High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4182/2002dismissed

New India Ass.Co.Ltd. v. Shivender Pal Bedi Etc.

2015-07-24Mr Justice Kanwaljit Singh Ahluwalia10 pages

! "!#$%$& '

(

)%*!!+&"$%%,-&#!. " //!00& 1!-%,% 2*$1!&"!-0!"$&- !%/&"!& %

3*! *!-!/- !-% .#0!+%//!-%456!00+!" %!! *!7,"84!& 9 5!%

6!-!

!--!" *!!/- !-%-& 95!% :3*! *!- *!7,"84!& %*,0"6!-!/- !"$& *!$8!% 95!% -!%!& ;2*-$<%*46="1# ! - *!//!00& 2*-$%*+&$--="1# ! - *!-!%/&"!& % !+&"$%%,-&#!. "*%"$-!# !" *!/-!%!& //!0 8$&% *!+-"" !" (

/%%!"652*-$"-= - ##$"!& 0$4% -$6,&0= *&"$8-* 1$"! +*$#* *! -$6,&0 /- 05 ##!/ !" *! #0$4 /! $ $& $0!" ,&"!- 2!# $& >: *! - ?!*$#0!%# = @

$&%*- A *!# &"+-"!"%,4 %'

)B *0"$&8-!%/&"!& %0$60! /5 *!+-"!"4,& 7$& 05&"%!1!-005 +$ *#% %0&8$& !-!% C@D/!-&&,4 -4 *!" ! /! $ $& $00$ % -!0$E $&

-$!

05% !" *!#%! *!#0$4& $% * *!+%!4/05!"

%20!%F!#, $1!$&$&",% &!4!"$!%=-+& * $4!

*!+%:

5!-%0"&'

=*!+%#4$&8 *&"$8-* -4!0*$ +*$0!"-$1$&8 *!$00 !"#-B BB> &"-!#*!"G$-H/,- 6,

/4 *$%#- 4! +$ *&##$"!& +$ * *! -,#H6!-$&8 -!8$% - $&B BB>:(+*$#*+%/-H!"65 *!%$"! *!-" ,! *$%##$"!& =7$&"!-<,-+*+%%$ $&8$& *! -& %$"!%! = "$!"& *!%/ &" *!#0$4& -!#!$1!"$&7,-$!%&*$%/!-%&$%0!

*&"&"0!

#01$#0!8 -# ,-!"!0%%,% $&!"$&7,-$!%&*$%&%!= #*$&&"0!

*,46=+*$#*+!-!8$1!&% $ #*!% !+%"4$ !"$& *! *%/$ 0 & '

&" "$%#*-8!" & ('

! $% % $00 ,&"!- -! 4!& : && $#!-!%/&"!& "$"& //!-"!%/$ !*!-%!-1$#!= *,%%*!+%/-#!!"!"8$&% !FB/- !6!

-! *!-$6,&01$"!-"!- " !" '

!%/&"!& B&%,-&#!4/&5$&$ %+-$ !&% !4!& *%/0!"!" * *!/! $ $&+%$&#4/0! !=18,!&""$"& "$%#0%!&5 #,%! # $&8$&% !%/&"!& *!/! $ $&$%6" -&&7$&"!- +&!-% &" *!-% *! -,#H *! /! $ $& *% 6!!& $0!" $& #& -1!& $& *!/-1$%$&% *!# *!"-$1!- *!#-+%& *0"$&810$""-$1$&80$#!&#! *! $4! ##$"!& &- *!#-+% $&%,-!"+$ *-!%/&"!& & *!" ! ##$"!& *!#0$4& +% *!-!

-!& !& $ 0!" &54,& %#4/!&% $& !&5$&8 *!- 1!-4!& %=-!%/&"!& /-5!" -"$%4$%%0 *!#0$4/! $ $&

( -4 *! /0!"$&8% *! /- $!%= 00+$&8 $%%,!% +!-!

-4!";B 3*! *!- *!#0$4& %,% $&!"$&7,-$!%$&-"%$"! ##$"!& +*$#* H/0#!&'

+*!&*!+% "-$1$&8 *!#-B BB> 9

$%%,! $%/-1!"+*! *!- *!#0$4& $%!& $ 0!" &54,& %#4/!&% $&=$ %= +* 4,& &"

-4+*49 : 3*! *!- *!/! $ $&*%6!!& $0!"+$ *, &5#,%! # $&9 3*! *!- *!#0$4& +%"-$1$&8 *!#-+$ *, 10$" &"!

!# $1!"-$1$&80$#!&#! *! $4! ##$"!& 9 ( !0$!

> *!/- $!%*1!0!" *!$--!%/!# $1!!1$"!&#!& *! -!%$"

$%%,!%& *!0$8* *!%4!= *!-$6,&0/- 05##!/ !" *!#0$4 /! $ $& &"+-"!"%,4 %'

)B *!#0$4& *0"$&8 *!

-!%/&"!& %0$60! /5 *!+-"!"4,& 7$& 05&"%!1!-005+$ * #% %0&8$& !-!% C@D/!-&&,4 -4 *!" ! /! $ $& $00$ % -!0$E $&1$"!+-"" !" (

' !!0$&8 "$%% $% $!" +$ * *! +-" " !" (

= $&%,-&#!#4/&5/-!

!--!" *!/-!%!& //!0

.!-&!"#,&%!0 - *!//!00& *%%,64$ !" * #%!

*!#0$4& )$&7,-!"*$4%!0 $% * *!+%"-$1$&8 *!

!&"$&8#- -4 !0*$ *&"$8-*&"+*!&$ -!#*!"G$-H/,-= *!$&7,-!" -$!" 0$

*!+ !-6 0! -4 *!6#H%$"!&"$& * /-#!%%#- ,-&!" +-"% 0!

&""%*!"8$&% *! -,#H $%%,64$ !" * "-$1!-&"+&!-

*! -,#H$&#0,"$&8$ %$&%,-&#!#4/&5*1!& 6!!&--5!"=0 *,8*

67!# $&+%%/!#$ $#005 H!&$& *!+-$ !&% !4!& @ *!&!F #& !& $&-$%!"65#,&%!0 - *!//!00& $% * $&#%! *! # %/0!"!"$& *!#0$4/! $ $&-! H!&%$ $%=$& * #%! 0% *!#0$4& +%&!80$8!& $&"-$1$&8 *!#-&"%%,#* *!&%,-&#! 4/&5#&& 6!-"!-!" /5 *!#4/!&% $&,&"!-2!# $& >:B *!#

$% ,- *!-#& !&"!" * +&!- *!#-$%&&!B!0%!6, *!+$ ! *!#0$4& 2*$1!&"!-0!"$=+*$%#0$4$&8#4/!&% $& &##,& $&7,-$!%%,% $&!"65*$4$&##$"!& *!#0$4& %*00% !/ $& *!%*!% +&!--$ %+&+-&8= *!#0$4& #&& 8! *! #4/!&% $& -4&%,-&#!4/&5 $% ,- *!-#& !&"!" * $& *!

$&%,-&#!/0$#5=&%/!#$ $#/-!4$,4*%6!!&/$" -$&7,-$!% *!

+&!-)"-$1!-&"%%,#* *!&%,-&#!4/&5#&& 6!*!0"0$60! /5 *!4,& #4/!&% $&!1!&$ $ $%/#H8!/0$#5 &%,//- *$%#& !& $&=0!-&!"#,&%!0 - *!//!00& *%-!0$!",/& *! 00+$&8, *-$ $!%;B

!"#$!

$%"&!

())*'!()()+

,$%"&!

#$ !"$ "!'

()-(./'!-

.!-&!"#,&%!0 - *!//!00& *% ,- *!-%,64$ !" * 65 $%%,$&8#4/-!*!&%$1!/0$#5= 0$6$0$ 5 +-"%+&!-)"-$1!- #&& 6! 4"!,&0$4$ !" #1!-%-$%H +&!-$&-!%/!# "48!% $&%,-!"

1!*$#0!%,//- *$%#& !& $&0!-&!"#,&%!0 - *!//!00& *% -!0$!",/&, *-$ $!% !0 $$%"&!

#$1

( "!'

())(.(/.#,/'!((&"&% $ , $&0!&#* , *-$ 5 &I60! 2,/-!4!,- $& 2""3"$ !"#$ 4 !""!'

()-5'!-56*.7 / : &-!/05 *!61!& !"%,64$%%$&%=0!-&!"#,&%!0 - *!

-!%/&"!& )#0$4& *%%,64$ !" * $&-!%/!# /#H8!/0$#5= *!

0$6$0$ 5 /5 *!4,& 65&%,-&#!4/&5$%,&0$4$ !" $% %,64$ !" * /! $ $&*%6!!& $0!",&"!-2!# $& >:B *!# &"

#0$4& $%& -!J,$-!" /-1! *!&!80$8!&#!*!+&!-&""-$1!-

!&"$&8 -,#H*1!& 6!!&--5!"% *!5+!-!& &!#!%%-5/- $!% ,&"!-2!# $& >:B *!# *! #0$4& $%-!J,$-!" /-1!00 -!%/!# $1!$&7,-$!%$& -?!*$#0!##$"!& &"$%& -!J,$-!" /-1! *! # ,4 &!80$8!&#! $%%,64$ !" * *!+-"/%%!"65 *! -$6,&0 % !&$&8 *!0$6$0$ 5 *!&%,-&#!4/&5$%/!- !# 0510$" .!-&!" #,&%!0 - *! -!%/&"!& % *% -!0$!" ,/& *! 00+$&8 , *-$ $!%;B !

$%"&!

'1 !

#$ "8 !"9

::55 4()--

!& !

-*):()-(+

"!,$%"&!

#$$ ;!#

!"$ .#,/

.$/(*6(<=())) !& !

):-)()-: : !"!,$%"&!

'1 !

#$ $ ;!#0

0 !"$9

6-(=())* .7/ !& !

-))(())*+

!0 $$%"&!

'1 !

#$ "

% " !"9

:5>(=())*

!& !

(>)?()-)+

> 5

33,,@2!!",$%"&!

#$ % !"$9

:6() 4()--.7/

!& !

(5)5()-- > !

$%"&!

#$%,% " !"!'

()-:'!(?5< *1! 8$1!& 45 *,8* ,0 #&%$"!- $& *! -$10 %,64$%%$&%4"!656 * *!%$"!%&"*1!8&! *-,8* *!-!#-"%

*!#%! ( & -"!- /-/!-05 //-!#$ ! *! # % *! #%!= *!

-!0!1& /-1$%$&% 2!# $& >: *!# = -!-!/-",#!"% ,&"!-;B A-<:'!&,'"

#$ $$ '1 ! 4&

'!$

$"%&%"!

4 "

%,B$$ +$ *% &"$&8&5 *$&8#& $&!"$& *$%# -$&&5 *!-0+ - *! $4!6!$&8$& -#!-$&% -,4!& *1$&8 *!

-#! 0+= *!+&!- *!4 -1!*$#0! *!, *-$E!"

$&%,-!-%*006!0$60! /5$& *!#%! "! *-/!-4&!& "$%60!4!& ",! ##$"!& -$%$&8, *!,%! 4 - 1!*$#0!=#4/!&% $&=%$&"$# !"$& *!2!#&"2#*!",0!= *!0!80*!$-%- *!1$# $4=% *!#%!456!

- *!/,-/%!% *$%%,6B%!# $&=K/!-4&!& "$%6$0$ 5L%*00*1! *!%4!4!&$&8&"!F !& %$& *! 3-H4!&I%4/!&% $&# = @ : @ :

&&5#0$4 -#4/!&% $&,&"!-%,6B%!# $& = *!

#0$4& %*00& 6!-!J,$-!" /0!"-!% 60$%* * *! "! *-/!-4&!& "$%60!4!& $&-!%/!# +*$#* *!#0$4

*%6!!&4"!+%",! &5+-&8 ,0# -&!80!# - "!

,0 *!+&!- *!1!*$#0!-1!*$#0!%#&#!-&!"-

&5 *!-/!-%& :

*!!& -01!-&4!& 45=H!!/$&8$&1$!+ *!#%

0$1$&865& $ $# $&$& *!

$#$0E! != -4 $4! $4!4!&" *!2!#&"2#*!",0!L > 2!# $& >:B *!# *%6!!&$&%!- !"65# (

@@ +! @@=$&-"!- 1!-#4! *!"$

$#,0 $!% -"

1$# $4% /-1! *!&!80$8!&#! "-$1!-$&#0$4/! $ $& ' ,&%!0 - *!//!00& *%%,64$ !" * #0$4& *$4%!0

$%&!80$8!& &"& * ##,& =*!#&& 8! *!4,& #4/!&% $&

-4$&%,-&#!#4/&5+!1!-= * #& !& $&$%4!-$ 0!%%

& , *-$ 5 , $%"&!

!"$ &$!.$%'"/-!0$!",/&65 *!#,&%!0 - *!//!00& ",-$&8 *!

#,-%! -8,4!& %=2*$7B"!#!%!"+%"-$1$&84 -#5#0!&"+*$0! 8$1$&8+5 6,%#4$&8 -4//%$ !%$"!=4 -#5#0!*$ 6$80 !-$# % &!05$&8& *! --",! $4/# =4 -#5#0!1!- ,-&!"-!%,0 $&8 $&$&7,-$!% /$00$&-$"!-& *!%!#$-#,4% &#!%= *!&I60!/!F,- *%*!0" * !1!&$&&# /0$#5 *!$&%,-&#!#4/&5$%0$60! @ , *-$ 5

$&$!.$%'"/-!0 !% # /0$#5&"& #4/-!*!&%$1!/0$#5&"%%,#* *!%$", *-$ 5$% "$% $&8,$%*60! *! # % *!/-!%!& #%!

2 -%, *-$ 5 !0 $$%"&!

#$ 1 $&$!.$%'"/ &", *-$ 5 2""3"$ !"

$&$!

.$%'"/-!#&#!-&!"= *!%!, *-$ $!%-!0 ! "48! *!/-/!- 5

:-" /- 5 &! *!%!, *-$ $!%-!0 ! #0$4$&-!%/!# $&7,-$!% %,% $&!"65 *!"-$1!- *!1!*$#0!*!-!$%&"$%/, ! *! # * !-4% *!/0$#5+$00/-!1$0,&%!0 - *!//!00& #,0"& /$& , &5 *$&8 -4 *!/0$#5 * 0$6$0$ 5 *!&%,-&#!4/&5$% 0$4$ !"$&#%! $&7,-5%,% $&!"65 *!"-$1!-)+&!- *!

!&"$&8 1!*$#0!

&I60! /!F ,- $& , *-$ 5 , $%"&!

'1 !

#$ ,,8"$ !""!'

.()-:/ %'"!

! %" $!$ 6:- +*$0! "$%#,%%$&8 *! # /0$#5 &" #4/-!*!&%$1!)/#H8!/0$#5*%8&! *-,8* *!&%,-&#!!8,0 -5 &" !1!0/4!& , *-$ 5 +*$#* $% /-!%!& 05 *! % , -5 -!8,0 -5, *-$ 5-!8-"$&8$&%,-&#!& *!%$", *-$ 5=$ *%6!!& *!0" * *!0$6$0$ 5 /5 *!4,& #4/!&% $&$& *!# /0$#5 &"#4/-!*!&%$1!/0$#5-!"$

!-!& 1!& - *!%H! -8,4!& %=$ $%/-!%,4!" * #0$4& % !//!"$& *!%*!% *!+&!-=$& * #%!

0%=%$&#! *!-!$%&0$4$ $& *!/0$#5-!8-"$&84,& #4/!&% $& *!+&!-&""-$1!-&"%%,#* *!&%,-&#!#4/&5*%6!!&-$8* 05 *!0"0$60! /5 *!4,& #4/!&% $&

*$%,- $&, *-$ 5!

$%"&!

#$ "8 !"

$ &$!.$%'"/ *%"$%#,%%!" *$% /$&

: &I60! /!F,- $& , *-$ 5 "!, $%"&!

#$$ ;!# !"$ .#,/

.$/(*6(<=()))

!& !

):-)()-:"!#0$&!" !& !- $& *!%/!#$00!1! /! $ $& &05& *!8-,&" * 4,& $&101!"$%%400&!*!4,& $&101!" $& *!%$"#%!+%%:=:>=

)B+*!-!% *!4,& $&101!"$& *!

/-!%!& #%!$%%'

&, *-$ 5 ! !0 $$%"&!

'1 !

#$ "

% " !"

$&$!.$%'"/ *$%,- !-"$%#,%%$&8 *!, *-$ $!%

$&$!.$%'"/&" $%"&!

#$ !"$ &$!.$%'"/ *!0" * *!&%,-&#!

#4/&5$%0$60!+*!-! *!"! * *! ++*!!0!-"-$1!-*% H!&/0#!

& ##,& *$ $&8 4&*0! 0$" &" 00$&8 -4 *! 1!*$#0! &"

%,##,46$&8 $&7,-$!%

( &I60!/!F,- $&, *-$ 5 !

$%"&!

#$%, % " !"

$&$!.$%'"/ 1!--,0!" *!

67!# $&-$%!"65 *!&%,-&#!4/&5+*!-!$& *!$&7,-!"+*+% "-$1$&8 *!1!*$#0!+%*$4%!0 &!80$8!& +%6%!-1!"65 *!/!F ,- * 0$6$0$ 5,&"!-2!# $& >:B *!# $%& *!/-$&#$/0! &

,0 0$6$0$ 5.!8$%0 ,-!&!1!-+& !" *!#0$4& /0!"-!% 60$%* &!80$8!&#! +&!--"-$1!- *%6!!& ,- *!-6%!-1!" * ,&"!- 2!# $& >:B *!# = *!-!$%&/-1$%$&% - //- $&4!&

0$6$0$ 5 *%6!!& ,- *!-6%!-1!" $& *!%$"-,0$&8 * +&!-- &%,-&#! 4/&5 #&& 6! /!-4$ !" /-1! *! #& -$6, -5 &!80$8!&#!& *!/- 1$# $4 *!-+$%! *!1!-567!# /-1$%$& ,&"!-2!# $& >:B *!# +,0"6!"!

! !"2= *!4 !-+% -!

!--!" 0-8!-!&#* -$& !-/-! $&8 *!%#/! 2!# $& >:B

*! # $& 1$!+ *! 6%!-1 $&% 4"! $& , *-$ 5 , $%"&!

#$ !"$ &$!.$%'"/

> 2=$&1$!+ *!61!"$%#,%%$&= *!//!0$%+$ *, &5 4!-$ &" *!%4!% &"%"$%4$%%!"

' #/5 *$%7,"84!& 6!%!& *!-$6,&0 -% -$# #4/0$&#! ./ ;2 %,1(>()-5 $#