Sultan Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"!
#$%% &' &
& (
& )$* ') % &+ &%
% ,,,, + &%
- %. '/ !" #$%&#%#' ( )*+* , - " -- +
!"!#!$!# #
%!&! '
#
$ ( &!
$
(
% &
#
(
) " ' *+,-! ) + + * .+ " %/%'#%#0
(1 ,
2 + + '$#3 +( + "4 5 "5 + ".+ - !+ 16 + #%%'#%'7 1
"+ -8"9 -( 1+!--
- "" + ("
- -( (
- + 9 - .+ !-6 1+ !--
- , - 8" 9 +
" - 5+ +-
" +"
- -( " (+
+ * -8"9
" " + -* - " + 4 - - - 8" 9 "
, - #%%'#%'7 4 + ,! 5+- .+ - 9
- " ( - + + - + #%%'#%'7 6 + +" 8"( " ( " )(+ 1 -
" - -
+ + : " -
"
+ #%%'#%'7+
+ " #0%'#%'7 ;+ " - < " - " 8" 9 1 , + *" +
--%/%0#%'79
- .+ (1++ + '7%3#%'7 +(-+ + (4.+ 6 " " 8" 9 (
- + -- - *" " - 9- + *" +
+( + %0%7#%'7 " - + ( "
+ " +- ".+ "
(
+ (4.+ 6
- "+ - + -
+-+
( + '7%7#%'7 "" ( + - - + ( 4 5 "5 #/%7#%'79
!+ !=:/&/%> #%'7 *" " + -- (+ %&'%#%'7 !+ ( " 4 5 "5 " 2+ 4 - #>%##%#% 4 5 " 5 + + - " -
( + ( " " + !!!.
/
0
! 1 (2
3
!4
5 &/
6
# (
! .
6
78'
'8#- 93 1 (
: 6
# (
0
8
!"
!
/
!
$
!!!
- - - ( - 8"9 - -( ":>' #%'7%#%/#%'7
( )*+* , + '% #$?'@ , )*+*
#%'# *" " + 9 - ( ( )*+* , - " -(" + ( +- 4 5 " 5 "
( ( +" )*+* , %'%/#%#' ( 9 )*+* , (
- #$%&#%#' ( -*" -- (2 ( , + + + ( #$%&#%#' 1 , 2 " + +'$#3 +( +
+ " -A +-A
+ '0%'#%## ( #>%##%#%
( 4 5
"5 +"( + - " + - - (- 9 :' - " - A +-A + #3'%#%##+ +'$#3 +( + ( + - + &B ( - - 9 !=:'$#7> #%#'" -- - ( )*+* , " - A +-A + '0%'#%## #3'%#%##
( :#9 ( !+
%7'%#%#/( " + ;! <
$
,;!+,!*+** "
3 (*, *=!,+!*+**"
3(*>
,+
!
' !>
!
&
*-!+?!*+*, "
3 (,-
/ !@ 9"< #$%&#%#'
( )*+*, --+ " " - * + + ( " ( +(- '#'%#%#/ ( 1 , 9 :#A1 ,
-+" %/%'#%#/ " - A +-A
+ '0%'#%## #3'%#%## 4 5 "5 + "
.+ - (" *
" "
+(" ( .+
( + "" ( !+ - "+ )*+* , 2 +
+" A + " - + + + )*+*, + , )*+*
#%'# 9 )*+* -- + )*+*, ( + +-(+
+" " ;4 4 "+ #$%&#%#'
( )*+*, + -"
- + " " + + #%%'#%'7 + -8"9 " " *" - - ", + +(- + ( - - - - " -8" 9 +(-( " ("
( - , )*+* ,
"( +" , +( ( - (
" ( ( )*+*, 9 "+ + --
( -! .+ "
(" (( 4 + +(-
(4 5 "5 ( (
, ! ?+ - @ + #%'$ (+ + +( - "( )*+*,
2- "< 4 + "+- +"-
!
"
"#$%
&"'()
*+ (", (
! ('
+ "(
&
* " ;4 + (
+( )*+*, 4 + " +" +- ( (
C " + -
2-
( )*+*, + (
- 4 - +
( )*+* , - - " - .+ +(- ( " %7%7#%'79 - +
6! ' 6#8 #!6 #
8A
1
)7 (
,#
(
# < %(# (
* "#$# #
> %& '
#
# :!! ' (
; 6! '0 1B .8 7& (
! *! $
5 2
.87& (
!.
*+!+,!*+,CC++ (6
6
# (
! "#$# #
%& '
#
3 /
!" (
5 !
/ 7!&!
0
'
/ & .
7!&! '
/&. 5
&
% (
#%. & (
7#(
#%.
&&A
# ! .
*;!+,!*+,C
#%. (
# & 7#( &
$'! 5
*+!+,!*+,C *=!+,!*+,C! .
*=!+,!*+,C 5 (:$ '/!&
#
(
!&
#!(! # <
"#$ # #
%& '
#
! D
$ !
>! "
7 : (
%
!
!&
0
0
! ;! / E"E #!# <: 7#(& (
*+!+,!*+,C
(
& '(
5 #
& /
& /
7!&!
(
# $ # #
& .
! 5
*+!+,!*+,C
.87!&!(
A$(
(
'
#
# #
! # $ # <
1!*?*+!+,!*+,C
(
( #-8F %D7"(
! 6!# < #%.
(!#!& (
"#$# #
1!=*?8(
%&'
#
1!,CC8(
5
(
!#
! *;!+,!*+,C
# <7#(!
/E4E *+!+,!*+,C5
3
0 !" 5
"#$# #
%&'
#
5 (
#
! 4 ! 3
0 5
0 5
!
"#$# #
%&'
#
8 >?> ) >>* $(&! &&A /
/
! $
"#$# #
%& '
#
(
.
/
(
7 !$
/
!$ #%.# < $'
!#
#%.# <
/
B # < #%.
!
!#
"#$ # #
%& '
#
B
$'
!
#!(!(
# <
"#$ # #
%& '
!"
% 9// # < #%.
"#$ # #
%& '
#
B
$'
"#$# #
%&'
#
B
8>?>)>>* $(&! 4 + ( " - 8" 9 - A" 2- #%%'#%'7 + + 4 + - -8"9
+- -+ + /&//#/ 4!4 ( " 4.+ 6 + .+ *
!!9 "
+ - 11 - .+ + --( -
+ ".+ - + .+ -- - .+
+ " - ( - A +- + + (
-8"9 9 + 4 "" " +(-
.+ +( ( +" - (+ ( -- - " 4 ,+ 6 5+- "";4 " *" " " "D( - -+
( " ( 4 + ( " ,+ 6 "+ + + + " - 6 ( - "
+ * +" - " 9 )*+*, - .+ ( 5+- +- 1+ + ! " - ( 8"9 "+ "-" + -( -
+ 9 + "+ -.+ " -4 +
+ -.+ "
- + - + - " + - - + - " + - ( + ( "++ - 8"9 +
"
" + - ( - -+ "
+ 9 )*+* , ( ( +" " ++ + 4 + - .+ + " +" ( "(+ - ( + -8"9 " .+
" ( (+" " -" -
+ 8"9
+(
4 ( )*+*, (" -( +" ( " - 8" 9 -
--
+ /&0 4! ;4 +" ( " 9 + + - " ( ( +" : ( " " - + - 9 - + - " " "D( (+ +( .+ ( (+ "
- ( - 8" 9 ( ( D ( .+ (
+ + "
" , + + - .+ (" - + "( .+ - 9 - .+ "" "(+
+ (+ ( + +" ( +( + -(- 4 ( )*+*, - .+ (.+ -+ "" (" (4 5 "5
( "
( 1
<+ " + + -- + -( )*+*, +
.+ - + ?
@< ?
@ + "+ 9 -- - ( - ( A
+ " ;4 " 9 -- .+ "-
92
+ + + +
.+ + ( + 9 --+ +"--
- ./ +( 9 -- :?@- ( )*+*, + (- " ;4 9 2
"
+( )*+* , "4 5 "5
, ! ?+ -
@ + #%'$ 4 5
"5 + G$
!$
+-!+*!*+*+
!7
#!5 &/ !!*+!+,!*+,C!
#(8(
.
/
0
! 1 (2
3
! 4
5 &/
6
# (
! .
6
78 '
'8 #- 93 1 (
: 6
# (
0 8
! "
!
/
!
$
! %
#(8(
,C!+C!*+,C ! "
%& '
#
1!,CC8(( !@ 4 - + (
+ "
- .+
+ - " < -- -(4.+ 6 '7%7#%'7 - -
9
+ .+ "
+ ( .+
+ 4.+ 2 + G$
$
7 2
*+!+,!*+,C
(
& '(
"#$#
&!'0<,+;C8(
7!&!&.
5 & .
1B '0 ! %
0 /
! 5
"#$#
%&'
"#$ # ! " 5
1B '0
"#$ # 7(. :
"#$# %&'
! $
/
#
!
/
5 0
!$ #%.
/
!" 5
/
6
# 5
! $ 6
'
# - 93 1
16
# (
7(. :
6
# "#$# %& '
5 5
!6
6
! 4
/ $
!$ "#$ # =*?8(
%& '
,CC8(
5
! $ /
!@ 94 5 "5 - - "( + " 9 - )*+*, +
+ "
9 "+-
, 2-" +( .+ ("
+ !+ D + ##$ ! + 4 " ( +" ( !+ + " + + - ( + + +
+ +( " .+ + " -
+ ( (+ , +( .+ "
+( )*+*
+ + ("2-( !+ 2 + ##$ ! + 4
4 ( !+ * +
( +( " ?@ 9 ( (
-"--( ("
( - 8" 9 + " " +
" +
+(- - "
+ (
+ ?@ 9 " - - + - (- - - + ?@ 9 2
* + - "11 " - "D( -+ 2 "- " - ,E(+ -!+ 4- F&%(
1"2(0 "
3004
-/ -/ 55
%
-" " ;4 " "D( ? @ 9 - - "
( 4.+ 6 1+ +
" - .+ (" + - 4.+ 6 - "
+ " ( ( ?
@ 9 1+ + - !!9 " ( + 4 ( )*+*, + ( ( "
+" ( -- " 4.+ 6 + + .+ " ?
@ 4 4.+ 6
- " -( +( - -
( "+" " - - 9
2 - (
( + "
+- " - - 1 , " 8" 9 + "" + +
-" -8"9 " +-
-+( +(-+ + + +
-( ?
@ 94.+ 6 4 5 " 5 + ( ( A
- -- "
"
2( -4 " -8"9 + (
4.+ 6 -* -- *"
- " ?
@ 9 2 4.+ 6 ( 4 5 "5 - ( 9 ( +- "+ (
"
( + - +" + (9
+( )*+*, + (" - (+ +( +- 2
+ (
+ 9 4 E + " + + + " (
( + )*+*, - - ( .+ ".+ ( " (
)*+* , ( 1 , 4 -- -!+ G44
( )*+*, -( " ( + )*+* , + +- ( - ( - (
+ ( !+ 2 + ##$ ! + 4 !+ * "D
( 4 5 "5 ( ( "" (-4-
( 1 , "4 5 "5 + .+ - (
9
" -
" .+ &%
/ (
- 6 +
2/
8 H81 2 H81