← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/4526/2016allowed

Dalwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-07-31Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan21 pages

      

   



!"#"

$% & '

('

) *+"$ , "$-.

/''00 **$

,#2# 

2$34 // #0 $ $

(&

#+$

"$-.

/''00 **$

,#2# 

2$34 // #0 $ $

 )

2,5"

"$-.

/''00 **$

,#2# 

2$34 // #0 $ $

 (&

( .5#.

, "$-.

/''00 **$

,#2# 

2$34 // #0 $ $

6% $74*

6,'2# "!

82* "0 "$-.



        

!"##$%#&#'($ ) *

    

!"##+,'-#&#'(- &     

!"##+-.,#&#'(- )   /*      

!"##+,$%#&#'(- 0 ) 10

'

 

 

 

      



   

   

  

   82* "0 "$-.9 '

&2  33 4/3

5   

3      0  /  !"##+,'-#&#'(-  !"##+,$%#&#'(- !"##+-.,#&#'(- !"##$%#&#'($ / 65"7+-  '(.888   

+-$+-.+$'(#&5!  

%     %'   

!  8..

 /

     9/   &         /

 1/3

     

     ,''(-  

  02        4/  " /     

)3 /       

'(#& +-$+-. +$     '(#& 5!   

 

 4

  /  *     /     3     /       

'(#& +$    '(#&5!  

 

     # 

  !  "  #$% 

  &  ' (    &



)*+,-

   

 ).###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  

 * - !" 012

 &' (    &



2*",-

   

 #.###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  



* - 

% !" 013

 &' (    &



)*+,-

   

 ).###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  

 * - !  " 02     "    #$%

   & '(   &



 * -       

  .###/$.      

 

 .        

 &



  

     !  "  #$% 

  &  ' (    &



)*+,-

   

 ).###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  

 * - !  " 02     "    #$%

   & '(   &



 * -       

  .###/$.      

 

 .        

 &



  

     !  "  #$% 

  &  ' (    &



)*+,-

   

 ).###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  

 * - !  " 02     "    #$%

   & '(   &



 * -       

  .###/$.      

 

 .        

 &



  

  

+     !  "  #$% 

  &  ' (    &



)*+,-

   

 ).###/$. 

 

 .        

  &



  

 * - !  " 02     "    #$%

   & '(   &



 * -       

  .###/$.      

 

 .        

 &



  

    

     

2       # 

 :

 /    

%     %'   

!  8.. 6

    '(.888*  2 

  9/   &  10"    

3

    65";<=8>     3

  0        3  ?

* / 70@   4

/ :

 / /

  *

  "    

      " 1   / ! ? 

  

 !

*

 "     3   5     /    

   

   3    3   /'8   /  ! /    0

3  "

%  3 7'8.' '8.% '+888$

 

          /   2

  <  0 ((#'% /

      /  @  10) 

 

7##8$>%,(#$. 8+88$   20   3   @

    0    !

  (888-

 ,'>88-  /  ! /     '+888$   



 

  (888-

,     )3 /      

  /  3       *  2 !33

"

 3?   *

 "   

    / /0 2  1   /

   3*  !33

"  0 / /    *  !33

 

            /  

.88$3?       /



7%%-- '.88$    3  *

 /  70  @      

2     /     *  !33

" * /70@   1   



0?  *  2!33

"

0? *

 "   

  

7%,#%  %%88- /   3

 3 

  3  

 /

/ 3

*  !33

"  0 / /    *  !33

"   3  3  /   7%+-     ,888$  

     *  2  !33

  "  02 3  

   @ 2  3      



2     3  / 

5  2 * /70@   4

/ :

 /  /

*

 "   

  " 1 /! ?

       *    !

  *

  "   33



   

+-$+-.+$'(#&5!  

%    %'   

!   8..   0  



3  65"

- ;<=8>  /

     9/   &   

'(.888 *   

/ 

           3      2      /    **/

   (888-        -88. 



  )3 2 * / 

/   " 1

 /     )3   /    

           /  

/ 3? / !

  /

    3 '8   /  ! /  * /70@     / 

/   :      *

  "    

         02  / 

      2  ?

 3 7'    &/  / / & /       

/

4

/*   /3   / )3 / 2      /     

+-$+-. +$'(#&5!  

%    %'  

!  8..   2   / 2 

    <3 3 2 ',

 =  <3     %%!!*   /

?      

 /    

    02    

   *  2  !33

           3  70@      / 

          /

  /

 3

$ 

      <3 *   /*    

     

       

     / /       # 

    

    3  3   / 33

3  4

/ 

/ *   / 

 /3   / 



 )3 /

    3       *  !

  3  @ ! 

2     0   

  

    

  = / / 3 2

3   /,(#'((  

/0 "

%(A"

%, ?    3  02    02  3  /    3? /  !

 /     

?

 /     ='& / 3  3 

@   

 

 1

 

 2      

 =%1 / 3  3 

       / 3

 "

$ ?  /

" 1 /! ?  *   @/ 

# <3 

23

3   

  =+ / 3  3 

 =,3? /

     / 

.

 !

 10   3'$88+ +(88- (888-   

  ? 

  ?&   2 

  

 3



(888-     /   ?  &     

  02 3  /          ?

 02    

/    2  ? ?!   

 

3 ?* (888-  2 

 10  /  2 / 023 

 / 023   /  0    

 /   ?&  !         /  0     

3    /  ! / 

 023 5 

# <3  

       10 ;

/    



?

  2     

 /

         /      3

     ?

 02  

/ /

 0  ;<   /

 B "3 /   /  / 0      2 

3

0?      /    

 /    

0  3

  /  

     @

 

  0   3    ;<*)    0    /

;<*)>       

    

      0 

       3

 /

  

    /   / / 

/

        <@  

2

   <*?

?!  0  / *  



# <3  

  

     

3   3 =,> " B 9 3 

7'>8->'(>'8  '-88-    3      2 ) 

 10" *  3

 2 * 

! / 



*  2!33

";<=,>  

  3  0  =-*  /   

   3    /  ! /  388% 88. 

3 10/  B3 ! /  %,

3          /    

    /          C "

-((((>#  @ 2

 3  /     C "

-((((>#  @ 2

 )3 /  /     3    

 

/ 3

      33  @  /        !

      ( 

   /  

/     C"

-((((>#    2 3  "



?  3? /  !

 ?    /    3  @ 



    0  2    @    3? /  !

 3

 

   

   ! ? 3 2 " 1 /  

  *  !

  ?    / 

        30  2     

 3 

 3    @ 0   3

(

  /  

 3       " 1 /3 / 3

 / /     3

    3 @   

     0/ ?    " 1 /" 1 /

   /13  /     /   3 "

%((((># " 1 /  

        / @ 3

     @   3   /      02 !

* 

  33  0  / /



 3  &*"  <    2  /  /   3     

    0  2

/ 0 

 3  ?        

 **"**" -88.       )3 2 

   /     

 

?  /  02" 1 /@  

  /  $#.  /    70  @        /  1  0 ? 

 /

   

2 

02**= 

    2

2  @   @     3   /

     3 +'       2 <   0  / 70@     2

2    

  /  /     <  C "

  ?  5     <  C"

'((((># 

/       "

  ?     

3? / 3 

  D0 /!  

          

 9/   &  @  @  /  +( 

  /  ?   3 /  3  0      "

.((((># /  30    "

%((((>#    "

%((((>#    /   /  /    * 9/      /   /  0 +(

              *  /   

   0

  02  9/   * 

  +( 

  0

0   0  2    5 

 <3 

  

 0    



 =$"3?

34  

/ 6  !33

    10! /

3 88'

  4 2  '((     3   

           *   !

 %(.'(((! ?3 !   



  0    

      0   3   

      



 !  !

 10

    

"3?



?#E

0   / 5 

# <3  3

  

0/ 23



 2 3   3 3  @  3   10 ;

/   =.  ?    3  4   

  

   *  B "  104  !

= /4  

3  2 88- 88.  

   

 



*  !

 10! /!3    3 3? / 

 !

  

 3  (888- 7,'#88-     +'  !

  3



   /  

 (888-   ;<=.>

'

 

3  

/ /   

 //  

%- 30  3   

,+ 5 

# <3       

  :2   

" 1 /  / 2 3     " 1

 /     3? /  !

   

  2 =8  @    /         

  *  !33



 "

/

 30 88$

 //   

"     

  *  !33

"      0   / 0   023  ,888$*   / /

3   

  3  /  ! /    / /  3            3   ?  

 

      

    

0

    

2    /



     2  



0  

7%+- ,888$ 

70@   1   02)3 / =(  

 "1   

 )  55  !33



   3  2      * / =  "1     ! ?  @             

  4

/ ='F1// /

 2 88$ 

"     

  *  2!33

"   " 1 /! ?  

  *  !

 10  0/ 2

?0  /7''->9"

 ,888$

%

       /  ! / )7%8- %8-+ 7,'>88-  0  03

 D0  10 2 /!  

  / " 1 / =%B12"3   

 =+ /   0? 3   / 

 =,& )/55)  2 10   



/  

3 

 =-4 0 /

 :? /@    

 2 888   /  /   : 

 ! /  0/  /   

3   /

3 

2 / /3    

   3   !

 (888- 4 0 / /

3  70@   * /

3  =$@  /

 2 '((( 

    /  



  

02 **  

 0? )3 2  

 )3 2  =."3 /    ? / @   #3# ;<   /

 B 3? /  0  3 /   3 / 8888 =8       /      *   @  @

  :2   / / 65" ='(?  /

 :B  

2 '(((  ? / 



  /  @

+  

     

  /   3? 

@   )3 / 

 /  ! / 3 

  /

/  3    /  ! /   3? 0270@   * /  

 / 

3   & ?1 

2 

 

 /     0      

  0



!2 3  ;<=8> =' * 1   /   

B &  *  !33



 "  / /  /   3 0  // 

2 F11/ / =''       /  

  /  !3?  0    0?

*   / 3   /  ='%"3

! ?**

 "  2    -8.8

02   / ** "    

  )3 2  ='+  4 0   /  4   

  

    *  !33

  "     =',  "1    ! ?  

    @         3     5    

       2/ /     /

  /

    3     '8    /  ! /   /0   !

 *

 "       



02

(888-     3 

/          #

,

  3   5 3  3     

3

0   /    (888-

3      3

3    

   0   1    5  

/ 23    /  3 02

   /    

2  5 3  )3 / # 

  /

 3    /   3     (.88$  /



  /   0  *   /  /" 3  2   3 

@ 2   20    3

  @

   2 0  70@   1 

 3

3  /    0 0   @             

   *  !33

"  :

3      0

      

  3

5 3

   

02*   /

/0    

"   

   *  !33

  @    /  =8    3   

7%%-- '.88$     70@    1 

  3      @  /  0      *  2!33

  3          /    0  /        / 

   2

 

 8+88$ 0     /         0/  

 *  2!33

   /*  2!33

"5

0/    *  2!33

 

- *    !

             3     @           2 @ 

 /      

 "       

    *  !33

" 0 /    *  2!33

          0 / /   *  2!33

  3 2           2 70@   15 3  70@   1             

 7$-.   '8.88$ 3   *

 "   

 0 / /   

7%,#% .$88-      0

 / / 3  5 0/   

    3   



     !

 10

  @    3

0 /

  3  

*

 "   

  0 /   *  !33

     /

  3    70  @     1 



7%+- ,888$

 

2     !

     

       70  @             /   ! /   0   3 0 

    @ 3 70@   1    3   

6 

/  3 2  4

  /  10    888$   

   3  3   / :

 / 2 3  3

         /  3 2*  /=-3  ?

0 3  3     **" 

2   

$ /  

   0?  )3 2  6

 5   

    

  3 2 *     /    /  4

  /   :  

   3   /

 5 3     /

    

@  / @  / 33

   /  2  02   0 / /           *  !33

0

    3  ) 

  

3  70@   1 



/  *  2!33

 =    0270 @   1  *

 "   

 0 / /

  

  ) 

   

3   0 / /    *  2!33

 /

      70  @     1   F ? 2  ) 

    /

       *



"   

 @       @  /  

    3  23  

 @    /  2 2   @  /  

"   

  *  2!33

"=8 *

 "   

             70@   

  0   3   / 

/

  0   3  

 

  0

  3

 @   *   / /4

/  :

 3   /

  3    

.



0    2    / 2   0  

 2

 

 2

2  /    33  

  / 2    +$  5!    

   /    /     /  3

@    /    *   /

/4

/ :

 3   /

?

  / @ 23  2     

02

   @     2  0      

'(#& +$    '(#&5! !

:

2 !"##+,'-#&#'(-  !"##+,$%#&#'(- !"##$%#&#'($:*   / /4

/  :

 3   /

    2

:

  /    

'(#& +$   

'(#&5!@ 0 0 20   /  7 5  3     )3 /F 0  2 )3 /   3    /      

  !

  3   @   )3 /

   0 

 320 0  3 

3? /=,

 !

  2 

  

/  

2    ?5  

 

33

/ 2/     

2  

   /   /       7 :

     !   

  0  / 

/ 3

 

 /   /    G

8 53    

33

/ 2

2   /  3

   / 3

  <

 02     0    /

/        3

/ 

    3

       3?   /     *   !

   3 /  3 

    3 6/    (888-  2    '.88$  3 3? /  2   3   

 1 5 

3?

 /   / /  / 2       "3?

 3  =$   ?   3=.     



 5 3  3

?   3 =.  

  :2    " 1 /  3>! ?    / 2    ? 2    " 1 /   /

3   65"@         (888-     *    !

  /       

  02

3 02@  ? 2  0  

    3   

    3  

   

/ 

 /    /

 3     

0   

     )3   /           / 2            3



)3 / 

  (888-     ?



  <

)3 / 2 70@   1

    0      

   *  !33

        / 3

 

'(

3  

     3    /      @  +'      <  02

    =

 2  3 ?

   

/    3?   /

/ 3

  5     ;  /      )3   /  3   0   *  2  !33

      2

2 3   0  @   )3 /  /   



 / 3 /  3 

3 2/  )3 /  2?

   /  3      )3 / 3

/   

 

 3  

2 2     /  3

           

+-$+-. '(#&5!

 0    2 

/   )3 /  /   /   @       / 2           +$  5!       '(#&5! 

 

2      / 

   / 2 !"##+,'-#&#'(-  !"##+,$%#&#'(- !"##$%#&#'($:*   / /4

/  :

 3   /

    2

:

  /    

'(#& +$   

'(#&5!@ 0 0 20   / 7 

2 2   ?

 2  0  3/ 1/3

    0  0        / / 

!"##+-.,#&#'(-

 02)3 /  2    

'     

 +-$  +-.     '(#&  5!  

        

 

     +$5! 3

   0 0 20     0  #

33

1    /   3 /

  2   0     

  & '

('

) :82* "0 "$-.;

5 2 -

=    ? /> 

=  "  0