← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/638/2013dismissed

Vinod Kumar v. State Of Haryana

2015-07-15Mr. Justice Veeraswami Ramaswami14 pages

  

      

    

 



    

 

 



 

    

  

 





    

  



  

!

   

 

 

  

     

 

 !   "#$%#$&%#$'()*$+$,%-#.(/)0$&$1.&%$)2,%#$)2*$-%3 $-  

  



 

456.758

9.75 

  8

5.75

 "



 

5.75 

  5

5.75

 

  

5.75

 

   

 ! "

 

         

        

       

    

!"#   

!$ %&      '  %   

 (

 ( ')))*+  

(    ( 

( ! 

 %, 

    

!-!   

!$ %&       '  %   

 (

 ( ')))*+  

(    ( 

( !

 %, 

    

!--   

!$ %&      .  %   

 (

 ( ')))*+  

(    ( 

( ! 

 %   

    

!.-/"0/0 %&       )  %   

 (



( ))))*+  

(    ( 

( ! 

 %         

  1      

 '))))*+     

2 " 1 2    (  (  3 !))

( ")!



 (    

      

 ! %    (  

 &4$ 

      $   

      

"-")  

 #))     

    5     ( 

 

  (

   6

         

5 $ &4$ 

      

"-")  

 #))     

     (             

   

  

                   6 (

    (   

  



 

 1( 

 



  

 6

    

6       

  7 ""-")  

 



    (     8  1

((         

  

 1 

6  



 8   

 6

  

((   8     

  (

   

   (  (       (       

    (     ( 

        ( 

       (   

 

 9  2 



 

          ( 

       1(   

  (    

 

3



   

 

  

 6

      

 7 "!"")  

  (   

 



   ((    :2&;       2

 7  (      

      2

  ' &4     8 %  ( 

: <    8  

    8   

    

  

   2    

   

'#==. 1 

 >

   2

  :2& - &4!  

 <  

      + 2

 

"!-")  

 "!'

     

      

  

     

 (      (    



    

 



 

         8  7 2

(  2     

2  6 ( (

  

 ( 

2 7

  2

  (   

  

   

  

 

 9

 

      

         2

 2     2

    (

        - 

    "+!   9

(

 

     (       

  . &4) 9 9 ?

  + 2

     &4" 8

 @  2

 

  9      

   



        

(  2

  %  



     

      2

         

 

(  2

   

 

((   (  

      (     

 "

(  (

 



 # &4 %        ( 





   

    

  

 

       

   (    

 "

(  + = %      

!!

&  

     

   (   (



  

( 9

 2+    

 

          ( 

 (

            @        8  (  



 &  



 9

 1 ( ( 

2 

   9

 8  

 

  

 1 +

+ (   @

     (    (    

 

 

   

 

   

   (

 1

 

     

 ( &     

   

  (     

 1  

     (     ( )   (  (  $   2

 4 

  %   

   

  ;% 3 $$  -===. 4" @

 :8

6 

   

 (  

 :2"     2 9

   4!



 

6 

  

 (  

 (  

   9 6 3



 4$   

   &  

 



     

4 ( (    

   9

  1  

 

   

  ( 

2

6 (        

      



          (  ((  " 1 2   2

  &4$   

      ( 

 

(   (  ( 





          

          (          6 (

    



    

 6

   

  (       

 



     8            2

 ! &4!  

 < 

  2

( 

2 (        

    

  

  

 

 7  (    2

    

 (  

  

2     2

  $ %  



  &4!  

 < 

2

(  2     

  

  (  2     

     1    

  

  2 

         2

      

    



 (  2

  &4! '  (   ( &4   

; ((       



  2  

'#==.   $          



"-") 1  ( &4) 9 9 ?

   &4"

8

 @ 

        

         2

  

( 

 2

     

      2

   (

 

 

  

 

       

 6    (   

      2

   

  

 

(  2

  % 

  

      

6   (    

 

( 

 2

  - 1 

 

          

   2 

    (

   

   ( 6

           

 . >    



 (   

  (

  :2"    (   ( % <

  & 

 8 

   



  &4)      :2!  

   <

  %      2  

(   ((      

   



  (    8  1(   

    

 (  2       ((   



 (    

      

 

 >  < 8      2    

6   (

 ( 





       

((     (    8  # %  (    2 

 

 

           

 % (   

#       (          

( (  (

   

    

 



     (      

     

  6 (  

 2      (        ( 

 (       %(  

 

    



  2  (

     



    

     $     

   (  ( (      (      

 ;

  

 6

% <

 ( 8   

   ((      

   = 1   :2!

   

 % <

        :2" 



  

   ((  % <

  

    



 

   

(     % <

  

 2

 (  

 % <

      2

   (

 (( 



  

     +2

    ((      

 

  

 

2      ;  

 ( &4$  

(        

((    

9  

   1(    ((    (   (  

 ( 





 

 

  :2!       :2"  

  (     ") >    



 (   



      

 (

  

 

( 

2    % <

  1 2   ( 

        

     ( 

 1(   

        &  

 8 

(  

((     % 

   



 

    (  8       

( 

    

    :

  %     :2"   :2! 

 





 ( 2

( % <

  1(  

:2"  !  

 

   

  

 



       

   " >    



 (   

         



  ( 





 1  

  



"-")  

 #))    (   

   8 

""-")  #))  1 ( (  2  

 

 

 1(  2      

  (      7(   

 

  

( ((   (  

 ( ""-")

&  

3



 9   ( &4 %           (  2   



"!-")  "'



 1   

   

 (   *  ( @  ? 

    -")  "" ;

 % (

  



 



  





 



  (    (     6 ((   

    6        

    

(   1  

(  ( 

  6 1  B    (   (  

(    



(  

     

  



 (  1 ( (   

  6 1( 

%      



  ( 







  (   

 6      "! 7(   (  



 ;%  



 ( ( 

(    (  

     (

 

 1 2       

(  

     (    

 6

   

  (  (

    

   8  ( 





  (  6

   (     (            %   ( 

 % (

     

 2 

 :

     

  (  ( 

(    ( 



 "$ >    



 (   

  (   (  2      

      

   (          1 2    

 

   

 1

 

  

 

   

 6

  

 (   

  (

     6



   1

    

 

 1    2

  

     

     

       2

 1(    

  

            2

         

        2

  %  

     (  2

         

 

        2

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



 (

    (

    :2'  .    

    

 ( &    :2#  )     

 ( &  

 

 

   ((    

 



    

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

$-%=0/2-#%#$?=-$.7%#$1&.-$?(%2.,%#$&$2-,.&$=-.,%.*2@$=?/$=, ?#2%%.=??(-$) =' (+=&'(-%0=-$).,%#$.12,2.,$A1&$--$)0>%#$ --2-%=,%(1$&2,%$,)$,% .7./2?$=,)%#$(1$&2,%$,)$,%.7./2?$2, A-%.<#2?#=&$2,=)+2--20/$2,$@2)$,?$ 9 $=&,$)?.(,-$/=11$=&2,*7.&=??(-$) =' (+=&-(0+2%%$) %#=%.,$#..12,*#<#.<=-=,$A=&1=,?#2,-%2*=%$)%#$7=%#$&.7%#$ 1&.-$?(%&2A%.2+1/2?=%$=??(-$) =' (+=&=-%#$7=%#$&.7=??

(+=&&$+=2,$)2,2+2?=/%.#..12,*# 5 #$  7=+2/>  .7  %#$  1&.-$?(%&2A  <.(/)  ,.%  #=@$  %#.(*#%  .7 -=?&272?2,*%#$7=+2/>#.,.(&=,)%#$&$1(%=%2.,.7:>$=&-./)1&.-$?(%&2A

5 '(-%%.#$/1#..12,*##$1&.-$?(%&2A#=).&2*2,=//>&$7$&&$)%.=??(-$)

=' (+=&2,#$&72&-%@$&-2.,0$7.&$%#$1./2?$.772?2=/-.72-=& #$ =//$*=%2.,.7&2@=/&>.7%#$7=%#$&.7=??(-$) =' (+=&<2%##..12,*# #=)0$$,-#&$<)/>2,%&.)(?$)0>%#$)$7$,?$2,%#$#.1$.7?&$=%2,*-.+$ ).(0%2,%#$+2,).7%#$ .(&%=+,.%2,?/2,$)%.=??$1%%#$-%.&>.7%#$ )$7$,?$%#=%=??(-$) =' (+=&<=-2+1/2?=%$)=%%#$2,-%=,?$.7#..1 2,*# 5 #$?.(,-$/7.&=??(-$) =' (+=&7(&%#$&-(0+2%%$)%#=%%#$&$ <=--.+$?.,)./$,?$2,%#$7=+2/>2,?.,,$?%2.,<2%#%#$)$+2-$.7#20&.%#$&C-)=(*#%$&2,/=<#$%$=?#$&-7&.+%#$-?#../#=)?.+$%.?.,)./$ %#$)$+2-$.7#2-0&.%#$&C-)=(*#%$&2,/=<=,)%#=%%#$&$7.&$=??(-$) ='

(+=&<.(/),.%#=@$0$$,1&$-$,%=%%#$-?$,$.7?&2+$ 5 ?$,$.7?&2+$2-,.%/.?=%$)7=&=<=>7&.+%#$&$-2)$,?$.7 =??(-$) =' (+=& #$?&$+=%2., *&.(,)2-/.?=%$)2,%#$@$&>-=+$ @2//=*$(&%#$&2%2-,.%=-27%#$)=(*#%$&2,/=<.70&.%#$&.7=??(-$) ='

(+=&)2$).,%#$)=>.7.??(&&$,?$.&7$<)=>-1&2.&%.%#$.??(&&$,?$ #$&$7.&$).,.%=??$1%-(?#=-%.&>.7%#$)$7$,?$

.+2,*  %.  %#$  &$@2-2.,  72/$)  0>  %#$  1&.-$?(%&2A  7.& $,#=,?$+$,%  .7  -$,%$,?$  =,)  ?.+1$,-=%2.,    72,)  %#=%  =,  =)$D(=%$ -$,%$,?$#=)0$$,2+1.-$).,%#$=11$//=,%(%=%%#$-=+$%2+$72,) %#=%.,/>=-(+.7 ED(=$=?#.7%#$=??(-$)=11$//=,%#=-0$$, =<=&)$)=-?.+1$,-=%2.,,+>?.,-2)$&$)@2$<%#$1&.-$?(%&2A#=),.% 0$$,=)$D(=%$/>?.+1$,-=%$) 5:

,  %#$  =0.@$  7=?%-  =,)  ?2&?(+-%=,?$-  %#$  '()*$+$,%  .7

: ?.,@2?%2.,=,)-$,%$,?$1=--$)0>%#$%&2=/ .(&%2-?.,72&+$)=,)=//%#$ %#&$$=11$=/--%=,))2-+2--$).<$@$&$=?#.7%#$=??(-$)=11$//=,%2- )2&$?%$)%.1=>=-(+.7/=?2,-%$=).7E=-?.+1$,-=%2.,%.%#$ 1&.-$?(%&2A(,)$&$?%2.,5; &  .,-$D($,%/>%#$&$@2-2.,1$%2%2., -%=,)-1=&%/>=//.<$) (/> #

 ! $

(/=%2 

%&