Manpreet Singh v. Union Of India And ORS

 



   
    




 

   

   !

"## 

$ # CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS SURI   %&'(

$ )%#* )

  +  *)%#* )



#  $&  )%##( %#* +() &,



#- ..... 


  *#   # #%(0


 

"#) 1

(# ,

 022  #     *(# ((   ) # (#

3 (
(
 4 5

6    7 

8 * 

# ("""  $ ()  #( 18# -  "  #( )*#(##   5%9 -6 1   1  # :"$

 ##

  # ))-) -) -"
 #  #)+ # # # (') 1 ((#  

1  1 '  8  #  565,6# 5 65,6

 %) 025

;  %<6) 

(#   , #   8  = 1 (  ##   # 

 >#  (

      ,8     )   (   ? 5%9  26)     

1   #( 1; ( $  (# (  #*1$  ( @

<    (##      :"$   # 

, *) *  1

, #  (  #  2
 ) 1?
( 8

  = 1*)  #
  88 #     #

 
 ## ( #*# ###A     # # 1 (# ,' 1'


$$  ) 1  * 1(( 1#   # 8 # #1#  (* 

# ## # ;%    ((      :"$) 

 # *?,( 1 ##%

?B 8 , 



8)1  (, 1



8 %,(

? 8# ( ( 5%9 6

1 & '

A 

8& ,( 1 (, 1&  = 1*) 81 ,( 1 ((

)## ( # #  
 ,  88 # ('1  
# 8  
     8#     8   %    ) (' 8

C(#*$& , ##  B   *1   

# )  # # (( # / 
 ((,(,' 

 #       1 ( ?   #     8( ( #  8# ( (  ## #

<  " ,(  #

(

 



)  -  ) 1 8( #   " (  

 8(  #

 %# ,# ('1   #8(
?

D

(( #   #) 1   

8#   #  

:"$   # #  ,'  #
) 1 (#      8(    #     0565 6

 %   /  

#    #(#,'

#C 


            

      #    ! "  

      #

 $% @ 

8  )('1 (# , (



 # ) 1 ,'      

'   #   #*  (   # (  ## ( 

8  

8   

 *# ( ##   5%9  $ E 6)  ((' ,   

(  

   

#  ( (  ,8#,' "     

#  88  ) *# ( ##      , 8# ,'  (     *  ) 

5 6

(&

)#

(( #  @

F 

)1

, ,'

* 

8)  )
' + #  #  

-% ## 0

  1 (  ##  # " 8 ) ( ,###  

 ,#  2  )1 1 ,8# ,

  #
     #   8  # # # 88   # ( (

 ,&  * 

 

) = 4,(
(( 1 8?

" ( 8 #(1  # *

#  , *  #((#  (( *

- ,#  8)8 

:"$1 1 8(#    (  )  (#  8    1'   #'  ( E (( 5

6) ,

' 8 8(  8 >?1) ,    )## (

#*

?

(

) ) ' #

 ()
')+ # ) , (



#- , (# 

 #  , # #

#*) (*  

# # ;0  8,(' ,8#  

# (# ##  

E+ #  #     /

E+ #   # #   

 *  )    ' #

  ()
' + #   #   *  ) * '  8( # ? '     (1 # &     * 

  E
'E+ # ) 1

,      8,('  ,8#      *  )  ((1( # ># 

    "  ,8#   #%*

1#(# (8#

#,' ># 
A     8,(' ,8#  8( ' # (#(  #  


 88 

    #C(&#

 G >##   /  (#
  #  88   #  #C(&#

G>##*# # ##0    / # (#  = 4,( =

       , * # # *#
$$

 

  / = 4,(=


# # ##      &'()    *     + #    ,  +        -  ,

    .  )

  

     )))

  *  "    +         +, +/ )0

A     8,('  ,8#      8(

###  ) ># 
# ###   ;1++, ),+ ,

- . ),+  ,%1 ))  1   +    3 4  3

, 5,       %%  

 6  % 789  :

 .  7  % 9 ) 

 5  * ,

      ++, -        0    8,('  ,8#       #  ># 
)1  9#

 A 

   *# < " 8  #  

( ## 5%9 $ E6# (

, * #

#* ## 0 A  ,

  
      )   

8 *('(D# #* )(('  ,8#   

)  ,((1#  

 #  , ?    ## ( 

#*     *)   # 

#* #    #(  ' ## ( 8( #       #' 8   (



  ( (   5

6)(1 =# (#  (

    # 1  ,( " * #  # ># (



# ,8  ,( #  # ) 

  (
(
  5

6   ## #,'   

'),  (

# 

' (8# # 8

 ((   ) 8## #  (

 () #(

 #  )8# ('  , 8  ( 

) 

#-

0 >#%##( %#* +() &,)    8 % " B (1

)  #    #) + # ) 1

   * 8  #

  ( 5*6)  #
 

,
 #  #  % ')     #:"$) ,8#  #

,

 ?##* #)  8    (  , 88 # ,'  #
)8

(,' #,' 
*# # ##  5%9 6 "*1

8)

# ,?,

      (  

 *  ,&   *  

  

)  1   #  (#  ( ##   5%9 $ E6)

1# = 4,(
(( 1# @  

 7 ' #  #  , *)   7 * (('# C 

 ## (##    1 #1)       8      *  #   #( 8 8   (  

    " *1

 , *)    1    # #

1   #    

     98   8  #( #   )   ((   8  

#     #      8#8  #   )   7   *  , ,8# 

1 1 1? 8  

   '

 #   /  ) 

 1

( 

81 (#?'   (

 



# # ,(  8(#

2 1    #

 1  1? 8   #

 

*  8  ( 

 C

   1  & # 8)  8' ,  #    81  ( 

 * # # 8(*#

*

(' (

?#   8 # *  8(       

  ,

 
)  , *(

?# % # (') 

  ##   7   8  #  ##  #   ( #  

( ,(

 ,8  (*     

#

 

8##) '



#9, #?

1  #  8(# 9# (')  ,(' 1 

  8 #



 '

 # ' * 8 ,8(8# 8('    1 # #

 

#8 


  

!

"#"$""     ? E # H    ,(