Kanta Rani v. Haryana Bijli Uttran Nigam





 
     
 
































































































 



 !"#$!%&'&"()*+*  + ,- *.( (&/&$"/"#0 !,*.1 1,&(23 31"4233!10*151!! .41 ***! & &"(!1'

6,,  117( &89&6& 1(&2-($" 3!1'

***!'5"($!( '

 )  :

0 *,
,, 





 



  



 


,,  ;*

19  






!

"

##$%##&
 
'"

(
)*
"




 
"



 
+" *
 
,"*



#& -# #--
./"
 #0

 
$ -1 #--
./"
 10
!



2
3 31&1 34
 ,

 


,

 
,

!
"
,
 *"
,"

2 &#$-$ 4-

!
" 
*



! 
,
 




#

5


 



 
 "!

 




)*

6"
7*

 
 8*,

""

 





& -$

999





"*


"
 
"

 "!

 


*

,
,*
 
 

!"
 

  "


"

,

  *  

"
*
,



*
 
*
,


,


)
*
,

  


,
:
2
.
0
!*
 


 
,
,
:
*



 *


;

8

#

<

#& -# #-- 
 
,


/
!"


/"  #

"
;





,"
 2
3 41&1 34
"


2
#3#&$$ 94


,
 

 

2

&#$-$ 4-
,
 
*"

,"

(
  

,"


2 3 41&1 34

!

,
 
 ,
:
2
.
0




"
*

! 

 
"!,
 
"*
 


 



 
:
2


 


 

!*
 "* 
*



"!,
 
 

:
2

 


"!







"



) 


"* 




 
*


 


 **
!
 


 
 8*,



 
,"
,
 

!


 
,
:

*
 "


" 



 "

"


"!, 

 
,



:
*



 

 
*



 *  


)

  "
 *
,
 "*
 

*


*

,
,*






,

 

!"
"*


,



)
!
  8*,



(



 


 

:

*
 
,



"*
,"


2
3 41&1 34

 ,



!

 


 "
*


!
 ,
" 
!"

!


,)*


 ",
!
  "
;



,
/"
 #


"!,
 
 


 

:
*



"

!
)
 

 

,"

 



 

 
*  




"







"!,
 

 
,
 
%
!
,"




 )
*




+"

, 
,
:
2


 
.
0



!
"




*   

!

,
 

!

 

 " 





"!,
 
 



!

 

#--

 
,


 



 
"

 

,"
* 


;
 
 


  


 "
*

! 

 
 8*,
"!,
 



 




!

"

 




 ,

!
"
!"

 

,


:
* 




 
 "*
"


"

,
!"
  "


"

,

 
,

!




=
"!,
 

 


 

"
,
,
 





 *


 
7/ +"

!
"


 





,
 
,





+




!




=

"!,
 

 
,

:
*




 *  

 *


  "



"

,

(


 

"

 


$

(





 


!


!



 :
*

 




 

#--

"*
 
 
 


 

:
2



 
 
!

"* 



*
 

:
* 

 

999



,
:
2


 
!

"*


"*
,"

2
3 41&1 34




"


 

#---




 

,)

 !

,
!"
 



)



"* 
7

 :
2

 
"*
 


 


(

 ,

 

 

:
*



 
 

)
*
,

 
!



  "


!
  *  





*



,








*



!
"

 

:
2

 
,





:
*



,
 !
 






 

 






! ,
" 


 
*


*


,"
, 
!
= 
,
*,



 
 ,"

!
,
!


"
;

 

 
/"
 #


  "
)




"!

 
 


(






!

 

 
,

!
 
!
 *
 
"






"


<






= 

 


 

:
* 
 "

 
 8*,



!
!

 


 
"


"

"

!

8

 
 








 
 

!



"

 


!

(
 
!

 
,
 

 
 8*,

!
"

&



5

 
'"


 





      

!!" # $ %&!'& !!"





 

,


 


!
 
 


 *  
"*
 

""

 



,



 







,
+"
 
 
"



*
 


 

 "*

 

 

:
*



!"



 


999
!"
 


 

"*,

!
!

 
 

<


* 





!


"! * 



'"
2*
>
!)

 

9& 


'" 5

=?!
",
'"

( $)

 & $* 

$ @
%'

+ ,  --! !
 


 
 !



!"

 


",



 


 "!
* 



!

 

* 
 
7
* 







A",
2* 
" 
1

 
'"

(


 (((

 
'" 
(
= 



!


33
,,

 
'"


=



(

!,

'"
2* 
"

1-- 

 
'" 
(




",


*
 

 
!


 

!"


 
!"

"


 


 





 

!
 
,

-


=?!
",
'"

 
" 

"*,


B $*.  ) $  &.  / 

 00 $

@
!

-+ , !
*
"
 

 **
"!
* 
*

 
*


!
 8 <

$

 

"*,

"

"    

                           

   

   

  



     
 
   !"   # $ %    & '()*+ (

*,-  .


  

/ "   0


   

 /  /1 ( 2 
      

         /

   /       / /  

   3   

/
 4 / 
     

      3              /     
 
    
        
     
3 ()

5    3 5       3 5  
    

  

 "   3    "

     
 

  /  
 
         
 3 5  "

 /    

>




 

        
 /      7, 2  

                

  / /  
    
    



    
   
  

    /

 
   
  

   0
 "   8

   0   # '()9(+

**, / 

                     

  
   :               :      
  /       
     /              

    ; 
          

           
          
         
     
    /   
  
     
   

      2

/ /    6     $    '()9<+

(=          /
 

           = 2   
   " / /    
  /        
 *,,   

      (< 2 
           
     
     
 >   = 
 *,,   

       

1 -!!

1 

$  $  $  2   0   $*  3 $3   0  2  $ $*4

!              /=





#
 / 
   

  /  

  

         
      
         /    /

/
  

         
 *,,   

     /        " /             
  /        

 

      

  
  
= (
 





!


 '"


"
2* 
 "
 
" 



 " *


!
 
,
" 
!



!


 !








,
 ",


,"
!
 "
,


 

* 

"
)
,  , 





 
 


 
 8*, 


" "


"
!"







 
 
=





 "!

:
2


 


 

,
*
 



*
 

!" 
:
2


"*
 


 




 
#--&
(
 

*
 


 


*"
 
 


 
 8*,
 










2 -----%
.;
0

#

'+"
 



  

 

 

 

,"

!

,
 
 !

 

:
2

 
!
"

 
 * 

C
$D

",
.,0
 



 
, ,

(

,

 



,
 
,"

!






,
 

!

 

:
2


  ,"



"


"

 

 
,
 

! "

 


* 

C
$D

",
.,0
  


 
, 
,

(

 

,"



 

 



 
, 
,

 
 
!


""

C
9D

", 


 2 -----%
.;
0
 

!


 

 
 
 

 
,

,, *+*  +















 

) >  
)*%  E%8 >  
!  E%8