High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11818/1999dismissed

Avtar Singh v. Commissioner U\W.C.Act & ORS.

2017-07-05Mr. Justice Darshan Singh9 pages

!"#$%&$%

! " #

&' () '"( )*'

+ ,

!"( )$*& #+ !'*& # " , -"& # ./

, . $!+ ' $' !+

+! &' + # ' ' '

!+ 0- # ' "- # '

& ! ''

# #

1 +-'1 "'&' -

%) 33345- '-''6 ## #

"'-6' + #" " # 77)+ ' +"'# 6 # "' + &'-&, '& &

&++ % 8- &2- 3- & "#'- +9+

2 # ' ' '

" ! # 6"

# ! #" +-+

%-' + 6 % #'%

" #& ./

;#< ;

< . = #' :

& ! > & ''?+&6 ', !+ " !

' + "'- +

' -1 +'

"- # ' 1

"" # #' + %

" # %- "'&

0 6

''+ ""'# + #"

"#2 #%-

) 3&

845""'- ' 333@23@..02 %- 33& " # ' 6

#" ''"-+ ''+ A .B" 6

"" - + ) 3&33345#% " @ ## % # ) 83&

845% " C ''- / =# + + & & '-& ' "+ "' " " C "- - "' #->+

"' ""'# 8?

'-&

@52 @" %

3 6@#+ "" .D ""'#

E5 ;.6#+

# %- ""% /6+ ""# %-

26 @ " + "

+ !+' D6+#!+% '-+# #- + %

< 2 6 ' "

# "

. ?

'-&

6""'# %

# # + ! ".0 ? -&

0$ + ,F "& #"" .

"# &+ "- 9 # # '

" &'4= % # " + "" % """ -/ #&

06 + "

" # # ' '-"" %- / #&

0&"" " 6# + ! " "'&

0+# ' #'+ " &% ""

"# + >' # &

+ "

4 +- # '#-"#

+ '%'-* &""'# @"+ +

' + -

"" " % G - + " &""'#+

. ?

'-&

@5D"

' D 6

%-)$*&' '

"#''"

+ "" # # #+

# " ''-" C ) '8 +#"

""'#%'"# #>+ # % "

"$ # ' "'&

0 +#

% #'

# "" ''- " C %-'+1

+ ' +' + ' * # ' ' "'-1@ =>)+ ' %- &5" '# & '+# + !+ "'- > ##

# &" "

+'%'->+ #

- '

"" ""'# '+- $

+''%# ' &!"+

+## # !+% "# '-#" #-#

5 8 H "

" ,F "& #+

# ' % " " ' "" %

$ 1+& # +

'##

#6--%" " ''-$ &% # '+ + - +@ '+ %-

$ > .0 ? -&

0+# # + !

" #6# +

"'# ## #

''+'-# # =%+#9 # # + '6@ / #&

'-# +'# """ -'> '-"" # ' # !+' &

#''''- %-

""'# + 6

" "# ' / #&

0''

.27#%&

0++ + "

& '' ""'#+ " G- -

"# @"6 ' " + ' #+" # 0 6

-%## " + '%'- %- - +- "# > # *&+ # % "

' "%- " > % + ' %% &%

6 + '+ > "+ " # '$ & * + ' %##" 1+&# '""

# " #%-@

# & - " #

""# # +# +

#+' #> # ' @ "# '

# '&+ !+#+ # ' 6#" ' #+

# " ## '6

' # "

"'&

0+# E5 ;=#' &$ # " * + " ' &

+# ' % # %#! . % # %#!> "

" '-& ' ""I@5"# -% % 7 - %

@ 2D

#& , -"& ' # ' . / "

" #

' %-" #2

7 I ##& 0. #.0 F''

#& + ##

6 "

# ' %- " 6"& " #2 >

##& # 8 I ##+ ' '

#"'- 3 > ' +" &+ "

#> # " '+

6 &+ + "

"# # " # C '

" '+# + 6 +- > + ' ' " #/ # '%'- "-

#" "'- " '9 - #

+!%- ## # "'- &

"'- ''%'%'"-#" +! " ">> #>+ - " "- #" " ' " # %#

'%'- #

''" & & # "" ##%##" #

%' '&

% 'C '+ '

"& - ""' " #/ # "

1 ""'%

' &-+ ' %"5C #/3 .

#6+" %'- ""' "

#/3 # &

""'# @5" &+-'6"- " + .2 7#%&

0 @5/ . ?

'-&

@5D9#""'# @5" + > +"

+ + '

+"%-'

+ ""' #/3 #%- "' "

+ %- !" ''##' '+>

% '9

# % %-

& # + %'- . > # % 4#"

2 @58 +'' 6" # '' ##" ) 03345 + ) ..3345' - " # ' -

7 # "&*

+ ' !#"'- "##

+###

'- '#

- "# '' % ' ''' > '

- '+%#

# . . # +# "

"- #" ''% #%''-+

% # #. # / 6 - # #" #

# 0 #& " #% - ## + % ## #&

9 +%-+!'C - #" "'- " ' 9 - #

"'-& ''% '' "

" #'%'- -" "-#" #6

'- # +! + '' ' &9 #' # - + 4 +''' " 2 = - # %& >

% 'C '+' "+# ## '-

/ , 0 #%&$% =, "!4 J

)"%' J