High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/707/2013allowed

Harmesh Singh @ Manga v. State Of Punjab

2017-11-25Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan8 pages

# $%&%!'(

* +, &- /

***00 11 2 +&3&

3'4

*** &0!'# '

( 67

* + & '(

+*+'

!!#9 #8!$

7 .

%# !3'& 1

001%$ ':

+&*'43 +!+ ##1*9 3'4

;;;;

#%+ $ #

$!'8%$%!'

& ' '$ <* *

&& # ##%%!'

&&%!'& 3#. 9

8%# >-%$-

$!'8%$ #

& ' '$ #

3'# +( :&

,0+%&!', '

# "

=, '

"%'

+& +%.!+!3& %,0+%&!', '

&* 9:

+& &* :

&%@ ,!'-& )?

,!'-& &*):

,!'- 11 & ' '$ & !+# + # +3'

$!'$3++ '1=*

'!%$ #

'!*

3'# +(

A***

)*)*

B31# 0

1!'.>%- !- + !""%$% 1& 0+%8

8 -%$1 $!'' $%!'

+!11%'.9

#03+ ++% +9 01

>- + &!'

--%

1!'.>%- ' 0- > , +C +=

"" $

.+%$313+%&* '

D*)*

5!3

'!!'9 > '

-!3& ' 0- >

0%0

-3

$+= +!!,* > '

%'&%# +!!,

'## 3.- + 0+!& $3+%@

3.- + , +C &-9 + &%# '

2%11 4.

+-9

. #

5!3

+& ,!'-&9 %&%'.

A $-!

$-!F

+, &- + 1 %8 9

. #

5!3 +&9 &!'

- ,0 + &%# '

2%11 4.

+-9 #!%'.

%' +$!3+& '# 3.- + 0+!& $3+%@

-+ '%'.

C 0 ,3,9 >%11 C%11 - +* 5 $ ' +8!3& & %'.

"!+ & %# 0%&!# * %& #

& %'.

-%,9 +, &- /

"1 #

&0!

" + 1%"%'.

$1!- &*

&C # '## 3.- + $1!- &* " + +%'.

$1!- &9 '## 3.- + + # > 0%'.

!1# -%,

+, &- /

$!,,% # >-%1 & %'.

1!'

-!3& *

1&!

-+ - +*

%, 9 ' 0- > , +C .!'

-!3& '% $ B+%&-'

8%11 #303+9

* %& 3.- +%'1

'4% 3+ .!'

0+%8

-!&0%

,5 >- + #!%'.

4!5

> 0 +* G- '

'4% 3+ $C

-!, 8 '%'.9

'## 3.- + 0+!& $3+%@

++ !$$3++ '$ * 5 $ ' +8!3&* G- '

, +C

-!, 9 - = #%&$1!& # !$$3++ '$ -%,* - = -%'C

- = ''!

++= - %+ 3.- +

- = %'&31 # &!$% =* - = 5 $ 3'# + # 0+ &&%!'* '

&%&

"!+ & %# , '9

+ .%& + #*****F

$!,01 %!'

%'8 &%.

%!'9 + 0!+ 3'# + $%!'

+*** "%1 # !3+9 &%& >-%$-9 $- +. & 3'# + $%!'&

?9 <)

"+ , #

$$3& #9 >-%$- .3%1=

$1 %, # 1*

0+!8 %& & 9 ,%' # G

+* &-> '% G 0+!& $3+%@9 G

'4% 3+9 G)

B31# 0 G?

+* +0+ 3+ - 1%> G '%

GD 3+5 $- %'.-*

, '9 3'# + $%!'

+**9

# '% #

%'$+%,%'

%'.

-%,

# # 1& %,01%$ %!'*

# " '$ 9 G

3+9 G %'# + 3+9 G

.#%&- G< 3+0+ 3+9 G) +8 '

B3, +9 G?

B-3&-% ,9 G

'4% GD '%9 GE !9 G 3+# 8 3+9 G

3+5 $- G

3+, G

G < 5- ,%' #* " + .!%'.

-+!3.-

+%'.

$!3'& 1 +% &9 +' # $!'8%$ #

& ' '$ #

%'#%$

5!8 * ..+% 8 # $!'8%$%!'

& ' '$ 9

$$3& # "%1 #

$!' '# # +' # $!3'& 1

11 . # !$$3++ '$ !!C D*)* + 0!+ # $!,01

)*)* &%& >-%$-9 %+&

'"!+, 0!+ 1!#. #

'* -3&9

3' @01 # 1 =& 1!#.%'.

%+&

'"!+, 0!+* "3+- + &35,% #

0 + , #%$!1 .

+ 0!+9 %'43+= "!3'# 0 +&!'

0+!& $3+%@*

- + 0+!8

$!,,% #

11 . # 0 *

#3= & '# .%'

&> 5&9 $1!- &

%'' + +&

51!!#&

+- 79 >-%$- $!31# $!'' $ -%, $+%, 9 #!' *

+' # $!3'& 1 "3+- + $!' '#&

H3 ++ 1

!!C D*)*

5 > '

,%1= 5!- +% &9

1& 1= %,01%$ & *

5 "!+

.%&+

?*)*

#,% #

5 %'.

0+ &&3+%& # .%8

D*)* .!

+ $!+# #*

$!'+ +=9 +' #

$!3'& 1 &300!+ # %,03.' #

&35,% #

$!,,% # - %'!3& $+%,

=!3'.

.%+19

. #

5!3

,!'-&

%, !$$3++ '$ *

!"" '$ $!,,% #

'#& #31= 0+!8 # + $!+#*

+# +' # $!3'& 1 +% &

.!'

-+!3.- + $!+# - %+

&&%& '$ *

) ,!!

0!%'

%'8!18 # $!'&%# +

>- - +

##3$ # 0 9 +%$31 +1= &%,!'= +3&>!+-=9 $+ #%51

>!+-= + 1% '$ I

8 + $%= # 0!&%%!'

+!& $3+%@ G ' #& #%&$3&& # -+ #5 + * ,%' # #3+%'.

>- + ++ %1& !$$3++ '$ 5 "!+ !3+*

G 9

D*)*

!!'9

1!'

-!3&

- + * 3.- -!1#

- '

,!3-

$!,,% #

>%&- &* "3+- +

# 0!& #

-+ ' #

C &

'!%& - '

>%11 1%,%'

- +*

'%, 9 '#"

& %'.

-%,9

&0!* !> 8 +9 '#"

- +6& 3'$1

# 0!&%%!'

&0 $%"%$ 11=

#!!+& +!!, 5!1 # %'&%#

+# -3

$+= $!,%'.

5!1 # +!!,*

"3+- + # 0!& #

>- '

' + # +!!,9

+, &- "!+$%51= $!,,%%'.

& @3 %' +$!3+& '## 3.- +* - '

%& # -3

$+=

&0!

" +9

+, &- /

0%$C # $1!- &

"1 #

&0!* &!+= 03"!+- & ,& $!'$!$ #* & +!!, 5!1 # %'&%# 9

5 $!, & $+3$%

>-!

!0 ' # #!!+* & 0 + # 0!&%%!'

G<9 >- '

' + # +!!,9

$!,,%%'.

%' +$!3+& 0+!& $3+%@* -!3& ,%##1 8%11 . *

!+ !8 +9 @01

-!> >- '

>%' && %& # -3

$+=9

-!> '!5!#= ' %.-5!3+-!!#

$ # &0!

&0!*

+* +0+ 3+ - 1%>

#%$ ""%$ +9 %8%1 !&0% 403+ >-!

$!'#3$ # , #%$!1 .

,%'

0+!& $3+%@9 # 0!& #

&+3..1 +C&

%'43+= +C& '!%$ # !8 + 5!#= 0+!& $3+%@*

G $+!&& @ ,%'

&0 $%"%$ 11= # 0!& #

%& #

+% # &!0

$!,,%%'.

- +*

,!'- !1# >- + &9

!1#

%, !$$3++ '$ *

'= + &%& '$ 0+!& $3+%@9

>!31# +C&

%'43+= 0 +&!'

0+!& $3+%@* 3 & 9

0 + , #%$ 5+!3.- + $!+#9 %'43+= +C 0 +&!'

0+!& $3+%@*

!'1=

$!,

>- '

+# $+% & +!!,9 '#%'.

!3&%# *

& ,& %,0+!5

'#"

+%'.

$+% & >!31# %#1 * 3+- + + ,

,=& +=

>-!

!0 ' # #!!+

5!1 # %'&%#

$!, >-!

>%' && #

$!,,%%'.

0+!& $3+%@* - + @01

-!> ' + # %'!

+!!,*

$%+$3,& '$ &9 " 1&

0!&&%5%1%= 1& %,01%$ ''!

+31 # !3

1&!

$!, + $!+#

$%8%1

1%%.

0 '#%'.

5 > '

+% &9

#,% # G 9

- = 8%&%%'.

+,&

1%%.

0 '#%'.

5 > '

,%1% &*

!+ !8 +9 3'# + $%!'

?< +***

?*)*

#,% #

5 %'.

0+ &&3+%& #

+ $!+# #*

# 0!& # $+!&& @ ,%'

51!!# $!9 @01

>-= 51!!#& & '

7* #! & - + * - + 3' @01 # 1 & 8 '

=& 1!#.%'.

* & 0 + 0+!& $3%!'9 .!'

8%11 #303+ 8%&% &%& +*

1&!

0+!8 # + $!+#

#%& '$ 8%11 4.

#303+ -+ -!3+&* @01 "!+-

+ 3+' # 8%11 #303+ 8%11 4.

)*)*

- '

+ .%& + #9

$$ 0

11*

0 #

$$3& #9

, && $!31# $!'8 = # - +9 >-!

#%& '$ -+ -!3+& !'1=*

!+ !8 +9 >- '

11 . # $!,,% #9 '#"

8 += ,3$- 8%11 4.

1&!

,!- + + 3+' # -!, 8 '%'.

" + #!%'.

4!5* $!31# + 0!+ # %- + - ,*

&+ '!3.-

0+!& $3+%@9 >-!

+ .%& + #9 ,%' #

>%' &&*

&%.'%"% &

8 '& 00 '

'' +9 0+!4 $ #* - + "!+ 9 # 1 1!#.%'.

+ , 3' @01

0+!& $3%!'*

8% >

5!8 9 " 1&

0+!8 %& 5 =!'# #!> &!'

#!35* !'& H3 '1=9

11!> #

%,03.' #

<* *

&%# *

$H3% # $- +. & "+ , #

-%,* %& %1:

&3+ = 5!'#&

#%&$- +. #*

.&8

G- - + &0 C%'.

&!' #I & :

G- - + + 0!+ 51 I & :