 13 of the Punjab Public Works Department (Irrigation Branch), Ziladars' State Service Class-III, Rules, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as "Rules, 1955) from the date of the confirmation of the members in service as per Rule 13 or from the date of joining or the length of service, as opined by the Legal Remembrancer, Punjab, these writ petitions have been filed. 2.
While the petitioners in CWP-15374 of 2014 claim that the seniority list prepared by the respondents has not been drawn in accordance with the said service Rules and therefore have challenged the tentative seniority list as circulated on 01.04.2013 on the basis of length of service. The petitioners in &'.*//( "
!$ 4 1 $ % ! ! 1 "
% $ % $
! % % % 7 $
8$ %
$
1 $ 1 % 4 ) ! !
4 "
1 %
% /((
!
-3- "#
$%
!
&
!
' ()
) *
!
+ "
+ "
( %
$
+ "
!
+ "
' "#
)
-4- #
# ' )
#
+ "
$ ) ) ,
&
' "#
- + "
#
&
,
#
!
#
-
,
.
-5- ()
/ ,
+ :
&
% &'()*+,+ &'.*//( !
!
% % %//(! 4 " ! 4 $ 1 % %" 4 1 !
% $ ! $ % 1 ;)< ( "
, "
!
= 1 > 7 $
8$ 1% !
% $% $ 4 1 "
);< "
!
% !
% $ $ % 4 % $$1 % ! 9
!
"
!
" % $ 1 "
!
$ % 4 $ 1 !!
!" ) "
!
%!
% $
% "
!
%7 $
8$ $ 4 > 1 "
% 4 1 $ ?
4 %
% 4%14 &'.*//( "
2 !%! "
!
-60
, 1 2 *
3 , +
$***' $455 6$ '
, ' 455
#
' ) (
' "#
$$ ) (
$ "#
0,@ " ,
&
-
' "#
+ "
! #
&
,
#
!
#
0(
-7-
,
*
' ) (
' "#
$ & &
,
' "#
7$$7 '
-$ 8
$
$ ' "#
: ;)<) (94) =4) >5 ) * 1 )5><< 594( ?4( >? ( ! 55;> (94> =4> >) '
=
)(=<( )?=;5 5;5 ?; 5 + 1 )5=<; )(=;= 5;= ?= ? 3 4?;) )5>;5 ;5 <=
-8- < @ A 55;> )>>;( ;( ?( ; 45<; )?=;5 5;5 < *
' "#
(94)594( (94> 2
( <
' "#$
=9;5 =9;= >9;5 >9;( =9;5
, 8 ?; ?= <= ?( ;
>5>? >)*
1
+
)
, 4;( 4;;
)
(
C
D +
, 4)<) )5><< 59;>
&
' "#
& (94)594( (94>
AB
' "#
& 6
-9- . %
1 &
!
% 4 14 !
! 4 1 "
! % "
"
!
$ 14
* :
&
% 5 + . * &'.*//( %
% !%! 2
4%14 $ " & " %1% 1 A & 51 13 A 2 "
!
" !
B/// )*/B/ ! 4 ?
!
" % 0
$ "
14 !
% $ " $% $ % % $ 8$ 9 1 ! % " !
% $ = % % 7 8$ ! " ?
1 & &
!
4 % 4; ! %
"$ " $ <#
1$ " % & &
!
4 1 "
% $ % % $ 8$ C!
% $ B :
&
% &'.*//( !
0
$ 2 !
1> $ % ,(.,+?
8 ! % !
05 2 1
DC+ +2
8 5=)< 5=);
4;= E
-10- ' E'
9
1 E '
>4445 ! ' ) )
(
,
!
' )F' ( / ' )
-'" 2 )
'
#
1 "
*
' ()
' ( ) ' ' )
'"
#
*
'"
9
-11- ? 2
,
7 )>>(9)>>
C
DC+ );)44<
+2
8 5=)< 5=);
)4;=
E ' 1>4445 :
(>44?
+ 2
8 )>;
)>>?
, 7 )>>(
7 )>>(
+2
8 )<>44
)>(
'" * 4;(
C
D 1 C C + 1 );)44<
+28 5=)< 5=);
4;= 1 &
1
,
C
G 1 C C + +2
8 )>;
)>>? <4=>
)>>;
# $< +2
)<>44
)>(
+ "
9+
-12-
!
* #
@ !
C
DC + >))>(
4))>(
16 / ?
4 1$ 4%14 &'()*+,+ " !
"
1 1$14 $ 4% &'.*//( &
% "
1$ " " % $ 14 &
&'(+,* %/B+ 14 : $$1 !
1 4 2 ! $ 4% $ % $
! % % 7 $
8$ 1 &
% !
! ,B,//* &'(+,* %/B+ $! $ "
1 ! % 4
, ) 1 2 !
"
?
"
" ! 4 1 "4 %$ 4 4 4 % 4?
! 4
1 8$ 14 &
$!
4 "
41 ! ! ?
%:
-13- $$1 ! 1 14 1 $ % 4
, &
% " !
) 9
&
1 % %
!
!
$ 1 !
+ ?
4
1! $ % % $
% $ $ ! = > 1 1 % %" 4
% 1 > 7 $
8$ 1% !
% $ %
4 1 $ 14 %!
% $ ! ?
> ! % !
1 $ % $ % 4 "
!
$ %
7 $
8$ > 1% !
% $ ! 1 % !
% $ 1 $ 1 % $ % 4?
,B,//* &'(+,* %/B+ 1 14 %,(.,+ 1> 14 :$$1 ! $ 41 % ! %,B,//* 1 !14 % ! ?
4
1 $ % $ %!
% $ ! );< % %/((
-14- ( 9% % ! ! 4 4 "
$ $
"
!
4 1 $ % % ! ,B,//* &'(+,* %/B+ !
!
,B,//* > % 4 % " 4"
!
1
14 ) ! 2 !
! $ 4 "
41 ! . '
2!
8! 2 !
!%!
!1 1
14
"
!
" 1! $ % 14 &
*
% !
14 41!
!
$ $ "
!
! !
$
8
" 4 &'()*+,+"! % !
% 4 +,)?
! = D 4 //. " %
4!
+,) "$$4 1$"
!
"
! ?
!!
4 !
&
+2$ )<>44$)>(0@ !
1
6"
!
" %14 &
,,) "
! " ! " %
$ ?
%
!
,(.,+ 1 ?
"
" %
$$4 % 4
-15- ,( !
1 "
> % 1 $ 4 % 1! &'.*//( !
" !$ % E % 4
1 % % $ " % ! % E 4 .,//(?
4 $ 1 % E14 !$ % &'()*+,+ !
!
4
4 ! %$ !
&
18.
Under the given circumstances, I find that the order dated 25.06.2014 passed by the respondents and under challenge in &'()*+ ,+ 1 !
! % !
?
% ! 4 " $1 4 11 $
"
!
4 1%8 # ! "
"
#$ (&)# !$) 446 ,(.,+ "
"
#$%$&$#$'' 2 ! % E 4 1 % % $ 7 8 / ! ! $ % ! ! ! $ 8 ! % $ % 4 % )% $ % !
% $
!
> % 7 $
8$
1
$1 1 % $ %: % 1 14 7 $ " %%
$ % ! %! %! 4 %
-16- , $! ! ;< % % 2. - "5
1 @ '
2 C
FC5 '
1 FC5