Mohan Lal Kaushik v. State Of Haryana And ORS
-1IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of Decision: 01.10.2024 MOHAN LAL KAUSHIK ..... PETITIONER
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS ..... RESPONDENTS CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA
Present:
Mr. Shvetanshu Goel, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Harish Rathee, Sr. DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Sumeet Jain, Addl. Standing Counsel, for respondent No. 4.
TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA, J. (ORAL)
! " # "
$" % & ' ()*
!
-2- !
" " + , -
! ! "
.!
#!/! 0 + , "
. " !!"" 1 " /!21 3 " ! !
! !
"
/! +&)&#) /! 2 4 . 1 !-44 /! 53 1 !/ 1. 6 7
!
# 8
!"
. ! 2,- ! !
!
$
! 1 19 :+ ,, -
. ,- ! ! !
" 0. !
!" ! ! 1
! " 1;1 :+ # ! ! " !
! ! 1 /!
-3- %. " 7
." ! "
!
< 9
!. "
!! %. " !!""
! . . -,2
$ &=>) $ ? 1 ! @: #"
1 @ !
.
! #1$%
! !! % &>0)7
1 &=>) $ ? 1
8 "
. ,
8 ! .
! !
"
. 22
" ! : # 1 @
1 &=>)$ ? 1
!
9
!
.:#1 " !
!
!
! A: #"
1 @ ! !! % &>0)7
"
#1$%
! : #"
1
2 ! !! % &>0) 7
! 8
! !! % &>0)7
.
#1$%
!!
"
!
#1$%
! !
"
@: # 1 @ "
-41 &=>) $ ? 1 ! ! + 6 !
! "
!! . " !!"" "7
2,
,
1 => &$ ) 1 "
! ( ! !! +-,
"
! B!
! "C#1$
! * !
#!/! 0
!
< 7 C! ! !! +-,
"C7C
/ B/ #
;
! #! /! 0 " ! ! DE .
%. "
C !!
!
:;
B!
! "
C#1$%
+ 6 !!""
.
2 ' "
! (
! . "" 42 !
!! ! " !!
!
" "
!
"
-5-
" " ! " ! 1 " 6 / 1
!
"
(
3
!
! " !! !!""
' ! (
!! !
7
$C -
8 " .F $C -+ $C, , $C2 , !
/ %. " !! ! " "" 6 !
1 "
' ! ( 7
24
! ! +-, @ C B! ! @
. 2, .
. " !!"" 2
! ' "
! (
. 42 / %. " "
" '
-6- ! ( .
< +
! +-,
: ;
B! 1 . /;$ 33C7 +C,C , 2,
!
B!
! "
C#1$%
!
$ C
!""
/ 7
> ,
" / 7
"
! ! . $ C $ C / 7
" ! ! , " .
! !
. ! 2 "
!"
"
" !
B
. "
" ! !
"
= 5 !! . --2&+)/1,4*.
< 4 / ! %. " " " !" "" "
$ "
!
/
"
-7- " " ! !!
"
! !!
"
!" " " !" "
1 G
"
:
@ !
&
) 3 / !""
"
! ""
"
! !"
!"
" "
" "
. E
!!
"
! !
!
" ! "
. 4E -, 2 H3
. $ " .
!
.
"
!
B "
!
"
" "
" "
. "
!
/ !8 .
" "
!.
" "
! C
-8- " ! " !!
1 /! / 4 3 !
! !
" .! + ,
" - ! 1
19 :+ ,, - !
! ! ! 2,-* ! " 1;1 :+ . !" ! !
1 3
! ! " "
-
!
A
" " #
$%&'$&() #*+,-
./ 0 #
12 3 0 4 " 30 ! "
! *,5- 6 3 ! " " C
$ &=>)$ ! !
@ ! @
%. " . 22
-9- ! ' "
! (
C!! % 7
2
" - 4
"
!
" !" ! -,2
/ %. " ! . '
"
!! . " !!"" ( !
!!
-,2
$ C
/ &/.! ) 3 "
! 1 /! # " 8
' ! ( . : .
! !
"
8 C" ! ( .
! ! " !
!! !
!
! / %. "
' C B! ! (. 2,!
B!
! "C
"3 ! ! . ."" 2,
1 /! %. " 7
! #!/! 0
!!
-10- %. " ! C " 4 0. / %. "
7 "
" "
!
" : ! ! !
!
C
" ! !!
"
! !
!
" !! "
!
! 1 "
"" !"
. !
"
"
!
!
! - 3 .
. "
! ! .!
" "4, & "
! ' ! ()
-11- " - 1 8
₹2 ! ! ! !
!. ! ! "
" %. " !.
! "
!& ) C" & ) !! ! ! !" "
!" !
.
! 1 /! (TRIBHUVAN DAHIYA) 01.10.2024 JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No