High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/341/2003allowed

Kuldeep v. State Of Haryana

2018-12-20Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh12 pages

!""

#$%& &&%% $ '() *+ &

,$%-)".( ( &&%% $ ) *+ &

#"(/% 0 " " $ ) *+ ( & "#$% &'()* "+,-./* #0.123#"$# &'()* "+,-./*#".&4*"2.&532.43+ 0 1",("2)"! 3" ( )"4&) )($2! 2 (&&%% "

) (42)"! 3" ( )$45" #$ ) "()(42! 2 &&%% "

0 ) %2)"! 3" ( 1"(% /4-2! 2 (&&%% 6"

) )("2! 2 (& " " " 6 6 1"(%,.2" "%! ,%2*+

#0.123#"$#6 '("5$.4 3"%%"& (!-".

'(& &&%!"4"%""" " $ ." 5$.4

2 -+ " "%)"7$.2#" (%2")"

3("!(!!$,$%-)".(27"08(2#$%&25(#$42 (& )".(245 )".(2(#$4(")".(3!(. 3" ( " (!&$"(-%$)! " 2 2 29

:;0 %% (!!$3!"! !$)! "

;0 $.%""4&"4 &+" 2<!( "$% &+4 "2 $ ($.".$"4&"4 "=4 ( '(+3%!"! !$)! "

;0 $.".$"4&"4 &""=4 ( '(+ 3%!"! ! $ )! " ;0 $. ".$"4&"4 &""=4 ( '(+3%!"! !$)! "

;0 $.".$"4&"4 &""=4 ( '(+3%!"! !$ )! "9 ;0 $.".$"4&"4 &"+ %% ( !3 $!!$ %+ '(! (&!$ ""$ (%%" ( 0> #"( /%4 4 2?= 0#2 6 -$ 0 " (""% *&" %2 #" (%2 0>

" )$-;&! (" )".( !!". (!4&%" 2#"(/%3 $ ;;; # ) %%.2 #" (% 6 -$

2 ( %. 3" ( +!210%2)$"2(23(3% $ # ) %%.2#" (%2!4$ (& ; 3" !%%. ; ( 4 "42 )$4 ("!% && " #$%& 3 !+".3%"83&2(!+".2(!+".2 7 0 !+". (&)".(!+"."25(!+".32 45" )".(!+".3&%"8 !$ +4&" %,$%- %".( 4' )$4!4 3 (4 '(+. (

3+&"2 (+!4&%" & +(!$"5$" ("4 !!$4 6 +.($%&$( (" 43 (+(!4 8 (. #$%&.3%"8 3&-%3 (3" + 3 (% "("3" 7" 08(. -%3 (% "(" 4!( !!$( . -%3 ("4 ; (" (" ".( ( ". * -!4 $!!"$ '( 2%% (!!$!$"5$" ( %4 3" +&&%. ( (& !!$3+4 ( & 3" ( ("&! "3&2(323("%%". (+.". ( + ( +2 (!4&%" & +3" $ $ (+3$%8"%% (4 ;5$3-$.( ((&" % + $!!

$4- ("5$" '("5$34"!%%+=4" ( -"?= 0#2@;?= 0#< 3! '(-+3 & 4 4=4" " '("!%$ 4 34-+ ( !!$ ( -" 3("!( 3& ! 3 ! ; ". "3!4&% !(%%3&$ $& !4&% "%% (!%4%" " '(&!$ "=4"$4-3" "$&& (! '( 4 (!!$3%!$)!

0 '(+" (! (&!$ " !!$#$%&( 8 (&%%"-" '(!!$3!"! !2 "!- '(&&%(-"%-+ (&&%% ." ( 5$.4 ( % "% $ 0 " " #"( /% !4&%" "% ( " !"4"% "" (!4 !!"! "

/ !$% &&". -(% ( &&%% (4 %+.$ ( (&!$ "("% &" ! / !$%&&". () (4 %+.$ ( (&!$ "( &" !-+-%$- $&& (5$.4 (%$ -%323(%!$% (& " " $-4" ( !3 (&&%% -(! ( & " "-. $" -%!4& " >((%!$% (& ". ($.( (5$.4 !+!$%%+ 0> (3%(4"!%%+=4"+ ! * "! (%%3"."5$"("-+

;!"& ".3$ (% %&! (% " (!( 6 9!44 ("&&%

% B". $ " ." 3 (& >$3 !4=C!423("!(=+3 " ;!"& ".3$ !44 (4"%" &"%!26!44 (!&$%2!4%. C!43"2-%B".$ " ." 3(& D+!( 3" ;!"& ".3$ (% " ( !( !44 (&"%!25$ -"5$+ ."3(& %B".$ " 2 3("!(=+!( 3" E $ ""5$"33" (" ($ >&$3(&. '83-$ $"5$+2=+3" 0> (3%%=4"10%0" 4 )".( * "! (%%3"."5$"("-+

;!"3$ !4=C!4 ( $42

9 !44 (D"&("&!24."3(&2 -%B".$ " )$-!$ $ "$3 D+!( 3" ;!"3$ !4=F!4 ( "&!

(% " (!( (%%:"-2: 9 !4 4 ( 4"%" )$-!$ $ "$ 3 3("!(=+!( =+-43 " ;!" 3$ ( 4"% " 4"% &! (% 4" (4"%" 24$!% &2-%B".$ " 24."3(&2 !4=C!43("!(=+- (-" ;!"3$ (& 4"%&! ( % 4" (4"%" 2 !44 (%-3 5" 2 4$!% &2 4." 3 (& % B".$ " D+- (-" 0--%$ ""5$"33" (" ($ >&$3(& . D+3" :

0> (3%%=4")$"(4 0% * "! (%%3"."5$"("&

/! 3$" (4"% (!%&2 !4 %.!%&&2-%B".$ " 23("!( =+3"

$" =!4 (".( %-35" 3" ( 3%%". = !4 (".( %-35" 2 3("!(=+%-3- (-".( 4 "

$" =!4 (% & "&! ( !( 2" (." 262 "- !&" $3 % 23("!(=+!( 3" )3%%". (% %.25$ -%3 (85" -$" = !4"("!%$23("!( =+ (85" "!%$".- (-3

" E '(&--%$ ""5$"3 ($ >&$3-%$ " $ '("5$38& $- " *%&4"!% $G2?= 0 *& ( ) ) # 7"( (&&%"! "2 ?= 0*2 ("4!$! ".& 4 4=4" " *" "" ( ". $ 7" (4 2?= 0*< *!$! (& 4 4=4" "+ 6 90 '(-+ 3" ""-+((55$4)("44( * "! (%%3"."5$" (-++

;!"& ".3$ (% %&! % " (!( ( "="%%+%"2 -$ 6 9!44 ("&&%2"! "2 ( "! " (3$34"%%+&$! $". (!&".& (%$. ($.( ($.( ". (% "!% (( 2 (4 (=(4&"!"$43& ;!"& ".3$ !44 (4" %"26!44 ("".% (!&$%2 !4=C!4-%B".$ " 2"! "2 "! " (3$3 (% " ( !( .". "%+%".( %+4"%%+2 "5$". (!&".& (%$.

;!"& ".3$ (% " ( !( 2 !4 4 ( 4"%" & "%+ 5$ -%3 !4-%3 ("5$+ % "!%%".

$ " "5$". ($%+".& (%$. E

%% ("5$"3 4 4 ;("&"" (!$ (3(!8(4(.$ "5$+ ( %$." % .3("!(3$"!" !$ ("4%!$%" ;(" !=4" "2(& ( ("5$" (&+

6 10%!$%(-!$-+(&.3& *% 4" ( "5$+ " (/+3 (-!8 3 (% %"!( ;5$+ " (/+ 3 (-!8+ ;5$+ (-++ !"-"& 4 42?= 0723&$& "%%( *32(( 4 " (& ("4$4 %"84"%%"4 ! "4 * (% 4 "%. (- ("5$+ (-+ + " ( & 4 4 =4" " & * ( % 4 " (& ("5$+ "4"%%"4 ! "4 *% 4 " ( "!"5$+ (&+3!$-+ )32?= 092 ( ()3!$% (= 9 !4 "" (-+ (! *" "")32?= 092"$ * 4" ( "!"5$+!$ (&)$")".(3-+ 2?= 0

2 ( (".3$%&& (-+ (&%! "5$+ *" "+$!(48 (&)$")".( * %& ( (3&&!"-%& (""5$" (& 10% ;5$" 3$-!$ $"5$"

34$!%& *3!%%$ (!=4" " *( 4" ( . (33-%$ (.3(& *%4" ( ""5$"3!$-+3 ( (&"-"%" + ..4."!$% -$%$ 0> );)($4(! (4%@;2?= 0#<

0> #"( /% " ( 4 "% 3" * ( %. !4&%" 2?= 0# !!". ("42(3 $ " # ) %%.2 #" (% 6 -$

2(2)$"2+21 0%2(3 8". " (! (!%%. '(+!4$

(! &! 3#" (%" + $ ,$4!4 4 (!%%. %8".3" (+ ; (4 "42 3(" ' $4 !4 ( !!$ 7" 08(2 #$%&2 5(2 (242,$%-2 (&2(!4$ ()$4 '(+3 !+".3&%"8 (!8+2" 43(". !$ +4&" % '(+. ( -$ 3+-!82 ("4!4&%" & +H4!$"5$" (4!!$& + 6 +.($%&$( ("4!!$ & +4 -$ (+(!4 8. ( #$%& 7"08( !8+3" ( ("3 (. -%33("!((" ("( *%%3 ( -!4$!!"$ *" 83 3( !83(4 !!$ !

& * ." !!"$ 4 "4 >("%%". (&%!2"% . ( (+( $.( % (&"$"!" = "42 (+3$%8"%% (4 '("5$34 (&" % ;("! =4" "2(& ( "!" % %+9 4"$ ."". ( 2 ( G$" 4 1 0%2 )$"2 ( ,$42(3 (+3!$"5$" *%4" ( G$% ( 8&%! 3+-!84 ( "!" "G$ ""(" &! '("!" -$ ."". (($%&$(( 8&%! "("&! 0>9)$"!- ( 4 0> #"(/% * (4"3("!(+3 !8-+#$%& 7"08( *%.!"& " (&! "3&!

"-+ (!!$ '("!" 3("!( (!(-4-+ ( !!$ 3+&" (& "!" ( 8&%!

: &! *%" G$"4+-$ ("!" 0> 10%3 ("5$3" *& ( %% (!!$3!+".4"%"! "5$" + ( &"!%$".("4 *%" ( 3("%%".2 (!!$( ." ( (+( $.( %5 %"."$ $" (+ . && $" +2 (+3$%8"%% (4 *%& ( (" 83 ("!" 3("!(( 8&%! 3+-!8 *(% 83%.-$ (%%."!" 6

0>6,$4)".((%& ( (3.". 8 " ((& ' $4!4 (& (!!$!4$ " '(+ 3!+". 4 '(+ !8 + ( "5$ 3" *%4" ( -$ 9 $ 3& 3( ("!" ( 8&%! *%" (+&%83%. ("!" 23("!(34 "-+ (!!$$". ( 0>:;&! 0$(& ( !"". ( "4 "(!( (& *%" -% " (4 (& 4&!% '(43&$ "% '(!&& +3&" -+("43" ( (* *&& (!8 *3"! (!&& + @)/2($- *!$)! "

6;0 (-" ( 4 ("5$3"

0> );*4((!$! (" ". "%. 3" ( 5 )".(2 ;&! 2 ;2 #" (% !!$ #$%& 4 ( "!%$ 4 2 ?= 0 !!$ 7" 08( 4 ( "!%$ 4 2 ?= 0) !!$ (" 4 "!%$ 4 2 ?= 0' !!$5(#$44"!%$ 4 2?= 0I !!$45" 4"!%$ 4 2?= 01 '(3&!3!

(-""!%$ 4 *% !!$,$%-)".(

*""!%$ 4 "?= 0D *!8+3. ! -+("44("($8& " 0>

); (" )".( ! ( 4 !4&%" #"(#$42?= 0# *!4&% ("G$ &!". "?= 07< *( . #"(#$44"!%%+=4"

0> );408(& ( (-""!%$ 4 4-+ (!!$2!"34 0> 9 5 )".( ( % 4 4 G$ "!%$ 4 4-+ (!!$!+' $4*9 6996

'(&!$ """ ( (&&%% 43" (2 "23%"83&2 2!$ +4&" %

!4$ 4 (' $4 #$%&7"08(.3-%3 + 0> #"(/%-!4$!!"$ !"".-%3 ."-+!!$( )$"2(210% ("5$3 (3" +$!!$4- (""5$" 0 4 4 ( -++3!$! -+ (3% '(!$ ( 3(!8(4(.$ "5$+ ( %$." %.2 3("!(3$"!" !$ (""+!$ $ '(4 " "-$ (&&%% " ( (& (!4&%" & + " +(."&$( ""% 3+-!8 " (&&%% 3- &&%% 3 !(% ( ." 3("% %". 4 ( & ( " (+ . && $" +2 (+3$%8"%% (4 0> #"(/%20>9)$"20>

10%0>6,$4(83%.-$ ("!" 23("!(( 8 &%! 3 + &" ( "!" " G$ " '( 4 "

"-$ (&&%% "+38 ""% '(! (&!$ "" ( 3("%%".4 (& 2 (&&%% (=( ( (+( $.( %" (+. && $" + (+3$%8"%%%% (4

0> (3%( ." (& ( ("5$"" 4$4 %"84"%%"4 ! "4 *(% 4 " %. (- ("5$+ (-++" (& 4 4=4" "& (& ("5$+ "4"%%"4 ! "4 '(! (4 " ( (&&%% (! " $ $%3$%4-%+(!$"5$" (!4&%" (" !4&" !4&" + % (" %" '( ! ( &!$ "" ( 45" )".(3!+".!$ +4&" % !!$45" (."-$ (!$ +4&" % *( &+" ;! (" " ("% & +3 8"%% (!4&%" ("!4&"2!!$45" !$%(& ( " '( &&%% ( $ 2 3 %"8 3&2 3("% !8". (!4&%" & + '("5$""%"! $&+3 "$23("!(!$(" ( 0> #"(/%( !"+ "5$+ 0>9)$"0> 10%(!""5$"

"". ("! 2 ("!3$% %%$ )! " ;0 9 /!$%&&".-(% (&&%% ( (4 %+.$ ( ("!" !$)! " ;0 " 3$%-!$)! " 0 ;;;0

> (!""3 ( ("!3$%%%3" (" (4-" )! " 0 ;2!"". (3&!$-+

(&&%% $% "." ("! "4 '(&&%% 343" ( 3&(! " $ $%3$%4-%+3" (!44-5! 6 !!".%+2 (&&%& %+%%3 '(!"! "" ! 4)! " ;0 )! " 20 ;;0 '(!"! " !$ (! ""4&-+ ( "%$ $&(% !(!4 !"4$ !!".%+2 ("" & " "!4&%" #"(/%""4"

'( ! &&%% #$%& 3 $&

9 6 :

'( !&&%% ,$%-)".(25(#$42( #$4(")".(J(3$&6

'( !"4&$& (&)".(45" )".( 3$&"

'( !&&%% 7"08(3$&

9 6

;"3$""!$"2 (&&%% "! -& "$

: -( (G$ $4 ! '("-"%-!!%% 5")(4 7$.

*")".()"($ 7$. >( (&8".< K< >( (& -% K<