High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/3330/2017allowed

Harbans Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-11-29Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu24 pages

!"#$ %& '() ) !" *$

" # # $ "

% &' ( )"*

, & !" )"* # # $

- ()#() !

++ ..

/ 0 " + * *"

" ) 1 "" " -

". 20 "+" !

". " " "$

""-"" 3 ") + $ 40- 0+ "0

" + "+ 5 "0+ 6 '" "7 8' 89 2 "0 + *+" "+"

. . " - :)5 "

-. ) "

. . " - + " + ' 0

*+" "+" + "+ ' "

. . " 6 - " -

)5 ""

-. ) "

. . " ;.

0 *+" + "+ ' "0+ 6' +" "

. . "

- - )5 ""

-. )

. . " ;.

6 2+ +

. !

) < 0 ")='0 " ++ " + =') 7 "90 .

" 0 * .

" 0 " "> $4 4)) " " "0 0 +

- " 0 " + .

;+ "+ "

?5?. " "

"". 2- "/

0 +

"0 - "+ "2 ) "

"+" 0 " " " "

" 0 0"

. "0 " "2 ".

*" "-

.00 + 0 "2 "0

" : 4 "

0 " " 2 "- " 0 ; ." 2 .

. 0 +"2* 0 + ." "+ 0

+ . + .

: 2 + ;

." . 0 .

"0 + "" "+ ++ " .

-0 -.+ " 4 @ "+

* *.- " + " *+

@ "+

+ + $ < * " "+

" *

". "+ "*-+ - ? < !

"" + + ++ " ) " "0""2 . 00 " .0 !

* & " * - 4 """ 1 00 00 "+ " "+ ;

."- "" + + "." . A; + "" "+ 46 "" ..

" +.

+" " "+ "+1

- "

< " " 0 . " ( .

( .

"* "0 + + " " " 0" +

" " "-

+*+ " " " "-0 + + "

- " + " " "- 0 ; ." ' + ;

. " " * " + " "

+ + . " " "-

<#!

- " 4 40 " &"+ >+)*

) .2

" "

." " " "-

" " .

= +&"+)( *.&"+ ) .

;

. " " 0 " B 2"

2#&) ." ". # - & +" #!

- 0 0. ++ " " + *"" " "- 0 "+ "- ."+ . 0 + "'+ ;

. " " " " .

" -"+ . + 0 0 + *- -

<:#B 1& " " -+ +" .;

. " " "- "2" " "- ""- 2+

" 0 "!

-0+ .

. '0 +

" " -

2 . "0" " .;

. 0

C .

. A; 4

6 <4 !" " 0 + * "" 1 0 " " *+ . . *+ " - 0 "+ " "+ ;

: < # " " " " -"+ . . 0 "+ " + ;

."- " + +

4 <?'+ !

- " 0 " >) + ! 0' .!'+ & " + + +" #= 1 + " + + 0++1 +.* + . !

. + - "+ "" .A; 2 0 *" " 2 "0 " # " " "

" "+ .A; "A;

+ + .

0 +

2+ + < !

" . 0+ =' 0 " ++ " ) " " " "0

" "" " " "-0 + " < !

"+ +

0 "+ " "." A; ""+ 2 .+ "" "+ 46 *+ *"+. - <4 ! "

+ + ++ " .) " " .

" - "+ . . 0 "+ " <

" " " .

" -+ .

0 "+ " 2 " " "- 0 + *" "+ . "+ "

$ 2.

-0) < "+

+ ++ " + ) ".

" ; !

"+ + ' 0 1+ *"+2; !

"+ .

-2+

" "!

-0+0 .

. .

;

. A; 4

? @ " +

*.- " < "." A; "

+ .

" . .0"

& * " . "+ *+ *"+ 2@ "

D .

! "# $%&'(%' *" .+ ""

"+ 46 *+ *"+ .

" ;+ + "+02 @ " *" "% 2"" 3 " *"!

". 0+ 0 0% "

+ ;

. .

" + "

.0+0

" 0"

. .0 .

" . " .02 " " ""+ ". . 0 0 0 * , -

* + " " + "0 ;. -0 2+" + . " 46. +"

" >+ ) ?:

) "

0 . -. &'

"0 "7'" 9 . -)0 0 "

" "-"."-

" +

.8 "+ 0 2 " "F '+ "3 "" . . 0 + "" " 46 . +"

"2 . " 46"

++ - 0 * "+ . .+ "" " 46 " **"+ "+ .

;+ + "+0

". - 0 . 0 + "" " 46 " " 0 "0 0

" .

1 .

"..

+ - +

" " **"++ 2"" " " 0 .

0 " 46 . + + "0 *' .;+ "" " .

0 "0 * ;

. +0

2@ "

D .

# ") ! *$%&+$,-' *; "*" -*

. "+ 46 "% 2 * 0"" .-" "

'( 1 '@7 ?::9" 4 4$G7' ?::" 4 469 "

)3)" 0

* B

" * A. ' ?6B 6F E< . 0 *

- + "" " +

46) . +"

") " + 0 .0 +

-+ 0 +1 . .

" - .

) . + . 0 *

- + "" " + 46 0 + "+ "2

) 0*)

+* 0 +

" ++ . + + "0+"

*"+ +0)+ +" F

< 0

)3) * "3 " B

0 +-H 2@ "

D .

#.!

) ! "#./"$%-,(&+ *" . "+

46 **"+'+ " - . 0 "+.2@ " *"

"% E$ . "+ 46 " . +"

* *"+ ' + "

. 0 ' + "

"+ 0 2 .

0 ""- 3 "-+ + "

I "+ 46 "

. +"

" * +" " - + + 3 "

!+ *"+ B

)

I ) " 0 -

+"+ ?'

" " +/ '"

)

*0 *"+ 0+ " +/

""2

"*0 " +"- 02

1*0 . ++ *

" " " "

= -

* +/ 0 !

"2 +/ - 3 "+ "

*"+ " " *"+B + +/ " * +

+. !

" +/ " 0

" *" 3 " 1 " .

I A; 600+

I "+ "'+ ;

I " . & A; 60 .

" " "0 0 .2 3 "

I .

" . . " 0 .

I 0 + ++0.

" "0B

""+ " H 2@ "

D .

)0 ! # 1/$%+'&,+ *" 0 . .*-. "+ 46 + ..

)0+ + ;

." . ) +1 .*-. "+ 46 .. / - " .

) +"

+" "+ $$ 0 * *"'

" 1

++ . ++ " + 0 "")+ . + + 0 0

"*" 2 . 0 "+

46 + " + / *"+ + .. +

2@ " *" "% 2+ " + "- "+

0 1

.+ "" .0 " 46 . + . + + *"+ *-. ..

"" 2

"F0 " * " . < ": .*- 0 ..

" F " +"" * F .

. "."*"+ " $$ . )*"+ 0 ..

+ "- *- F)&& ) "+

) ." .+ "" "

46 . "+ +

" " 0 1- +

" ) " + . " 46

. 2 . + "")+ "

"-0 ..

' + "+

+ *

. *

J )7 ?449:6' + .+ ""

. 0 " 46 . & "" ++ 0.% F" . .

"* - 2" 0 0 " .

1 . & "+ " .+ "".-+2 + 20""

0 * .8 2

*" "

" "+" ."

- 0 * 0

+ -.

1*"+*-0

+ * 2*0

A. *& 1)' ?$ ? ?:)0 * .

"- +

K A.*3 # )7 ?9'@

?:) . 0 "

"+ 0 - + * -.

"0 " )0 " - "+

"" 0 *0;" "0 *0

)37 0 9'( 1 )'@7 ?::9" 4)0 "*0;"-B

" * A. ) ' ?6 B 6 ' 0

*" . + 08 . *

- + "" " 46 0 + "+ "'0 *"

+*0+

" ++ . + + "0+"

*"+ +0'+ +" # * +>+) .. ;" * . 0 + "" " 46) 2 0 0 +. + - + +" 0

" 0 " *- 0+ -) 0 " *2 . + "" "

. & . " .

" - 02. + + "

+ 0. " * " 0 ;" * .+ ""- & ) 0

" .

1 . 0 + "") "'0+1

.*-. & "

46) . '0

. .*-. " 46 ..

)0+ + ;

." . +1 . *-. " 46 + .. / - .

) +"

+" " $$) ) 0 *

*" '

+ " 1

++ . ++ " + 0 ""+ . + +

"*" 2 + + " 46 .+ ""- & ) 0

" - .

1 *"+ +

6+ :

A*"++.

1+ .+ "" " 46 + "

+ ..

"-0 ..

;"*0

" " 46 *"+)+ * 0 " ..

*"7 ?

9':42

- . 0 "

46 + / *"+ ..

) A/

- "+

.+ "" " $$ 0+ + .

0 " $$2 . " **"+ 0 "0"

- 0 . 0 + *

2 / 0 "- "

2 !+" " *+ "++ ."2 +

0" "+ *+ "+ "

"+" - 0H 6 2@ "

D .

#2"!1 !

"3$%%%456' *" .+ ""

- & "+ 46 + . 0 *""+ :

A*"++ "+ . *""+ :: 2@ " *"

"% : .

-)/ 0

. *"+ - + :

A*"++.

- . ..

" - 0 . + F -

- -+ . * +F ."

- +02

+ + -+ . * ) - . " . "

+ * + "

- 0+

+ "++ "+ 4 " . " & +" - " "+ .

+ + " . *""+ 46 "

" + .0

"* "

+ .

1 . / -"

0 . 0 0 - .+ ""- .

"+ 46+ .

0 *""+ :

A*"++ "+. *""+

:: H : ' * )1 ! *,''( " $%'( #* + "

*" 00 .*"" * ) . + ""

"+ 46 +

" * + 2@ " *" "% $@ """ + + .

" . 7 < 9 "0. & 11 7 < 90 +" & + " . "+ 46 0+ - - " +5++ . + " .. .

" + 2 "

+ "" .

"* 0 "

"+ "" * + 0 0+ 0 + " >

" + .

)0"

" . +2 . 0 "+ 46 0 "

* "- - + ;

.. " " *+ *"+)

- ""

" 0

" +"- + + ;

. ' ; " "*

+"+ 0 ! * A. )' ?64 $7 ?6476 9@349 " *

) ?

@3 4 %7' ?

64$9 '+ *-

+ "

8 .

* + + - " . + ""

"+ 46 **"+'+ " - . 0

"+.'+ )007 <

" < 9 *.*"" * ) . + "" "+ 46

" * + ' +

") .

.) " - + + "+ )

+ ' *

" +-

+ * + . 0+ "" "+ 46 "-

+ "+ *+ " H 4 2@ "

D .

"3,'$'4&-6& *" . " + 46 **"+2@ " *"

"% E4< * " "+

" *

+ "< .!

0 -.

" . "+ 46 2

. *

" ?

9 $9 " . 46 **"+ "+ I" -

+ "+0* * ..

0 ")+ - I" - *

" .

< . + " 0 +" 0 "+.

" " " " '" *"+' . "+ 46+ " A* 0)

1 ."

* * -.

. "1" "- " "

.)0 0 ' 0 ")0

8 . 1"

"- 1 + 2 +

" .+ " + "+4 44 ' " *"+ 0* *.* +"1" $< "- 0 " "!

". . "2 +/ "H

2@ "

D .

"8 ! ." 3$%%+4(&'5 *" . "+ + " - "+ + .

1 .2@ " *" "%

4<.

- 0 *"+ <:)" "

= .!

0 + + ..)7/

" 9 " .+ "" " 46) " *"+

2 " . 0 " **"+L 0

"*" . 0)

* .

"- "

% F'A; 6 7 .+ "" " 46) 9

" .+ "

. + *"+ + "

0+.F '.

1 * ". + ..

" . +. !

"+ . 0+ "" " 46) + " **"+ "+ " - + "+ + . ' "

+ *"+ <: . +*

+ " .

- .

+ "" " "+"" . 2 .- )

+ .." +")

" "*.0 . 0 ."!

-) .-) 0 0'

"+ "

0+ . A; :60

" . . 0

"+ . "

0 ) )

"+ .. + . . "+ + " . "

. +2+ ..

<: " . & 7A; 6 9 + 0 "+ + 0 ;++ 0

- 0 *'" 0 *+

0 .

+ +"-

+ + / ) .-)A

60 I"- + & - ) ?? " 0 " 3 $)

??++ "

0 0 -" "

- + + " . <: .

. " "+ >+ I" + 0 + "

- " + "

"+ + "+ 0 "

+ .. " + 0 +

++ . +

*"+ <:0" + + * "-

"* <: - +

-+ +H $ ' + ) & 0 " + "" . < ) " 0 ? 2@ "

D .

9 )2

! 1 :*"1!

$%-%$&,' *" 0

- *"+ ; !

"+ + .

" ) 0 * "

. .

+2@ " *" "% E6 ++ . ++ +" +

+ + + *+ + *- + ..".

" "+ "++ " +< 0 ) ) 0 0 " 6 8+ +1 * ' ++ . +) ) 0

" * +1"

"+ " -

- 0

" *

"- + " +.

" -0

" *+

" .!

= ) 9 . + ""+ "0 ""

" +

"""+ " " ; !

"+ + .

"- 1 )

0 ** *-0 1 <;

." 0

"+ - " 0 .

" . 0 0*" 0 ..

"- . + ..& 0 " "."

0 " / "

". "+ .." . 1 " 1" "

'+ ;

. 0 "." "" - .

" - "- .

""+ .0 + " + 20. .

- "" . + . - .+ "-*"+ 0 0 1 0 " 0" "+ * 0

1 0 0 1 0 . = ) )0"0 - ++*"+ ; !

"+ + +< 1 . ++ . +0+ * + + .

*0 * 1 " *"= "+ " * +*" .

- +"

" *

"- "+

" * "

- 0 . "

- "< + - *0

"+ - " .

" . 0 0*" 0 ..

"-. + ..& 0 " "." 0 " / " ". "+ .." . 1 " "1" "

'+ ;

. 0 "." "" - .

" - "- .

""+ .00 + " + 20 . . "

- "" .

+ . + - .+ "- *"+ 0 0 1 0 0""+ * 0

1 0 0 1 0 . = ) )0"0 - ++ *"+ ; !

"+ +

+< 1 . ++ . +0+ * + + .

*0 * 1 " *"= "+ " *+*" .

+"0

" *

"- "

" *"

- 0

. "- "< + - *0 + *"+ - " "

<) ) 0 )

". +

" +/

+ ." .2 .

- 0 " 0H 2@ "

D .

##! :!"$%-$$+-$ *" ; !

"+ .

" 0

- "0+ . - + * -+ + " ".*"+ " ""* +"

* -)"

+.)

. + . " - + "

" ++ . + "

"+ " - .. + " .

- 2

+ I * + ) + ) 0 . 0 .

"). " + .

1)++ . + 0+0 .

" " - +

0 "2@ " *"

"% E? 2 +

0 *

- ." - .

- ( 7 <69

+ *+" "

- 0" + "+ " 1 0" + .. + " +0" " "-0 -2 +

"" -

- " ; !

"+ + +

0 + ""+"2

" "0 +

+ *"+

<6++ "

*"+ <6 + "-*"+ < " < :2 ; !

"+ + 0 ) )" ".

" < - 0 + "") ; !

"+ + " *F.

" <6 ". " -*0

+ .

+ .""

+ + ' . " < 6 0 * +" + .+- .

" ") )

" " .+'

)++. !

" .

) ".*"+) " . + -) *

+ *"+0+ * ++

"+- . + .. + +

"+ +

" ) * -)"

+.) . + . "- 6)'" A*"++

"++ . +"

"+ " - . . - + + " .

- = )+

+ * + ) + )

0 .+ .

"). " + .

1) ++ . +0+.

" " - +

"'+ "/ + <6

-2+ / -

+.) . " + * B -+ 8 "0-

" *.

" + <6 0 6

" + "+ ">

") *."- . 1 + <6) 0) + + 0 " " " "- *+. + *

+ "" 2+

. - 0+0

" 0 + * -+ + " 2 + * < 6 0 +" * *".

" + -"

* - + + + +

1 0" <6"*" .*- 0+ *" + .<"

" " <6

* + + - 2+ ) ) ".*"+ " )"*

+" 20 " " / + "8 ".

8 "

*"+

< 6 "

" - + 0 " .

+ + . + "2;+ " " "- " +

+0-0

" "*"+

7 < 90+ ** <6 "

- 0" +

"+ " + 2

0 / - ; !

"+ + " <62+ " *.

< " "

7 < 9 " "

0 * + ""

- + "0"

" - + " 0.H 2@ "

D .

":)$%-($5(5 *" *"+

; !

"+ + 0 1+ *"+

" . +1 -0

" "+ - !+ .2@ " *" "% 6 " ; !

"+ +

" + +") + " *"+ . 7 < 69 * 1

*"+ 0)0" . +1+"+ ""* " - 2 + "."- + + * +- * = .

- :) ?

< " 0- ") " " . +)

. * = .

)

. " 1 . + " +B 0 0- "+

" .

+< *. " *

. .

"+ + - + *- . "+ " " 2 . * +-

+ -

* .

"+ " "+ *- . "0

) ++"- *"+ " ; !

"+ + " *.

" <2*"+

; !

"+ + 0 1+ *"+' . +1 - + )0

" "+ - !+ . < ) ) " + - + *"+ " ; !

"+ + "H #* + >

/1/)! $%+," ,6(, " *"+ 00 " ; !

"+ + .

- ".

+ "+ +

. ++"#* + " "% E? < " 00 *"

; !

"+ + " * .

" -

.2*"+ ; !

"+ )*- ) 0 1+

*"+) *"- .

* !

2*"+ 00 " ; !

"+ + .

+ "+ +

++"#* +

)+ ( * > : @2 % ?$ @?$ " * *"+ ; !

"+ + 1 - *"+"" * +- 0 0 . .

" " * +

++*"+ +

0 " + * - 0 + " +" + ""

0- .

+ & 1 * J "' ?:?? % ?:?@3

? "& * !

H 2@ "

D .

":) )8 )1 "! ! *$%+5$&-+ *"

" "" ++ . +) . 0 0 .

" "+"- 00 1 +

2@ " *" "% .*"+ <: "?0

" "." . ".

"""+ "2 " 3 " " "*"+- . . ; !

"+ + *-0 1-

*"+2 0 *0 0' -

0 . ; !

"+ + 0 1- *"+'0

""" ++ . +).0+ 0 .

" " +"- 00 1 + + ) *"+ <: "?0

" -0++

" " + + ""00 2 *"+ 0 07 <: "?90+" *"+ <

0 + 0 *+ "2 3 " + .." * 0 - " + *"+

<: "? " . "

"H 6 2 + " *+ "

- " "

++ "- 0" 2 !

". " ""

M " " " " - " "+ "2 " "" "

0 + "- - + -"+"

0 " + ,

- +

/0 *1$ < 15 "

N5B

< N5B