M/S Vishal Retail Ltd v. Hardayal Singh Dhillon And ORS

 
   
  

!"# $#%&'&()

*'+&',!-#"!&-.&/&"#$  #"&"&(#0 1#0'2'

!0$!3!-4&(5, ,&--(!($",#0'

 #'6($#("'

)  7 .4
 .4 0#'#(") 0!20!1
,60!8$1%!"#8 0",#6#"&"&(#0 0!,2-4,!0/!8$1%!"#8 0",#0#'6($#("'  .48

0!-

3",&'6#"&"&(8",#6#"&"&(#0%/6!(3%,!--#(5#'",#0$#0 ",#-#!0(#$#9#%2"&(%20"$!"#$

8:3;,&%,<!%%2("' ",# %/6!(38!--!"+&--!5#=!6!',#0!8#; #-,&8;#0#0$#0#$":#!""!%,#$ "0#%1#0",#:!-!(%#$#%0#"!-!/2(" ' 8>>8 ?* "",#"&/#;,#(",&'6#"&"&(,!$&(&"&!--3%/#26 0,#!0&(5 (

8",# --;&(50$#0,!$:##(6!''#$:3",&'%20") @,#&''2#&(1-1#$&(",#60#'#("6#"&"&(&'!'";,#",#0 :!(A  !%%2("'  ;,&%,  !0#  2"'&$#  ",#  B20&'$&%"&(    ",# 9#%2"&(5
20"%!(:#!""!%,#$&(#9#%2"&( "&%# /"&( 0<

 .#!0(#$%2('#- 0",#6#"&"&(#0'"!"#'",!"",#!/2(" $2#&'' -!A,'$$# 20",#0'"!"#'",!"",#6#"&"&(#0&' 0#!$3"/!A#  ' <-!A,'!($$#6'&"&";&",",# 9#%2"&(5
20""&--6#($#(%3 ",#6#"&"&(

 ($#6'&"&(5",#  ",#'!&$!/2("8",#!""!%,/#("

/!3:#0#/1#$C ,#  !:1#  2($#0"!A&(5  ,!1&(5  :##(  5&1#(8  !(  !/2("   ' <8

*&''"!"#$",!1#:##($#6'&"#$:3;!3 ! &9#$$#6'&"&( ",# 
 !(A8 0!6#0&$  /(",''"!0"&(5?

8;&",",#$!"#  /!"20&"3:#&(5?

8!''##( 0/",#6,"%63 ",#@$#6'&"

%( &0/!"&(*0#(#;!-!$1&%#C60$2%#$&(%20""$!3:3-#!0(#$%2('#- 0",#6#"&"&(#08!%63 ;,&%,,!':##(5&1#("04,!0/!8-#!0(#$ %2('#- 0",#0#'6($#(" #%0##-$#0'

0
,60!8-#!0(#$%2('#- 0",#6#"&"&(#08'2:/&"'",!"",# 6#"&"&(#02($#0"!A#'"0#(#;",#'!&$$#6'&"&//#$&!"#-326(/!"20&"38 &#(?

&"'#- ,!":#&(5'!($",#$#%0#"!-!/2("",#0# 0#:#&(5'#%20#$ &("#0/' ",#2($#0"!A&(55&1#(!'0#%0$#$&(",#! 0#'!&$0$#0 ",&' %20"8",&'6#"&"&(&'$&'6'#$ ;&",!$&0#%"&(",!"",# &9#$$#6'&" 0 !(!/2(" ' <8

*;2-$%("&(2#":#0#(#;#$"&--",#$#%&'&( ",#!66#!- &-#$:3",#6#"&"&(#0!5!&('"",#0$#0$&'/&''&(5&"'!66-&%!"&( 2($#0 0$#02-#> ",#

:3",#"0&!-%20"

"&'/!$#%-#!0",!"& !"!(3'"!5#!"!--$20&(5",#6#($#(%3 ",!"!66#!-8",# &9#$$#6'&"&'("0#(#;#$8",#&/625(#$0$#0;2-$ '"!($  0#1&1#$8 ;&",  &"  ",#0;&'#  '#"  !'&$#  '2:B#%"  "  ",#  &9#$  $#6'&" %("&(2#$":#0#(#;#$:3",#6#"&"&(#0 ,#6#"&"&(&'$&'6'#$ &(",#! 0#'!&$"#0/' "",&''"!5#80
,60!,!''2:/&""#$",!"",#D2#'"&( -!; !'0#5!0$';,#",#0",##9#%2"&(%20"%2-$!"!--,!1#$&0#%"#$!""!%,/#("

>   :!(A  !%%2("'    ",#  6#"&"&(#0  %/6!(3  !"  !  6-!%#  :#3($  ",# B20&'$&%"&( ",!"%20"8/!3:#-# "6#( E&",2"/!A&(5!(3%//#("(",!"%("#("&(8;,&%,;2-$ :#0!&'#$8& (#%#''!038!"",#!66060&!"#'"!5#!($0#6-&#$"8,;#1#08",# %($&"&(&/6'#$,#0#&(!:1#8"",## #%"",!"& ",#!/2("&(",# &9#$ $#6'&"&'("0#(#;#$$20&(5",#6#($#(%3 ",#! 0#'!&$!66#!-8",# &/625(#$0$#0;2-$'"!($0#1&1#$8&'!(0$#0",!"'"!($' 
























 6A





















  E,#",#0'6#!A&(5*0#!'(#$ 

#'* E,#",#0#60"!:-#

#'*