High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1041/2013dismissed

Gurdial Singh v. Piara Singh & ORS

2015-05-25Mr. Justice S.C. Datta11 pages

!"#"

$% & &

!"#"

$% & &

!"#"

$% & &

!"#"

$% & &

'( "

) *"$+, '( "

) *"$+,

--)"!

.--))

--)"!

.--))

--)"!

.--))

--)"!

.--))

/(#'# /(#'# /(#'# /(#'# "

,(# "

,(#

#- $ $

#- $ $ % 01 * * % 01 * * % 01 * * % 01 * * 2 3, ,( - (#

, ) ) - -(# 4 5 6

, 8' +4$

6 (

, - (# ( $

3, , 8' +4$ ') 6 (- "+# (#$ % ( '):

( ; <

--)"!

--))

( ,'4 $; <

, (#- $ $

=== *;

*; >12 >12 >12 >12 , "$#

--)"!

$ , # 6$ ") '$ ( *!

?@>2 (

( +(

, "4-'+$ 8' +4$

## 65 ) ($ ' "!"

) +"#

# ) ##;

,")) '( 7,(65 !

") 65 --)"!

>,("$

# 0!

02 '$ ( *!

$# & ; ?;

;

B; @;

, $ "

$ $ ) # 6$ "#4"## $ (#- $ $ #

!!'# >,("$

( (

# 0 !!'# 02 , < 6$ !C'"

, !, (+

") 65 '$ ( *!

$# & ; ?;

;

B; @; A

, $ "

$ )

))+"$+

# -(#$ "$ ,"# , )) !!'# !("4"$ ))5

(#- ## "$

,"# , '# 7"

)5 7 $# "$ ( (

"$8'("# $ ,"# -(#

'# ) ##

, -( -(

"4; ")6 + *"$+, (4 7"

, D"(- $;

!,,- ) *"$+, $ )E ( *"$+, (4 7"

, #"

)E"

(4 7"

$+; ( "# ) )E

'+,

)##

( $

)"<("$+ ####"

-( 3"

,"# !!'# ")6 + *"$+, + D"(- $ 6) , -(#

7,"!, ,"

$ ("+, ,'46 $ -( F"4 ) -, $F ("

( )

) #"

!!'# !,,- ) *"$+, + < + #" 6) # (<(# #"

, -(#

7,"!, ,"

, 6 !E 7( #"

!!'# )E"

*"$+, + $+ 6)

, -(#

7,"!, ,"

, )

') ( 8

!!'# )E ( *"$+, 6( E , '# , "!)# )5"$+ "$ , ,

$ !

'# ) ##

$ G;. 6$ <((

$ ( "#"$+ ( ') ; *

E, $ #7"$ ( *"$+, !

$ #

, !)'

!,#

)) !!'# (

( !

44"

"$+

# +

"$ ("4 , $ (; $ "

7,( , 7 # 4 "!

)+ ))5 F 4"$

--(

!, )"! #

$ !

$!($

E"$+

< $ !!'# 6'

$ 7

E$ 65 )"!

$!;

, -(#$ ")

$ , 6 #"#

-()"4"$ (5 <" $!;

!!'# 7(

( (

6 #'44

44"##"

$!# -'$"#, 6) '$ ( *!

$# & ; ?;

;

B; @; A

, $ "

$ )

$ -(!, (+ <" $!;

, !

'( "

) *"$+, ,"4#)

( "$

$##6 # 3 6#" # F 4"$"$+ #7"$ ( *"$+, # 3 ; *

E, *"$+, # 3 ; ( #, E D'4

3 >7( $+)5 4 (E # 32; ( #6"( *"$+, # 3& >7( $+)5 (E # 32 $ , 6 #"#

-(!, (+ <" $!;

!!'# 7( !, (+#,

44"##"

$!# '$ ( *!

$# @;

& ;

;

B; ? ( , *!

$ A

, $ "

$ $ ) ;

7,"!,;

,5 -) 0$

+'") $ !) "4 ("

!!'# '$ ( *!

( 7( (!

( 7,("$ ,5 -) "$$ !$!

"4-)"!

, ("

) ;

--(!"

"$+ , <" $!;

!C'"

, !, (+#

,4; <" "4-'+$ 8' +4$

$!;

,"# --)"!

( +(

, < , ( ) ($ !

'$#)

--)"!

$ +

,( '+, , "4-'+$ 8' +4$

, ("

) ;

--(!"

"$+ , <" $!

$ (!

( ;

6#(< # '$ (% $ , -(#$

( , ("$+ "# -('#"$+ , (!

( "

, -(#$

!!'# , < 6$ !, (+ #,

-'$"#, 6) '$ ( #!

$ @; & ;

; ? (

, #!

$ A

))+

% - ;

!!'# 7(

(4 7"

)5 7 $# 7,$ ,5 $ ( "$

,5 !

'# "$8'("#

# 3

#'44 $"$+

!!'# -(# $ , - # -( ,"# $ ,"# !( ##F 4"$

$ , #

") ,"# -(#$

$ ,

" $

+"< $5 #

)"! $ ( ,

(+"# ( -5

, '!

,"# #

4$ # $<( (!

( "$ , - )"! #

$ 6'

, #

,"#

4$ # (!

( "$

, 4

3 #7"$ ( *"$+, "# #

6 5 7"

$##

!!'(($!

))+ 65 , !

$ ,"# <" $! , -

, # !!'# -(#

'#"$+ "$8'("#

; 7,( 3 '( "

) *"$+, # 5# "$ ,"# <" $!

, 3

#7"$ ( *"$+, $ 3

E, *"$+, !

, #-

7,$ , ( "# ( ') 7,"!, !(

(+ ( "$+ -(#$!

,# 7"

$###

!!'(($!

"$8'(5 7

, 7"

$### 7,"!,

# ')5 !

3 #7"$ ( *"$+, # 7)) # 3

E, *"$+,

#-!"

))5 #

"$ ,"# <" $!

, " $

)"! #

$ $ ( , + "4

$ "$ )"! #

" $

+"<

$!,

"$ ,"# <" $!

, 7$

)"!

+"< 7("

$ !

;

,"# !

# $

E$ 65 )"!

7<(; , " $

$5 !

-5

#'!, !

#7"$ ( *"$+, $ 3

E, *"$+,

,4 + $5 "$

)"!

#7"$ ( *"$+, #

'( "

) *"$+, + < "$

)"!

<$ #

)"! !

7,( ,"# #

4$ # (!

E, *"$+, #

, $<( 7$

)"! #

$ 7"

'( "

) *"$+,

$ , -(#$ "# #-!"

"! -)

!!'(($!; , 7$

)"!

$ - )"!

##'( ,"4

( $!## $ 6'

,"$+ 7 $ "$ , 4

3,$ , - # "$ ,"# <" $!; , #

, # 4 <(#"

3 #7"$ ( 4"

, "$

$ 7 # +"<$

)"!;

E, *"$+, (4 "$ #")$

, #

3,$ !

,"4#)

, 7$

)"! #

$ , !

') #")5 6( '+,

, (!

( -(

"$"$+

E$ "$ ,"# 4

(; 6'

, $ "( !

# "# #")$

, # " -

& # -(

$ 7"

$### , C'

(() # ) 4"$'

3 #7"$ ( *"$+, "$

,"# <" $! #

!!'# -(# $# (

, #-

4"$'

( ,"# (("<

$ *

E, *"$+, 6

, 7$

#"4')

'#)5 ,5

"$8'(5 7

,4; 6'

"$8'("# 7( !

'( "

) *"$+, 7,"!,

65 '( "

) *"$+,

, <(#"

,# 7"

$### "# <(5

') ,"#

6 6)"<

, 7"

$### (4 -(#$

!!'(($!

,5 #

!!'# -(# $# !

'#"$+ "$8'("# # 4'

#-!

(# ,"#

E$# , #

E, *"$+, #

"$ ,"# <" $!

,( "# $ -)

*"$+, "$ 7,"!, , , # ( ('!

'$ (5 7 $ +

"# "$#

)) 65 ,"4

/(#"

, !

*"$+, ( )E

!, )##

,"4

E"$+ - ####"

" -)

####"

, # " -)

)( 6$ 7"

, "

,( !

') 6 $

( ,"4

"# ) )E

"# $

##"6)

(()

E# -)

4"$'

4")5

# -(#$

4 $ $"+,6 ((# !

, #-

, 7$

)"! #

$ 7,$ , 7 # "#!, (+ , , #-"

, 7 4"

, , #-"

, 7 # "#!, (+ , , #-"

@ 7,"!,

, , # 4$ &

@ "$ ,"# !

4"$ 3 ( #, E D'4 ( 6'

, # " 4 "!

"!( " $

$5 7,(

, , #-"

@ 7,$ , 7 # F 4"$ 65 , #

( , #

$5 7,( "$ ,"# <" $!

# "#!, (+

"4;

))+ 65

@ '( ,(; ) ($ !

'$#)

(+'

$! '$ ( #!

, "# 4

4 "!

"!( ,

$ 7 $)5 !'

,( 7 # $

3,") -('#"$+ <" $!

$ (!

( "

3 ( #, E D'4 ( "#

4"$ 7,

( F 4"$

-(#

'$ ,( "$8'("#;

7,"!, # "$!"# 7 '$ , ("+, ,'46 7,"!,;

"$"$+ I( -"$"

$; 7 # !) # +("< '# "$8'(5

'( ,( 3& ( #6"( *"$+, "# F 4"$ 7,

"$8'( '( "

) *"$+, 7 4"

"$ "<") #-"

( ,"# F 4"$

$ # " 7"

$## + < ,"# (- 7,"!, 7 # -( # I & # -( , #

!'4$ ,( "# $ 4$

$ "#

$)5 4$ $ (+ ( "$+ $ "# +"<$

$ 4 !'4$ F 3).& "# $ (!

,# !'4$ # #, 7#

, (-

I( 5 7,( "# #-!"

))5 4$

,( "# $

<$ 3 ( #, E D'4 ( #

"$ ,"# <" $!

##"6")"

'#"$+

"$8'("# $

, , ( #'(

6 (')

<$ , 4"

# $

, 6 "# -("$!"-)

!("4"$ 8'("#-(' $!

< ,"# !

!!'# -(# $# 65 , ( 6)

$ ,"# <(#"

$ 4'# ('# ,5

, <(#"

, !

(4 "$ "$ , #-"

@ &

'+, ,( "# $

!'4$

$ (!

3 ( #, E D'4 ( #

4"$

"$ '( "

) *"$+, 7 # 7)) ("$

, -) ! 7,"!, 4

, !

') '$ (#

3 & ( #6"( *"$+, -

$ '!

, I( ")4

'( "

) *"$+, 6'

#'!, I( ")4# 7( -( '!

"4 "$ <" $!

,"# 7"

$##

$ 7 # $

, , #-"

, , # $

4$ , F

$)5

,'46 7 # !'

7,"!, "# $

$ # 4 7 # (- "( 7,"!,

65 3 #, E D'4 ( 7,

,( 7 # $

,'46 3 #, E D'4

"$ ,"# <" $!

, + < ,"# -"$"

"$8'(5 $

7 # +("<

, (

$ 7

# -( !) '# #<$

; ,'

+("< '# 7,$ "

"# 0 ( "#)

,0 '( # -( !) '# "+, #!

, 5# ,'( "# +("< '# "$ !

# 0 $5 ,'( 7,"!, $ $+(# )"

( 7,"!, !

'## , #'

((

6 '("$+ , #-

7$ 5# "$ #<( 6 ")5 - "$;

( '$ 6)

7 ,"#

( "$ (5 -'(#'"

#0 $ , -(#$ # !

,"4#)

, (4 "$ "$ , #-"

5# (

5# 7"

!'4$

7,"!,

)#"

" 65 , <(#"

3& ( #6"( *"$+,

, 7 $#!"

4"$

$ 65 ,"4

"$8'("# (;

$ "# "4-("$

6( #"

,( "# #7))"$+

'( , <(#"

(+ ( "$+ '#"$+

"$8'("# !

$ 6 !

$#" ( $)5 7,$ , #

(+ ( "$+ , (#- ## "# -(

, # " <(#"

$ !

,"4#) 4"$ #7"$ ( *"$+, $ *

E, *"$+,

"$ ,"# <" $!

!!'# "

$ ,"4 "$ 7,"!, 6

, #7"$ ( $ *

E, *"$+,

"$ -$ $ $## ,

, <(#"

,(; !

$ ,"# 7"

$###

("!

))5 #

,( -(# $ !

, #-

$5 -(# $ 7 # -(#$

, ,

"4 7,"!, <(#"

$ "# "

"# $

6)"< 6) "$ , !"(!'4#

$!# 7,$ ,

"# #"

,"$ , <")) "4

!!'(($! "# ))+ )5

% - <"$+ $'#

< ,"# - ####"

$ (+ ( "$+ '# 7,( ))+ )5 "$!" $

E -) !; 6'

, " $

$5 #'!, <" $!

$ (!

( "$ 6#$!

7,"!, , <(#"

$ (+ ( "$+ , , (#- ## !

6)"< '( ,( #

(5 (+ ( "$+ , "$ )"!

"$+

"$8'("# "#

') "$ , -(#$!

< # " !"(!'4#

$!#

$ 4 "!

) <" $!

$ (!

$ # 4 "# $

!!'# -(# $# 7( !, (+ #,

44"##"

$! -'$"#, 6) '$ ( #!

$ ?

,5 7( ))+

< 4 ('!

"!)#

, ,

"$ ,"# !

"!)# 4 '$

G);. 7( 6( E$ 65 !!'# )E ( *"$+, 7,"!,

, - # "$ ,"# <" $!

$ ,"# !( ## 4"$

$ , #

, " $

$5 )"#

"!)# $ ( , # -( '!

$5 -,

+( -,# ;

3 #7"$ ( *"$+,

, # 4 <(#"

"$ ,"# F 4"$

$"$!,"

'( ,( 3

E, *"$+,

"!)# 7( !

"$"$+ (" +; )<"#"

$+ 7"

"!)#

(; #

) <(#"

# $

<(#"

, !

7,$ , #

#) (4

') ') < -( '! !

(5 <" $! "$ #'--

,"# -)

<(#"

, 0!

"# 6)"<

4 6 !E

,"# ,

( & 5# 6'

, " $

$5 #'!, !'4$ 7,"!, , ,( 7 E$#

& ($ !

'$#)

(+'

,( "# ,'+ )

")"$+

, -(#$

# -( ") , !

))+ !!'(($!

@ , -(#$ # 6$ ")

$ A

$ 4 $ #<$

5# '

,( "# $

$5 !

+$ F-)

( , <"$+ '# #'!, ) $+ ) 5 "$ ")"$+ , -(#$

, 5 !

'# "$ ")"$+

, !

,"# !

< # !"(!'4#

$!# #,

, # " ) 5 7 $)5

"))0 '- , ) !'$ , #

B ( , "#!'##"

$# 4

,"# !

-"$"

# $

6$ 6)

))+ 65 ,"4 "# $

!!'# -(# (#- ## "$

, ,

$ !

'# ,"4 +("< $ #"4-) "$8'("#

'#, "!)#

$ <"7

< # " "#!'##"

$#;

# $

6$ 6)

6("$+ $ (!

F"# $!

"( !"(!'4#

$!# 7,"!, ( #'

"!"$

< "

# 65 , #,

( "$+)5; 65 +"<"$+ 6$

;

!!'# "

*"$+,; ")6 + *"$+,; !,,- ) *"$+,; )E"

)E ( *"$+, !C'"

, !, (+#

,4 '$ ( #!

$ @; & ;

; ? (

, #!

$ A

") 6 $ # $ #'( 5 6 $ #

!!'# #

$ "#!, (+ ,"( )"

6")"

") 6 $#"+$

, (!

( (

( ' !

4-)"

J , $06) *'-(4 "$ '( )" , ( K "

L $(

'( )" , ( K "

L $(

'( )" , ( K "

L $(

'( )" , ( K "

L $(

> 2 >("4"$ )2 &? , # ,) # '$ (% H ( '##)) "$ ( '##)) "$ ( '##)) "$ ( '##)) "$ *, *7 ('- <# D"$+ 4-( ( M *, *7 ('- <# D"$+ 4-( ( M *, *7 ('- <# D"$+ 4-( ( M *, *7 ('- <# D"$+ 4-( ( M A ("<5 '$!")

?N A ("<5 '$!")

?N ,"+,)"+,

--(

"+,

--))

("$+

!C'"

( '##)) # " ; H , "+,

') $ 7")) )7 5# +"< -( -( 7"+,

$#" (

#'!, 4

(# # >2 , <"7#

' +

, !( "6")"

, 7"

$###O > -(#'4-

"$$ !$! "$

!!'# ;

-(#'4- $ !(

"$)5 $

E$ 65

# 6$ !C'"

,"# ("

)O > , ("+,

, 6$

O $ >2 , #) 7$##

--))

"$ "# '(6"$+

"$ "$+

(("<

' + 7,

#"$+ $### J , -"$"

, 1 ( '##)) , # 6$

<( , 5 (#

# ()5 # "$ A& ;

,"# "$ *'( 8- ) *"$+, <

O P A& * & N; 7,") )"$+ 7"

7(#

, "+,

!C'"

) '$ ( *!

$ ?

, ("4"$ ) ( ! '(

6#(< ;

, "+, ')) - 7(

(<"7 , <" $!

'- $ 7,"!, ( (

!C'"

) 7

'$ ; 6'

))5 7)) #

, -(#'4-

"$$ !$!

!!'# "# ,( ("$

(! 65 ,"# !C'"

) 65

) !

;

"$ "$+#

) !

7,"!, ,

#"$+ , 7"

$### $ , ("$+ ,"( <" $! !

$ 6 (<(# $)5

( <(5 #'6#

4-))"$+ ( J

, --(

--))

!C'"

) , # 6$ , 65 ,"# ')#"( 4 D $' <

O M A& * N;

')#"( 4 D $' <

O M A& * N;

')#"( 4 D $' <

O M A& * N;

')#"( 4 D $' <

O M A& * N;

$ *"$+, <

O M A& * B ?N; )5 <

*"$+, <

O M A& * B ?N; )5 <

*"$+, <

O M A& * B ?N; )5 <

*"$+, <

O M A& * B ?N; )5 <

O M A&& * @?N; ,( D,"4

O M A&B * ?N; )6"( *"$+, <

'$8 6O M A&? * BN; + (7 ) <

O M AB * N;

( D, $ <

O M AB * N;

( D, $ <

O M AB * N;

( D, $ <

O M AB * N;

( D, $ <

$O M AB * @BN; D, '

$ <

$O M AB * @BN; D, '

$ <

$O M AB * @BN; D, '

$ <

$O M AB * @BN; D, '

$ <

", (O M>A?2 * &N; *,"< 8" * 6(

O M>A?

* ?A N; 1E,

O M>A?

* ?A N; 1E,

O M>A?

* ?A N; 1E,

O M>A?

* ?A N; 1E,

", (O M>A?

* N; D,4 D $ <

", (O M>A?

* N; D,4 D $ <

", (O M>A?

* N; D,4 D $ <

", (O M>A?

* N; D,4 D $ <

O M>A?2 * B N; "#, $ *"$+, <

'$8 6O M>A?2 * @@N; 4 6, "

<6, " <

'$8 6O M>A?2 * @@N; 4 6, "

<6, " <

'$8 6O M>A?2 * @@N; 4 6, "

<6, " <

'$8 6O M>A?2 * @@N; 4 6, "

<6, " <

O M>A?@2 *

@N; D ) 5 <

O M>A?@2 *

@N; D ) 5 <

O M>A?@2 *

@N; D ) 5 <

O M>A?@2 *

@N; D ) 5 <

O M>A?A2 * &&N;

*"$+, <

O M>A?A2 * &&N;

*"$+, <

O M>A?A2 * &&N;

*"$+, <

O M>A?A2 * &&N;

*"$+, <

'$8 6 MA@?> 2 >("4"$ )2 &% >A@?2 * & AN;

4 D'4 ( <

O MAA> 2

4 D'4 ( <

O MAA> 2

4 D'4 ( <

O MAA> 2

4 D'4 ( <

O MAA> 2

>("4"$ )2 B % AA& *'-- >2 * @N;

$ 1 ) <

>("4"$ )2 B % AA& *'-- >2 * @N;

$ 1 ) <

>("4"$ )2 B % AA& *'-- >2 * @N;

$ 1 ) <

>("4"$ )2 B % AA& *'-- >2 * @N;

$ 1 ) <

LDO MAA?>2 >("4"$ )2 @A% >AA?2 ? *

LDO MAA?>2 >("4"$ )2 @A% >AA?2 ? * B??N; * #"< $ <

D( O MAA@> 2

B??N; * #"< $ <

D( O MAA@> 2

B??N; * #"< $ <

D( O MAA@> 2

B??N; * #"< $ <

D( O MAA@> 2

>("4"$ )2 BA % >AA@2 & * N; , +7 $ *"$+, <

O M > 2 >("4"$ )2 &A % > 2

O M > 2 >("4"$ )2 &A % > 2 * @&N; ("8 ,"('- '6)"! ( #!'

(; "+, * @&N; ("8 ,"('- '6)"! ( #!'

(; "+,

O M > 2 >("4"$ )2 @B % > 2 B

O M > 2 >("4"$ )2 @B % > 2 B * ?N; $

$5 < +, $ "(O M >2 * ?N; $

$5 < +, $ "(O M >2 >("4"$ )2 ?& % > 2 * N; *

>("4"$ )2 ?& % > 2 * N; *

E("#,$ O M &> 2 >("4"$ )2 ($

E("#,$ O M &> 2 >("4"$ )2

% > &2 A * AN; *

$8 5 , E( $O

% > &2 A * AN; *

$8 5 , E( $O

% > &2 A * AN; *

$8 5 , E( $O

% > &2 A * AN; *

$8 5 , E( $O M ?> 2 >("4"$ )2 &@ % > ?2 * ?&&N M ?> 2 >("4"$ )2 &@ % > ?2 * ?&&N M ?> 2 >("4"$ )2 &@ % > ?2 * ?&&N M ?> 2 >("4"$ )2 &@ % > ?2 * ?&&N , $ (

O M ?> 2

, $ (

O M ?> 2

, $ (

O M ?> 2

, $ (

O M ?> 2

>("4"$ )2 A % ?>2 !$ -F ' +4$ # > >("4"$ )2 A % ?>2 !$ -F ' +4$ # > >("4"$ )2 A % ?>2 !$ -F ' +4$ # > >("4"$ )2 A % ?>2 !$ -F ' +4$ # > @% > ?2 * &N

@% > ?2 * &N

@% > ?2 * &N "# $

$!##

) 7"

,# !

## "$ "<" '

))5 *'

"! "

,"#

$#"# )5 ,)

)"$+ 7"

!C'"

);

--))

4'# ( "$ 4"$

7"$+% >"2 ,( "# -(#'4-

"$$ !$! "$

!!'# -(# $ #'!, -(#'4- $ "# ($+ ,$ 65 ( (

!C'"

) - ## "$ ,"#

'( 65 ("

) !

; >""2 , !!'# -(# $ "#

, 6$

6) 7,$ "

, 4("

!C'"

); >"""2 , '+,;

--))

"$ !

$#" ("$+

!C'"

# F $#"< # "

7(# "$ $<"!

$# 6'

--))

"# +$( ))5 )

, "$ "# '(6"$+ "$ "$+

( 65 ("

) !

"# # 6!

) !

#"$+ , 4

$###

) !

E# 6) <"7

#; "$ ($! 65 --))

, 8' +4$

!C'"

) "# $

8'# $)##;

$!)'#"

$# ( !, 65 ("

) !

( - )- 6)5 7( $+

( 6 $ (( '# <"7

, ) ( "

#'!, $!)'#"

$ ;

,5 ( )"E)5

(#')

"$ +( < "$8'# "!;

, ()'!

, -

--))

"$ "$ ("$+ 7"

, #'!, !

$!)'#"

$# "#

'))5 8'# " ;

$ >"<2 ()5 6!

--))

$ ( --(!"

$ (< )'

, <" $! "# "$!)"$

($ <"7; "$ ($! 7"

8' +4$

!C'"

) "# $

8'# " "

, <"7

E$ 65

) !

##"6) <"7 , <$)5 6 $!

<"7#

, <" $! 4'#

(#') , "$ ($!

--))

, 8' +4$

) !

J ($ !

'$#)

--)"!

( "$ )

, 6 #"#

7,"!, "$ ($! !

$ 6 4

,"# , 8' +4$ '$ ( !, ))$+

# #'!,;

--)"!

( )

) "# "#4"## 4("

> *2 > *2 > *2 > *2 $!,