M/S Abw Suncity v. Tarun Malik And ORS
!"
#$%$ & #' ( #)$$
) *+,$ - ,-
! " # $ %"$ &'
()
! *"
"# $ % '
!""# $ %"
( '+,--'.,./) - . $!
/ (/) " ! " 0
" 1" $
%
1
%
0%*23'/4
!
(.) "
"
% " %&
1 0
$ &
$0&% !! ' '+5'.,./ '/-'.,./ '+7'.,./ '.7'.,./ '.-'.,./ '.9'.,./ '.5'.,./ '7.'.,./ '84'.,./ (8) :"%% # 0
'* '.7'.,./
'* '/5'.,./26 '+5'.,./
'* '/4'.,./26 '/-'.,./
'* '.,'.,./26 '+7'.,./
'* './'.,./26 '.7'.,./
'* '..'.,./26 '.-'.,./
'* '.8'.,./26 '.9'.,./
'* '.+'.,./26 '.5'.,./
'* '.7'.,./26 '7.'.,./
'* '.9'.,./26 '84'.,./
'7.'.,./
%"%% #%
0
1! '7.'.,./
'.7'.,./
(+) ;
% " $ &'
'
""& 1 0"
'7.'
.,./0 !!
%"
(7) ;
'
"" " '* './'.,./
'.7'.,./0 !!
0"%%" ()
(-) '7.'.,./"0 % 0
%
//(-)%"0
*
#/44- & " %
! % 0 "
"
(9)
% " "& " &" "
1 & " "
! !
%"
10%"
./,/.,./#"
* "
%" $
./,/.,./2 " #
&
0"
,4,4.,.,
0% &&/ 1 2 -3(&4 " $ 5 6 $ - 6
!! $ (5) "% '* '.7'.,./ & %
'7.'.,./
<;22
/ & " //+
/7/**& "
$ & " ./,/.,./ 0 "
* 2 $ &
% 0"%%"
# "0
""
()%&"! $ ()
./,/.,./ " 1 $
" $ ()"%% """$ 0=
"0 %!" %0
(4) "
1#
% "
'$ &
" ""
./,/.,./"
"
&"1 $
"$
%!" $
"""$ 0=
0
0"
* # " $ " $
"
% " $
%
1 1
2
"
% " $ &'
()()
() " 1 $ "
>&$#
"
"""
0$ %"* " !%"
1
#"%#
"$ &
"$ &
()
()0&
"1
%" $ &
1
"
! %" 0 (/,) $ & % " 0$# "
*
%
!
0$
%=
#
" ?
% " $ &
()
() " 1" "
% "
()
"1 !
1# ./,/.,./ (//)
& % " "& " ,8,8.,./
$ &
&
'
8/,8.,./# " ! & = ,7,+.,./ 2 " ! !# $
&
!
"
1
1#" !&"
(/.) "
* % " %
"
# "
% "
% "
"
//(-)%"/44-
"0
> @0A
1%"
0 (/8) ;
0 !
1 %
"
1
"" " $
1
"
= & B";;CD6EF
7+#C%* #
1! 2 " "
&
& " " ;
0
1 6//54 //48 .5,4.,,-
0
6.8/ /,/,.,,9 0 " &
*
3 ! #> 2 "
1" %
#"
" 0 ! 6'/,,/#/,":#'&# $
,7,..,,5
"% "
% G
H ! 1! @ 8,,9.,,4(.)"
" " %
" 1"
%$ % "
6.+$
! /,/,.,// (/+) "
# " "
"
1
0 0
0 " !
% " H ! 1! @
0?
#
% $ "
! "
0 G
1 "
$
/+,5.,/8
"
$ %" ! &
"
$"
"
" * *'.,%"1! 8,,9.,,4# "
1
1 ! ! % " G# G* " #" 0 % ! %G & 0?
& 1
! 0"
$
G
(/7) "
1# %! "
1 % " 0 % "
0
2 ".,,8#">
G#.,,8 & $
%$
%G "
"% 1
" % >
!
"
"& ">&$# "=
1! 0"> @0
!*
%
# "> C$
! % G>&$#% " =
1! # " > C$ '1 !
%
0
0
! "
!" %!
"!
"! ! " H> $ G *!
"! % * #.,/-@ /.,4.,/-%" $%G
2
!
// % " " "
$ &"
%" ! & $ "
"! 0 %
*'2 ,-/..,/-
1# 3
EG
G *!!
( )# C 1! (E) $
.,,/.,/9
! .9,/.,/9
"
!
.9,-.,/9# " % "
() 0 "
0 %
?
"! !
! %!
% /#5,#-59'& "
8, %
1&"
"
"0$ 0" ! %%" 1"$ !
1& " "!!0%"
%
#"&$#&
$
B
$
F 0
* 89/-8.,/4& "
% !!
89%**% $% .#.9#---' 1& "
2 "
# "
"
!%!$
5%"/44-
1"" 0
00& "
#"%# !
& "
&"
"
" 1" 0 $
(5) "%# " 0 !
1%
* 97%"1! 8,,9.,,4
/7,/.,.,
1 " ! &" ! 0 % =
% "
2 # "&$# " "
()#
"&$#
1 $ 2 "
"
%" " "0 #"
& 0
0 " 0 # "&$#
$ & " =
1! % " > @0
! *
! "# $%!$ & ' (
)! *
+! , # " " %
//(-)%"/44- %
! %" 0
" "
" ,4,4.,., 0"
6/8+%.,.,&"0"
"
3
A
10 (4) (/-)
0$# "
* $
./,/.,./ "
% " 67. % .,./ "
1 "%"$ 0
"%1
% & 0
"""$ &
'* '.7'.,./&
"
6
%"$ &
& ,8,8.,./ % 8/,8.,./ 2 " $ &
# & " " $ &
0 &
" 1 1
"
! % 0 ;
% " $ &
()
()" % & 1 .+,8.,./2& " "
& 1 0 0"%%$ &'
()
()
"
! (/9) >
(/5) : " %
0$#
% " "
#"
%
!
" ! 0
%" (/4) " % 0= %
% " $ &'
()
() ""
% 0"%%
%
$
() % 0 " I0% " * $ A
1 (A3 $ )# C 1 J
0 " H @ % %
1 " ! 0 2
% "
#
0 %
1 .. % " # " " 0 1! #&"
"& %" 1! &
G
" ! %
$ % " 0 " 1" "
/7,/.,., 2 " "
&
" 0 G
!!
"G
% :
"" %
% " $ &'
()
() "
% #
" "
5%"/44- #" 1 "$
" "
"
% 0
0&
2 "
1 # " G
0 "
" & 1 1 "&
1"
%"
"
'
! (.,) ;
"&$ "
% " 0$ & "
1" 1""
%
"
% 0 # "%# "
& !
0# "&$# " "
% %"
" 0 " "
" &
5%"/44- %
"
$ 0 % " 0 ;
0
!
1%
"
6/%" "$ &
%
'* './'.,./ " "
1
! $ 0 " $ &'
()
() //(-') " 0 !
$
!
# .,/4 ;
% "
% " "" " % 0 +8
$
% " $%!
#&"
" 0= !% " $! !
.%"
% "% 0 "
# %"%0$ # !
%"!
%"
1 (./) "
%
%
" %
2
0 1"%"
% !% ""
%
(
"
)
"
" %
5 % " /44- 2 . % "
# " %
'
"
" " "$ 0
1 " 0 1" 2 7 % "
# " %
"$
$ ""
# "!
(..) "
0= 0
% " $ &'
()
() " %"
% 9%" /44-
# & "&"
#"
%%
0& " %
"
% "
;
"
1
1
# !
%
88%"& 1 ""0 $
" ! 1! G
G
% $
2 "
0"
$
" " 1$
$
"0 +,%" $
>#"%# " +,%" $
" * C 1 " "$G $=
"! (.8) ;
0!
1%
/ %"
%" %
'* './'.,./ " "0$ %"$ &'
()
()
$ "
%
%
%"
%" >!
%
8-%" $
" " !
% ! 1! 0"$
"0 ! "$0
$
8- % 0
% "
"
' $% && '%%( ) *
! (.+) ;
% " $ &'
()
() % * 8-+/%" $
#%
%&"
"" 0 ! 1 -+ % " & 1 % 0 " $ &'
()
() ;
" % . % "
$
"
% "
!
""!& $ 0"$
"%#" %
%"
() "
%
0 *
()# 0
" #
0$# "
1 "" 0
!
1 !
0 0"
()"
(.7) ;
% " # "&$# " "
()
0&"
"!0"2
#"% 5
1"* $
% 0" #
!
& &" " ! %
! % 0
& "" $ %"0 1!
97
1 " 0 # "
@ 0=
$0= 0
1!
$ "
1! & " %" (.-) :" %' #"
"
! 0 " %
! % 0 2 "
1 # %
! " $ % " =
1! ,5,8.,./
!"-$!$- .-/0)"1!!1
+! * 2 "
=
1! # "
" % %
//(*)%"/44- %
! % 0 % =
%"
0&
" =
1! %
1 A
1 % 3"
> 1" * &
0% " G * 2 " =
1! #
1! ,9,9.,/+
&%
"
=
1! #" &% %0 %
0
1%!A
1%"3"
> 1"* 0 "
#"&$#%"
"
&""
1! &
%
" $ %"=
1!
' "" +)
, -
. *
*
.* / # 0 1 2 2 0 *
* 3
! (.9) "
"
!
%"!" 0 &"!G!
" 0" 1
" G
% 0 1!
" 1 %
% 8-%" $
2 ! " "
1 0$
" %1
0$ " 0
0 %
1%"
"0 !
" " 0$ ! 0$ 2 ! ""
* "1 $ !!
() !
" %1
# 0 " 0 !
"
" & ""
0 "% #
(.5) %"
1
#A
3" "
" ( )#%!A
1%"
#
" 0 >&$#
"
! & 0 0= " 0! 0A
3""
" #
/.%" K & "1 "
"
0& "0 ?
G!
"0=
0"
"!
& "&
$ &% "0$ %"> @0
!*
!"-$!$- (
) (.4) "0 ?
!
"
1& "
!
.4%" (8,) " 0 " 0
%
& " " : "
"
%" #!
!0!
0"
"0 (8/) %" 0%& A
3""
" "1 $
' 4&56 2 $5 8 95599%((%: ;8 %&<'.6::::%: (8.) %
1 " $
% " 0 # "
0%"
!(" 1"$
%
1# %
0)& "
! "%!" %
% %"
(88)
1# " 0 1 & " !
1& "$ &
%
"0$! /.,7.,./ ) ! 676#&!
7