High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3616/2022disposed of

Sudhir Bajaj And ANR v. Indian Bank And ORS

2026-04-24Mr. Justice Suvir Sehgal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda8 pages

#!$%&%' %"(%% % %'

"# $ "#%# & #'!( !# )*+

) ,$-

-$ - !

$ "#%# &-.

#'!( !#

'))*

' ,-

. .

' ,/012

+ .

. /1* / ,00 #!33 1/, 4 '056 1 56 1 /,12 %//0170

,006 "%8 9&3"$!:

:!;

9&3"$!:

'%<% %'% "

# !/ "!0!(11 220"3 ! "(450 "

' !( " !613 ! "(450 7 1 #

4"080!(1%3(450 "$0 210401! 3(450 0!( "!( "8

!613(450 3

"1 '

"# !9

0!(

#'!( !# 0!( !9)*+

) ": 10!8 3"(450 7 1 " #1021.%'03(450 0!( "10#10!;1 ;10"10":03(450

"1 '

" !9)*+

)0!(

#'!( !+ !9

"#%! #10.0!(1 3"(450 7 1 #0< !010<0!03(450 "0" 0"0!63(450 0!( "&&.=0<(450 3 ""

#'!( !90!; "

'0;10"(7083((<(450 .

"0<30"=0!0 >>>>

:!;

%36$

1 ## !6%<0""( "#10<<( #'# 211 024 ! (7" '

!#0#1 =0"

"5!!

(

205;6"%!( < 0( !6 < 60 ! :0= 2 ! 5 ( ,# & 0<150"

" 40 - :

( 1

" "

( 0# ?1 2""7 "@ 70##0!5 !

(0 !0!5 0<0## #0!5 !#10'

":<0! #

5""

# 4 ( <

" (0 * A

B%"

9 2= 1 1 !<<01020( 0!; 1

(0#?1 0!;@ "# !6%'0 0<150"

0!( <<!

## ! ! #" 5 .%"%6"0: 2= 5"

0 !6 0 :"606 510"6 ! 2""7 "#@ '"'

#0#7 <<0#!<0!( !1 !0:

%(1 "08083 0<< !6 !4 <<06 1 ;1'%"3 #" 5.%"%6"0:% (

0%< !"

'0=:

! !#0<<:

!#3 <0!055%!70#5<0##

(0#!!9'

": !60## !

0!('"5

( !6#7 ! 0 (%!( "1 5%" C0 !0!( 5!#"%5 ! D !0!5 0< ## # 0!( "5 ! 5%" = !

# 53

(0#?1 D 5@="( "#(0

A 0!(

*!!

B%"

# 9

0!( ) "

5 4 <=3 #" 5 06 #"0 "( ( ( < 4 "= '1=# 50< '## ## ! :"606 ( <0!( 20!; ""7 "# 0''"051 ( 1 # %" 2= < !6 0 7" '

! 0!( 2= "(

E *

* !!

B%"

9 3 1 # %" "

#"0 !

( 1 20!; ": 0; !6 '## ## ! '"'

"=:

! !

( !"( "3!!

B%"

9 )0!; <0 (0 !

< ! 0!(!0!0''< 50 !#%2:

(2=2""7 "#3 <

B%"

9 E70# ##% (2=20!;055 ' !6

"0!0:%! # E5""

#""7 "#:0( 0'0"'0=:

!%!( " 2%(% %2"

0; '0!( : 530"

F% #70#:0( " !# ! 71 51 70# "

( 2= 20!; ! E

B%"

9 ) " '

! < (2= 2""7 "#7 ( #'# ( 2= 1 # %" !

B%"

9 +0!;060 !0''"051 (1 #" 506 #"0 0!(%!(

B%"

9 3'## ## ! :"606 (<0!(70# 0;

!0!(10!( (4 "20!;#0< ! 5 (0

B%"

9 E 70# ##% ( 2= 20!; %!( " 1 5%" = !

# "5 ! %< #3

" "

( 0# ?1

%< #@ " #0< # 5%"

( 0##

":0; !6#:

'0=:

!32""7 "#060 !0''"051 (1 #%" 2= < !6

371 5170# "0 !

(0!( <<7 !6"( 70#'0## (2=0 4 # ! !51 1 #%"!

# $

% %" &% !

'() *+

& $

"& , - . % ! !

"& '

! / !

012 +3# 3 " % !

1 2 % "

* 42#5 "%

6 7 % &% '()%"

"& 0 - - .

/ '()

+ " % "

&! "&

8 %& 9

'()

!+3

% &"

& +;#

1 2 "/

% &

" %

"& ! &

% "

& "&

% (

% 1 2 !

= ,# $0<% 9!

0 < " 40 - :

( " 2"

4 = 1 !0

( 0# ?1 0%5 ! '%"510# "@ 70# 1 61 # 2 (( " ! 0%5 ! '"5

( !6#!055 <

70# ##% ( ! # 04%" 2=20!;0!(0( '# )G 5!# ( "0 ! # )*A5""

#70# :0( 2= ""7 ":0( 0!1 "

"20!;0#10#2

!! 5 (2=1 # %" !"( ( *

+371 51 #"

'"(%5 (1 %!( "/ , "%

! "

( &

& %

>#!

># <

"% "&

"& % & % 8 "

?>< $?

"& % & "

(

>2 &

"/ / 7 <

># & %

8 /

# #= + %5 !'%"510# "%!#%55 ## %<<=510<< !6 (1 #"( "2

%'"

%"2= < !6- +)*

+71 5170#( #: ## !

+7 1 <<7 !62# "40 !#/ 1

! %

- A

' 2 < %&

45 &

= ) %"#%0!5 "( ( *

+'0## (2=1 #%"30! "#

A+5""

#70##0!5 !

(2=20!; ! 04%" "4 ( <

+371 5110#2

! :'%6!

(2=0%5 !'%"510# " ! )*+

) "!0!(11 220"3# ! "5%!# < "2""7 "10##0 (10

! "

0:%! %!( " 10# 2

! '0 ( 20!; 0## "# 10 0%5 ! '%"510# "50!!510<< !6 0%5 !'"5

( !6#0#!" 6110#4 # ( !

1 :0#0%5 !'"5

( !6#!

"2 50:

!0<0!('

"#50!"

: :"606 ('"'

"= 10#'<05 ("

< 0!5 %'!

! "#$% E "#%! #10.0!(1 3# ! "5%!# < "20!;310#0"6% (10 #0< ! 5 :0( 0#'

!5 !

" :"( "#'0## (2=1 #%" 0!(0%5 !'%"510# "'0" 5 '0 ( !'"5

( !6#01 #7!" #;0!(5# 1 #0 #100<1%61 )G 2 (0:%!10#2

!( '# (2=0%5 ! '%"510# "2%#0< 10#!

!5!

(!"0#0< 5 10#2

! ##% (1 10#5!

(1 ( '# ! "

0:%!%!( " 0!(10# #%''"

(1 " A ": 10!8 3# ! "5%!# < "0%5 !'%"510# "3%"6 #10 2""7 "10#5<<%( (7 11 20!;71#0!5 !

( (%" !6'

!( !5= < 60 !0!(0

"'"'

"=70#'%0%5 !#"!6"

< 0!5 10#2

! '<05 (2=1 :%'!1 2# "40 !# %'"

%" !&' (

)(*+',

) " -+ .&&$ * 104 6 4 ! 0 1%61 %< 5!# ( "0 ! 0"6%:

!# 0(("

## (2=5%!# < "1 '0"

#0#7 <<0# B0: !

(1 (5%:

!#0!( 8%( 5 0<'"

!#"

(2=1 :

%"#%0!"(

'0## (2=1 #%"320!; 5!(%5 ( 0%5 ! :"606 ( '"'

"= !

71 ! 0%5 ! '%"510# " :0( 1 61 # 2 (( " 0 # )*A 5""

#%5 ! '%"510# " 70# ##% (0<

" 055 !#0:

(0=71 !20!;5< 0"<=#0 (10 #0< 10# 2

! 5!(%5 ( #%28 5 5!

":0 ! 2= 20!; 0!( #%28 5 %5:

'"5

( !6#2

61%" !

70# %"1 "# '%<0 (10 %"1 "# '#5!

":1 7 <<2 0;

!!<=

" "

: 0!5 )G 0:%! 71 51 70# (%<= ( '# ( 2= 0%5 ! '%"510# " #!1 50# 0%5 !'%"510# "101 70#!070"

!( !5= 7" '

! 0 1 10!(# 2""7 "# " !

" : "( "# '0## (1 ! 1%6130%5 !'%"510# "( (( '# )G 2 (0:%!3 2%1 ( (#01 #7!" #; ##%0!5 055 <

""( '#

)G 2 (0:%!7 <<!4 #0!=" 61 !0%5 !'%"510# "37110(2 (

"0'"'

"=71 5170#%!( "< 60 ! #!:0 " 0<2

1 # %" #02< #1 10 2""7 " " 20!; 10( 5<<%( ( 7 1 051 1 "

01 5<0 : !

!( !6'%"510# "

"'"

!6 1 0:

!( ( '"4 # !# 5 ! A 1 D 53%'"

%" !&'/ #%'"010#1 <(10 " 61 ""

:# 5%"

(0## #0!(# B !6% #1 (!1 (0 '%2< 50 ! ! 5 "'%2< 50%5 !%!( "%< *

%< # 10#2

! %"1 "2# "4 (105!

":0 ! 2=20!;%!( "%< *

%< # !4 ###%55 ## %<0%5 !'%"510# "7 104 # " 6120 !05 ::402< '"'

"= !'"

#5" 2 ": 1 ! B0: !

( !< 61 05%0<'# ! '"

# !50# #3 # 4 ( !10 0%5 !'%"510# "10('0" 5 '0 ( !0%5 !'"5

( !6#%'!2 !6 %<<= 070"

" :"( "#'0## (2=1 #%"5!( !0<055 <

10(2

! ##% (1 :0< ! 04%" 0%5 !'%"510# "7%<(5!5<%( !<= 71 ! 20!; ##% # 0 #0< 5 <1%613 0%5 ! '%"510# '# )G 2 (0:%!32%20!;( (!5!5<%( 0%5 !#0< (% " :"( "#'0## (2=1 #%" #!1 !6#'1 20!; ":

" !6 !0! 7 12""7 "0#<!60#0%5 !#0< #!5!5<%( 2= ##%0!5 0 #0< 5 # <!6 0# 1 #0< # ! 5!

( !

04%" 0%5 ! '%"510# "3 1 ( # ! 05F% "

0!= " 61 " !

# ! 0%5 !

( '"'

"= < 0!5 ! 1 # "

60"( 50! 0<# 2 '<05 ( %'! 1 2# "40 !# 1 & "0<0 61 %" ! / #%'"0 ! 0 ! 8%(6:

! ! 0 ( * 1 2

(3 .

4#!%553%'"

%" 10# 1 <( 10 71 ! #0< '"5 ## 10# ! 00 !

!0< = ! 1 :0!!

:'<0 (%!( "1 #0% 0!(1 "( #510"6 #1 ! "

( 23 # ! < ("

:1 :"606 ('"'

"= 1 #8%(6:

#1 #0!( "

%5 !'%"510# "10#( '# (0!0:%! #3**3)

,9 '%"#%0!5 055 <

" (0

71 51 # <= !6 ( '# 7 120!; 0:%! #2 !6% < C (2=20!;# !5 (0 ( '# 3 0!(20!; #< 02< "

%!( 0%5 !'%"510# "0<!67 1 !

#01 "0 E)G '

" 0!!%: ": 1 (0 ( '# 3 7 1 ! 0 '

" ( !

:!1 ":(0=

#0"

#%< 024 ( #5%## !3! 5 (0

0!(055 <

##% ( ! 04%" 0%5 !'%"510# 0"

F%0#1 ( 0!; #10<< "

1 '1=# 50< '## ## ! :"606 '"'

"=2""7 "%'! #"

:' ! !055"(0!5 7 1<07

+ 11 024 ( "

5 !#3211 7" '

!#0"

( #'#

) << '

!( !6 : #5 <<0!

%# 0''< 50 !# #10<< #0!( ( #'# :!;

%3 $!' '%<% %'%

. .

$!'

1 "'

0; !6, 0#!

(/ #, 1 " '"02< / #,